By tony keen
September 6th 2009 @ 2:18am
Related coverage
Qualifying Final Preview: St Kilda v Collingwood
The honours have been shared in the past four clashes between these two sides. St Kilda snapped a two-game losing streak with a solid 47-point win over bottom side Melbourne at the MCG last Sunday. The victory saw them become just the fourth club to win at least 20 games in a season since the 22-round season was introduced in 1970.
They also conceded the least amount of points ever by any side in a 22-game season. Collingwood has lost just two of its past 14 matches – the most recent a 24-point loss to the Western Bulldogs in round 22 which saw them lose third spot on percentage to the Dogs.
MEDICAL ROOM: St Kilda welcomes back ruckman Michael Gardiner from a hamstring injury but defender Matt Maguire (hamstring) remains unavailable. Paul Cahill (ankle) and Xavier Clarke (knee) are out for the season while Jarryd Allen was forced into early retirement due to an ongoing hip injury. For the Magpies, classy midfielder Scott Pendelbury and utility Leigh Brown return from a back injury and illness respectively. Untried youngster Tristan Francis (groin) is the only player on the Pies’ injury list.
KEY MATCH-UPS: Ben Johnson vs. Nick Dal Santo
Dal Santo was infleuntial in his side’s 88-point win over Collingwood in round seven with a game-high 38 possessions and four inside 50’s.
The 25-year-old is damaging with his ability to set up scoring opportunities for his teammates with his clean use of the football.
Limiting his influence will be a key for the Magpies if they are going to contain a powerful St Kilda forward line.
Johnson has been given some big run with roles this season and will be given the job on Dal Santo in what shapes as being a crucial match-up in determining the outcome of this contest.
The Collingwood veteran will need to be switched on defensively for the full four quarters and deny Dal Santo any time or space in which to work in otherwise he will cut the Pies to shreds with his sublime skills.
Harry O’Brien vs. Nick Riewoldt
Riewoldt played a key role in the Saints’ win over the Magpies earlier in the season with 17 disposals, 11 marks and five goals.
If Collingwood is going to have any hope of securing a preliminary final berth they will need to quell the influence of the St Kilda skipper who collected 20 possessions and booted five majors in a semi-final against the Magpies last year.
O’Brien has the athletic capabilities to run with Riewoldt and is also capable of going with him in the air so you would expect him to be given first crack at the Saints star.
If O’Brien is going to have any chance of winning his duel with Riewoldt who is virtually unstoppable on the lead he will need his teammates to suffocate St Kilda’s midfield with their tackling pressure.
Zac Dawson vs. Anthony Rocca
Rocca returns to the side for just his fourth match of 2009 and will be keen to repay the faith shown in him by coach Mick Malthouse.
However, his task won’t be an easy one as he will be matched up by Dawson who kept Rocca to just one goal when these two sides met earlier in the year.
Collingwood doesn’t need Rocca to kick a bag but is important that he creates a contest and doesn’t go to ground otherwise the Magpies will be punished on the rebound.
It is vital for Rocca that he gets his hands on the football early to get his confidence up.
Clinton Jones vs. Dane Swan
Swan has been instrumental in Collingwood’s success this season, averaging just under 32 possessions per game.
The Magpies midfielder is ranked first in the AFL for total kicks and disposals, third for total inside 50’s and fourth for total goal assists.
Shutting down the drive Swan provides through the middle of the ground will be a key for the Saints if they are going to contain the Pies’ multi-pronged attack.
Jones has claimed several big scalps this year and will be keen to add Swan to his list on Sunday.
Swan will need to run hard all day if he is going to have any hope of having an influence on the outcome of the contest as Jones will apply relentless pressure and make him earn every possession.
VERDICT: Although St Kilda were convincing winners in the clash between these two teams earlier in the season the Magpies actually won the clearances and had the same number of entries inside 50 – they just didn’t have the class up forward to capitalise with John Anthony, Alan Didak, Paul Medhurst and Leon Davis all missing from the side. If the Pies are able to at least break even at the stoppages they are more than capable of kicking a winning score against a Saints’ defence that has shown signs of vulnerability in recent weeks.
Magpies by 15 points.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...



![On Monday Tennis Australia votes for its latest President. In the blue corner is the establishment doyen Geoff Pollard, now 20 years at the helm. And in the red corner, with the promise of change, is Paul McNamee, a former professional player and now a gifted and successful administrator.
If Tennis Australia wants to be re-invigorated [...] Spiro Zavos: It’s got to be Paul McNamee for Tennis Australia](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/paul-mcnamee-tennis-australia-th-128x150.jpg)
![I have watched live Test cricket since 1952 (Bombay Test between India and England remembered for centuries by Tom Graveney and my childhood hero Vijay Hazare) and televised Test cricket since 1970 (the Perth Ashes Test when Greg Chappell scored a century on debut).
Both have been experiences to cherish.
But since 1970, television coverage has made [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: Memo Channel 9: show us the batsman’s back!](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/weird-or-wonderful-clarke-th.jpg)
![Willie Mason’s long search for a club has won the ‘drawn out saga of the off-season’ award pretty comfortably. But it seems to be pretty unique by modern sporting standards.
We all like to talk about about clubs having a ‘No Dickhead’ policy, but when a dickhead with particular talent is out there, there is usually [...] Steve Kaless: Mason finally signs, but will it just bring more sighs](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/big-willie-soft-mason-th.jpg)
![Expect a steady stream of positive news stories to come out of the A-League this season. There’s a real buzz about the competition, which kicks off in less than a month.
No where is that more the case than in the west, where Perth Glory are banking on some high-profile signings to return them to [...] Mike Tuckerman: Rejuvenated Perth Glory great for the A-League](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/rejuvenated-perth-glory-rukavytsya-th.jpg)
![If there is one cricketer who gives Pakistan a whiff of a win, it is Boom-boom Six-o-Maniac, Shahid Afridi. In the first ODI against Australia in Brisbane last Friday, he made a difference in the Pakistan attitude by smacking 48 runs off 26 deliveries, belting 5 fours and 3 sixes, with a strike-rate (SR) of [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: Big hitting Afridi should be in the Pakistan Test team](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/never-afraid-shahid-afridi-th.jpg)
![The scoreline of 32 – 19 to the All Blacks against the Wallabies in Toyko did not give justice to how tough this Test was for New Zealand to win. The All Blacks scored two tries to one, admittedly. And the Peter Hynes try was awarded by Mark Lawrence, the South African referee when he [...] Spiro Zavos: Wallabies All Black-ed in a tough Test in Tokyo](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/wallabies-miss-chance-th.jpg)
![While my wife was in labour at Hammersmith Hospital in London for the birth of son number one, we passed the long hours of waiting by playing Scrabble. Such is the word-power and determination of Judy that she only succumbed to a defeat, after many victories, just before she was wheeled away to give birth.
My [...] Spiro Zavos: Scrabble is a five-lettered SPORT](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/scrabble-th.jpg)
![As a contributor to SBS website The World Game, I often find myself perusing the site’s long-standing and mildly infamous forum. A hodge-podge of nationalist flag-waving and juvenile humour, it can be a diverting way to spend a couple of hours.
They’re an unforgiving lot on the forum, quick to highlight mistakes, ready to pounce on [...] Mike Tuckerman: Time to unite ‘new dawners’ and ‘bitters’ supporters](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/time-to-unite-socceroos-th.jpg)
![I have never been more disinterested in a one-day series. Australia wins, Australia loses, who cares? Craig White scores runs, Nathan Hauritz takes wickets. Big deal!
This is a crowded time of the sports year and the care factor for these games is lower than Kyle Sandilands’ approval rating.
All and sundry have acknowledged the demise [...] David Wiseman: Farewell One Day cricket, thanks for the memories](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/botha-got-justice-th.jpg)
![Billy Murdoch has never received so much publicity. Everyone is now fully aware of the fact that Ricky Ponting joins Murdoch as the only Australian captains to twice lose the Ashes in England. As a batsman Ponting is peerless, but how is history going to assess him as a leader?
Instead of damning him, the usual [...] David Wiseman: Ponting will be remembered as a very poor captain](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/ponting-only-current-player-th.jpg)
![In mid-October, I wrote a piece regarding the A-League’s need to better market itself. Here is an example of one area in which the league and teams can drastically improve on.
Social networking sites such as Facebook and Twitter have transformed how we communicate and interact with one another. It also presents businesses, including sporting [...] Adrian Musolino: The A-League failing to engage with fans online](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/a-league-failing-online-fans-th.jpg)
![The Twenty20 Big Bash is going to take over the Australian summer, not because Twenty20 cricket is so great, but there is a void that needs to be filled.
The way it currently stands, there isn’t that much cricket played between November and February. So what there is, is horribly stretched out.
So much so that the [...] David Wiseman: Big Bash could be the saviour of Australian cricket](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/twenty20-can-be-fun-th.jpg)



