By Darren Walton
May 16th 2008 @ 1:32am


ADVERTISEMENT

Super 14’s own State of Origin: Reds v Waratahs

Saturday night’s crucial Super 14 derby between NSW and Queensland has taken on State of Origin intensity with barbs flying from both sides of the border and the Waratahs today refusing to publicise their team and snubbing a traditional pre-game function.

The scenarios for remaining finals contenders

More rugby
Fisher sure about Brumbies future, not about his own
Crusaders aim to iron out bad habits

NSW coach Ewen McKenzie was forced to explain his decision to release only a 23-man squad to travel to Brisbane - rather than name a starting XV and seven reserves - and also defend the Waratahs’ decision not to attend tomorrow’s annual interstate luncheon.

With the third-placed Waratahs needing to beat the Reds in the final-round fixture at Suncorp Stadium to ensure a semi-final berth, McKenzie said he had no choice but to delay announcing his line-up because he simply hadn’t finalised it.

Teams for the 14th round of Super 14 rugby

The Waratahs only arrived back from their demanding two-match tour of South Africa on Monday afternoon and today’s hitout at the SFS was just their second training session of the week.

“Being a short week for us, we’ll just maximise our training opportunities and work out our best team,” McKenzie said.

“I’ve got time.”

Of most interest to the Reds is whether NSW will start high-profile recruit Timana Tahu and, if so, exactly where.

The options are on the wing or opposite in-form ex-Waratah Morgan Turinui at outside centre, where the former rugby league international appeared in his cameo return from a hamstring injury against the Stormers in Cape Town last weekend.

While adamant there was nothing sinister in his selection approach this week, McKenzie was taking great delight in the fact his delay in naming the NSW team was causing such angst among the Reds.

“Morgan’s been ringing everyone. I think he’s rung most of our players to see what’s going on,” McKenzie said.

Asked if he thought the Reds were concerned about the uncertainty, McKenzie said: “I don’t know. I don’t know if they’re the worrying types”.

“I’m sure they’d like to know what our team is and I’m sure they’ll spend plenty of time trying to find out.

“But whether they do or don’t, we’ll see how it goes on the night.

“I know Morgan’s been on the phone a lot so, I guess if he’s not the worrying type, he’s worrying on someone else’s behalf.”

NSW winger Lote Tuqiri had fired the first salvo of the week on Tuesday when he branded the Reds a “cop-out” for declaring themselves the competition’s “spoilers” after falling out of playoff contention.

“Why not try a bit harder at the start of the year?” Tuqiri said.

Continuing the verbal warfare, the Reds hit back today, accusing the Waratahs of reneging on a deal to attend their annual luncheon tomorrow.

Queensland Rugby Union chief executive Ken Freer was incensed the Waratahs, with the exception of McKenzie and a couple of token injured players, snubbed the invitation to help promote the match.

The Reds attended a similar function, put on by the Rugby Union Players Association, in Sydney last season and Freer said the NSWRU agreed to return the favour this year.

“Talk about copping out and not fronting up,” Freer said.

McKenzie, though, said the Waratahs were not deliberately brushing the Reds, but merely had to train.

“We do our training and captain’s run in the afternoon. That’s when we normally do it, so it sort of clashes with the lunch,” he said.

“I’m going to go to the lunch and I’ll stand up there and ‘Buddha’ (Chris Handy) will ask an array of questions, so I’ll be the punching bag on behalf of the team and then we’ll go to training.

“One thing we’ve been this year is very consistent in our preparation and we don’t want to compromise that.”

Watch Episode 8 NEW of The Roar Rugby Review

Free Email updates:

Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...


© 2007 AAP

 

Crowd Says (10)

The Link said  | May 16th 2008 @ 8:42am | Report comment

Darren, at least they’re not calling it State of the Union any more!! Comparing the game to a token speach by a US President each year pleading for passage by Congress was always an interesting analogy. I can’t recall the Union and League games being so close together in the past, should make for an interesting comparison. The Union game historically tends to get bogged down, whereas the League version is the games showpiece.

Westy said  | May 16th 2008 @ 11:28am | Report comment

I find it interesting concept the super 14 waratah club side represents the state of New South Wales.

Andrew said  | May 16th 2008 @ 11:57am | Report comment

Westy, the Waratahs are NOT a club side. They are a provincial side; they represent the entire state. The Super 14 is a provincial competition, not a club one like the NRL or AFL

El Capitan said  | May 16th 2008 @ 1:06pm | Report comment

Do they really represent the state as a whole? So is there players from Orange, Wagga Wagga ect in the team? No they are all from Sydney. Same can be said about the Reds. No players from Townsville, Mt Isa, Toowoomba that play for the Reds, with the exception of perhaps school boy reps.

Andrew B said  | May 16th 2008 @ 2:39pm | Report comment

El Capitan,

Both teams do have some country boys out there.

Tom Carter & Will Caldwell – Young, NSW
Berrick Barnes – Kingaroy, QLD
Greg Holmes – Allora, QLD

This is just off the top of my head, maybe more there.

chris ash said  | May 16th 2008 @ 3:59pm | Report comment

bugress is from maitland (he was in my year - only reason i know) All the players are def not from sydney… the love is shared

ulysses said  | May 16th 2008 @ 3:59pm | Report comment

Andrew - not quite right either. Super 14 is neither club nor provincial. They are “franchises”. That is why it is the Crusaders and not Canterbury, the Highlanders and not Otago, the Bulls not Northern Transvaal etc etc. Using the HIghlanders as the example - that Super14 franchise “represents” the NZ provinces of Otago and Southland. Only in Australia (with fewer provinces) did we exactly align S14 franchises with our state RU’s / provinces. But they are still separate things.

Think of it this way - if the S14 stops tomorrow, the Bulls and Highlanders disappear; Nth Transvaal, Otago and Southland continue. The Waratahs S14 franchise also disappears, but the NSW RU representative team the NSW Waratahs continues.

cosmos forever said  | May 16th 2008 @ 4:31pm | Report comment

Not wanting to be pedantic but I’m not even sure ours are completely aligned with the States, I think the Brumbies actually represent southern NSW and the Tablelands as well as the ACT (not sure if that is just marketing or an actual agreement).

BTW - “Why not try harder at the start of the year” could be LT’s personal mantra couldn’t it…

Reds by 5.

wallythefly said  | May 16th 2008 @ 7:46pm | Report comment

I don’t know whose right or wrong, but it’s a shame we’re talking about this at all. Maybe if the Tahs played a game at the Central Coast or the Gong and the Reds played games at Townsville and the Gold Coast people would feel the sides are more representive.

sportym said  | May 16th 2008 @ 10:05pm | Report comment

cosmos forever is correct,

The brumbies are no longer the ACT Brumbies, they changed thier name to Brumbies. And they represent southern NSW and the Tablelands. Though the world represent does not mean much to be frank.

If you travel around rural NSW, you will infact realise that most people associate the waratahs with Sydney. In southern NSW you will find more people following the Brumbies.

Have your Say

If you like this article, Subscribe! Subscribe to our daily email

Please be sure to enter your name and email before submitting this comment. Please also refer to our comments policy

 

Hot debate

What you're Roaring!

  • By signing up to the daily The Roar email you'll receive all the new articles and sports opinion that we put up on the website each day - delivered direct into your inbox. For free. We think it's the best way to receive our content.

    Our emails contain the article along with the images - just like on the website.