Advance Australia Fair
By Mike Tuckerman, 18 Jun 2009 Mike Tuckerman is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- 2010 World Cup, football, Japan football, Nicky Carle, Pim Verbeek, Shunsuke Nakamura, Socceroos, Takeshi Okada, Tim Cahill, World Cup finals
Related coverage
- Football news
- Socceroos news
- Socceroos Fixtures news
- Tim Cahill news
- Socceroos 2014 FIFA World Cup Qualifying news

Australia's Tim Cahill wins the ball against Abe Yuki of Japan, during their final match of the Asia Qualifiers round for the 2010 World Cup, in Melbourne, Wednesday, June 17, 2009. Australia beat Japan 2-1, with both countries having already qualified for next year's World Cup in South Africa. AAP Image/Joe Castro
“First team to qualify, first team to go home” was the joke doing the rounds of the local press after Japan confirmed their place at the World Cup finals. And it was Australia who did just enough to suggest that they might be able to advance beyond the group stages after a 2-1 win over the Japanese at the MCG last night.
It was the curse of Tim Cahill yet again for Japan, as the Everton midfielder reprised his role in Germany to score twice from set pieces.
Following a drama-charged build-up that included allegations of a drunken night out, an emotional Cahill refused to talk to reporters outside the ground after his Man-of-the-Match performance.
Fortunately for Australian fans he let his football do the talking, and it was a gritty performance all round from a Socceroos outfit that conceded for the first time in the final round of qualifiers..
“Typically Australian,” was how tenacious midfielder Vinnie Grella summed up the hard-fought victory, with Grella himself turning in a characteristically understated performance.
After a bright opening, Australia soon succumbed to a Japanese side hoping for Kengo Nakamura to shine in the absence of fellow creative talents Shunsuke Nakamura and Yasuhito Endo.
It was Nakamura’s in-swinging corner that the talismanic Marcus Tulio Tanaka powered home just before half-time to hand Japan the lead at the break.
Yuto Nagatomo’s fascinating duel with Rhys Williams had resulted in the Middlesbrough defender conceding a corner five minutes before the interval, and the powerful Tulio timed his run to perfection to beat marker Cahill to the ball.
It was no surprise to discover that Tulio’s battle with Cahill was one of the most fiercely contested of the night, as the two unflinchingly patriotic players went at each other hammer and tongs.
Cahill returned the favour when he arrowed a header into the top corner from a Vinnie Grella free-kick on the hour mark, although television replays suggest that the first contact actually came from Tulio’s head.
It was Cahill again who saved the best for last, profiting as Japan keeper Seigo Narazaki flapped at a Nicky Carle corner to bundle home the winner.
“Of course they must be disappointed and at the same time they want us to be stronger,” was how Takeshi Okada predicted Japan fans might react to their team finishing second in the group.
There was no such disappointment from Pim Verbeek, who won his duel with former Kyoto Sanga sparring partner Daisuke Matsui, whom Okada excused from a relatively ineffective performance by claiming that Matsui had picked up a knock.
Highly-regarded Shimizu S-Pulse striker Shinji Okazaki also failed to stamp any influence on the game, although strike partner and dead-ball expert Keiji Tamada did have one curling free-kick cleared off the line.
A procession of foul throws prompted gasps in the press box, but anyone that has witnessed a J. League game will be well aware that throw-ins are one aspect of the game that the Japanese are yet to perfect.
Nevertheless there was plenty of technical skill on show, and it was nice to see some of it displayed by our very own Nicky Carle.
The Crystal Palace man has become a cause célèbre for his inability to crack the starting eleven, but if the gifted midfielder’s commitment has come into question in the past, surely a performance that saw him track back and defend as doggedly as anyone dispells such notions.
Humble in the extreme, Carle told me after the match that he was happy to do “whatever the team needs” when quizzed on his preferred role for the Socceroos.
It was that kind of game for Australia – with all involved simply pleased to drink in the big-match atmosphere generated by the 69,238 fans in attendance.
Whether the Socceroos advance to the knock-out stages of the World Cup finals depends heavily on the draw, and there are plenty of kinks in the team still to be ironed out.
But if it’s mental toughness that could ultimately see the Socceroos crawl over the line, then Pim Verbeek’s outfit have got it in spades.
Recommend this story.
Follow Mike on twitter @Mike_Tuckerman

June 18th 2009 @ 10:10am
Pippinu said | June 18th 2009 @ 10:10am | Report comment
You’re right Whiskey – but one doesn’t expect to see it in the modern age.
June 18th 2009 @ 10:10am
Koala Bear said | June 18th 2009 @ 10:10am | Report comment
Lads,
I witnessed the match as a recently new member of the local Palm Beach Soccah club (btw I have written to the club president for a name change) I found the atmosphere very exciting and will return for the big matches…
Nicky Carle was great… A bit heavy legged in the first half tho his touches were sublime and all he needs to do now is believe he belongs in the team.. I see his role as a very good super-sub to come on for the last 20 minutes ahead of Holman at this point in time…
Lucas Neil was brilliant as always as with Timmy of course and Jesus has cemented his claim for the one striker’s role up front… I thought the new lads at the back along with North have nothing new to offer except for the last resort type of players you need when there is no one else to choose…
We urgently need Craig Moore to return as quickly as possible along with our other first choice picks Emmo, Bresh, Chippers, and Wilks… This should fix our appalling miss-directed passing at the back… The inability to hold the ball and control the game at the back was apparent with poor technique… Even the goal scored against us was atrocious with the newcomer standing on the goal post failing to clear the ball at his foot…
In any case it seems we are going to the WC with this one striker formation 4-5-1 and we need to find an extra pacey player to take instead on Maccas… He has nothing to offer in this formation… As being a goal poacher he looks like a gold fish out of his fish bowl … And that’s a shame as I admire his work at Celtic… Unfortunately we don’t know how to play him as a goal poacher who has to have the Calvary to support him from behind and that’s not ever going to happen…
~~~~~~~
KB
June 18th 2009 @ 10:18am
Slippery Jim said | June 18th 2009 @ 10:18am | Report comment
“he was playing out of position” That is the same old excuse that has been used for the last three years – DMF isn’t his position, now left midfield isn’t his position – if you have skill you can play anywhere in midfield surely…
Besidies, I have watched many a Crystal Palace match in which he played out on the left wing (where I prefer to play) so it is hardly a world of mystery for him to be playing five or ten metres to the left of the centre, especially as he is a left footer.
Carle didn’t do enough to convince he is worth including in our South Africa squad, but at least he didn’t disgrace himself the way he did against Uruguay. He still has a lot of work to do to earn a spot that so many others are ahead of him for. The good news is, his work ethic and commitment seem to have turned a corner, and he has a good 12 months to improve.
June 18th 2009 @ 10:24am
Slippery Jim said | June 18th 2009 @ 10:24am | Report comment
KB, I agree, the dude on the post looked knackered, he kept leaning on it like he needed a walking stick! If he was upright and sharp he would have kept that goal out.
I am starting to agree about Scotty Mac. He is great in the system and leage he plays in at club level, and even UCL…but if he’s not working in Pim’s system and the system is here to stay, make no mistake, then I can’t see it changing sadly. Much like Sheva for Chelsea, one starts wondering how much longer to persist in hope he will fire, or when to give him up as unworkable for whatever reason. Some players just don’t fit certain systems and environments.
June 18th 2009 @ 10:40am
DiCanio said | June 18th 2009 @ 10:40am | Report comment
Koala it was Lucas Neil who lost his man which resulted in the goal. I don’t see how you can blame steffanuto for not deflecting a direct header from about 6 yards, You’re better off pointing the finger at Schwatter for for staying on his line or Grella for not clearing a path for his keeper, or hell even Rhys Williams for falling over and giving away the corner in the first place.
The 20 minute period in which we scored 2 goals was exactly how I anticipate the Socceroos to play game in game out, its a shame we can’t replicate it each match or for an extended period of time.
Not helped by the ridiculous sub choices made by Verbeek. Who was playing left mid after Carle was taken off? Saw an immediate downturn in our control of the match not because of the players but the destruction of any sort of formation. Its frustrating that as soon as we pushed up and onto their squad we reaped the benefits, its a shame we only get 20-30 minutes of football for every 90 they are on the field
June 18th 2009 @ 10:46am
Koala Bear said | June 18th 2009 @ 10:46am | Report comment
Much like Sheva for Chelsea, one starts wondering how much longer to persist in hope he will fire, or when to give him up as unworkable for whatever reason. Some players just don’t fit certain systems and environments.
Slippery Jim,
Sheva is a good example; once a Super star in Italy for AC Milan, then to move to the wrong country, wrong club and a manager that does not suit him… Or playing a foreign footballing philosophy that a player can’t adjust to…?
In saying that, he may just return now Carlo is in charge…
we just have to wait and see…
~~~~~~~
KB
June 18th 2009 @ 10:48am
Towser said | June 18th 2009 @ 10:48am | Report comment
Slippery Jim
Regarding Mcdonald. Still remain unconvinced. Nick Carle would get the nod over him for me on last nights performance.
June 18th 2009 @ 10:54am
whiskeymac said | June 18th 2009 @ 10:54am | Report comment
Sj – fair points. but he hasnt had a great deal of time with the NT in the last three years. I am mostly with you on the Carle issue – having not seen him much previously, and re: that backheel fallover game was less than impressed. so I don’t normally climb aboard the Carle bandwagon – and dont put him above the frst choice incumbents (bresh, Cuilna, Kewell, Cahill etc) but
I also believed these last few games provided a good opportunity to give him some reasonable game time. If only to re-evaluate what championship footy has done to his game. He got that. and he did OK. Still harsh to rule him out completely from the time he has had. IMO certainly the performance wasnt anyworse than Holman’s have been – in fact possibly better in that his shot was on target and the corner got a goal.
Re Soctty MC. Good example with Sheva…or Crespo? Sadly not all club footballers are made out for internationals for whatever reason. Robbie Fowler and Ian Wright – great for their clubs, couldn’t reproduce for england to the same level. I hope Scotty isnt in the same predicament…
June 18th 2009 @ 11:02am
Tom said | June 18th 2009 @ 11:02am | Report comment
Its amazing how everyone seems to have a different perspective on Carle’s performance. There are a lot of people who want to see more of his brand of technical skill in the national team, including me. But I just don’t see how a team that relies on a passing, possession game can carry a player who can’t find a teammate with a short ball.
If he somehow finds a way to play first team football at a decent level over the next twelve months somewhere, then hopefully his passing would improve to a level that would allow him to play for the Socceroos.
June 18th 2009 @ 11:07am
DiCanio said | June 18th 2009 @ 11:07am | Report comment
SJ as a left footed Central midfielder I can say that is does make a world of difference playing out on the left, that said I still think Carle had a decent game, a shot on goal, some good corners and decent as anyone in defence (one great slide tackle in particular, Grella’s foul happy legs should take note). He scuffed a free kick and not all of his passes stick, but same can be said about any midfielder on that park. You might not get the consistency of holman etc but you get a bit of inspiration and creativty, a bit of right brain action just like our mate Viduka. Play the player for what he is, not for what he is not.
Cahill as an attacking midfielder is great for getting in the box and on the attack, but his distrubution and playmaking is non existent. Remove one of the holding midfielders and playing a 4 1 4 1 is miles better then anything we are doing now. Hell Culina is good enough going forward, and you have other options in bresciano, holman, carle. Its such an ugly game we play when culina and grella ineffectully dink the ball around the backs, especially with the likes of Cahill as the only central midfilder. When we rose to prominece in the second half you saw more of either Grella or Culina going forward and beating the Japanese to the ball, not just hanging around in our own half waiting for them to run at us.
I’m not championing any player or saying we need to attack attack attack, but the 2 holding midfielders “holding hands” with the 2 central backs is positively useless.