By Steve Kaless
September 23rd 2008 @ 7:06am
Super 14 tipping now live for sign-ups. Join now and invite your mates..
---------------
And then there were four

It’s clear that the NRL finals have been so good that everyone needs a good lie down.
In the past two weeks I’ve read and have also had people say to me that the key for rugby league is to get this level of intensity every week.
Sound familiar? Maybe we could call it Super Duper League.
But enough naval gazing, I’m just enjoying the footy and it has been hard not to like it, unless of course your team has been pulverised in the second half or had victory ripped away from them in the dying seconds.
The Warriors and the Storm both survived their shoot outs and now have that x-factor often termed momentum right behind them.
Nearly everything just seems to be going the Warriors way at the moment, save the odd brain explosion from video referees.
Okay, okay I’ve said my piece in the past about these clowns and it is pointless to ponder just how Steve Clarke contrived a penalty try for Anthony Minichello but I think two things should be noted.
One is the psychology of the decision makers, the best description I have heard was from the ABC’s shrewd analyst Warren Ryan who said the biggest problem with video referees was that they seem more interested in impressing their peers than with getting the decisions right in the spirit of the game.
The constant replays seem just a time killing method while they search for the most obscure ruling.
Maybe there is some sort of referees’ bingo going on behind the scenes and the first one to tick off every different interpretation of the obstruction rule wins a hamper.
Clarke’s decision would in Victorian times been enough to get him put into an asylum. Of course in those days, members of the public were allowed to attend asylums for their own entertainment so they might have got something from it.
In these enlightened times we are sensitive to other feelings.
So much so that referees are protected because we fear a follow on to the Saturday morning touch lines of our little leagues.
The theory is that if Ivan Cleary blows his stack on Friday night because a referee makes a blunder which could cost his organisation hundreds of thousands of dollars then little Johnny or little Johnny dad might do the same at the Under 9’s on Saturday.
I find it all a little week, if people can’t put their own lives in perspective and realise that the Under 9’s is not the NRL Grand Final qualifier (and I know for many parents it is very hard) then all is lost.
It is like saying if a bloke at work doesn’t hand in a report that could cost the firm a million bucks then no one should yell at him because he might do the same if his kid in Kindergarten forgets to hand in his homework.
But Clarke survived because the Warriors have found a whole new toughness. Mental toughness.
In the past a bad call would have seen the heads drop but this version is built of sterner stuff.
The finals back door was swung wide open and the Roosters kicked out in no uncertain terms, it was a bit like watching 13 bouncers using strong arm tactics to eject a group of over hyped and over paid players from a drinking establishment.
Perhaps therefore the match was so enjoyable because it was the perfect analogy to modern day football.
The Warriors played close to the perfect second half on Friday and had the momentum right behind them, when Michael Witt found touch from the most unlikely position you just felt it was their night.
What is more they finished strongly, Aiden Kirk could have run they ball right across the Tasman at the death and there was a feeling the Warriors would have wanted to play the Sea Eagles on Saturday if they could have.
The big question, what to do with Wade McKinnon? I should admit I like Wade McKinnon more than I should admit to in the company of other males. The guy is a throw back, he plays with passion and commitment and refs might not like him, but he doesn’t care and certainly doesn’t like them.
If I still had posters on my wall, Wade McKinnon would be there. Of course he is as likely to score the match winner as he is to punch the ref so Ivan has some thinking to do.
Saturday’s thriller at Lang Park (always will be to me) stole the headlines for its classic finish but in truth it was far from a classic game.
It seems almost weird that the best finishes come from games which seem to be bumbling their way towards a predictable end. I always thought that about the 1997 ARL Grand Final.
It seemed that the Storm would go out and the enduring memory would be Cameron Smith shanking his drop out into touch, but things don’t often work out that way.
There seemed to be a bit of afters between the media and Wayne Bennett after the match, there has always been an uneasy relationship between the two but I thought it was a decent gesture of Channel Nine not to show his coaching box when Greg Inglis dived over.
I’m sure the image of him blowing up when Mark McGaw scored for the Blues would had been superseded quite comfortably…but like a Hitchcock film the true horror of it will always just exist in our imaginations.
Ashton Sims shouldn’t feel too bad, I mean THAT drop ball was about his 15th of the game and I was sure that he and Joel Clinton were involved in some sort of conspiracy such was their handling.
At least we know that as a unit the Broncos are likely to take their mad Monday seriously.
Our MTV inspired attention spans now mean we can barely remember whether it’s Brett Stewart or Graham Eadie at fullback for Manly or if ET, Steve Rogers or Fraser Anderson in the centres for the Sharkies.
They were all sitting on their respective beaches last week so they slipped from the public consciousness.
How they return is up to them, but I can’t wait.
Super 14 tipping now live for sign-ups. Join now and invite your mates.
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...

(11)












oikee said | September 23rd 2008 @ 8:03am | Report comment
Just one point i want to make about the droped balls the other nite, it was raining for awhile there, very greasy in the middle, the storm also had a few pop out. The warriors are playing good football, just hope it keeps going from here. They have plenty of experience as do manly, this might be the game of the season, where have i heard that before.
Matt S said | September 23rd 2008 @ 8:33am | Report comment
Pity, Victorians couldn’t see the games live. What do the AFL lackies in channel 9 have to fear? A superior sport?
Michael C said | September 23rd 2008 @ 9:31am | Report comment
Matt S -
Channel 9 is run out of Sydney.
They aren’t in the business of giving free kicks to other networks,
and obviously don’t face similar contractual obligations to those the AFL managed to insert.
Nothing to do with ‘AFL lackies in channel 9′………………………but, typically, there’s a nice little ‘blame culture’ perpetuated by bozos like Roy Masters who via his hypocrisy is willing to blame everyone else for the arrangements negotiated between Ch.9, Foxtel, and the NRL.
Spiro Zavos said | September 23rd 2008 @ 9:37am | Report comment
Steve is right. I belive that in all the football codes the referees should be subjected or allow themselves to front a media conference after the big matches. Most of the rugby referees are amenable, and I’m sure the referesss in the other codes would be too.
So let’s have it.
Mr Mac said | September 23rd 2008 @ 10:03am | Report comment
Matt S
Were not the weekend games on delay to Sydney? The warriors for sure because the results were on the web before the game finished.
From Memory the Bronco’s game had too many convenient adds to be live
Setgo said | September 23rd 2008 @ 11:42am | Report comment
About the criticism of referees
“….referees are protected because we fear a follow on to the Saturday morning touch lines of our little leagues”
Believe me it happens.
Journos and coaches who should be required to referee in a competition every couple of years to become familiar with rules and to experience the workplace.
And point two: Why does Rugby League have penality tries any way? The way commentators go on you would think somebody had stolen grandmas handbag.
cosmos forever said | September 23rd 2008 @ 12:51pm | Report comment
Steve - i disagree on the Storm. I reckon they have lost momentum and Bennett was absolutely correct in his assessment that they are running out of puff, rather than building up a head of steam.
If you take moments of brilliance out of the equation I think they are only really scraping through and now that the ref’s can’t quite help them as much (C Smtih is the new Buderus when it comes to getting away with things during a game) because of the finals glare - they are in even more trouble.
I know it sounds like a whinge but if Melbourne are policed correctly in the play of the ball they are much less of a threat (though with IF and GI and BS in the team - I’m not diminishing their ability to attack from anywhere).
Come on the Warriors - everyone’s new favourite second team!
PS - Smiths’ tackle of Thaiday represents everything that is bad in league - that they made it, that they deny it, that C Smith wasn’t picked up for it by the ref, that ex-players who don’t have to take these tackles are playing the faux-tough guy routine and saying they shouldn’t be rubbed out!
Jerry said | September 23rd 2008 @ 1:24pm | Report comment
Spiro - refs having press conferences would be a hiding to nothing situation. No-one would pay them any attention unless they’d screwed up a big call and then they’d just be badgered about one or two controversial calls and nothing else.
Essentially - if Wayne Barnes had held a press conference after the All Blacks v Italy match in the World Cup, no journos would have even bothered to show. If he’d held one after the 14/4 final, however….
Rocky said | September 24th 2008 @ 2:59pm | Report comment
On behalf of my fellow directors from Hearts in Union Rugby Foundation Australia (HIU) we want to give you loges, Dick & Jo a big thumbs up and a sincere thank you for your commitment to HIU, great work and thanks again.
Rocky
Spitfire3 (GO RAIDERS!) said | September 24th 2008 @ 5:11pm | Report comment
Right on, cosmos! Smartest opinion I’ve read or heard all day.
Steve Kaless said | September 25th 2008 @ 3:18am | Report comment
Setgo,
I actually do a bit of refereeing, part of my whole “put a bit back in” philosophy. However my view is that most park referees are approachable and humble, a marked difference to those in the spotlight and I think this causes a lot of problems.
Parents, sadly, will often always be lunatics and I don’t think many of them will stop acting like cave man if everyone starts clapping Tony Archer from the field.
Also, as I have said previously the bloke in the middle may have a tough job, the video ref doesn’t. Let’s not pretend for a minute he is under the same pressures.
I’ve heard plenty of times “It is a hard job”, however like most hard jobs it does get easier when you know what you are doing.
Cosmos,
You could be right with Melbourne, or they could have had their off week, still survived, and now kick on. Oh for hindsight.
Comes down a bit to Bellamy, fair to say he failed when the heat was on to prepare NSW in Game 3, will be interesting to see how he goes at this test.