By Jesse Fink
February 20th 2009 @ 3:26am
Moore, Culina and Chipperfield can subvert the Socceroos paradigm
Now, part of the deal in getting a Dutchman as your head men’s national-team coach is you get a lot of plain talking thrown in for no charge. It’s something his domestic peers still quite haven’t come to grips with, if we are to inspect the damage from the latest verbal hand-grenade he’s lobbed into the A-league breach.
North Queensland Fury chairman Don Matheson is livid about comments Pim Verbeek made midweek regarding the representative prospects of new Gold Coast recruit Jason Culina.
It’s not especially breaking news – Verbeek was warning of Culina possibly jeopardising his Socceroos career by returning home in his prime a month ago – but it is timely, given Matheson is, in his own words, “busting his guts” to convince Culina’s fellow Socceroo Scott Chipperfield to play in Townsville and simultaneously keep his dream of going to South Africa 2010 alive.
“This could not have come at a worse time,” he said. “If I was a player, I’d probably be worried about what he’s saying … we’re right at the death in terms of the negotiations, and now the worry is this could have an impact. We’d be shattered if this affects his decision.”
And fair enough.
From a business perspective, Verbeek’s comments are unfortunate for the Fury, and they haven’t been helped by Football Federation Australia chief executive Ben Buckley’s tacit support of Verbeek’s views.
On the surface at least, what Verbeek is saying about the quality of the A-League compared to European leagues is highly incompatible with the goals and objectives of the FFA, which philosophically has been to lure the best available Australian players home from overseas.
But the FFA’s efforts have been piecemeal. It has been largely the individual initiative of clubs that have persuaded the likes of Jason Culina, Ljubo Milicevic, Paul Agostino and others to come back to Australia.
So it was perhaps fanciful of Matheson and anyone else to think Buckley was going to condemn Verbeek for whiteanting the A-League.
But there is, to be fair to Matheson, some inherent flaws in Verbeek’s broadbrush assessment of the A-League and what its players can offer the national team.
Craig Moore, the only A-League player to take the field in the recent Australia vs Japan World Cup qualifier in Yokohama, was arguably the Socceroos’ best on the night. Playing in the A-League has not hampered his abilities, as much as I can tell. He still seems sharp with his skills and positionally aware.
There is no reason, I believe, to think Culina cannot emulate the example of his Socceroos team-mate and play to the level he has hitherto provided for his manager. Culina says he can do it and who is to doubt him? He’s one of the hardest working Socceroos in the game’s history.
The A-League needs as many quality Socceroos that are still playing in Europe to finish their careers – either mid or late – in Australia.
It is incumbent on the clubs and the FFA to give them all the encouragement and incentives they can. And, to a certain point, that includes our national coach.
But it is up to them, and no else, to prove once they get back here that they are up to the task of combining representing a domestic club with representing the Socceroos.
If Culina thought he was blazing a trail just signing for the Gold Coast, he’s very much mistaken.
Get Australia's best Football opinion emailed daily.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...


(44)
![The Wellington Phoenix are kicking and screaming for their very existence, and doing a damn good job of it. A sell-out crowd of 32,792 watched them defeat Newcastle 3-1 in extra-time to book their place in the preliminary final against Sydney FC for the right to face Melbourne Victory in the Grand Final.
It was an [...] Adrian Musolino: Rise of the Phoenix gives us a true trans-Tasman rivalry](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/wellington-phoenix-tim-brown-th.jpg)
![Ahead of our first match of the 2010 Super 14 season against the Western Force in Perth, there is a real sense of excitement building amongst the group as we embark on our three month journey.
After a shorter pre-season then previous years, which included a three day bike ride from Canberra to Mt Kosciusko and [...] Ben Hand: Brumbies fired up to start Super 14 on winning note](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/patrick-phibbs-th.jpg)
![As the time of the year rapidly approaches where we take time to reflect on all things good and bad over the past twelve months, it seems the perfect time for me to cleanse the mind of all those seemingly confident and assured predictions made this year on The Roar.
So where do I start?
Well, back [...] Brett McKay: Confessing the worst sports predictions of 2009](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/david-warner-th.jpg)
![I’m no expert on rugby league commentary, so it’s only when I’m positive I have some good ideas that I would pop something in the suggestion box for the “voice of rugby league” and the “super coach.”
Now, I love a punt as much as the next man. But I’m finding it hard to define [...] Steve Kaless: Suggestions for the Channel Nine commentary team](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/early-points-soward-young-th.jpg)
![The sight of Clint Bolton in a Melbourne Heart polo shirt in the week he wore the gloves for Sydney FC as they began their finals campaign didn’t go down too well with Sydney fans and football purists. But it will go down as a significant moment for Melbourne’s second franchise.
It was the moment they [...] Adrian Musolino: Finally the Melbourne Heart starts pumping](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/melbourne-heart-th.jpg)
![The most important part of any season is getting into a position to play finals, and hopefully grab that double chance. During my time at Hawthorn, we were very fortunate to play in thirteen consecutive finals series (1982-94), including seven straight Grand Finals (1983-89).
Usually a month out from September you would know that you’re [...] Robert DiPierdomenico: In finals footy, the players must do everything right](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/in-finals-footy-hawthorn-th.jpg)
![The AFL’s expansion to 18 teams means the talent pool will become more diluted and clubs are reacting to this by seeking new ways to find players. It presents a new challenge for footy clubs and it’s interesting to observe their different methods.
When the Gold Coast and West Sydney clubs do arrive on the AFL [...] Ben Somerford: AFL clubs beginning to think outside the square](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/AFL-clubs-think-outside-square-karmichael-hunt-broncos-th.jpg)
![Tonight, UEFA Champions League football returns to the Emirates, 113 days since its last appearance at Arsenal’s home ground. On that occasion, Gunners fans held up giant placards that spelled “believe,” before seeing their team humbled by Manchester United.
This time round it will be the away fans clinging to hope with Arsenal expected to [...] Davidde Corran: As history repeats, there’s no way back for Scotland](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/a-league-celtic-scott-mcdonald-th.jpg)
![Finally, having a passport is becoming worthwhile for rugby league fans with English Super League side Catalans Dragons taking their match against Warrington to the Olympic Stadium in Barcelona this weekend in the hope of drawing a few interested onlookers.
It’s probably about time some of rugby league’s much maligned administrators got a few pats [...] Steve Kaless: Going global in rugby league’s brave new world](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/going-global-rugby-th.jpg)
![There is an odd peace about the final day before the season begins. Your team is undefeated, you’re buoyed by the talk of the toughest preseason ever and heartened by that young player you’ve admired for a while getting a start while the big new signing claims he is loving it and is raring to [...] Steve Kaless: New season is here, with the same complaints](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/bulldogs-eels-th.jpg)
![Kevin Sheedy will coach West Sydney on a three-year appointment that will include the club’s first season in the AFL in 2012. That was the bombshell news delivered by the News Limited press late last night which will have the football world buzzing. The western Sydney AFL project suddenly has wings.
In fact, for [...] Adrian Musolino: Sheedy signing exactly what West Sydney needs](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/sheedy-signing-sydney-th.jpg)




goober said | February 20th 2009 @ 8:05am | Report comment
Is it also the case that Pim was referring to Culina specifically and not necessarily extending his damaging comments to others who may want to come back? I think i read on other websites that “Chippers” position was safe.
Mid career roos probably are better of overseas, and as much as i wld like to see them here in the HAL, bringing back many of the boys late in their careers has shown that they can be overpriced and over age. A lot of the supposed stars from overseas have flopped in the HAL – incl Rizzo, Ljubic, Agostino, Juric and Alosis for a myriad of reasons.
Cpaaa said | February 20th 2009 @ 8:45am | Report comment
I originally thought Culina is not the type of socceroo to draw a crowd in the HAL. I have since changed my thoughts,
At 28 he is in his prime, he is fitter and hungrier than other socceroos, a work horse, not a greedy bastard and I think he will absolutely tear the HAL apart. the move to GCU will make him an even stronger player and leader. If Chippers joins the North then be assured the new boys will be pushing for Asia.
If MV can keep Hernandez, Aloisi wakes up, AU sort out their B/S, and QR win the GF …
Then next seasons HAL will be a new era in Australian Football.
md said | February 20th 2009 @ 9:01am | Report comment
If it encourages the A-league clubs to step up to the plate in terms of their training and professionalism, then that would be a fantastic result for everyone. SFC is going to have UEFA pro level coaches. GCU is going to be coached by someone with an excellent pedegree of playing on the continent in the modern era, and will have the added incentive of keeping Culina fit for WC2010. It will be interesting to see the effects of this on the team.
As for Culina specifically – well it’s a pretty crowded midfield in the Socceroos, particularly if everyone is fit, so Pim might have a point. I’ll say no more on that issue, lest I wake sleeping dogs!
Cheers
md
whiskeymac said | February 20th 2009 @ 9:20am | Report comment
I agree md, lets hope that a knock on of all this means better coaching here. If not just to entice back players but to (more importantly) train the youngsters.
I hope Culina plays well and I hope next season is better than this, but most of all i wld like to see peple such as Pim be convinced of it, and begin to realise the leagues merits. whne Pim says it’s OK then we can be happy the league is OK…
Slippery Jim said | February 20th 2009 @ 9:22am | Report comment
According to the FFA, Austrlian football fans “want to see more football”. Therefore I think the new six team finals proposed for next year should be extended to a ten team finals system to extend the season and keep those fringe Socceroos fit. This is mindful of the eventual 20-team structure of the A-League.
Kazama said | February 20th 2009 @ 9:35am | Report comment
I also agree with md. There’s no risk of Culina taking it easy here, because he obviously wants to keep his spot in the Socceroos squad. Therefore Culina will train and play as hard as he does in Europe, and hopefully this will lead to the rest of the GCU team training at his intensity level and playing at that level. Then if the Gold Coast start playing teams off the park, the other sides will have to lift their game to compete. Ok, maybe it is a bit too much to expect one guy to change the standard of the A-League by himself, but he might start the process. If more current Socceroos like Chipperfield come home then I think it will definitely raise the standard of play here. These guys have to impress Pim to keep their spot – they have to keep playing like they are in Europe – and that can only be a good thing for our league.
Also if Sydney are successful next season maybe it will encourage teams to think about hiring overseas coaches with good credentials – even as assistants and youth team coaches – which again would raise the standard and the profile of the league.
whiskeymac said | February 20th 2009 @ 9:52am | Report comment
You would hope that with players like Moore already here, and with Culina and hopefully Chippers coming, that they wld pass on to their teammates some of these “foreign” training techniques they learnt playing overseas and so that overtime the overall standard wld be improving, as indeed the coaches insist it is.
Millster said | February 20th 2009 @ 10:32am | Report comment
I think you’re onto something there Whiskey – far more than their own contributions, if a good spread of Euro-experienced older guys come back to the HAL and give the youngsters a couple of years of realistic advice, counsel, warnings and encouragement before those youngsters themselves head abroad then that cannot be a bad thing. Plus of course transplant a bit of the techniques and leadership they learned overseas.
Oh, and SJ, what is this about an ‘eventual 20 team structure’? When was this mooted? Is this all to be in one competition level? I must say I hope not – too many teams for our country. My own view is the limit is 12 or 14 in our top tier.
sheek said | February 20th 2009 @ 10:34am | Report comment
I was talking to a work colleague & football fanatic about the Socceroos the other day. I ventured the hope that it would be great if one day the A-League could provide 50% or more of the Socceroos primary squad.
My colleague replied he believed this would eventually be the case, arguing young players were better off playing in the A-League than some obscure comp overseas. He further pointed out European clubs were becoming wary of signing Australian players only to lose them to various qualifiers on the other side of the globe.
My colleague further pointed out, he believed the current standard of the A-league was equivalent to the English 1st Division, which fans would appreciate is the next level down from the EPL. My colleague ventured that Aussie players were better off in the A-league than 1st Division, although at present the money was better in England.
Anyway, it all made sense to me. As for Pim’s remarks, my post is designed to support him. In the short-term, Culina might be leaving himself underdone.
At present, the A-League is a backwater, but hopefully that will change as time moves on. And it’s true, Moore, Culina, Chipperfield, etc returning to the A-League will help the young guys playing with/against them to learn their trade better & quicker.
md said | February 20th 2009 @ 10:40am | Report comment
Sheek – you might have a point about the level of the A-league. I suspect that our best clubs would compete with the bottom half of the table, but over the course of the gruelling season they play would be found out for depth.
The reasons many young Aussies join Championship clubs, is for the chance of doing what the likes of Richie Garcia and Johnny Filan have done – going up with their team and carving out an EPL career.
Cheers
md
sledgeross said | February 20th 2009 @ 10:44am | Report comment
I actually think A League is similar to mid table division one in the UK (I am a Leeds United fan, so I can speak with knowledge about mediocre League 1 clubs!!!)
Slippery Jim said | February 20th 2009 @ 10:48am | Report comment
Millster, if you examine my post carefully you may notice a high ‘tongue in cheek’ quotient
whiskeymac said | February 20th 2009 @ 11:00am | Report comment
am not sure which HAL team wld prosper in the Champioship – of course its all conjecture anyway – yet. I think most wld hope that HAL will one day have the quality and intensity that rival leagues can have – over time it will. its not that bad now, but it will get better…
Pippinu said | February 20th 2009 @ 11:24am | Report comment
sj
I took it seriously too – and I love the idea – 100% of teams in the finals – with a 16 team comp, you get knock out all the way to the final 2 – love it, love it, love it!!
I always knew deep inside you were progressive!
Slippery Jim said | February 20th 2009 @ 11:43am | Report comment
I guess it would be like some Frankensteinian hybrid competition with a doestic cup torso sewn to the head and appendages of a domestic league – the stuff of nightmares for some traditional minded fans, but wet dreams for the FFA marketing suits like Ben Buckley…
Pippinu said | February 20th 2009 @ 11:57am | Report comment
sj
indeed.
Where we might have erred, and I have said this once before, is in our nomenclature.
Let us assume that we had called the first past the post our champion rather than our premier?
You then tack on a separate cup that utilises the finishing spots as a ranking system (nothing new there, sports the world over do it all the time) – and hey presto, you have another bit of prestige silverware to which crowds flock in large numbers (which ultimately, is the name of the game).
Call it what you like. The Golden Toilet Seat will do.
But once we get past this particular mental block – it becomes clear that you can throw any number of teams into that 4, 5 or 6 week intense period of high pressure games (let us call them finals for arguments sake). Half the teams, two thirds, three quarters – even 100%!!
In the end, we didn’t go with that nomenclature – and the Premiership is starting to win me over anyway, i.e. the Premier is the team finishing first.
The Champion – well – they’re better again! (as we have seen from AU too many times, the high pressure environment of finals is not for the meek and ordinary)
The Double – immortals!! The Double Double winners (as MV is about to become) – I’ve run out of superlatives.
Love it, love it, love it!!
Sick Parrot said | February 20th 2009 @ 12:10pm | Report comment
Anyone who thinks the A-League is as good as England’s third tier, really doesn’t know much about the game
jimbo said | February 20th 2009 @ 12:13pm | Report comment
Pimbo and his big mouth – we won’t see Archie Thompson in the A-League next season.
http://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,8659,25080943-5014539,00.html
The NQ Fury may miss out on Chipperfield because of our national team manager’s put downs of the national football competition and not selecting local players for the Socceroos.
In Business, if someone keeps denigrating you in public and causes you loss of prestige and loss of revenue, then you are more than entitled to sue them.
If the FFA aren’t going to take some action to control one of their wayward employees, then I hope the investors in the A-League clubs start talking about legal action – that might help Pimbo consider his works more carefully before opening his big, over opinionated mouth.
Pippinu said | February 20th 2009 @ 12:25pm | Report comment
I’d put up MV against a middle ranking League 1 club without any fear.
I’m not saying they’d definitely win it – but they’d walk off the pitch at the end of the game with their heads up.
Sam said | February 20th 2009 @ 12:35pm | Report comment
Jimbo
I agree with you. I think we should qualify for the World Cup and get rid of Pimbo, and get a coach who can organise and structure a team to play to instuctions. As much as Pim doubts the a-league I doubt his coaching ability. An that is a my honest opinion I’ve had of him since the beginning. I was prepared to offer goodwill and have a little faithin him, but it doesn’t seem to come the other way. Korea shafted him pretty quickly.
As much as the a-league is much more open, I kind of enjoy it like that. I know what Pim’s saying, but he’s just trying to make himself look good.
jimbo said | February 20th 2009 @ 1:03pm | Report comment
No one in their right mind, is going to argue that the A-League is as good as the top leagues of Europe.
Its bloody obvious and the height of stupidity to keep harping on about it. Especially coming from a highly paid employee of the organisation that has invested a lot of time and money in trying to improve it and expand it.
Where it sits in comparison to other Leagues depends on how opinionated you are.
I couldn’t stay awake during last year’s FA Cup final because it was so boring and it’s the world’s showpiece of Cup Tie football.
You can have tremendous entertainment no matter what the competition. Some of the best games I’ve seen are the juniors playing at the park five minutes walk away.
Its all subjective isn’t it and how much you want to big note yourself.
If Bob Bradley, the manager of the USA football team started mouthing off about how bad the MLS was and that all his players should go overseas to get selected in the USA team, how long before the investors in the MLS clubs start suing him, or he loses his job as head coach of the national team?
dasilva said | February 20th 2009 @ 1:11pm | Report comment
Jimbo and Sam
I think it was clear that PIm was talking about Culina specifically
It’s very much a warning to Culina that once your here – don’t slack of off.
Fair enough
Maybe a bit of diplomacy is required and should say that not in front of the media.
However – I’ll say the context behind his commments. He was lecturing in the 2009 FFA Coaching Conference. The title of the lecture was “The differences between Australian and European Football”. He was educating the Australian coaches how the european coaches train their team and how it’s different to how Australian coaches their team. It was after the lecture he was interviewed by the media – the question of culina returning to A-League was a pretty relevant to the topic of his lecture and that’s why he answered that way. Perhaps a mistake? but a pretty understandable one considering he was doing an FFA sanction lecture on the exact same topic.
Greg said | February 20th 2009 @ 1:12pm | Report comment
Pip
A knockout comp including all HAL teams after the season proper is a great idea. A pure knockout, no home & away games.
Jesse
I can remember All Night Dwight’s complaint/observation when he was playing for SFC, that players in the HAL lacked a professional attitude to training unlike his time in England. Pim is obviously of the same view. Culina has a fantastic work ethic, if he continues that in the HAL he will be ok, and hopefully he will be a role model for his team mates. However, he will probably have to do his extra work alone, which is a shame.
Sam said | February 20th 2009 @ 1:23pm | Report comment
Da Silva
Has anybody been honest with Pim in his last coaching effort? If we are going to be brutally honest like he wants to be, we should put the blowtorch on him. I know he’s blown up a few times when people question him on his player selections.
Point is 90% of our Socceroos will come from Europe. We need to make the a-league attractive to the public. People are currently enjoying some of the open games they see. This might not be sufficient for international football, however we are currently seeiong what some of the young Queensland players have to offer which is brilliant. Also Sydney have some exciting youngsters coming through, and Melbourne have been playing smoe exciting football in the last month. It is a good starting point for our young players as it actually encourages them to express themselves. It is also good for the fans who see these younsters mixed in with returning Socceroos, exciting imports and your hardcore club players. I think it is agood mix, and a good enough comp for us to watch here.
Obviously when these youngsters go to Europe this will be when the test comes ala Djite, Burns etc. But Craig Moore showed in the game against Japan that perhaps the level isn’t so bad as Pim makes out, so why would Culina suffer. I think 3 or 4 a-league players in a Socceroos squad will do the team no harm, although I don’t think that will be the case.
phat-boi said | February 20th 2009 @ 1:49pm | Report comment
i think it’s time for Pim to go. yes pim you are the weakest link goodbye.
* yes he has gotten the results but with the quality of our squad, even a fwank farina-coached socceroos
would’ve breezed through these asian qualifiers. the players have gotten the results IN SPITE of pim.
*he has singlehandedly destroyed everything that was great about our national team and the respect
and admiration given to the socceroos from home and around the world. What happend to the very aussie
qualities such as courage, bravery, never taking a backward step, taking the game up to the opposition,
going for the win at all times, etc? sadly these have all but dissapeared under Pim’s overly negative and
cautious style.
* our national team outplayed by the likes of Iraq, Bahrain, China, struggling to cope with minnows such as
Singapore, Indonesia etc. pim has taken aussie football back into the dark ages. One of the saddest nights
was the night Pim turned a Socceroos world cup qualifier into a glorified practice game for the Olyroos and
even then, our Olyroos put on an insipid, lacklustre display that drove thousands into despair.
It is pretty obvious that Pim is just not up to the level required. I cant wait to see him go. I wont miss him.
and I am yet to hear a South Korean with fond memories of Pim.
jimbo said | February 20th 2009 @ 2:16pm | Report comment
Greg,
where is the evidence that Australian players in the A-League aren’t as fit or aren’t as professional as the overseas players?
Who was gasping for breath at the end of the Japan game – Craig Moore, Scott Chipperfield, Lucas Neill?
Was there any noticeable difference?
Remember Craig Moore is the oldest and has played in the A-League for the last 2 years.
Do you really believe Jason Culina will have to train on his own to keep fit?
I would rightfully feel insulted by those comments if I were an A-League player or coach.
Have you ever been to an A-League game?
Cpaaa said | February 20th 2009 @ 2:58pm | Report comment
For those that are on the anti pim train I say just take a little step back for just a moment. As Australians we want to see the best out of our national team everytime, but in world football this is not always possible. There is no second chance, every game counts, 30years of disappointment has taught us that. Pim may not be the worlds best coach but he does know the world game. The game recently against Japan was considered a small victory, a game you will soon forget but the World Cup, qualified or not you will always remember.
What was ever wrong with Pims concern over socceroos returning to Australia
1) the training in australia is not as intensive as European style clubs ( debateable)
2) the amount of matches you will get will be about half (true)
3) more quality coaches are needed (true)
4) competitive football is in the major leagues of Europe. (true)
5) As long as you know… the choice is yours, prove me wrong and best of luck
I disagree with some of Pims selections and tactics, but that will always be no mater who is in charge. What I do love about Pim is that he calls a spade a spade. As long as he continues to point out the issues of the HAL only then can it improve.
So to people like Matheson I say take a chill pill. Everyone is entitled to an opinion, including our national team coach.
jimbo said | February 20th 2009 @ 3:48pm | Report comment
Cpaaa,
Playing more games is not necessarily a good thing, especially as you approach 30 (or over 30).
How often is (or were) Kewell, Cahill, Viduka, Emmerton, Kennedy, Chipperfield, Aloisi, Okon, Ward, Muscat, Rizzo and many others injured while playing for the big overseas clubs.
How many games has Grella missed with injury since he moved to the EPL?
How many injuries is Craig Moore carrying?
Playing once a week in warmer climates is much better for you and your longevity as a player than being knocked around in the frozen overseas leagues up to 3 times a week (sometimes more if you are an international).
In Chipperfield’s case he would be better used by NQ Fury and probably play for longer in the A-League, bring in extra crowds while helping to improve the standard and profile of the A-League.
How is the A-League ever going to improve if we keep bagging it by pointing out all the negative bleeding obvious (especially as the national team manager) telling Socceroos they won’t play for Australia if they come back here and making all our best players go overseas?
Give the A-League players some encouragement and direction instead of using them as excuses.
dasilva said | February 20th 2009 @ 6:05pm | Report comment
1) the training in australia is not as intensive as European style clubs ( debateable)
Actually in top clubs in the top 8-9 leagues in Europe that isn’t very debateable at all.
Guus Hiddink made observations that the A-league players got fatigue a lot quicker. During his boot camp before the world cup
Pim Verbeek makes the same observation as well
I believe when Pim had his training camps he put the A-league players in a “european style” training session and let’s say the player were in a rude shock. The players themselves (I remember it was one of the griffiths) actually said to the media after the session that it was an eye opener and shows how far we had to go and that the training in the A-league wasn’t as intense.
Now people may say the likes of Craig Moore has succeeded. That’s true- he probably brought his same professional attitude and training that he learnt back in europe to the A-league. However is Craig Moore representative of the entire A-league? Probably not as Pim already observed the training session, run camps with A-league players and found them wanting and the players admitted it themselves.
Culina would most likely be as professional as Moore was. However is it wrong for Pim Verbeek to give him caution that Culina must keep fit? Of course not.
I’ll concede that Pim probably shouldn’t have used the media as a vehicle in expressing that.
Nothing he said was wrong though.
Cpaaa said | February 20th 2009 @ 6:37pm | Report comment
Jimbo
Less games can be better, but these questions to Pim had to be asked. Culina and Chippers are first choice Socceroos looking to play in Australia with several years left in their careers, they are not pensioners. Pim had given his honest answer and as I understood it was…
you will still be selected if you can prove you can play at the highest level!
To be fair, HAL is not YET the highest level it can possibly be, and that is the caution.
I do like Pims comments, they are enough to encourage improvement without being too negative. Its better to hear whats wrong with football from football personel, rather than the rebeccas of this world.
So when it comes to the Diet Socceroos in Asian qualifiers, Pim will now have the option of adding a little sugar. Bonus to him, us and the squad. The Socceroos are sitting pretty on top of their world cup group and yet, he can still find plenty of improvements to be made….sounds like my father.
Or is just that European mentality?? Always could be better.
Sam said | February 20th 2009 @ 9:11pm | Report comment
In my opinion Pim would make a great politician. He told everybody exactly what they wanted to hear.. If we qualify for the World Cup then congratulations must be given to Pim. But in my opinion we learnt more about the art of football in the short time with Guus, then we will learn in the next 5 years with Pim.
We need someone to explain to us in detail how to master the art of football like the top nations do. How to play in a formation, how not to play as a team, how not be tactically naive. If Pim can help us with this than it will do much more to help us, than explaining to us how our league is below other European leagues. Does Pim have the knowledge?
Sam said | February 20th 2009 @ 9:12pm | Report comment
Sorry, should be ‘how to play as a team?’
dasilva said | February 20th 2009 @ 9:31pm | Report comment
Sam
I believe that under Pim, to some extent we have achieved some of the goals you listed.
I remember the Asia cup performance and we see a team playing 100 miles an hour in stifling conditions and a team that was not tactically organised where we have been torn apart in the Asia Cup. Al,so remember pure performances against Kuwait away as well as the Denmark debacle
Under Pim – for the most part we play to the conditions. He has demonstrated that under stifling heat or in high altitude we are successfully slow down the tempo, keep the ball, conserved energy and be patient. Sure we had trouble breaking down sides but we improved tremendously then from the Arnold era. Also under Hiddink – never had to deal with the conditions that pim and arnie got.
For the most part we look defensively organised. The performance away in Iraq and China. Whether you agree with his mentality or not for those matches – you have to concede that the opposition had only like 1-2 chances in the entire match and we were very successful in defending and keeping possession. Also we won away in stifling heat in Qatar and a tough away trip to Uzbekistan. Under most Australian coaches I’m convince we would have
There were a few shockers like Bahrain, Ghana, Iraq at home (incidently the 3 worst performance from a non-a-league or olympic socceroos team, are matches we won) but they were the exception and you can’t say we didn’t make any progress or learn anything under Pim.
So yes – pim has teach us to play in formation, as a team, and be less tactically naive. It’s just it’s not as pretty as people like.
Sam said | February 20th 2009 @ 9:50pm | Report comment
Da Silva
The only performance I can say Pim’s tactics had a true influence was against Uzbekistan. And I think that is because we were well prepared. We were only troubled in that game to a small degree. The Qatar games were won mostly thanks to Josh Kennedy (lol). All the other games I don’t want to talk about.
I am still giving Pim time. He did work under Hiddink after all. I will make up my mind after the campaign. I do think we are thin in defence, so I can see the problems he would be having. I just wish he would be more constructive and detailed in his analysis of our football. Although I suppose a technical director should be more involved in these issues. I just think sometimes they are stating the obvious, and it is boring the shit out of me!
Green n Gold 2010 said | February 21st 2009 @ 11:42pm | Report comment
sack pim!!!
bring in troussier!!!!!!!!!
jimbo said | February 22nd 2009 @ 10:45am | Report comment
Obie One and Captain Feathersword to the rescue!
http://www.smh.com.au/news/sport/football/verbeek-learns-his-protectedspecies-status-has-its-limits/2009/02/21/1234633127624.html
“You shouldn’t have said that about the A-League,” Captain Feathersword told Pimbo after the national football coaches’ conference.
Even if it is true that the A-League is shit and we train like drunken farts, then who is responsible for improving it?
Doesn’t receding Herr Verbeek as national head coach and national football team manager (based right here in Australia) take responsibility for improving it.
What measures or suggested improvements has Pimbo put in place in the 18 months he has been employed by the FFA? – SFA.
dasilva said | February 22nd 2009 @ 10:55am | Report comment
Actually the responsibility is with Mr Berger the new technical director
In any case
I think Verbeek invited all the A-league coaches to watch his training session. He then gives advice to all the a=league coaches on training sessions and tactics (clubs are playing 4-2-3-1 more often since Pim joined here) also advice to Adelaide United during their ACL campaigns.
Sam said | February 22nd 2009 @ 11:07am | Report comment
If it is true that Pim was angry at the FFA about being grilled by the media, then he only said what people wanted to hear as I had thought. He more than likely did not want to answer questions.
You have to develop a culture before you improve the standard, and for this we have to draw people to the game. Like it or not the league has to be entertaining. Australia differs to other mentalities around the world. Once the culture is developed you can work from there to improve the standard and people will be more accommodating once they learn what the game is about.
It seems people like Craig Foster criticize mostly for the sake of criticizing. This to me becomes destructive over time. Believe me it is happening to rugby league now, and it has a snow ball effect.
Midfielder said | February 22nd 2009 @ 11:33am | Report comment
Jimbo
Much more interesting from the same article …Hmmmmmmmmmmm Obie One (FL) and the Dark Knight (RM) wonder what they where talking about with K07 there as well …..
http://www.smh.com.au/news/sport/foo…633127624.html
Now that’s a cheer squad
Cosy chats we’d love to have sat in on: FFA chairman Frank Lowy, Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and international media mogul Rupert Murdoch. During a recent dinner with Lowy and Rudd, Murdoch referred to Australia’s national team as “our beloved Socceroos”.
dasilva said | February 22nd 2009 @ 6:03pm | Report comment
Midfielder
DId you see the world game today?
what did you think about the coverage of FFA coaching conference.
I thought it was pretty good
I wish there’s a bootleg or lecture audios of Pim Verbeek 2 hours lecture explaining his detail on his reasons on tactics and selections for the japan match as well as how he trains the players. It would be a fascinating watch.
and people say Pim doesn’t offer suggestion for improvements to Australian football.
Midfielder said | February 22nd 2009 @ 8:10pm | Report comment
Das
I did it was well balanced and I think Pim is even starting to grow on Fozzie … actually Les was not there today not saying anything but then again Pim said what Fozzia has been saying for a while… What was interesting was the chosen guest come in and ad libed and Pim and co came prepared … still nothing about the three training academies..
I have a mate at SBS … he asked me to personally email some of the stuff I have about the academies and he is going to personally hand it to Fozzie watch the next few weeks.
Midfielder said | February 22nd 2009 @ 9:02pm | Report comment
Das & Others
I must have missed it in the papers but and Australian team is playing in China in a couple of hours broadcast on FTA all over China … it’s a warm up game … expected massive audience BTW … AFL Nab cup nay, NRL pre season nay,
Actually its the Mariners http://www.footballaustralia.com.au/2009InsideFFA/default.aspx?s=insideffa_newsfeatures_newsitem_new&id=26703 … funny how it missed the papers
Chinese on menu before Asian smorgasbord
Friday, 20 February 2009
by Mariners Release
Central Coast Mariners_625×195
Central Coast Mariners
© Getty Images
The Central Coast Mariners will accelerate preparations for their maiden AFC Champions League tilt in the most fitting fashion possible next week, with a two-match tour of China confirmed on the back of a pair of friendly fixtures closer to home.
The Mariners will take on recently promoted Chinese Super League (CSL) side Jiangsu Sainty at the Kunshan Sports Centre on Saturday, 28 February before clashing with reigning CSL champions and fellow AFC Champions League qualifiers Shandong Luneng at the Shandong Provincial Stadium on Tuesday, 3 March.
With the Mariners’ first AFC Champions League away date against CSL challengers Tianjin Teda, these matches will provide the yellow and navy with an ideal opportunity to familiarise themselves with the culture and the conditions of the world’s most populous nation, with both trials set to be played out in near 0°C temperatures at world-class arenas.
Furthermore, the Mariners’ clash against Shandong Luneng at the 43,700 seater Shandong Provincial Stadium will be broadcast live on China Central Television (CCTV) – showcasing the Mariners and the Central Coast to China’s phenomenal potential television audience of some 1.2 billion.
Before departing for China, the Mariners will take on reigning Queensland State League champions Sunshine Coast FC at Budgewoi’s Frank Millington Field this coming Sunday, 22 February at 10am before clashing with northern rivals the Newcastle Jets, again at Frank Millington Field, at 11am on Tuesday, 24 February.
“We’re very serious about success in the AFC Champions League and these warm up matches will provide us with the perfect preparation for the adventures that lie ahead for us,” said Mariners Executive Chairman Lyall Gorman.
“Ahead of our trip to Tianjin in mid-March, there is simply no better way to prepare our playing group and coaching staff for the challenges that we will face in adjusting to the Chinese culture and conditions, which could prove to be most beneficial in bringing home some valuable competition points.
“We thank the people at Golden Star International for their efforts in co-ordinating this trip for us, where we will further expand the Central Coast Mariners brand to an overwhelming audience and build upon our preparations for the AFC Champions League.”
Jiangsu Sainty and Shandong Luneng are each warming up for the new CSL season, which kicks off in late March.
Jiangsu Sainty will be competing in the CSL for the first time in their 15-year history, having secured promotion from the second-tier Chinese Jia League last season.
Representing the Jiangsu Province of China’s east coast – home to a staggering 75,495,000 people, Jiangsu play out of the stunning 60,000 capacity Nanjing Olympic Sports Centre, which was the main arena of the 10th Chinese National Games in 2005.
Reigning CSL champions Shandong Luneng have long been one of China’s most consistent club sides and their domination of the most recent CSL season, where they lost only three of their 30 league matches, was a fitting statement of a club that is among the most ambitious in China.
Since 2004, when well travelled Serbian coach Ljubisa Tumbakovic took charge, Shandong have claimed five trophies – the most famous of which being their CSL titles in 2006 and 2008.
Aside from their host of local internationals, Shandong is home to experienced imports from Serbia and Venezuela, while off the field, Shandong attracted the highest average crowd in the CSL in 2008 – 26,501.
Shandong have encountered Australian opposition twice previously, having defeated and drawn against Adelaide United in the group stage of the 2007 edition of the AFC Champions League.
“We’re now three weeks away from kick off against Pohang Steelers at Central Coast Stadium and the buzz and excitement about the club and the Central Coast is tremendous,” said Gorman.
“Like never before, we have an opportunity to make an impression on the world stage and these preparations will ensure that we have done our utmost to give ourselves the best possible chance of success.”
Match Details
Central Coast Mariners vs. Sunshine Coast FC
Frank Millington Field
Sunday, 22 February
Kick off 10.00am
jimbo said | February 23rd 2009 @ 11:48am | Report comment
Mid,
the way they run the Mariners on the smell of an oily rag, if they were to make the final of the ACL and the World Club Cup an amass all those millions, will they turn into the Seaside Bling.
Greg said | February 23rd 2009 @ 1:11pm | Report comment
jimbo
You asked me, a couple of days ago (sorry to reply so late), if I had been to an A-League game, and what evidence did I have for my views on the fitness of A-Leaguers v those in Europe. Yes I have been to A-League games. They were entertaining games and the crowd are vocal and enjoying it (Sydney and Newcastle home games), but the standards are not up to those I see in the EPL etc.
By the same token, the A-League games are a better standard and product than NSL games. I used to watch Parramatta Power home games.
Still, I prefer to watch our local product, live or on pay TV, rather than watch EPL etc, because I feel a closer connection to our local league that Europe. I like the Fox commentary too. But the standard is less. That doesn’t mean its less enjoyable.
I am told, thru the media, by Pim, York and others that the training standards as less intense here. The players play less games in our comp too, so would be less match fit. I am not bagging the A-League, just being realistic.
Craig Moore is an exception to the rule imho. But I also think he lifts levels for the Socceroos these days. He played much better v Japan than he did v Adelaide on saturday night.
Matthew Hall has written a good article for his SMH blog today, he is of the same view as me.