Related coverage
- Adelaide United news
- Football news
- Socceroos news
- Socceroos Fixtures news
- Socceroos 2014 FIFA World Cup Qualifying news
Years ago Craig Foster derogatively referred to the A-League as the English Premier League of Asia. Although he meant that as a negative comment, about our style of football, I argue that we can become the EPL of Asia, in a good way.
Afshin Ghotbi believed that the A-League could be a hub for ambitious Asian footballers aiming for a big break to get into Europe and that eventually the A-League could become the best league in Asia, attracting the best talent.
Unfortunately that ambition is still a way off the horizon.
Our sponsors still don’t pay enough money to match that ambition; the Socceroos are still subsidizing our leagues; and our wages are half or a third of Asian counterparts in the J-League and K-League.
However, with a bit of ambition and foresight I believe that we can make some steps towards reaching that goal.
Right now, when the sponsors are bidding to represent the A-League, FFA or the individual clubs, despite ACL participation, they are primarily doing this to reach the Australian market.
Unfortunately, a lack of population has limited the business scale, and as long as A-League remains the way it is, it will never compete financially with the big Asian clubs.
However, there is one option that so far hasn’t been explored: the South-East Asian market.
Imagine if Adelaide United’s great run to the finals of the Asian Champions League was captained by Thai Datsakorn Thonglao and spearheaded by Indonesian Bambang Pamungkas?
Players like Bambang are rock stars in their own countries and I’m quite sure a similar scenario will pique the interest of these countries and open the A-League up to a very large market that has not been explored by any major Asian countries.
Those countries may take an active interest in the A-League and we may convert some fans to support an A-League club.
The prospect of going into any South East Asian country, like Indonesia, and seeing the locals wearing an A-League top with their star local player on the back of the shirt is not impossible. After all, many Australians ended up supporting Leeds United due to the exploits of Harry Kewell and Mark Viduka, and perhaps an A-league club could do the same with a Suree Sukha of Thailand and an Erol Iba of Indonesia.
If the South East Asian countries take an active interest in the A-League and watch it in large numbers, suddenly the TV rights value will increase. Similarly, the value of sponsorship for the A-League and their individual clubs will skyrocket.
The more money in the A-League, the more we can pay the players, and perhaps this ‘crisis’ of the exodus of players to Japan and Korea may be avoided.
We can then aim to attract the best Asian talent in the same way that the EPL attracts the best talent in Europe, as Afshin Ghotbi envisioned.
Perhaps we can then make Craig Foster’s fears of becoming the EPL of Asia come true.
Recommend this story.
The Crowd Says (32) | Page 2 of Comments
Have Your Say
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Football articles
- Socceroos vs Japan in Brisbane is a masterstroke (130)
- Fans want a club, not a name, that fills them with Pride (129)
- The war that’s not a war (128)
- Western Sydney’s new A-League team: What’s in a name? (101)
- Too many doubts over new A-League club (101)
- Magic EPL finish as Manchester City triumph in tightest of title races (93)
- Sydney FC want Australian A-League coach (63)
- Abbas wants A-League excitement at Sydney FC (13)
- Axed coach takes Adelaide United to court (6)
- Milicic yet to sign say west Sydney
- Oh my god! They’ve killed Kenny (12)
- Is Chelsea’s Abramovic finally satisfied? (15)
- Is this the end of the football salary cap? (63)
- Supporting a loser will make you love sport (27)
- Oh my god! They’ve killed Kenny (12)
- Is Chelsea’s Abramovic finally satisfied? (15)
- Is this the end of the football salary cap? (63)
- Supporting a loser will make you love sport (27)
- Relegation: Great entertainment and good business (5)
- My EPL team of the season (17)
- Bayern Munich vs Chelsea: UEFA Champions League final live scores, blog (160)
- Explore:
- Adelaide United, Champions League, English Premier League, football, Mark Viduka, Socceroos

February 8th 2009 @ 2:12pm
lol said | February 8th 2009 @ 2:12pm | Report comment
Hello dasilva.
Japan have tapped SEA maket. But they were not good player for J-league.
2006
Vietnam’s U-17 practitioners joined J1′s Jubilo Iwata.
http://english.vietnamnet.vn/sports/2006/07/592492/
2007
South China’s duo practitioners joined J1′s Yokohama F. Marinos.
http://www.geocities.com/hkgfootball/2006-07/index2.htm
2008
Le Cong Vinh from Vietnam loses chance to play J2′s Ehime FC.
http://english.vietnamnet.vn/sports/2008/05/781675/
Adul Lahso from Thai had played for J2′s Gainare Tottori on half year loans coz the coach of Tottori is from Thai.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adul_Lahso
But I think it’s good for player to could choose from a lot of places to play.
February 8th 2009 @ 4:31pm
onside said | February 8th 2009 @ 4:31pm | Report comment
The key is not the players
The key is A League clubs being both owned and funded by wealthy Asian owners.
That would generate both the player links and the interest in Asia.
Would not break salary cap as it would be impossible to ascertain bonus commercial
consideration in home country.
Also think scholarships.The young rising star on the cusp of national selection in his
home country who wants to study for a degree at an Australian University.
And as much as I have always been a fan of Gary Fowler,the A League is selling itself
short .The A leagues motto should be NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN.
Once again think scholarships.Think apprenticeships.Think youth. Think fringe football
academy lads from the UK clubs. More people would go to games to watch classy
youngsters sprint and score, than they would to see yesterdays heroes, limp off sore.
February 8th 2009 @ 6:53pm
lol said | February 8th 2009 @ 6:53pm | Report comment
Sure, in in the past J clubs had employed top players. But now, there come into existence some J-clubs developing young foreign players in order to sell to a bigger and richer club like Urawa or Euro’s.
Ex-Gamba’s Bare was sold to Qatar club for 500M yen within last season. At first, He came to Omiya Ardija as a practitioner at ’01. After that he was transfered to Ventforet Kofu and transfered to Gamba.
Ex-Kawasaki Frontale straiker Hulk was sold to FC Porto for 500M yen at ’08 summer transfer market. He at 18 came to there as a practitioner at ’05. And now he is playing in champions league as a regular starter.
’05 Côte d’Ivoire premier division top scorer Doumbia at 18 came to Kashiwa Reysol at ’06 as a practitioner. After that he was transfered to BSC Young Boys.
Ex-Consadole Sapporo’s practitioner Davi came at ’07 was sold to Nagoya for 300M yen this time. And he is interested by Panathinaikos etc.
And this year some young players will play in J-league.
Adebayo (J1 Kashiwa Reysol, U-19 Nigerian NT, MF, 18)
CHO Young Cheol (J1 Albirex Niigata, U-20 Korean NT, FW, 19)
JEONG Don-Ho (J1 Yokohama.F.M, U-20 Korean NT, DF, 19)
KIM Dong Sub (J1 Shimizu S-Pulse, U-20 Korean NT, FW, 19)
KIM Jin-Hyeon (J2 Cerezo Osaka, Ex-U-20 Korean NT, GK, 21)
BAE Seung Jin (J2 Tokushima Vortis, Ex-U-20 Korean NT, DF, 21)
Kim Tae-Yeon (J2 Mito HollyHock, U-20 Korean NT, MF, 20)
JUNG Jung Hyun (J2 Shonan Bellmare, Korea, FW, 21)
CHO Song Jin (J2 Roasso Kumamoto, Korea, DF, 18)
BRUNO (J2 Ventforet Kofu, Brazil, FW, 19)
Gilton (J1 Albirex Niigata, Brazil, DF, 19)
Josimar (J2 Ehime FC, Brazil, FW, 21)
Fabio (J2 Tokushima Vortis, Brazil, FW, 21)
sorry for my poor english.
February 8th 2009 @ 8:11pm
Kazama said | February 8th 2009 @ 8:11pm | Report comment
A lot of young Koreans there. Just goes to show we aren’t the only strong nation losing talent to another Asian league.
February 8th 2009 @ 8:28pm
lol said | February 8th 2009 @ 8:28pm | Report comment
In the end, J-league is richer league just in ASIA. Although EPL is top of the WORLD and the player can move to all of the WORLD.
So if A-league want to become like EPL, A-league have to become richest league in the world, IMO.
February 8th 2009 @ 8:56pm
dasilva said | February 8th 2009 @ 8:56pm | Report comment
lol
Thanks for pointing out the recruits from SEA in the J-League. I guess I was probably over-excited with that idea.
I’m also quite aware that the J-league youth policy is first class. They have a track record of getting young players and developing them.
When I say EPL of asia – i just mean most popular league in Asia or the leagues that attracts the best talent from Asia. Right now the EPL of asia is the J-league.
I thinks what’s needed is for one of the leagues to grab someone from SEA who then stars and excels.
the sole advantage of A-league so far is that it’s a western countries and that scouts from europe are more likely to be in Australia therefore ambitious players who want to make a career in europe could go to A-league first before heading to europe.
Nevertheless we lack the money which is a handicap. I’m trying to propose an idea that will increase the brand of the A-league so that it will worth more which will make us be financially competitive. The only way we can do that is establish an international brand and try to spread the brand to other countries as the market in Australia isn’t big enough.
I’m kind of interested – how popular is the J-league in SEA countries? DFor the most part I know that most of the attention goes to the EPL.
February 8th 2009 @ 11:26pm
lol said | February 8th 2009 @ 11:26pm | Report comment
Dasilva
Before I said this is very helpful in another article. Did you read?
http://www.euro2day.gr/ftcom_en/126/articles/441565/ArticleFTen.aspx
I think this article say a similar reason why the management of J-league and these clubs didn’t refer to SerieA’s that biggest league when J-league started, but Bundesliga’s.
When the players move to next club they seek the money and the club’s and league’s play level and the honor, and Uefa is best now and can give a lot of things player seek than asian now, so It’s necessary for us that the domestic leagues and ACL do higher level competition in the world, too. IMO.
I suppose the reason J-league is popular in SEA is what most of asian people know that Japan national team level continue to rise and qualify for WC since the time J-league began at 1991, and they are seeing about the difference of play level between national match and J-league from a same point of view.
sorry for my poor english.
February 9th 2009 @ 12:13am
dasilva said | February 9th 2009 @ 12:13am | Report comment
Lol
I’m not too sure what’s your point. (It’s ok – You don’t have to apologise for your english. You still speak one more language more then most people in the world)
Is it that Japan when setting up the J-league, that they used Bundesliga as a role model in how to create a professional league rather then Serie-A which was the strongest league at that time.
February 9th 2009 @ 12:19am
lol said | February 9th 2009 @ 12:19am | Report comment
Sorry, Yes. Bundesliga is a role model of J-league
February 9th 2009 @ 12:27am
dasilva said | February 9th 2009 @ 12:27am | Report comment
Thanks Lol
I’m pretty curious about the similarities of bundesliga and the J-league and why the J-league was such a success.
In a way Australia has to look at J-league as role models in our football development.
I’ll be going to sleep now so I won’t be able to respond for a while but thank you for your information on the J-league and their recruitment policies