It’s all or nothing for a young Blues squad
By Steve Kaless, 24 Apr 2009 Steve Kaless is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- NRL, NSW Blues, Rugby League, State Of Origin

N.S.W Blues Benn Cross is tackled by Queenslands Sam Thaiday and Justin Hodges during game 1 of the State of Origin at ANZ Stadium, Sydney, Wednesday, May 21, 2008. N.S.W defeated Queensland 18 - 10. AAP Image/Dean Lewins
The NSW selectors announced a preliminary squad of 40 players this week for the first State of Origin match and, with any luck, there should be roughly thirteen left standing by the time the series rolls around. Injuries and suspensions for littering and double parking start to take their toll.
Queensland selectors must be having their yearly chuckle at the Blues as they once again look to completely reorder the team.
The Maroons will, like they always do, stick with the same core team, making a few adjustments where it’s deemed necessary.
But that’s not the way it is done in NSW. It is always all or nothing.
My prediction is they’ll go for a fairly fresh side for Game One, they will get beaten, and they’ll then have a side for Game Two which includes Anasta, Mason, Fitzgibbon, Hindmarsh and Ryan.
But if you are going to make changes, you have to make changes. There is no point naming young blokes in form if you then chicken out from naming them in the final side.
Using the list of 40 players at my disposal, this is the NSW side I’d opt for in game one.
1. Kurt Gidley
2. David Williams
3. Michael Jennings
4. Joel Monaghan
5. Jaryd Hayne
6. Terry Campese
7. Peter Wallace
8. Brent Kite
9. Michael Ennis
10. Luke Bailey
11. Ben Creagh
12. Anthony Laffranchi
13. John Sutton
14. Michael Weyman
15. Robbie Farah
16. Alan Tongue
17. Josh Perry
Gidley deserves a spot, and with Brett Stewart out, I’d go for him at fullback. He has plenty of experience there and it allows him to continue his roaming role, which has worked so well for the Knights.
Williams and Hayne get the nod on the wings because they are adept at the high ball and are good finishers. Both are probably a better bet than most when dealing with the aerial threat of Israel Folau, even though they’d still be underdogs.
Jennings and Monaghan are my centres because they are great gap runners and good defenders. Jennings was excellent against Justin Hodges the other week and deserves a shot.
Terry Campese is my five-eighth. He has been the form number six of the comp. Simple as that. He should also offer a good combination with Monaghan.
Peter Wallace gets the halfback role. I think he has a more varied game than Mitchell Pearce.
John Sutton locks the scrum after missing out at five eighth.
He can still look after one side of the ruck and use that much talked about “X factor.” I’d then go for some good yards men to make up for his lack of metres.
Creagh and Laffranchi are in the backrow, good attackers on the fringe and out wide, and 80 minute tackling machines.
Starting up front is no place for rookies, so it’s Brent Kite and Luke Bailey. They have more than a few carries between them.
Michael Ennis takes the hooking role for his mongrel and the fact he can kick goals if required.
The bench has replacement props of Josh Perry and Michael Weyman, who can keep the yards ticking over, while Farah and Tongue offer versatility.
Watch for that side to bear no resemblance to the one that represents NSW on June 3.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
The Crowd Says (8) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- NRL, NSW Blues, Rugby League, State Of Origin

The Link said | April 24th 2009 @ 8:47am | Report comment
Steve – not a bad squad, although its hard to see Bellyache not going for a few favourites like Quinn and maybe Hoffman / Cross. Also i’d have Mullen on the bench instead of another hooker.
I have great respect for Allan Tongue, but also a fear that he will get ragdolled at this level. I’d have a Glenn Stewart / Paul Gallen in the side before him.
oikee said | April 24th 2009 @ 8:59am | Report comment
Good squad, and keep this squad for 2 years at least, win or lose.
The Answer said | April 24th 2009 @ 9:14am | Report comment
The selectors shouldn’t go for Paul Gallen on principle. There is no way a player that gives away the amount of penalties that he does should be playing rep football.
Steve Kaless said | April 24th 2009 @ 9:18am | Report comment
Link,
Fair call Link, Mullen may well be worth a shot. However, Bellamy selections took a bit of beating last year when we opted for the likes of Quinn and Turner. With any luck he may have found some humility to leave the Melbourne boys at home, their form certainly doesn’t demand selection, Hoffman in particular has been off his game this year.
The Link said | April 24th 2009 @ 1:01pm | Report comment
Here’s my 17 (posted elsewhere yesterday)
1. Gidley
2. Quinn
3. Monaghan
4. Cooper
5. Williams
6. Campese
7. Wallace
8. Kite
9. Farah
10. Bailey
11. Laffrainchi
12. Stewart
13. Gallen
14. Watmough
15. Weyman
16. Mullen
17. Tupou
Yeah Steve – mayne substitute Hayne for Quinn. The bench has to have some punch, Watty and Tupou give you this as opposed to Tongue (too small) and Perry (not in good form)
Brendo said | April 24th 2009 @ 1:23pm | Report comment
Steve – surely Anthony Watmough’s form deserves at least a bench spot?!?!? He has the line & tackle breaking ability that NSW sorely need!
oikee said | April 24th 2009 @ 2:11pm | Report comment
Agree with Brendo, you have to include Watmough somewhere.
Greg Russell said | April 24th 2009 @ 4:24pm | Report comment
I would be very surprised it The Link’s starting XIII (which I saw yesterday and have ruminated on for 24 hours) is not the actual starting XIII.
I agree with Steve that Sutton and Creagh are terrific players, however I feel the NSW selectors are almost dutybound to go for the all-incumbent-Kangaroo backrow of Gallen-Laffranchi-GStewart.
I also expect Gallen to be captain, simply because I don’t believe any selector could close his eyes and honestly imagine Kurt Gidley leading a winning team onto the field and holding the trophy aloft.
Hayne is not the player he was a few years ago, so I expect Quinn to be a starting winger. He didn’t do much wrong last year.
Cooper (defence) vs Jennings (speed) in the centers is tough, but one would expect the selectors to remember last year: Qld didn’t score a single try all series on Cooper’s side of the field.
Aside from Watmough on the bench, I think the other three positions are very open.
Warren Ryan speaks very highly of what Mullen has been doing for Newcastle from 14, and we know from two years ago that the NSW selectors really rate him. So as The Link says, he may well make it.
I have huge admiration for Tongue, but I just cannot see how the NSW selectors will find a role for his unique skills.
What is everyone’s fascination with Tupou? When did he last play a good rep game? There are so many good backrowers in NSW that it amazes me that Tupou keeps making it.
As this discussion has illustrated, backrow is the area where NSW has huge depth and genuine superiority over Qld. How can this be turned into wins?
No doubt there will be lots of injuries over the next few weeks, and our discussions will be rendered irrelevant!