The Brumbies win one for Shawn Mackay

 

Columnist

By Spiro Zavos, 13 Apr 2009 Spiro Zavos is a Roar Expert

18 Have your say

Email

Brumbies V Stormers team huddle, photo by Darrell Wallace

There were two plangent moments during the ACT Brumbies – Stormers match, an emotional event that will become known as one won for Shawn Mackay, rather in the Notre Dame tradition of winning ‘one for the Gipper.’

First, instead of a minute’s silence for Mackay there was a minute’s heartfelt applause which continued on for more than 60 seconds. This was a touching and relevant way to farewell a player who simply loved rugby, from playing it, to practicing it relentlessly (apparently his bleep tests were phenomenal) and to coaching the World Champions Australian Women’s Sevens side as a self-described ‘one of the girls.’

Second, after Patrick Phibbs scored the match-winning try for the Brumbies late in the second half he looked up to the heavens as he ran back to the Brumbies half, there were tears in his eyes, as he made his ‘this one was for you Macca.’

Phibbs was close to Mackay. They were part of a very good Waverley First XV in 1999. The side also included Stephen Hoiles and Morgan Turinui.

As it happened I live close to Queens Park where Waverley play their rugby. In 1999 I made my way there to see the home side play St Joseph’s. One of the Waverley coaches strolled across to me and said: ‘Watch our inside centre. He’s a great talent.’

The inside centre was Turinui. He played splendidly and scored, from memory, a couple of tries as Waverley defeated Joeys (I think).

The point is that Mackay was probably playing that day. And while the best of his team-mates still have years to go in their professional careers, he’s been taken away from us.

My ancestors, the ancient Greeks, explained the seemingly unexplainable of why some people die young with the parable of Achilles who was given the choice of a long and boring life or a short and vivid life. Achilles chose to seize the day. In a sense, Mackay will be forever young in the memory of his friends. Whenever we think of him it will be the image of him striding towards the tryline in his Australian Sevens colours, looking somewhat like a runaway Viking …

On to rugby, now. The Brumbies lifted their points on the table to 22, with six teams in front of them and two others, the Crusaders and the Highlanders also on 22 point.

The Brumbies are only 5 points behind the fourth-placed Waratahs who like the Sharks (on 30 points) are the only teams in the top nine who are yet to have their bye.

The Brumbies were helped by one piece of really dumb play by Shalke Burger. Late in the match Burger was charging towards the Brumbies tryline, about 10m out and with only Mark Gerrard (who had missed Jean de Villiers in a similar situation earlier in the game0 to beat.

Burger put in a chip kick! Gerrard could hardly believe his eyes. There was no one chasing the kick and even if they had the dead-ball area at Bruce Stadium is designed for the thin rugby league format.

With minutes from time the Stormers had a penalty from about 40m out. One of the threads on The Roar is critical of the Stormers for taking the penalty shot. But on reflection this was the right decision. The points were actually there on offer to take. There was still time to score a try, if the kick was successful, to win the match in the same manner of the Hurricanes in the last play of their match against the hapless Western Force.

As it happened, Peter Grant, missed the penalty and the theorising became academic. There is talk of Grant being offered a job with the Force next year. Say it isn’t so, John Mitchell. How can Australian rugby develop five-eighths if overseas players take the position from locals?

The Force as it happened did everything to win their match against the Hurricanes, except actually win it. They scored four tries to three. They led by 11 points with about 10 minutes to play.

Then the Hurricanes kicked a penalty. Shortly afterwards they scored a try and Willie Ripia took a lot of time to ensure he converted. This meant that with only a minute or so remaining, the Hurricanes had to score a try (but not a converted try) to win.

The Force rather conveniently gave away a full-arm penalty. Again Ripia was precise with his kick. From a lineout just inside the Force’s 22 the Hurricanes smashed forward and then released Corey Jane, a neat stepper to cut inside Nathan Sharpe to score the try their season needed.

The tournament is so close that if the Force had won they would have been on 23 points and only 4 points behind the Waratahs (with their bye round still open).

The Reds scored a try virtually from the kick-off against the Highlanders. For about an hour their backs looked like ripping the Highlanders apart every time they got the ball. Unfortunately, that was not often enough.

The Reds have to learn that expansive rugby depends on tough, grinding, ball-winning rugby from the forwards.

Then towards the end of the match they started to rely on Digby Ioane for every attack. The Highlander double-teamed him and the breaks he made so effortlessly in the first half dried up.

At the end of the match the Reds needed a try to snatch a victory that should have been there’s if they had played a smart game. The whistle sounded as they were awarded a penalty on the halfway mark. They had no option but to run the ball. But on the second phase Mark McLinden, who played pretty well aside from this mistake, grubber kicked the ball down field where is was joyfully taken in and belted over the touchline.

Why did McLinden put in this kick? James Horwill, after the game, conceded that the wrong option was taken. My feeling is that McLinden was in his rugby league mode. Did he feel that play would be over when the next tackle was made?

Or perhaps he’s being watching too much of the Waratahs who have definitely caught the kickitis disease. I talked with a noted rugby man before the Waratahs match and he told me that the level of skill of the players was incredibly low.

‘Why don’t they practice the skills at training?’ I asked.

He shrugged his shoulders.

At the beginning of the game against the Bulls, the Waratahs made a succession of mistakes that endorsed the criticism of their skills deficiency. Then Ben Mowen broke away. He only had to draw the fullback and pass to the winger for a certain try.

The pass was not given. Mowen was tackled ball and all. Miraculously, however, the Waratahs won the ruck and seconds later there was Mowen with the ball and charging into the Bulls 22 with virtually no defence to beat.

And what does he do? He kicks. Can someone explain to me why fast monsters like Mowen and Burger try a fancy kick near the tryline instead of barging through, over or around a flimsy defence to score?

I got rang up after the game and told: ‘After that terrible display by Waratahs, you’ve got to admit that the ELVs are ruining rugby.’

I told the caller that the opposite was the case. The rugby over the weekend was exciting and generally skillful, EXCEPT for the Waratahs. And the proof of that contention was the final match of the round when the last-placed Cheetahs thrillingly demolished the top-placed Sharks.

The Cheetahs did it with some terrific rugby. Their lineout, particularly, and their scrum were solid. Their loose forwards were everywhere, making tackles, winning the ball and then making charges that threatened to over-run the Stormers, which happened at the end.

Best of all, though, was the way the Cheetahs moved the ball along the line with a sequence of thrilling and menacing backline movements. The two flyers on the wings, Jonji Nokwe and Bjorn Busson, scored three tries between them and exposed the limited, defense-oriented, break-out game that has so far taken the Sharks to the top of the table.

The other aspect of this game that I found intriguing is that Nathan Pearce, the young Australian referee had a splendid game. Three times in the first four phases of play by the Cheetahs he warned the Sharks to move back to behind the last feet in the ruck.

With the Sharks about half a metre further back than what they’ve been allowed this season, the Cheetahs were able to get their wide game going, something that other opponents of the Sharks haven’t been able to do.

Without pushing this matter of non-neutral referees too much, it was interesting that Stuart Dickinson started to hand out full-arm penalties to the Western Force towards the end of their match against the Hurricanes for continual infringement at the ruck and maul.

This was something he did not do when the Waratahs played the Hurricanes at the beginning of the tournament at Wellington and conceded 19 short arm penalties and only a warning about a future long-arm penalty.

The Waratahs crowd, too, after having Dickinson and James Leckie refereeing two home matches against the Chiefs and the Highlanders (both won by the Waratahs) did not enjoy Jonathan Kaplan, an excellent South African referee, handling the match Bulls.

To be fair, though, to the crowd, it was sometimes difficult to work out if the booing was for the referee or for the Waratahs. If it was for the Waratahs, it was well-deserved.

If they want to be title-contenders they have to start playing title-winning rugby, which means more skills and brainpower being applied, and much less kicking.

Are they capable of this type of rugby? If the bottom team in the competition can play so exuberantly and aggressively, surely one of the top teams can do so as well.

Next Saturday’s match against the Force which is to be played at the Sydney Football Stadium (where a run of 11 straight victories for the Waratahs is now over) could provide an answer to the riddle of the Waratahs on why they are so high on the table when they are playing ordinary rugby.

Brumbies V Stormers team huddle, photo by Darrell Wallace