Why league is a winner in the culture wars
By Mick from Giralang, 19 Aug 2009 The Crowd is a Roar Pro
- Tagged:
- country rugby league, Greg Inglis, Les Murray, NRL, NRL grand final, Rugby League
“Anybody who dares suggest that rugby league is not a culture to despise, then they are just as stupid and boorish as the offending players” – Patrick Smith, writing in The Australian newspaper.
Greg Inglis, a country boy, would have known days like these. Everyone would turn up from the town mayor to the town drunk. You see, the local footy team was in the finals.
It could have been any community, from Cairns to Cowra, from Port Stephens to Port Headland. But for the record, it was the Cooma Stallions playing a sudden death semi final against the reigning premiers, the Eden Tigers, last weekend,.
The highways to Cooma, the gateway to the mighty Snowies, wind through barren paddocks. Recent teasing rain had produced a cruel green pick that fooled none of the locals, especially the scrawny sheep.
The drought meant there wasn’t much money around.
“One’ll do ya, it’s not the bloody NRL grand final,” growled the gatekeeper at the Showground, refusing to take money for a young passenger in the car.
The ground was ringed by big-engined four wheel drives, the muddy kind, and utes. There wasn’t a Toyota Prius to be seen.
Thin lipped country blokes with ruddy cheeks and forearms like ships’ hawsers stood quietly, sipping on cans of beer despite the bitter westerly. Some of them coached the juniors earlier that day. Others helped set up the field or supported the club’s fundraisers when there wasn’t much to go around.
They looked at an announcement in the program and made a mental note to attend a benefit night for a family whose breadwinner had fallen ill.
“…a catalogue of incidents which indict rugby league as a sport infested by a culture of booze-fueled infatuation with manhood, manifest in the cowardly mistreatment of defenceless women” – Les Murray, writing on SBS World Game website
Wind-chapped women with more responsibilities than hours in the day gave up their Sunday afternoon to run the canteen. They refused to hand over a meat pie until it was warmed to perfection, and served with a smile and a “Thanks, luv.”
The Cooma fullback was a skinny blond kid who looked as if he should have been playing in the juniors. By the end of the match, he had saved two certain tries by standing his ground between rampaging Tigers’ forwards and the Stallions’ try line.
And yes, there was a bit of biff. The ref gave a penalty and quickly got the game going again, issuing stern warnings on the run. There was no wringing of hands, and the sky did not fall in.
As the day wore on, the graceful old grandstand was taken over by a riot of children chasing footballs and dreams Among them perhaps was an Aboriginal boy with a look of the happy, joyous kind.
Another Aboriginal boy had earlier that week stood outside a big city courthouse among a riot of media.
Greg Inglis had a look of the haunted, hunted kind. Commentators with thinly veiled agendas had already rendered their judgements. Guilty of all charges, your honour, especially the accusation that the dark culture of rugby league could produce no other outcome.
“There is a major cultural problem there, that can’t be disputed now” – The Roar forums.
Of course, someone could have asked the good folk on the wild Monaro about the culture of rugby league. But you see, they haven’t given it much thought.
They’re too busy living it.
POSTSCRIPT: The Cooma Stallions overcame a twelve point deficit to defeat the Eden Tigers and live to fight another day.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby League articles
- An open letter to Channel Nine (107)
- Gallop and some of his precious Sydney NRL clubs must go (101)
- The NRL is back baby! (65)
- The NRL’s scariest players (56)
- The NRL needs a vision (52)
- Federal Court has it wrong on sports broadcast copyright (48)
- Bulldogs setting benchmark for Sydney’s NRL clubs (46)
- New league chief coy on TV deal
- RL Commission was never in doubt, says Searle RL Commission was never in doubt: Searle
- Chalk predicts bright rugby league future
- Clubs must stop knifing Gallop, if commission is to succeed
- Rugby league’s new era: where to now? (23)
- New dawn for rugby league gets underway (11)
- Rugby league commission ushers in new era (3)
- Rugby league’s new era: where to now? (23)
- Federal Court has it wrong on sports broadcast copyright (49)
- An open letter to Channel Nine (108)
- The NRL’s scariest players (56)
- Is the All Stars match increasing the divide? (25)
- Channel Nine needs NRL-cricket ODI compromise (36)
- The NRL needs a vision (52)
- Explore:
- country rugby league, Greg Inglis, Les Murray, NRL, NRL grand final, Rugby League

George said | August 19th 2009 @ 3:33am | Report comment
I think I got lost in translation with this story…… Is this story saying that League is a red neck sport for westy’s who drive ‘big-engined four wheel drives, the muddy kind, and utes’?
If it is then great piece, I couldn’t agree more.
Crosscoder said | August 19th 2009 @ 8:14am | Report comment
Smith is the personification of all that is bad about the press, a pretend moral crusader,when he can’t see his local environs for the trees.
If it is such a redneck sport one assumes the brawls at junior football matches in AFL (one involved a mallet)and death threats in an under 10 match in Tasmania ,are a culture to also to live up to.No comment by Patrick one suspects.
I am sure the rednecks who also play rugby league at Oxford and Cambrdige university are paying heed to Smith’s comments
Patrick Smith say no more, a creature of social convenience and Les Murray needs to look at EPL for some examples of good behaviour.
Of course we on the Roar have all without exception led impeccable lives.I am perfection personified.
Redb said | August 19th 2009 @ 12:54pm | Report comment
Problem is rugby league fans are hypocrits as they quite willing to attempt to tarnish the AFL at every opportunity as some form of revenge for their PERCEPTION of being persecuted by the media.
Apart from that its good to here about grass roots football no matter the code and as Hoy indicated country football binds whole towns together. It’s just a shame so many people are leaving the bush as drought bit by bit destroys these small towns in the great Australian landscape.
Salt of the earth these people from the footballers to the bootstrappers and ladies who man the canteen and fund raise.
Redb
Lewie said | August 20th 2009 @ 8:36am | Report comment
Rugby League fans are the hypocrites???????
Pippinu said | August 19th 2009 @ 8:23am | Report comment
Every weekend throughout the Winter, countless stories like this one are played out across the width and breadth of this big brown land.
By the way, I’ve played aussie rules and soccer in Cooma, both as friend and foe, and let me tell you folks, there days in the middle of Winter when you honestly wish you could be inside by a roaring fire drinking a hot cuppa laced with something.
Hoy said | August 19th 2009 @ 8:45am | Report comment
How can you say that country people with four wheel drives (needed due to actual dirt roads, not pathetic weekend four wheel driving) are rednecks? Come off the grass.
I like these stories about the heart of the game in the small towns and regions throughout Australia. This story can go for all codes of football throughout. People at the grass roots are the bee’s knees in my opinion. Talk about for love of the game!!
The other day on Today they had a story about a team playing AFL that hadn’t won a game in about 3 years or something. They hit the pub and were interviewing people, and they were all saying the local team was the heart and soul of the township, and it had been tough recently with all the losses, but London to a brick, everyone will turn out every weekend they can to support their team.
Now that is support!
Tom said | August 19th 2009 @ 9:06am | Report comment
This was a really well written piece, and I would’ve enjoyed it a lot more if it wasn’t for the implication that just because there are good things about rugby league culture, we shouldn’t try and fix up the bad parts.
The point being made by Smith, Murray and countless Roar forumites is that the misogyny and violence in the game needs to be stamped out. Not that the game needs to be stamped out.
Dogs Of War said | August 19th 2009 @ 10:03am | Report comment
It’s a reflection of society, rather than a “culture”. Not to say more can’t be done, but all sports have the same issues, and it’s education and support which are required, and even then, some people due to there upbringing are still going to misbehave.
The biggest difference is that NRL players have a trial by media before they are found guilty of anything, while AFL players have the media come in to defend them until they can’t anymore, but even then guys like Ben Cousins enjoyed a better run in the press compared to guys like Matthew Johns.
one wise man said | August 19th 2009 @ 10:07pm | Report comment
You lost me when you compared taking recreational drugs to assulting women
There is no comparison between which is the worst one is a crime the other bad judgement
Lewie said | August 20th 2009 @ 8:39am | Report comment
Pippinu said | August 19th 2009 @ 10:23am | Report comment
I dunno – Cuz had to step out of the game for a year and he was never actually found guilty of anything – it was basically trial by video – and the footage of him being picked up by the police (as it turned out, quite unnecessarily) was really quite distasteful all round.
John Ryan said | August 19th 2009 @ 12:16pm | Report comment
I don’t recall Johns being found guilty of anything in a court either,but by God he was crucified by NEWs LTD and the ABC,dont recall the ABC doing a program on Cousins either
Pippinu said | August 19th 2009 @ 12:28pm | Report comment
If they had, what would they have found?
Cuz being harassed by cops unnecessarily? Being taken off in cuffs, with “Such is Life” emblazened across his six pack, without the dignity of being allowed to cover himself up, in full view of the cameras.
I think he copped his fair share of bad press – can anyone truly argue that he wasn’t hounded for an inordinate length of time?
Michael C said | August 19th 2009 @ 2:37pm | Report comment
Why is anyone trying to compare A.Johns and B.Cousins?
The only comparison is that both exposed WADA testing alone to be completely inadequate.
Both got media grilling – - but, Johns came ‘clean’ after he’d completed his career and only after he’d actually been caught in possession – not charged – but, issued with a ‘caution’ (JR – are you trying to claim that being caught in possession and issued a warning is not deemed a proof of guilt? – - surely, a slap on the wrist as it was was still a legally applied slap on the wrist.). Johns then confessed to having a long standing issue with drugs use, depression and it came out the Knights doctor helped him ‘manage’ his problem.
The other – Cousins, whilst playing – never actually got caught – but, perhaps may have had he not complete an iron man course to ‘evade’ a breathaliser – obviously, his club had their suspicions and his actions spiralled to the point where his position was untenable. Even upon being de-registered, he hadn’t tested positive.
A.Johns is still retired, as he was – - never missed a game due to his ‘admissions’. B.Cousins – still playing, and has missed a whole season whilst de-registered and half a season at WCE before hand as they tried to nudge him down the right path.
What’s either got to do with this article??
Perhaps the problem with this article is trying to associate Cooma with the NRL??? That’d be like associating the AFL with a drongo N-W suburbs Melb bozo with a mallet.
The Link said | August 19th 2009 @ 4:34pm | Report comment
Michael C – careful to distinguish between Andrew and Matthew Johns.
Michael C said | August 19th 2009 @ 4:44pm | Report comment
D’y'know what – I’d completely forgotten about M.Johns.
I really didn’t contemplate comparing anything other than A.Johns with Cousins because of the drugs link –
otherwise, M.Johns vs Cousins is a totally different issue so even less deserving of comparison – - because, each issue has it’s ‘institutional’ stakeholders – - i.e. actions against women bring a whole different raft of commentators to a story than does an individual behaving erratically with respect to drugs. Surely people wouldn’t be trivialising by counting column inches in daily papers.
Cheezel said | August 19th 2009 @ 9:12am | Report comment
Great article!
This is what rugby league is all about.
Some parts of the media with agenda’s can’t fool rugby league fans with the rubbish they publish in the papers.
Rugby League may be part owned by a media company but at the end of the day they can’t rip it away from the grip of the people who love the game!
adrien66 said | August 19th 2009 @ 10:32am | Report comment
great article congratulations. And of course it can go for all codes,but bad beheviour of players too…
onside said | August 19th 2009 @ 11:55am | Report comment
The essence of popular journalism is a story that divides opinions down the centre.
The format has forever guaranteed the success of shows like 60 minutes and ACA.
Patrick Smith is capable of excellent writing. Too often though he deliberately jerks
the chain, irritates all parties,divides and conquers.It sells newspapers. For anybody
with doubts about the effectiveness of this time proven formula ,look no further than
this site. Subjects that generate hundreds of responses ,deliberately set out to ask
polarising questions on subjects guaranteed to stir the pot in both camps. A few
days later the same question ,on the same subject,will then be asked in a different
way,and off they go again. Good fun.Dont take it seriously.The media want you too,
because over reaction is quite lucrative.Kaching!
Redb said | August 19th 2009 @ 12:57pm | Report comment
Agree onside, too often Smith’s overly acidic comments just don’t resonate with reality.
Redb
Worlds Biggest said | August 19th 2009 @ 12:33pm | Report comment
Nice article illustrating all that is great about grass roots sport in all sporting codes. BUT ” Why league is a winner in the culture wars “. What do you mean by this and how do you measure it ??.
Pippinu said | August 19th 2009 @ 1:12pm | Report comment
I’m not sure whether Mick necessarily put it up with that title (often the editors add one of their own) – but it really didn’t need such a title.
I suspect that a day at the football in Dubbo is not all that different from a day at the football in Lavington – the game and type of football might be different – but not the atmosphere and the importance of the activity to the respective towns.
This article lets itself down by turning it into some sort of one upsmanship that wasn’t necessary.
MyGeneration said | August 19th 2009 @ 5:07pm | Report comment
If the title was put in by the editors, then it is they creating the one-upsmanship, not the author. The author only uses quotes from Smith and Murray and contrasts them with the reality of this day. So are the editors fomenting code wars?
Pippinu said | August 19th 2009 @ 5:14pm | Report comment
We can only speculate!
MyGeneration said | August 19th 2009 @ 5:15pm | Report comment
Actually, my first thought on reading the article was “Where did the title come from?” It doesn’t match the content.
Pippinu said | August 19th 2009 @ 5:18pm | Report comment
It’s one of the quirky things that can happen when submitting articles – and most of us have learned to live with it – but I agree with you that it doesn’t quite match.
As I’ve said, it’s day out watching footy in the country – and it could describe a 1,000 such events from all over Australia.
Mick from Giralang said | August 20th 2009 @ 4:37am | Report comment
Pippinu: No reasonable reading article could conclude that it’s an exercise in proclaiming superiority over the other codes. On the other hand, I’m always up for a bit of inter-code biff, if you’d prefer.
Mick from Giralang said | August 19th 2009 @ 5:38pm | Report comment
Worlds Biggest: If the heading has puzzled people, that’s my fault not the editors on Roar. I carefully called league “a winner” not “the winner” so as not to give the impression it was having a go at other codes. The point of the heading was to draw attention to the unfair generalisations about culture that are levelled at league by people who do not have a clue what the reality is on the ground. True the bush competition is not the NRL but most commentators who should know better impugn the whole game — and the many good people that are in it — because of the actions of a few.
Crosscoder said | August 19th 2009 @ 1:32pm | Report comment
Patrick Smith who has no trouble letting people know his sporting allegiance,gets the response he deserves.As fans of the other code have no trouble in bagging Roy Masters and the deeds of rl players at times.Maybe both need to have a good introspective look at themselve( tautology).
Hypocrisy resides on whichever side of the sporting border one supports.
When a player has a few too many and is front page news on the telegraph and headline the TV news,one suggests it is no case of a perception of persecution but fact.
Onside .
The trouble is there are many people out there in readership land ,who do take it seripously as though it were gospel.
Michael C said | August 19th 2009 @ 3:03pm | Report comment
Most AFL folk I know roll their eyes when they hear about each Patrick Smith tirade,……I certainly don’t know anyone who buys the Australian so as to read him. If he didn’t get a run on radio SEN with Kevin Bartlett every now and then – and they do that just to fire up people for talkback – then, I’d never have a clue what PS was on about.
So, don’t think that he speaks on behalf of too many people.
Now – does Roy Masters speak on behalf of your good self? or do you roll you eyes at his comments most the time?
MyGeneration said | August 19th 2009 @ 5:12pm | Report comment
The Australian must think Smith speaks for someone. And Roy Masters is not a patch on Patrick for pomposity (alliteration).
Dogs Of War said | August 19th 2009 @ 5:34pm | Report comment
I love Roy, he is prepared to speak up for the NRL, when the CEO and others are afraid to. Mainly against News Ltd, and how much conflict of interest they have managing the game.
onside said | August 19th 2009 @ 3:10pm | Report comment
Dont worry Crosscoder,I’m not immune,they still manage to hook me.