Lynch mob for the Hearts’ coaching role
By Paddy Higgs, 1 Apr 2009 Paddy Higgs is a Roar Pro
- Tagged:
- A-League, Andy Lynch, football
Should – if as expected – the Melbourne Heart consortium be granted the A-League’s eleventh licence, cue frenetic media speculation as the club moves to fill a host of roles from chief executive to boot studder.
But like North Queensland Fury and Gold Coast United before it, the main focus would be on filling the club’s head coach vacancy.
While both clubs appointed Australian-based managers, there is always a case made for bringing in a foreign coach.
Still, there are plenty of local options worthy of consideration.
Take Andy Lynch, for example.
Fans of the Scottish game will recognise the name, but for those not in the know, Lynch is a former Celtic captain best known for his winning goal in the 1977 cup final against auld enemy, Rangers.
Over an eight-year stint with the Hoops, the left midfielder or full-back won three domestic championships, two Scottish Cups and played under the legendary Jock Stein.
The Scotsman was also part of the halcyon days of football in the North American Soccer League, playing for, and later managing, Montreal, as well as an assistant’s role with the Canadian national team.
Lynch came up against the likes of Franz Beckenbauer and former Australian assistant Johan Neeskens, and was briefly touted as a candidate for famous New York Cosmos’ coaching job before the league went belly up.
Lynch then threw himself into football camps, working with the likes of Sir Stanley Matthews and helping develop the Coerver coaching method.
But his life was to take yet another turn when son Simon, a former Celtic striker, clinched a move to Queensland Roar prior to the 2006 season.
Lynch Snr. had visited Australia back in 1978 as part of a Celtic touring team, and remembered the “great welcome” the club had gotten from the Melbourne and Sydney crowds in front of which he played.
Suddenly Australia was on the radar, and late in 2007 he made the move.
With A-League jobs at a premium, Lynch took the coach’s job at Sunshine Coast FC in the new Queensland State League for season 2008.
His reign began well, until personal issues led to his return to Scotland. Under assistant George Cowie, the side went on to win the league.
He returned in time to apply for the North Queensland job, getting through two interviews before losing out to Ian Ferguson.
Lynch called the former Rangers midfielder to wish him all the best, but the snub still hurts.
“It was disappointing not to get it. I really felt I could do that job, no problem at all,” he said.
It’s only fostered his desire to land an A-League job. He’s studied the league closely, and believes he has the nous to succeed. Lynch says he can see the promise of the league but also its limitations, such as a lack of technical ability in emerging players.
“We’ve got to be realistic when we’re watching this A-League and we’re talking about the future of football in Australia. This is only the fourth season of the A-League, and it‘s learning everywhere you go.
“It’s not particularly great football. The fans will admit to that … those who watch the football will admit to that.
“It’s got so much going for it, but you’ve got to crawl before you run. You need more teams to have more personalities in there, so I think it‘s going in the right direction. I’m not just trying to say it because of my own situation, but you can’t have enough experienced coaches.”
Scottish coaches have a long history in Australia.
Four of Lynch’s countrymen will coach in the A-League in the 2009/10 season (Lawrie McKinna, Ernie Merrick, Dave Mitchell and Ian Ferguson) and state leagues are filled with ex-pat Scottish managers.
The development of the A-League has prompted certain sections of the football fraternity to call for a move away from the influence of the United Kingdom.
But Lynch isn’t keen to buy into that argument. He believes that the making of a coach lies in his school of learning and experience, and not by nationality.
“I don’t get into that at all,” Lynch said. “I’d rather me judged as my own person. I’m proud to be Scottish, but that’s nothing to me, that ‘Scottish mafia’ rubbish.”
Time will tell on whether Lynch will get a chance to land his dream job.
But if and when the new Melbourne club comes to beginning its search for its inaugural coach, it could do worse than start at its own doorstep.
Sometimes, all you need to do is scratch beneath the surface.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- A-League, Andy Lynch, football

andanotherthing said | April 1st 2009 @ 8:08am | Report comment
1. I agree… this Scottish Mafia is nonsensical notion – would the same sections of the football commentary complain of Sir Alex Ferguson or or Shankly or Stein were coaching in Australia? or is it not the nationality but the individual (for example to brits of differing pedigree being …Clough versus Butcher) that should be the focus.
2. It’s good to have coaches from all walks of life here – hopefully the locals get a chance too – at least at assistant level so they can learn from the experieced overseas coaches…. be they czech, brazilian or iranian get them in if they can evolve thegame here to the next level and drag the backroom staff and players with them.
3. Melbourne Heart – not a great name ( i hate all these marketing american names mind you), but hopefully it will serve up a good derby and wont struggle to much to live in MVs shadow.
BIGfootBALLS said | April 1st 2009 @ 8:30am | Report comment
‘Melbourne Fart’ more like it! Am I right? Booyow!
Albert Ross said | April 1st 2009 @ 9:13am | Report comment
I have a great idea. They could put a plaque into the footpath somewhere saying “Heart of mid-Melbourne” or something like that. That hasn’t been done before has it?
Jim of Altona East said | April 1st 2009 @ 10:11am | Report comment
Best of luck to Lynch – but when are we going to finally find out when Melbourne Heart gets its licence?
Pippinu said | April 1st 2009 @ 10:29am | Report comment
Maybe when the people behind Hearts are able to put forward more than a half-arsed plan that the FFA can tick off without feeling embarrassed by it all.
Midfielder said | April 1st 2009 @ 10:40am | Report comment
http://www.melbourneheart.proboards.com/
Just getting off the ground Melbourne Hearts Fans Forum
past player said | April 1st 2009 @ 11:56am | Report comment
The pedigree of Lynch would surely make him a leading candidate for most A league clubs.
Melbourne Heart must also consider when recruiting players especially from abroad a high profile name such as ex Celt Lynch would raise the profile especially in the UK.
jimbo said | April 1st 2009 @ 12:18pm | Report comment
Pip,
good to see you Melbonians are going to welcome the second A-League team with open arms.
Give em a chance – the 2010 season doesn’t kick off for another 18 months!
Its expected to be announced this week.
The SMH has reported that Melbourne Victory have oficially withdrawn from the A-League in protest.
Paddy Higgs said | April 1st 2009 @ 12:29pm | Report comment
Jimbo – i thought you could only make Fools Day jokes before noon?
Brian Munich said | April 1st 2009 @ 1:48pm | Report comment
Melbourne “Heart” a bad name? At least it’s a change from those Stateside-inspired epithets that have blighted our landscape in recent times. Fury v2.0 anyone?