Why NRL players must want to play union
By Steve Kaless, 6 Apr 2009 Steve Kaless is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- alcohol in NRL, NRL, Rugby League, Wycliff Palu
131 Have your say

Waratah's Wycliff Palu faces a challenge by South Africa's Stormers Sireli Naqelevuki - AP Photo/Mouton van Zyl
Quick question, which professional footballer faced court last week with the threat of a custodial sentence? An NRL player? BZZZT! Wycliff Palu of the Waratahs.
The player escaped a jail sentence for being caught driving without licence for the second time but will pay a $1000 fine.
What struck me was the media’s treatment of the affair.
There was no talk of him being suspended from matches (even when he was facing court), no handing out of fines, no call for rehab, no one even called him a boofhead.
Even though you must wonder how smart someone is who decides they should still drive even though they are on suspended licence.
He can’t even use the old “I was drunk” excuse.
Instead it was just squeezed into the pages as though it was good news the matter has been dealt with so that the player can get back to playing rugby.
The was even the old line of “he has really learnt from his mistake”. I thought that only worked on first offences?
Can you imagine if this was a rugby league player?
Jake Friend, a player with a handful of first grade appearances as compared to an international representative, has already been hit with a $10,000 fine even before he heads to court.
He also had calls of him handing that cheque out publicly to a charity and had his trip to the wheelchair rugby team played out in public.
But for “Cliffy” everyone was just glad he could again concentrate on his footy.
Isn’t it great to play a game from the right side of the tracks.
None of rugby’s high priests in the media who have been so adept at articulating the moral responsibility of players in the public eye to be cleaner than clean and attacking anyone who goes near defending a league player could even bring themselves to question this player’s stupidity or the fact that his manager clearly wanted to issue forgotten.
The Bulldogs Daniel Holdsworth got himself a full page spread for breaking up a fight on the way home from a night out and the Roosters have had to stand down players who have had a few beers at home.
Rugby players obviously aren’t news worthy.
Clearly the Waratahs have no problem with players facing charges so long as they can perform on the field.
God help an NRL coach who would attempt to argue the same.
Perhaps what was most amazing was that in the few paragraphs on the issue no one mentioned that Palu had a short but unsuccessful stint with the St George Dragons.
Surely it was rugby league’s “culture” that led the Wallaby to become a repeat offender in the eyes of the law.
Rugby so often bemoans the fact that it flies under the radar of mainstream public attention, but here they must be counting their blessings.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- alcohol in NRL, NRL, Rugby League, Wycliff Palu

Wallythefly said | April 6th 2009 @ 8:24am | Report comment
Mate I think what you say about Cliffy not getting much press about this incident is fair enough but the simple truth of the difference in treatment is because not that many rugby players have been caught doing the wrong thing. The press probably see it as an isolated incident rather than a pattern of poor player behaviour evident in league.
oikee said | April 6th 2009 @ 8:29am | Report comment
To be honest with you steve i dont know the guy mentioned. Maybe this is why we dont take any notice, or the fact that nobody is really interested in the goings on in union. Same applies to super league england, they seem to fly under the radar over there. Thank goodness hey!
el_capitan said | April 6th 2009 @ 8:59am | Report comment
When booze has been involved rugby players have had the hard stick wacked aganist them, look at Matt Henjak, scared and tossed to the wilderness.
No I think if the situation was Cliffy was drunk driving then all hell would have fallen on him.
I agree with Wallthefly that the press sees it as an isolated incident rather than common occurance.
hightower said | April 6th 2009 @ 10:18am | Report comment
Who would think that being drunk would make it better when they got caught driving with a suspended license?
Yep Palu stuffed up and got off easy in the press, however he didnt deny it or plead not guilty or blame it on a mate.
Couple of high profile league players have been there own worst enemies trying to avoid dealing with or admitting to their own mistakes.
Michael B said | April 6th 2009 @ 10:48am | Report comment
The number of high profile NRL players far outweigh high profile Rugby players. To become high profile in Rugby, you really need to play super 14 or for the Wallabies. With only 4 teams in Super 14 vs 16 teams in NRL, there is a big difference.
So naturally, the number incidents would likely be higher for NRL. AFL isn’t immune either, there have been a couple incidents this week alone about players bashing people/GF’s. Once again, they have 16 teams like the NRL
I this instance, it does look like Palu got off lightly.
Waterboy said | April 6th 2009 @ 11:31am | Report comment
Ah the rugby apologists trying to differentiate the rugby players misdemeanour from the league players. Nice try gentleman.
I was amazed when I saw how small the article buried deep in the general section of the SMH was.
Funny…….. at the other end of the SMH, rugby and AFL articles are disproportionately large for the interest held by the Sydney public in those sports.
Where are the comments from that buffoon Fitzsimmons now?
sunshinecoaster said | April 6th 2009 @ 11:39am | Report comment
He can’t even use the old “I was drunk” excuse.
Thats got to be one of the most bizarre statements ive seen on the Roar form a columnist,you think it would be better if he was drunk driving?
Sorry mate but driving without a license hardly comes close to what the NRL is going through,but you keep trying to spin it and making strange comparisons.
John Ryan said | April 6th 2009 @ 11:50am | Report comment
You have to remember that the SMH loves Rugger,it reguards Rugby League as something which is there it may be popular but it is really not a game for their type of people.
I like reading the SMH on line because The Worst has not improved and lifts a lot of stuff from the SMH anyway,the SMH wishes deeply that Rugby League would just go away,but then it sells Newspapers,so its in a bit of a quandary,and besides Rugger types just don’t do that kind of thing to well bred, just ask Fitzsimmons.
JimC said | April 6th 2009 @ 12:08pm | Report comment
It’s even worse in the UK. Both RU and RL players regularly appear in court, usually on assault charges related to drinking, fairly typical for 20-something young men these days sadly. The treatment of the two sports is completely different though, with any RL misdemeanours being evidence of some moral degeneracy, while RU players are “unlucky” or “struggle with the spotlight”.
Hypocrisy, snobbery, call it what you will, but the old school tie still counts.
The man said | April 6th 2009 @ 1:29pm | Report comment
The medias hyprocracy knows no bounds and not only in the case you highlighted Steve.
Despite the now tragic outcome of the Brumbies visit to a Durban nightclub in the wee hours last weekend the reasons why the team were there have not been analysed and none of the normally required hollier than though comments in the press – ie what is the club doing letting players be out all night
While I encourage the Brumbies to blow off some steam – one does wonder what the reaction would have been had it been a league team doing the same on an away trip to Townsville with similar results.