By Rich_daddy -
April 12th 2009 @ 5:07am
Related coverage
Call in the Stewards for the Stormers Super 14 decision
After attending the Brumbies Vs Stormers match on Saturday, I left the ground scratching my head. It was not over any referee decision but rather the Stormer’s decision to attempt to kick a penalty instead of going for the try in the dying minutes of the match.
For those of you who didn’t see it, I will set the scene for you.
The Stormers are trailing the Brumbies by seven points with two minutes remaining. The Stormers are awarded a penalty inside the Brumbies half.
If they had kicked for touch they would have been well inside the 22 and have had a strong opportunity the square the match up at the death.
Yet, they decide to take a shot at goal, 40 metres out on an angle, and it has been wet and windy all night.
Perhaps they thought they could kick the penalty, then have another chance at scoring the try all within the space of two minutes.
However, it was a low scoring match and neither team held onto the ball for extended periods. The tries had come from opposition mistakes.
The Stormers had also been outplayed for most of the night.
So the decision to kick for goal in this situation makes absolutely no sense to me. Surely a draw is better than a loss, unless, of course, you want to lose?
This is not like a missed tackle, a knock on or a forward pass which could be choking under pressure. This is a deliberate decision the Stormers made and I believe ensured they couldn’t win but stayed within a try of the Brumbies.
To top it all off, the penalty attempt was missed, but to me that is irrelevant.
If I was a Super 14 official, I would be wanting a “please explain” letter from the Stormers.
Going to the Waratahs v Brumbies blockbuster at ANZ Stadium, Saturday 24 April? If you're keen to meet up with other Roarers, register you interest and we'll keep you informed on the place to meet. Register now.
Get Australia's best Rugby opinion emailed daily.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...


(5)
![Melbourne Victory coach Ernie Merrick had every right to criticise Football Federation Australia and the Asian Football Confederation over the AFC Champions League fixture list.
For a tournament that is supposed to represent the cream of Asian football, neither organisation has acted in the best interests of the game when it comes to the scheduling of [...] Mike Tuckerman: Stubborn AFC are hindering the Champions League](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/victory-acl-ernie-merrick-th.jpg)
![Any CEO will tell you that a major risk factor for an organization or industry is the loss of talent. Talent costs money to find and develop, and if you lose it, you not only lose the original investment, but also the knowledge and experience.
It’s a concept that Australian rugby is finding out about the [...] Andrew Logan: Where are all the good coaches? Somewhere else](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/where-are-all-the-good-coaches-ewen-mckenzie-th.jpg)
![India defeated South Africa by an innings and 57 runs in the exciting Kolkata Test on Thursday to retain her No.1 Test ranking. What turned the Test into a cliff-hanger was the last wicket stand between Man of the Series Hashim Amla and no. 11 batsman Morne Morkel.
They stood between India and victory as a [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: India show why they’re number one in the world](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/harbhajan-singh-india-th.jpg)
![I’ve never read the Book of Revelations in which the signs of the coming apocalypse are detailed, however I’m pretty sure that amongst the plagues of locusts and rivers of blood there was no talk of a Queenslander coaching NSW.
Or in correct parlance, a f***ing Queenslander, and I’m sure none of my northern brethren [...] Steve Kaless: Bennett is no Blue in my book](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/bennett-no-blue-th.jpg)
![The AFL’s might over the Australian sporting landscape is down to nights like the Brownlow. Not the glamour of the WAGS or intrigue of who will claim the medal, but rather the tradition of the event.
The Monday night Brownlow ceremony is the perfect lead-in to the biggest week of the AFL year: the [...] Adrian Musolino: Ablett takes the glory and the 2009 Brownlow Medal](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/ablett-brownlow-medal-th.jpg)
![There is a strange symmetry between environmentalists and rugby league fans at the moment with both groups pinning their hopes and dreams for the future on some meetings being held by their respective world leaders.
Leeds hasn’t seen a makeshift tent city spring up filled with rugby league fans demanding action and binding agreements, but [...] Steve Kaless: Countdown to league’s Copenhagen](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/financial-meltdown-gallop-th.jpg)
![Since the Wallaby winger Ian Williams moved to Japan to work and play rugby for Kobe Steel in 1991, there has been an influx of players and coaches who have followed to ply their trade and experience the intricate and ancient culture of Japan.
The national team, the Cherry Blossoms, are without doubt the rugby Asian [...] Todd Louden: Japanese rugby: it’s just different!](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2008/12/japanese-rugby.jpg)
![Last year, some friends and I settled in at the Oaks in Neutral Bay preparing to watch a Tri-Nations match over a few lagers. There we sat, the repartee flowing back and forth, and the schooners of sponsors product lubricating the collective tonsils to monumental feats of rugby recall.
Every second story began with “Remember [...] Andrew Logan: Ireland Vs Australia, the greatest moment](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/top-five-sportsmen-david-campese-th.jpg)
![If you’re still recovering from unwrapping presents and singing Christmas carols, fear not. There is an escape from the boredom of the season: five great documentaries that not only entertain but also enlighten us about what makes sport so great.
1. Once in a Lifetime (2006)
Narrated by actor Matt Dillon and featuring a groovy 70s [...] Adrian Musolino: The Greatest Sports Documentaries](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/01/m-ali.jpg)
![As 2009 draws to a close, so will end one of the most controversy laden years for NRL off the field. Barely a week seemed to go by without another player being splashed all over the papers for “all the wrong reasons.”
The NRL has steeled itself to get tough on players and clubs in 2010 [...] Steve Kaless: Gambling on matches a risky bet for the NRL](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/nrl-roosters-storm-th.jpg)
![The success of football teams wearing red shirts – including Manchester United, Liverpool, and Arsenal – is no coincidence according to academics.
Their findings suggest that simply wearing a red shirt has given football teams an advantage – thanks to our deep-rooted biological response to the colour.
The research, by the University of Plymouth and Durham University, [...] Chris Court: A red shirt is the key to sporting success](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/manchester-united-th.jpg)
![A couple of Hawthorn fans stood outside AFL House the other night, just before Lance Franklin was set to face the tribunal. They held up a banner carrying a message of support. “Fight the good fight,” it read.
Their message expressed a sentiment that many football fans – Hawthorn and non-Hawthorn followers alike – would’ve felt.
Buddy’s [...] Michael DiFabrizio: Is there a place in footy for the bump?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/is-there-place-bump-ben-cousins-th.jpg)




Nird99 said | April 12th 2009 @ 7:55am | Report comment
I too was at the game and was so shocked to see the decision to kick for goal.
I will add a little more to the scene. The brumbies were well and truly on the backfoot. the times they had the ball in the last few minutes they had either kicked it away or made silly mistakes (as both teams did most of the night). The stormers had been applying more and more pressure as the game ground along. The brumbies looked tired and exhausted.
And as rich_daddy said surely a draw is better than a loss, they would have shared the points instead of getting one for a bonus point. The Brumbie now move ahead on the table and effectively end the stormers chance of semi finals football.
Jerry said | April 12th 2009 @ 12:10pm | Report comment
I just saw it as giving themselves a chance to win rather than draw. Having said that, it was a difficult kick so going for the try might have been a better option.
Greg Russell said | April 12th 2009 @ 9:09pm | Report comment
There was a similar situation in the Waratahs-Bulls match, where K Beale – never a reliable kicker! – was instructed to take a difficult (by his standards) penalty attempt with about 5 minutes to go and NSW 6-20 behind.
What on earth was that about? Realistically NSW’s only chance of salvaging anything from this match was to score a converted try and get a bonus point for a close loss. Kicking the penalty would have brought NSW no closer to that possibility.
Not surprisingly, Beale missed.
Bonza said | April 13th 2009 @ 8:22am | Report comment
My guess is that the SA mentality is that it is best to leave the “tour” with points and rely on home game wins. By taking the shot it runs down the clock and buffers from a loss of the bonus point for being within 7 – the only problem is that they have already had two home losses so chasing a draw might have been better. The difference in effect was 1 point with less risk
Max Lamberto said | April 13th 2009 @ 9:11pm | Report comment
Maybe they’ve been watching too much Test cricket and didn’t know when to stop “batting on”.