By Paul Harris
March 28th 2008 @ 7:01am
America’s Cup 2008: Lawyers at 30 paces
The America’s Cup is becoming more bizarre by the minute.
As many of you will remember, immediately after the last America’s Cup the winning Alingi syndicate declared that the next Cup would be held by a faux Spanish Yacht Club in Valencia in July ‘09 in newly designed boats to be 90ft long.
Some 12 entries were received and everyone thought that was that until Oracle BMW came along with a challenge in the State Supreme Court of New York stating that the new Spanish Club was a sham and the rules for the racing biased towards the defender. Supported by the best lawyers money can buy they were successful and it has now been decreed by the Court that the challenger of record will be the Golden Gate Yacht Club whose challenger will of course be Oracle.
To add more grist to the mill, Oracle has declared that the races will be in multi-hulls, catamarans or Trimarans we don’t know, to be 90ft long and 90ft wide. Shades of 1998 when New Zealand’s huge single hulled yacht was wiped off the course by Dennis Connor’s catamaran. The Oracle syndicate have been busy training in 40ft cats and are said to have their design well progressed.
To add further spice the GGYC has stated that the race will be in October 2008, only 7 months away. The Alingi syndicate, in the person of Ernesto Bertarelli, then staged a tantrum and said they would rather forfeit than race. However cooler heads have since withdrawn that rather empty threat. To add a further twist, designed for the lawyers to enjoy, the America’s Cup deed states that “The Challenging Club shall give ten months notice in writing naming the days of the proposed races”.
The two syndicates met yesterday in Geneva to try to iron out differences particularly over the timing, which Alingi wants for May 2009. It will be no surprise to learn that nothing could be agreed and so it is back to Justice Cahn in the NY Supreme Court. The principle argument seems to be over when the ten months began and whether or not a waiver was granted and if so by whom and when.
In the meantime the other 12 syndicates have gone off to do something more interesting, probably including actually doing some yacht racing.
For those wanting to know where Australia stands in all this the answer is nowhere; however the Oracle syndicate has nominated Aussies James Spithill as helmsman and Joe Newton as a sail trimmer on whatever floating apparatus the race is finally sailed in. Presumably Syd Fischer is talking to our best legal brains to see if we can get to the starting line at the Court!
When and if this series for two takes place it is most likely to be very one sided since the designs could be completely different and as a result boat speed quite dissimilar. Both syndicates are rushing about looking for catamaran talent. Alingi has hired Alain Gautier, who won the Vendee Globe race, amongst many others, in a huge catamaran and our Australian medal wining Olympic Tornado sailors might suddenly find themselves in a more lucrative occupation than Olympic sailing.
One thing’s for certain, when it is eventually sailed it will be a bare knuckle affair and don’t be surprised to see gentlemen (or ladies) in wigs seated on both sides of the helmsman.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...


(5)
![Ricky Ponting did an interview before the Ashes series for the BBC. It covered the usual subjects such as player form, predictions, what the Ashes means etc and near the end of the conversation, Ponting was asked what he thought about the England team’s over the top celebrations following their 2005 series victory.
Ponting didn’t rise [...] Alec Swann: Ponting shouldn’t take the fall for Ashes defeat](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/ashes-loss-th.jpg)
![Just imagine the following happened: Sydney FC played an A-League home game against the Melbourne Victory at the Sydney Football Stadium as a curtain raiser to the Socceroos-Holland friendly on Saturday night. Yep, I’m dreaming right?
Absolutely.
There are numerous and obvious reasons which would preclude an A-League-Socceroos double billing on the same night.
However, I can’t help [...] Adrian Musolino: FFA needs to look beyond the rules of Marketing 101](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/central-coast-mariners-player-drain-th.jpg)
![As a contributor to SBS website The World Game, I often find myself perusing the site’s long-standing and mildly infamous forum. A hodge-podge of nationalist flag-waving and juvenile humour, it can be a diverting way to spend a couple of hours.
They’re an unforgiving lot on the forum, quick to highlight mistakes, ready to pounce on [...] Mike Tuckerman: Time to unite ‘new dawners’ and ‘bitters’ supporters](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/time-to-unite-socceroos-th.jpg)
![The Fox Sports effects microphone has become a fair barometer of an A-League match’s excitement level. When you can hear the players and coaches cussing, it’s a fair indicator that the crowd isn’t really into the match. Sadly, it’s a common occurrence.
Aside from the raucous at Etihad Stadium caused by Melbourne’s passionate and large supporter [...] Adrian Musolino: Lack of atmosphere stifles A-League games](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/33-or-22-rounds-a-league-ryall-th.jpg)
![You might not have felt it, but there was a definite shift in the AFL this week. It might have been a minor one, but it was unquestionably there: the beginning of the end for what is known as the outside player. The omission of Nick Stevens rammed it home.
Stevens had, of course, put in [...] Paddy Higgs: No place for one dimensional players in the AFL](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/no-place-afl-nick-stevens-th.jpg)
![The rugby media around the world have had several days now to digest the news that Danny Cipriani will be one of the star signings for the Melbourne Rebels in their first year in the 2011 Super 15 tournament. But in that time, they have failed to see the real news behind the signing.
To give [...] Spiro Zavos: The curious case of Rebels fullback Danny Cipriani](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/danny-cipriani-th.jpg)
![Rudyard Kipling wrote memorably about ‘the muddied oafs’ of rugby football and the ‘flannelled fools’ of cricket. The cricket part of the description sums up the behaviour of Shane Watson and Sulieman Benn in the Perth Test between Australia and the West Indies.
I have played and watched cricket for more decades than I care [...] Spiro Zavos: Shane Watson and Sulieman Benn are modern ‘flannelled fools’](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/australian-cricket-watson-th.jpg)
![It’s a hard life being a die-hard fan. The disappointments far outweigh the triumphs, even though any fan will tell you on the day of victory that it was all worth it. Still, it all got too much for one Hawthorn fan on Saturday night.
Perhaps with the final hopes of a Hawk dynasty disappearing [...] Paddy Higgs: Despite fan’s frustration, Mitchell’s attitude refreshing](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/despite-fan-frustration-sam-mitchell-th.jpg)
![Brett Lee has been back in the news in the last week, and depending on which paper or website you were looking at, he’s either crucial to Australia’s future campaigns or he may never play again.
In many ways, he’s the forgotten piece of the ever-growing puzzle that is the Australian fast-bowling attack.
There are a few [...] Brett McKay: The curious case of Brett Lee](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2008/02/brett-lee-ab-th.jpg)
![There is an odd peace about the final day before the season begins. Your team is undefeated, you’re buoyed by the talk of the toughest preseason ever and heartened by that young player you’ve admired for a while getting a start while the big new signing claims he is loving it and is raring to [...] Steve Kaless: New season is here, with the same complaints](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/bulldogs-eels-th.jpg)
![I’ve just got back from meeting up with Carl Valeri at his new Serie B club Sassuolo. After a difficult few months late last year, when the president of Grosseto froze him out of the side for refusing to sign a contract extension, things have finally turned around for Valeri.
The Canberra-born midfielder is due to [...] Davidde Corran: An FFA scouting network could be the A-League’s cure](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/socceroos-valeri-th.jpg)
![Earlier this week, the AFL opened up the discussion on staging for free-kicks. ‘Staging’ is a growing scourge on the sport, so the AFL’s course of action was correct. But as the round ball code shows, it’s a difficult problem to police and the issue may go unresolved.
AFL Football Operations Manager Adrian Anderson brought the [...] Ben Somerford: AFL moves quickly to find a solution to staging](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/AFL-moves-quickly-to-find-a-solution-to-staging-alan-didak-th.jpg)




Kento said | March 28th 2008 @ 9:14am | Report comment
This is an excellent analysis. What a farce…how could they let a sport get to this? Is there any salvation for the America’s Cup, or is it now doomed as a sport.
Rabbitz said | March 28th 2008 @ 9:22am | Report comment
Seriously, it has been many years since this could be called a sport. Perhaps a “lawyers blood-sport”?
It has descended into nothing more than a rich mans d%^k measuring contest. It surprises me that it gets any “sports news” coverage at all.
Rabz
sheek said | March 28th 2008 @ 10:14am | Report comment
Since 1987 when Australia defended & lost the America’s Cup, it’s become a farce. Sad……….
Mark said | March 28th 2008 @ 1:37pm | Report comment
Sheek, look back before 87, it always was a farce.
Paul Cotton said | March 28th 2008 @ 8:56pm | Report comment
Thank you for an excellent update. Please keep on top of this story for us.