Blues selectors need to show faith in young stars
By Gabriel Knowles, 16 Jun 2009 Gabriel Knowles is a Roar Pro
- Tagged:
- Monday night football, NRL, NSW Blues, NSW selectors, Rugby League, State Of Origin, Terry Campese, Trent Barrett

Johnathon Thurston of Queensland scores a try during the Queensland v New South Wales State of Origin Rugby League game at the Ethiad Stadium in Melbourne, Wednesday, June 3rd, 2009. AAP Image/Martin Philbey
As if we were in any doubt about what controls rugby league, the NSWRL prove it once again. Perhaps they figured that they didn’t cop too much about it last time, so why not announce their State Of Origin team at half-time during Monday night football again?
Sure, there are the commercial realities of the game. But it wouldn’t do any harm to just wait until the game’s over.
At least in that case, if there were any injuries in the Monday night match, we wouldn’t have players coming in and out of the squad.
Mind you, with the squad they’ve picked this time around, the NSW selectors are a decent chance to have that problem anyway. With Jamie Lyon, Michael Jennings and Craig Wing all under injury clouds, the selectors have taken a risk by picking them all.
Jennings is probably the biggest risk considering he hasn’t played since the first Origin and it will be interesting to see who gets the call up out of Joel Monaghan and Josh Morris.
On current form, you’d think Morris might have the inside running.
However, current form and predictability haven’t been the hallmarks of the Blues selectors in recent times.
True to form, just when it looked like they’d show faith in a halves combination for the first time in years, they go and pick Trent Barrett at five-eighth. Now Terry Campese didn’t have the best of games on debut and Barrett isn’t the worst pivot going around by a long shot, but there isn’t a whole between them apart from experience.
Which begs the question, if experience is all of a sudden a factor again, why isn’t the in-form Brett Kimmorley in the side for Peter Wallace?
Wallace’s form hasn’t been so crash hot recently and he was on par with Campese in Melbourne. They both may have played and kicked poorly, but they both also played behind a pack that was only able to get on top towards the end of each half.
That didn’t allow the fresh combination enough time to gel and show what they could do at that level.
Campese will play Origin again one day, but if the selectors thought he was good enough for game one, then they should have stuck with him for at least the series. And at the very least, game two.
Perhaps if they show some consistency, then their team will, too.
Recommend this story.
The Crowd Says (15) | Page 2 of Comments
Have Your Say
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby League articles
- NSW State of Origin 2012 team announced; expert reaction (221)
- Make this the last Origin in Melbourne (165)
- League and Union: we should embrace the different codes (141)
- An answer to Sydney NRL crowd problems? (120)
- Who missed out on NSW State of Origin selection (115)
- That Origin try: Did Inglis score or did the refs get it wrong? (110)
- Brisbane Broncos on borrowed time (104)
- Inglis try was fairly awarded, says Harrigan (29)
- State of Origin revels in ratings records (38)
- NRL miss their big chance in Melbourne (45)
- The Agony and the Agony of State of Origin (51)
- State of Origin Game One: NSW player ratings (37)
- BROWNIE: Blues dominant everywhere except scoreboard (65)
- State of Origin Game One: Queensland player ratings (16)
- State of Origin revels in ratings records (38)
- NRL miss their big chance in Melbourne (45)
- State of Origin Game One: NSW player ratings (37)
- State of Origin Game One: Queensland player ratings (16)
- Why Victoria should never host another Origin match (42)
- Channel Nine cross-promotions: Delta just the tip of the iceberg (15)
- The next century of rugby league (23)
- Explore:
- Monday night football, NRL, NSW Blues, NSW selectors, Rugby League, State Of Origin, Terry Campese, Trent Barrett

June 17th 2009 @ 8:36am
cosmos forever said | June 17th 2009 @ 8:36am | Report comment
Chuck – you can be a player for a club and leave with a big chip on your shoulder, particularly if ex team mates are selectors, coaches of club sides
I don’t actually mind Barrett as a a player but it’s gutless not to stick with the same team. As for the manly players – Lyon – what is the attraction – he was terrible.
June 17th 2009 @ 8:51am
LK said | June 17th 2009 @ 8:51am | Report comment
Cosmos, I don’t get Lyon either. He’s carrying an injury into game 2. I’m worried Inglis is going to carve us up again.
June 18th 2009 @ 8:05am
jason gleeson said | June 18th 2009 @ 8:05am | Report comment
dont worry inglis will carve you up. im glad you have bellyache as your coach hes a toss in every way .
June 18th 2009 @ 9:46pm
fred said | June 18th 2009 @ 9:46pm | Report comment
omeely,mason, merritt, sandow, monaghan, daine laurie, watmough,campbell, mullen, wicks, patten, jennings, hayne, wing, soward, gidley
and this crap the selectors are saying blooding players for origiin say they are good next year, the game only comes around each year !?! you need players that are ready to go, this is just an excuse to say that the blues are going to loose and since no one is going to sack us from being selectors we putting our ourselves in for a 5th straight loss, bad luck !
they are making a mockery of it all.
June 23rd 2009 @ 8:52pm
fred said | June 23rd 2009 @ 8:52pm | Report comment
whoops i missed out covell