Five things we learned from the weekend’s AFL action
By David Wiseman, 12 May 2009 David Wiseman is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- AFL, Collingwood Magpies, Geelong Cats, Jarryd Roughead, St Kilda Saints
Related coverage

Farren Ray of St Kilda evades Sharrod Wellingham of Collingwood during the AFL Round 07 match between the Collingwood Magpies and the St Kilda Saints at the Docklands Stadium. Photo Slattery Images
Two undefeated teams, two teams with one win, and twelve teams within one win of each other. It’s turning out to be a strange old season. Geelong and St Kilda now have a three game gap over the rest of the field. Is everyone else playing for third place?
Collingwood were the latest team to feel the wrath of St Kilda.
Before Round 7, Collingwood’s lowest score for the year was 86 points. Against St Kilda, they could only muster 40 points.
St Kilda needn’t have scored a point after half-time and would have still comfortably won. As it was, they only gave their percentage a considerable fourteen-point boost.
Rumours of their death exaggerated
The obituaries of Fremantle and all associated have now been scrapped as the Dockers have won three games in a row.
Hosting a lacklustre Hawthorn this week, they could make it four in a row for the first time since 2006 when they strung nine wins together. Kudos to Fremantle for getting their season back on track when everyone else was running around like a chicken with its head cut off.
Over 22 weeks, the season is a rollercoaster ride, and therefore it’s critical that people stay grounded irrespective of whether things are going well or not.
You don’t want to get carried away by success at this stage, nor do you want losses to get you down.
But in this instant gratification world we live in, people expect results all the time. This isn’t realistic.
Not so exaggerated with the Tigers
Richmond have followed their win over North Melbourne with two losses.
To add injury to insult, they’re now without the services of Matthew Richardson for an extended period of time. In the revolving door which is Richmond, Ben Cousins was on hand to make his return to the side. Not only was Richardson Richmond’s best player, but he is their heart and soul, so his loss will be massive for the Tigers.
They need to win at least eleven of their next fifteen games to make it to the finals. Given how unlikely this is, the Punt Road brains trust should be working on their plan of succession.
A well oiled machine
Geelong is like the T-1000 from the Terminator: remove one component and another one simply takes its place.
Gary Ablett Jr may have been missing from the team which systematically dismantled the Swans, so that just meant that Steven Johnson, Joel Corey, Joel Selwood and Jimmy Bartel got more of the football.
There are no discernible weaknesses to this team who are playing some exceptional football. People were excited last year for Geelong-Hawthorn. Geelong-St Kilda can’t come soon enough.
Kicking themselves
Accuracy has been a major issue for some teams this year. North Melbourne made the most of their opportunities, kicking 20.5 to Port’s 18.12. Carlton has lost four games this year, and only in one of them did the opposition have more scoring shots than them.
Brendan Fevola’s 23.17 has hurt Carlton as much as it has helped them. Contrast this with Jarryd Roughead, who has kicked 24.5.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- AFL, Collingwood Magpies, Geelong Cats, Jarryd Roughead, St Kilda Saints

Pippinu said | May 12th 2009 @ 10:25am | Report comment
The 6th thing we learned:
The bullies are back in town!!
Redb said | May 12th 2009 @ 11:26am | Report comment
The 7th and forgotten thing, the Bombers beat the reigning premiers by 44 points.
Redb
WA said | May 12th 2009 @ 1:16pm | Report comment
David, I remember reading your column a few weeks ago where you said something along the lines of Fremantle being the biggest joke of a sporting club in Australia. Do you still suggest that?
Redb said | May 12th 2009 @ 3:37pm | Report comment
WA,
Fremantle a few weeks ago did look like the biggest joke of a sporting club but boy have they turned that around. Now we all should have known better and let Richmond keep that title.
Redb
David Wiseman said | May 12th 2009 @ 3:57pm | Report comment
Pippinu – Sure are – the Bulldogs look likely for 3rd place.
Redb I – Not forgotten but I wouldn’t get carried away just yet. Essendon are too inconsistent. The last five weeks they have gone WLWLW. Against St Kilda, you’d think the streak would continue.
WA – I did and to a degree I still stand by it. It just hasn’t been the on-field performances but the recruiting which is infamous. Also they have never hired a coach who had previous AFL head coaching experience. Sure this could be the year they turn it around and if they do – I’ll be the first to take my hat off to them.
Redb II – True. If it wasn’t for their huge fan base they wouldnt be around anymore. It’s crazy to think what South Melbourne/Sydney fans went through for so long. Now the Swans have won a Grand Final and played in another…Who would you prefer to be now?
WA said | May 12th 2009 @ 5:45pm | Report comment
I’d suggest there’s a few NRL clubs, a few NBL clubs, and even a couple of Victorian AFL clubs that are much better placed to be the laughing stock of Australian sport. Freo are strongly entrenched here in the West despite their mystifying recruiting policy and strange reliance on ex-Essendon coaching staff.
Redb said | May 13th 2009 @ 1:01pm | Report comment
DW,
Not getting carried away, but it was an obvious omission from the article.
Redb
Pippinu said | May 13th 2009 @ 1:12pm | Report comment
Caro has written a good article today in the Age about the drop in attendances, pretty much across the board (rds 1 to 7 this year compared to last year) – drop from an average just under 40,000 per game to an average just under 37,000 per game.
It looks like Collingwood has contributed 100,000 of the 220,000 drop off.
Honestly, if Collingwood fans can’t do their bit to keep up attendances – what the hell are they good for??!!
Lazza said | May 13th 2009 @ 1:33pm | Report comment
Pippinu,
Both Adelaide clubs have had falls in their attendances this season. The only way to judge the Melbourne teams crowd support is when they play an inter-state team. Some of them are obviously being propped up by the rest of the league? Even Essendon don’t seem to draw more than 30-35K against inter-state opposition, even for finals. That’s good but not great.
Now we had many articles and ‘opinions’ suggesting that the A-League was heading for oblivion because of a small fall in attendances last season? Is this the end for the AFL as well? Looks like all our Sporting Competitions are going down the gurgler?
Pippinu said | May 13th 2009 @ 1:47pm | Report comment
Lazza
I think the AFL can cope with the attendance average dropping from 40,000 to 37,000 per game – but most certainly it would be a worry if the average were to drop by the same amount the following year.
As you know, the cost structure of an average AFL club is quite high, so a long term trend of dwindling revenues would most certainly hurt most clubs (if that’s what eventuated).