By Geoff Lawson
February 23rd 2009 @ 6:28am
Related coverage
Australian cricket rests with rookies
The cricket caravan travels far and wide at a dizzying clip these days. One day at the “G” the next at Wanderers.
It seems like only last week that the Australians were celebrating wildly among themselves in the hallowed dressing rooms at the SCG their ego saving, nail biting win over the Proteas (well, up until Lara commanded her Michael to leave join her for champers).
And yet this Thursday the protagonists will be each other throats again – at proper cricket that is.
I haven’t heard any local punters sigh that they are sick of it, the contest between numbers one and two in world cricket has been compelling through our southern summer.
It should be as riveting a few thousand kilometers west . The football seasons can wait a few months more until we sort out this ‘number one in the world’ issue, but can Australia really turn around a declining if not plummeting form line?
New men have been called to the trenches, some fresh faced kids with hardly a whisker to part and others who are nearing 40 yet have not walked into a Test match battle.
Both Philip Hughes (the wrinkle-less one) and Bryce McGain (he really should wear a beard) will mostly likely debut at Wanderers. There have only been two openers selected for the tour and only one specialist spinner, obviously done that way so competition between players for spots won’t distract them from their goals.
Very consistent selection philosophy from the four wisemen I must say. Whatever you do, DON’T challenge anyone for their position, it could make them nervous and therefore not play to their potential.
It’s a revolutionary system that is the direct opposite of ’survival of the fittest’, that’s been working so brilliantly since McGrath and Warne retired.
Bryce McGain might argue that since he is the only legspinner left standing in Australian cricket (yes, I know Cullen Bailly has just gotten back into the Redbacks Shield team after a long absence) so he is the fittest!
A debut at the batting paradise of a postage stamp in Johannesburg against the inform home batting lineup will a challenge of the highest quality for McGain. If bowling might be tough for one new man then batting may be a bit easier for Hughes, if he can get past the early bombardment from an attack that were too good for Hayden et al on Australian pitches.
Hughes is certainly being thrown in at the deep end when the selection of a tested veteran like Chris Rogers would have been far more sensible. No doubt Hughes is a great prospect and he may make the biggest step without too much trouble just as his opposite J P Duminy has done, but even given a couple of more years in first class cricket and maybe some Australia ‘A’ tours he would eventually get a lengthy Test career started.
If he fails in this series where do Australia go for openers? A hopefully fit Phil Jaques or a man with a mountain of runs on English wickets, Chris Rogers?
South Africa have made the unenviable decision to leave their vice captain on the bench. Ashwell Prince is a very good batsmen who has steadily improved at Test level to become reliable against all types of bowling on all varieties of pitch and yet his hand injury before the Perth Test brought forth a debutante who has taken to Test match cricket like a research scientist to a carbon emissions project.
Australia once boasted of such great depth that Damien Martyn, Adam Gilchrist, Stuart MacGill, Brad Hodge and Mike Hussey could get nowhere near the first XI.
Times have changed, and the world champion mace may change hands as well unless the Australian rookies get their acts together in a real hurry.
Get Australia's best Cricket opinion emailed daily.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...


(3)
![Like him or loathe him, as I presume Lote Tuqiri now does, it’s clear John O’Neill rules Australian rugby with a firm hand. (I was going to say “he casts a long shadow”, but that is true only very late in the day!)
I was even going to put O’Neill in my list of “Top [...] Andrew Jones: The Next 5 things on John O’Neill’s To Do list](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/next-five-things-john-oneill-th.jpg)
![The Twenty20 Big Bash is going to take over the Australian summer, not because Twenty20 cricket is so great, but there is a void that needs to be filled.
The way it currently stands, there isn’t that much cricket played between November and February. So what there is, is horribly stretched out.
So much so that the [...] David Wiseman: Big Bash could be the saviour of Australian cricket](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/twenty20-can-be-fun-th.jpg)
![To see Adil Rashid, Ravi Bopara and Owais Shah represent England in the first one-day international (ODI) against Australia at The Oval last Friday is the inspiration behind this post.
All three have Indo – Pak origins although only Shah (6 Tests and 61 ODIs for England) was born in Karachi, Pakistan.
Like Test players Mark [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: England’s foreign-born Test cricketers](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/englands-foreign-born-cricketers-th.jpg)
![The Wellington Phoenix are kicking and screaming for their very existence, and doing a damn good job of it. A sell-out crowd of 32,792 watched them defeat Newcastle 3-1 in extra-time to book their place in the preliminary final against Sydney FC for the right to face Melbourne Victory in the Grand Final.
It was an [...] Adrian Musolino: Rise of the Phoenix gives us a true trans-Tasman rivalry](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/wellington-phoenix-tim-brown-th.jpg)
![As the fallout from Tim Cahill’s stoush with News Limited continues, what is becoming clear is the relationship between sports stars and the media, especially in the current climate of trash tabloid stories, is being damaged. As a result sports stars are being more guarded with their media dealings and the fans are losing out. [...] Adrian Musolino: We can’t have sports stars bypassing the media](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/ffa-cahill-th.jpg)
![Am I the only person writing on Test cricket these days? After seven One-Day Internationals in England, the ICC Champions Trophy starts the South Africa today, then the Airtel Champions Twenty20 in India starts on October 8, followed by more Fifty50 ODIs between Australia and India in India.
Test matches will recommence in November.
But [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: Short history of foreign-born Australian Test cricketers](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/ipl-mutant-symonds-th.jpg)
![I was lucky enough to get back to Australia for the festive season and, while I’ve just returned to Europe, my time home got me thinking about the changes our game is going through.
It was interesting to see how Australian football has developed over the last seven or so months, and to compare things with [...] Davidde Corran: Five things I’d like to see change in the A-League](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/a-league-failing-online-fans-th.jpg)
![When Australia walked onto the ‘GABBA against Sri Lanka in November 2007, it was the start of a new era. No Warne and no McGrath. All the talk was how this team was going to regularly take 10 wickets. Immediately the critics were hushed as Australia won the match by an innings and 40 runs.
Brett [...] Benjamin Conkey: The best rebuilding cricket team ever](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/test-cricket-struggling-fifty50-india-ponting-th.jpg)
![There are Test matches and there are testing at matches. Pakistan versus Sri Lankan at the National stadium in Karachi last week looked to be extraordinarily testing to all concerned, not least the poor bowlers who toiled on the unforgiving and relentless playing surface.
I can recall English seam bowler Paul Allot’s description of the [...] Geoff Lawson: Green wickets are vital for Test cricket](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/graeme-smith-green-wickets-th.jpg)
![The chief executive of the ARU, John O’Neill, went out of his way to praise the efforts of Phil Coles, Kevan Gosper and John Coates in getting the IOC’s executive board to select Sevens Rugby as a new Olympic Sport, along with golf.
The implication in the praise is that Sevens Rugby will offer an opportunity [...] Spiro Zavos: Gold, gold for Australia with the new Olympic Sports](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/gold-australia-olympics-beijing-th.jpg)
![FIFA uses the Confederations Cup as a warm-up for the World Cup, which is good given the problems that have already sprung up. But the off-field issues don’t concern me as much as the on-field ones do.
Egypt is furious after Brazil was awarded a penalty on the basis of a video replay that was screened [...] David Wiseman: FIFA turns a blind eye when it comes to new technology](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/fife-turns-blind-eye-th.jpg)




drewster said | February 23rd 2009 @ 10:45am | Report comment
Yes Geoff, The rookies wil have to do a good job or Australia will be embarresed by the end of the tour. North made a fair start in the warm up game with twin 50’s no and a 6 wicket bag in the second innings which you would think will give him a start in the first test, Hughes got 50 in the second innings, although against a side not exactly packed with international players but a fair return for a first hit out.
If Clarkes back doesn’t come good, Then What? Talk about a bare cupboard (Replacement batsmen on tour).
Good Luck Boys! I’ll be cheering (and praying) for ya!
O'Neill said | February 23rd 2009 @ 9:52pm | Report comment
Absolutley correct were the selectors to pick Phil Hughs regardless of how he performs in the up coming tests. He one of the best performed domestic batsman and more importantly young and enthusiastic. If they had of picked Rogers i’m certain you would have called the selectors gutless for not going with Hughs.
Your opinions are well founded and mostly accurate, but try writing a positive piece at some stage.
sheek said | February 24th 2009 @ 8:39am | Report comment
Historically, Australian cricket has tended to introduce young players in mostly desperate times. During the carnage of the 4-1 shellacking in 1928-29, the selectors introduced 20-year-old Don Bradman & 19-year-old Archie Jackson.
In 1970-71, following a 4-0 drubbing by the Saffies & during a 2-0 loss to the Poms, the selectors introduced 23-year-old Rod Marsh, 22-year-old Greg Chappell & 21-year-old Dennis Lillee.
Of course, the selectors have also selected young guys during good times. As the Aussies were ascending in 1991-92, they gave 22-year-old Shane Warne his spurs, despite avergae first class results up to that time.
Phil Hughes & Marcus North, both particularly, will energise the Aussies cricket team, reinvigorating the senior men. I can’t say the same for Dean Bollinger & Andy McDonald, who frankly, I don’t see as long term prospects. But Peter Siddle is another with a bright future.
That’s the way it goes, some debutants go onto great careers, others will fade quickly. Back to 1970-71, Marsh, Chappell & Lillee were the debutants to forge great careers.
Spinners Terry Jenner & Kerry O’Keeffe enjoyed several years in the sun without either reaching great heights. But other debutants from 1970-71, Alan ‘Froggy’ Thomson, Ross Duncan, Tony Dell & Ken Eastwood, all faded quickly.