It’s Saints all the way in the AFL finals
By Troy Chaplin, 18 Sep 2009 Troy Chaplin is a Roar Rookie
- Tagged:
- AFL, AFL finals, Geeling Cats, St Kilda Saints, Troy Chaplin

Adam Schneider and Andrew McQualter of St Kilda Saints celebrate a goal during their AFL 1st Qualifying Final victory over Collingwood Magpies
It’s Preliminary Finals week, and it promises to provide some fantastic games. The top four teams will fight it out to play on that last Saturday in September. I still like St Kilda for the premiership, but Geelong have found form at the right end of the year and always seem to play well in big games.
The Saints have been fantastic all year.
Their defensive pressure has been a stand out this season and will help them in the finals series should they maintain this for the remaining two games of the season.
They have had plenty of Finals experience over the past years that should lean in their favour, also.
It is clear that Nick Riewoldt is the most valuable asset to the Saints, and if his form in week one of the Finals Series is anything to go by, he will be simply unstoppable on Friday night.
They also face a selection dilemma that is going to be a huge talking point after the outcome of the game.
Max Hudghton, in my view, would be a better match up against the Western Bulldogs than Zac Dawson. Sure, Hudghton is injury prone. But his endeavour and ability to play on either tall or small players, as well as his Finals experience, will be extremely important against the Bulldogs.
The Bulldogs, on the other hand, have been around the mark for a couple of years now, and when firing, can kick a handful of goals in quick succession which can put the opposition under pressure.
Their ability to play a fast, attacking game style will make the match on Friday night a real spectacle.
They have always been criticised for not having a key forward in Finals time. But the way that they play doesn’t require a key forward, and they have had the ability to kick big scores. So I believe it doesn’t pose as big a problem as people believe.
Geelong hasn’t been as convincing this year as what they have been in previous years, but they are an experienced and skillful side who seems to play well when they need to.
They get Steve Johnson back from injury, which will boost their side dramatically, and the games that Brad Ottens has played over the past couple of weeks are going to hold him in good stead.
I think it will be a Geelong and St Kilda Grand Final as they are the best two teams in this year’s Finals series, as well as the most experienced.
It will be an interesting match up, as Collingwood have played well against them in their past few outings.
Mick Malthouse had some interesting comments to make about both Geelong and St. Kilda last week, but there will also be some heat on him. He has players who will be playing this weekend’s game with injury, and after playing in a handful of finals games, I know that you need to be at your physical best to have the best opportunity to win.
He will come under scrutiny for taking such a risk.
It is going to be an exciting weekend of football, and I look forward to watching with great interest.
They have clearly been the four best teams all year and the games will be great to watch.
Troy Chaplin is a current player with the Port Adelaide Power and a columnist for The Roar.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
The Crowd Says (6) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- AFL, AFL finals, Geeling Cats, St Kilda Saints, Troy Chaplin

Tom said | September 18th 2009 @ 8:47am | Report comment
Yeah, I’m hanging out for a Saints Cats grand final. Anyone who saw that game in July at the Telstra Dome would be.
If its half as good as that it should be a classic.
Republican said | September 18th 2009 @ 11:35am | Report comment
I hope you’re right however I think the Doggies have the grit and game to beat the Saints. St Kildas recent form has not been all that convincing to my eye especially their effort v Melbourne. Then their game v the Pies showed some metal so we Saints supporters continue to live in hope.
Warren Vargas said | September 18th 2009 @ 12:22pm | Report comment
The Saints will shut down the Bulldogs goal supply and will win comfortably, Geelong hasn’t been that impressive even though they beat the Bulldogs, the Bulldogs couldn’t make the most of their opportunities and Geelong doesn’t like teams that put physical pressure on them, if Collingwood can put the pressure on and make the most of their opportunities I think they can get up.
Tom said | September 18th 2009 @ 1:03pm | Report comment
Dogs were average last week. Only kicked away in the third quarter when the Brisbane defenders kept on generously handing the ball back to them.
Will have to play much, much better to beat the Saints.
davelee said | September 18th 2009 @ 6:04pm | Report comment
Collingwood-Saints GF for me.
Michael C said | September 18th 2009 @ 9:34pm | Report comment
Hmmm…..N.Riewoldt knee pending.
I’m watching tonight on tele, and seeing nice placid still conditions all afternoon and into the evening – it suits the doggies down to the ground……..who can run out the game.
Pip must be through his nails by now.