The scary part? Geelong’s only just getting started
By Michael DiFabrizio, 15 Apr 2009 Michael DiFabrizio is a Roar Expert

Max Rooke of Geelong & Nick Maxwell of Collingwood chase the ball during the AFL Round 03 match between the Geelong Cats and the Collingwood Magpies at the MCG. Slattery Images
The hype right now might be about how good St Kilda have been or how bad Richmond have been, but Geelong’s quiet yet unbeaten start to the season is a story in its own right. If you include the NAB Cup, this year the Cats have eight wins from eight matches.
In the season proper, they’ve reversed last year’s grand final result against Hawthorn, withstood a surprisingly-hungry Richmond (if only the Tigers played like that every week!) and last weekend overcame the closest thing they’ve had to a bogey team in recent years, Collingwood.
The latter performance was described by Gary Lyon as the “best win of the season” so far.
It’s a fine start, and it is one made all the more remarkable by the side’s pragmatic approach to early season matches.
You could hardly call it vintage Geelong footy, but the Cats are simply doing whatever they have to do – and little else on top of that – in order to come home with the four points. It’s obvious that, for the most part, they’re not playing at their full capacity.
The aim of peaking around September must be firmly in their minds.
This approach has, admittedly, led to some unconvincing periods of play – such as Collingwood’s first quarter or Richmond’s third – but Geelong’s ability to close out games like few others has made it possible to keep on winning.
You can’t help get the feeling during games that at any moment, their intensity will lift and their opposition will be blown out of the water.
The only real problem areas – not that there have been many – appear to be the club’s defensive stocks and the accuracy of its forwards.
The former may end up being nothing more than a result of the side’s injury woes.
Josh Hunt’s season-ending knee injury has been cause for adjustment and captain Tom Harley is due back in the next couple of weeks, so an end to those troubles may be near.
The accuracy concern has been lingering since the loss to the Hawks last September. However it must be said the Cats have been running extra goal kicking sessions since the pre-season and it may take some time for these to bear fruit. We’ll have to wait and see.
But as extra insurance, the Cats have a wildcard in the form of third-year player Tom Hawkins. The “Tomahawk” showed early signs last week of assuming a role not too dissimilar to Nathan Ablett’s in 2007 – Ablett’s third year at the club.
Evidently, the so-called “problem areas” are another example of the side’s room for improvement.
So far, they’re just getting the job done. It’s scary to think what may lie ahead.
As the season rolls closer to September, their intensity is only going to lift. Add to that the expected return of Harley and Brad Ottens, as well as a couple of young guns taking their games up a notch, and it seems like another stellar Geelong season is on the cards.
Just one question remains, though: can they go one better than last year’s efforts?
Follow Michael on twitter @mdifabrizio
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.

Michael C said | April 15th 2009 @ 6:08am | Report comment
Cling to hope -
the main problem for Geelong is the lack of experienced back up. The last couple of years has shown the salary cap squeeze via the need to clean out the fringe players, such as King, Prismall, Callan, Davanport, Gardiner, McCarthy and Playfair. That it forces Geelong to, should they try to retain the current group, it forces Geelong to build a whole new ‘next generation’, may actually ensure a short turn around at the end of the current ‘era’.
Kurt said | April 15th 2009 @ 7:53am | Report comment
No, they can’t. I find your analysis reasonably unconvincing actually. Far from being a side that is quietly building, Geelong strike me as a team that is a few weeks ahead of other teams in its preparation. I expect they will be top 2 at the end of the home & away season once again, but with the Hawks, Saints and Dogs in better shape for the finals.
Redb said | April 15th 2009 @ 8:41am | Report comment
the loss of Ottens is a big blow to the Cats – Blake is just not up to standard and does bugger all around the ground.
Redb
Forgetmenot said | April 15th 2009 @ 9:38am | Report comment
Hopefully our injured parties recover in time to gather enough experience for the finals. And i really hope that they can win the Premiership once again. Ottens injury gives Blake time to get a lot of experience, and the lack of Harley means that Taylor is taking more of a load than usual, giving him valuable experience as well.
Carn the mighty Cats!!
Redb said | April 15th 2009 @ 9:54am | Report comment
Forgetmenot,
Yeah Taylor has come along very well and looks at home in defence.
Redb
Michael DiFabrizio said | April 15th 2009 @ 10:37am | Report comment
Michael C,
Agree that the depth isn’t as strong as recent years. There is a reliance on youth to fill voids, and that has been met with mixed results. But remember, Thursday night’s game did not feature players like Ryan Gamble, Simon Hogan, Tom Lonergan, Kane Tenace, etc. Not exactly star players, but certainly comparable to guys like Callan, Davenport, Playfair, etc.
Kurt,
I’d be interested in hearing why you think the tackle-happy Saints won’t be spent come September.
Redb said | April 15th 2009 @ 11:06am | Report comment
MD,
St Kilda really have only one credible win against Adelaide to their name. Until they play Geelong or Hawthorn the jury has to remain out. You could probably add Carlton to that as well. Their percentage at the moment is worth a win though, they’ll surely make the top 4, premiership contender? not yet.
Redb
matta said | April 15th 2009 @ 11:22am | Report comment
baaaha.. My god you Melbourne centric boys have short memory’s.
Honestly when is comes to AFL you could pretty much write an article once and use it around the same time each season for a few years.
SAINTS. Give me a break! they will fade as they always do. Couple of good wins and all of a sudden Vic’s are talking them up as decent chances for the flag….gee sounds familiar.
Redb said | April 15th 2009 @ 11:28am | Report comment
matta,
Righto give us your team’s expectations, if your game. If they’re better than Geelong or Hawthorn I might agree with you.
Redb
matta said | April 15th 2009 @ 11:35am | Report comment
hey mate, not at all! I am a Crows man so I expect them to finish in the usual 7th or 8th…..
I just find it funny that year in year out after the first few rounds the same poo come out of Victorian supporters about some teams…only thing missing this year is “Richmond being flag contenders”.
For the record, I dont think anyone is as good as Geelong long term. The Hawks are a great side but last year they really just turned it on when it mattered!
Saints to finish 3rd, 4th or 5th – not hard to do in this comp is it?