By Geoff Lawson
March 2nd 2009 @ 6:07am
Related coverage
Green wickets are vital for Test cricket
There are Test matches and there are testing at matches. Pakistan versus Sri Lankan at the National stadium in Karachi last week looked to be extraordinarily testing to all concerned, not least the poor bowlers who toiled on the unforgiving and relentless playing surface.
I can recall English seam bowler Paul Allot’s description of the 1985 Old Trafford Test strip as ‘22 yards of rolled snot’, and that was his county’s home ground.
Now, I am unfamiliar with the actual flattened variety but his message was very clear in that high scoring draw in which the batsmen plundered and the bowlers plodded. No spin, no seam, no bounce, no joy.
It is a batsmen’s game after all I am constantly reminded.
The current West Indies v England game in Barbados is assuming similar proportions to the southern Sindhi one. Will they ever get Ramnaresh Sarwan out?
Why all this over preparation of the most important piece of apparatus in the noble game?
Is it to do with the batting captains who want conditions to suit their own careers or the administrators who want 5 full days cricket to ensure the gate takings and the TV revenue is at a maximum?
The fans who flock to the new wave of microwaved 20-over cricket only ever get the SMS code, no punctuation and bugger the grammar.
It has its attraction if the technology appeals to you and you need the extra time to download the latest podcast or iTune.
Test cricket needs to deliver its evolving dramas on the well coiffured stage, not brown and naked offerings which give no spark, presents no examination of technique and temperament, rewarding the good guy without ever letting the villain round-out the plot.
Certainly Australia’s steamrolling of opponents during the Warne/McGrath era in three day contests did not bring smiles to the face of sponsors, TV networks and media buyers. The team were happy to have extra days on the golf course but their paymasters sent out instructions to ‘make the game last five days’.
Groundsmen were hauled in before Chief Executives and the law laid down like a ten ton roller on overtime.
In a sporting contest that requires such organic input from sky and soil there is always bound to be inconsistencies, which is a good thing, otherwise we could roll out the artificial turf and sack 90% of the staff. The balance is key to a good contest and the entertainment factor.
So we come to the First Castle (local beer sponsor) Test at the Liberty Life (local insurance company sponsor) Wanderers Ground in Johannesburg.
As I write at the end of day four the match is in the balance, what a lovely thing that is. Australia are in front but never write off the Proteas (no sponsor, just local African flora).
It has been a wonderful match with wickets falling, centuries made by the deserving, catches taken behind the wickets by ‘keepers and slips. Good bowling is rewarded, bad bowling punished on a surface with grass and bounce and life. The ball has spun as well, but sadly the Australia selectors and captain see no need for a specialist spinner.
The fans are not distracted by beach balls, mexican waves and beer snakes because there is always something happening on the field, and the match is a joy to broadcast. Naturally the skill of the participants enriches the plot.
No matter what the result on day five there have been a number of outstanding performances, but perhaps the man of the match award will go to Chris Scott, the man who prepared this playing surface with loving care.
Should cricket be played on artificial grass and ensure the weather isn’t a factor and the players know what they will get across the globe ensuring TV rights and sponsors dollars, or should the game go on with turf and water influencing the progress?
Get Australia's best Cricket opinion emailed daily.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...


(3)
![Losing may not have been an option according to the marketers, but for much of the first half last night, Omani attacking midfielder Fawzi Basheer threatened to shift Australia’s planning post-South Africa from Qatar to Brazil.
Had Hassan Rabea taken the chance that Basheer delightfully teed up for him midway through the half, and had [...] Tony Tannous: Qatar dream alive, but much to do ahead of South Africa](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/qatar-dream-alive-kewell-th.jpg)
![With England due to face Australia for the 8th time in one-day internationals in the past few weeks – and the 15th time in all cricket in three months – it seems an approapriate time to pour petrol on the fire of debate that is surrounding the 50-over game.
The problem, certainly from where I’m sitting, [...] Alec Swann: One day cricket is a case of familiarity breeding contempt](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/ecb-forces-one-day-cricket-james-hopes-th.jpg)
![Of all the conjecture surrounding Robbie Fowler’s shock omission from the North Queensland Fury line-up, not much of it has focused on the reasoning behind coach Ian Ferguson’s decision to change his formation and play a lone striker up front.
“We went down the line of changing my formation to 4-1-4-1 and I just needed a [...] Mike Tuckerman: Is physical football ruining the A-League?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/fowler-smarts-th.jpg)
![There has been an erudite and fascinating discussion taking place on The Roar about my use of the words ‘first five-eighths’ to describe the position on the rugby field of the player standing directly outside the halfback.
This discussion has encouraged me to write this article, setting out my thoughts on what should be the proper [...] Spiro Zavos: When is a first five-eighths actually a number 10?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/dan-carter-video-foul-play-th.jpg)
![Any CEO will tell you that a major risk factor for an organization or industry is the loss of talent. Talent costs money to find and develop, and if you lose it, you not only lose the original investment, but also the knowledge and experience.
It’s a concept that Australian rugby is finding out about the [...] Andrew Logan: Where are all the good coaches? Somewhere else](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/where-are-all-the-good-coaches-ewen-mckenzie-th.jpg)
![Plenty of well wishers have dropped me a line recently in light of a fairly startling turn of events. For the first time this season, Shimizu S-Pulse have moved to the top of the J. League standings.
That the provincial outfit should currently find themselves on top of the standings is of itself no great surprise.
Under [...] Mike Tuckerman: J. League is no answer to A-League’s problems](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/kenta-hasegawa-th.jpg)
![Each week Andrew Jones will select a list of sports people united by some feature other than competence.
This week it is the correlation of their name with their talents. As always (well, since this column started last week) Jonesy welcomes your alternative line-ups.
My Top 5 Apt Sporting Names
1. Usain Bolt (c) – [...] Andrew Jones: The top 5 apt sporting names](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2008/06/bolt-th.jpg)
![UEFA ban Eduardo for two matches for diving, Chelsea are blockaded by FIFA from making any signings until 2011 after illegally poaching Gael Kakuta, and now Manchester United will “appeal for ideas (from fans) as to how to curb (the vile chant directed at Arsene Wenger during the last round of Premier League action).”
Maybe it’s [...] Davidde Corran: Which football chants are acceptable?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/which-chants-acceptable-th.jpg)
![After the much-maligned coverage of the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games, Channel 7 continues to annoy sports fans by delaying its Australian Open night session’s coverage into key states. It’s just another example of how the Free to Air (FTA) networks continually miss the fundamentals of getting sports coverage right.
Queensland, WA and SA viewers have had [...] Adrian Musolino: Free to Air TV still ruining live sport](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/serena-williams.jpg)
![I’ve been in New York for over a week now and I haven’t heard the Big Apples’ Major League Soccer team, the New York Red Bulls, mentioned once, despite being one of the few local franchises currently in season.
Yet, like in Australia, there are signs the world game is thriving.
Last week, pubs [...] Adrian Musolino: Despite the indifference, football is thriving in America](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/06/despite-indifference-soccer-beckham-th.jpg)
![Another Dragons game on the box, so another date with my nemesis. If rugby league is all about rivalries, well, as they say, “it doesn’t get any bigger.”
I’ll cut to chase. What is the story with the Saints fan who holds up the “GST, Great St George Team” sign?
Fair dinkum, it is driving me mad.
The [...] Steve Kaless: The biggest question in Rugby League](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/06/maths-suggests-soward-young-st-george-th.jpg)
![The brutal execution of John Howard’s hope to be the Chief Commissioner for a new independent Rugby League Commission by the Labor Left hard man, the Federal MP Anthony Albanese, was totally predictable.
Rugby league, traditionally, has been the Labor Party in NSW and Queensland at play. There is no way the party is going to [...] Spiro Zavos: Why John Howard is out of his league](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/why-john-howard-league-th.jpg)




drewster said | March 2nd 2009 @ 3:00pm | Report comment
Couldn’t agree more with you Geoff. As much as we all like to see a contest last 5 days there has got to be something there to keep the bowlers interested, A strip with a little bit of life in it keeps the game alive as has been shown in this 1st test in Johannesburg. If you are good enough you will have success, If you are having a bad day you get found out. That is the way a Test Match should be. The batsmen have enough in their favour already these days (Boundary ropes, Limited bouncers) Even up the playing field and selectors might start to pick balanced squads.
Spiro Zavos said | March 2nd 2009 @ 4:44pm | Report comment
Geoff, spoken like a former (very good) fast bowler who had to labour on the slow SCG pitch. There is a limit to how sporty a pitch should be to make an interesting Test. The Wanderers, as you’ve pointed out, allows for good bowling but also rewards stalwart batting.
This is the key. If good batting is rewarded with a predictable bounce, even if it is a bit higher than usual, and a fast outfield then we have the intriquing balance between bat and ball that makes for fascinating watching and great cricket by the batting and fielding sides.
As Geoff notes, the lack of a specialist spinner could rebound against Australia. This is being written before the start of play on the fifth day with the Test very much in the balance.
Davido said | March 16th 2009 @ 1:33am | Report comment
Agreed.
Look at the second test in SA. I watched every minute but it was deadly boring for the last two days.
I wouldnt worry Geoff, the rate the game is going we will be down to 1 over a side in ten years time.