Axed McKenzie freed up for Victorian Super 15 job
By Jim Morton, 10 Sep 2009 Jim Morton is a Roar Pro
Ewen McKenzie has firmed as a prime candidate to coach Victoria’s proposed Super 15 team after being a stunned victim of the cut-throat nature of French rugby.
The former Melbourne schoolboy suffered a shock axing as Stade Francais’ head coach just five rounds into the Top 14, a season after he took them to the semi-finals.
Club owner Max Guazzini said the former NSW Waratahs’ message had stopped getting through to his players, a claim flatly denied by McKenzie.
The former Wallabies prop and assistant Test coach, to return to Australia in the coming days, felt he and assistant coach Christophe Dominici were the scapegoats for a slow start to the competition.
Paris-based Stade Francais, the Top 14′s pink-coloured glamour club, sit second last with one win, a draw and three losses.
McKenzie said he and the flamboyant Guazzini were philosophically opposed and he paid the price for perceptions his team wouldn’t draw big crowds to Stade de France.
“We’re at the wrong end of the table but that said two wins and you’re in first place,” McKenzie told Sky Sports Radio.
“We’re not exactly in dire straits but the way the team is organised a lot is around bums on seats for the big games and the owner wanted to do something different.
“This is not an unusual in French sport.
“Often if you’re not getting what you want the public execution of the coach is part of the emotional solutions the French subscribe to.”
McKenzie, educated at Melbourne’s Scotch College, is understood to be on the short-list of potential coaches for the two Victorian syndicates bidding for the new Super 15 license.
He admitted he’d given little thought to his next move but said his situation should serve as a warning with Australian rugby’s moves towards private ownership.
“To me it’s been a lesson. There’s talk of moving to private equity teams in rugby and this has been one of the interesting by-products of private equity,” McKenzie said.
“You are at the whim of a person … which can have a major impact.
“It’s not actually about the coaching. You can’t sack the players so you sack the coach and that sends the message, that’s my interpretation of it.”
McKenzie, who helped recruit Mark Gasnier to the Paris club, is the second Australian coach to have his term cut short at Stade Francais’ after John Connolly took them to two European Cup finals in 2000 and 2001.
“It’s cut-throat and it’s a real test of your coaching ability because you are a foreigner,” former Wallabies coach Connolly said.
“It’s a hard gig, there’s a soccer mentality to it I guess.
“In my first year in France half the (Top 14) coaches were gone by Christmas.”
McKenzie, who took the Waratahs to the Super 12/14 finals in three of his five seasons in charge, lamented how he’d attempted to change the club’s style to suit Guazzini’s crowd-pulling desires.
His team was averaging 30 points a game, the best in the competition, but they also had the worst defence.
“It’s sort of ironic,” McKenzie said.
“I’m being classified as a conservative coach and defence-oriented but that’s what’s letting us down at the moment and in fact attack has been our strength.
“Philosophically we (Guazzini and McKenzie) have been running in parallel and trying to get that to merge but it hasn’t really happened.”
© AAP 2012Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.


Brett McKay said | September 10th 2009 @ 8:25am | Report comment
Does this make it a two-horse race for the Vics, between Mackenzie and Michael Chieka??
Gary said | September 13th 2009 @ 9:57am | Report comment
Don’t forget John Mulvihill, former Assistant Coach of the Force and now Head Coach of Toyota in Japan. He’d be a serious contender if he chose to apply.
Brett McKay said | September 10th 2009 @ 8:29am | Report comment
presumably still a two-horse race between Mackenzie and Michael Chieka, for the Vics’??
Hammer said | September 10th 2009 @ 9:01am | Report comment
Perhaps it’s that perception of being conservative and defence-oriented which may play against him ….
this Vic outfit (if it gets off the ground) is really going to need to hit the road running in order to build interest and maintain it in a market where they’re be swamped by AFL … I’ve doubt they’re recruit strongly and in the process weaken the existing S14 teams – some much more than others …. but will McKenzie be the right fit
Brett McKay said | September 10th 2009 @ 9:06am | Report comment
Hammer, that’s exactly why I raised Michael Chieka’s name (twice, sorry Roar eds). Chieka’s had reasonable success in Europe, but what sort of game does he prefer?? I don’t imagine Victorians would be overly fussed about rugby if whichever coach starts trotting out lines like “win ugly”, and “we don’t care how we look, as long as we win…”
Justin said | September 10th 2009 @ 9:20am | Report comment
He’s from Melbourne so this article is no surprise. You could have put your live savings on this being written as soon as he was sacked by Stade.
Personally I dont think he will be the coach. He may be a decent coach but he would play a conservative game (yes I know about Stade this year but that was against his wishes) and lacks any charisma or PR skills to get the media onside which will be very important.
Lets wait and see IF Melbourne get the side and then who is in charge…
Hammer said | September 10th 2009 @ 10:00am | Report comment
I’d liken the crowd building potential of this Vic outfit to the Warriors in Akld …. much fan fare when they started – got the crowds early – but after awhile dropped off considerably to the diehards once things turned pear-shaped (and remained so – with odd blip) …
McKenzie is not the type of coach to maintain the enthusium – just look how he polarised NSW supporters and administrators – even when they went OK ….
Viscount Crouchback said | September 10th 2009 @ 10:06am | Report comment
Don’t overlook Steve Meehan. His Bath team have played the most exciting rugby in the English Premiership by a country mile.
CraigB said | September 10th 2009 @ 8:26pm | Report comment
thats cause they’re jacked up on Coke! It’s class A it’s OK!!!
Pippinu said | September 10th 2009 @ 10:08am | Report comment
People are intimating that the new Vic team will need to play an attractive enough brand of rugby to get Victorians interested.
Sounds great in theory – but what does that mean exaclty in terms of the Victorian sporting public (most of whom won’t know the difference between a loose head and a blockhead).
What I’m really saying is: don’t discount the value of actually winning games!! I doubt the average Victorian will understand the difference between an ugly win and a meritorious win.
Justin said | September 10th 2009 @ 10:22am | Report comment
Pip I think they will have a fair portion if the crowd that does understand the game. Lets face most people around the world dont really understand it
But I agree winning is more important although doing it with a little more flair than NSW for instance would be nice…
Worlds Biggest said | September 10th 2009 @ 10:17am | Report comment
Brett – Cheika won the Heineken Cup this year and has transformed Leinster into a European power. Given there history of under achievement you would have to say he has done a better than ( reasonable success ) coaching effort. Cheika may have his eyes on the Wallaby job post 2011 and continue in Dublin for another couple of seasons. McKenzie would be a logical choice for the Melbourne Super team.
captain nemo said | September 10th 2009 @ 10:22am | Report comment
VIC super 15 side, Attractive style of play and win more than they lose. easy…..
If I was going to spend my hard earned on this new venture, I would only do it if the team had some type of either financial or player support arrangement with one or two ANZ Cup provinces.
Justin said | September 10th 2009 @ 10:28am | Report comment
Why would that make you go along and watch? Should the team be a feeder for NZ players/clubs? You must be a Kiwi…
captain nemo said | September 10th 2009 @ 10:46am | Report comment
Justin, no mate, I’m not a Kiwi, born and bred in the gong. Like I said champ, if it was my money (which it is not) I would have an alignment with an ANZ cup province or two. Why, 1. we don’t have the abundance of talent here to have a squad of 30 blokes who would compete with teams like the Auckland blues, Hurricanes, crusaders and lets not even touch on the big Afrikkan forwards. If you wanted to have a squad of local boys or even import a few from around oz, you would need to hire the score board attendant from St kilda cricket club. If the team is getting absolutely flogged, it will fail.
Invictus said | September 10th 2009 @ 1:47pm | Report comment
NZRFU would most likely not allow any such accomodation. ARU probably wouldn’t be too keen on it either.
Justin said | September 10th 2009 @ 5:17pm | Report comment
Thanks Champ
Pippinu said | September 10th 2009 @ 10:34am | Report comment
heh, heh, easy as pie!
It would be great if they can replicate what the Brumbies managed – bringing together a cast of rejects and misfits to produce some of the very best club rugby we have ever seen – but geez – let’s not get ahead of ourselves!!