By Tony Tannous
October 31st 2009 @ 2:09am
Related coverage
Old fashioned formation finally delivers Culina points

Sydney FC's team coach, Branko Culina faces the media after their match against Persik Kediri during the AFC Champions League game in Manahan Stadium Solo, Indonesia, Thursday, April 12, 2007. Persik Kediri beat Sydney FC 2-1 AAP Image/Ardiles Rante
It really is a funny old game this football. For six straight games, Branko Culina and his Newcastle Jets played with a back four, dished up some delightful football, and had very little to show for it.
At times, like against Melbourne in round 11, the football was top shelf, with Labinot Haliti and Michael Bridges forging a nice mobile combination up front and Fabio Vignaroli proving to be an excellent dictator of the tempo from deep.
All the while Jin-Hyung Song has been catching the eye with his ability to keep his feet and integrate with his front-men.
At the back Nikolai Topor-Stanley had been doing well, while Adam D’Apuzzo had been alternating between central midfield and left back and doing an admirable job at both.
But in six games the Jets were only able to muster two points.
Much of the blame, according to Culina, was apportioned to the lack of communication between the back three of Ben Kennedy, Topor-Stanley and Ben Kantarovski.
Neither, according to Culina, is a great talker, and, for all the good football, the odd lapse in organisation had undoubtedly resulted in a number of dropped points.
The classic example came in the above-mentioned Victory game, where Archie Thompson and Carlos Hernandez caught out the defence with a couple of rapid sucker-punches.
So last week, in the F3 Derby against the Central Coast Mariners, it was back to basics, with Angelo Costanzo coming into the heart of a three-man-defence, with Topor-Stanley to his left and Kantarovski to his right.
The logic was that Costanzo would be the organiser, responsible for running the team from his deep vantage point.
It has been a strange 12 months for Costanzo. For much of the regular season last year, he was a key fixture in the heart of the Adelaide United defence alongside Sash Ognenovski, and I felt he had both been doing very well.
Suddenly, in the midst of the dramatic and tumultuous end to the season for Adelaide, he was benched, deemed surplus to requirements. Seemingly something was simmering beneath the surface.
In the wash-up to another Adelaide grand final loss, he was released and moved to Newcastle, in time for the Asian Champions League campaign. But even here he has been bit-part at best, both under Garry van Egmond and Culina.
Seemingly, his best days were behind him and he would have to make do with the odd fill-in job.
But with Lubjo Milicevic seemingly on the outer again and Culina in desperate need of some experience and organisation, Costanzo was the man, and had a blinder against the Mariners as the Jets ditched the flowing football for a more rugged and direct approach built on organisation and determination.
As Culina said in the post-match dissection of the win over the Mariners, it was a throw-back to the “old days”, when a sweeper was par for the course.
Indeed, many of Culina’s successful NSL sides featured such a system, and he often found himself struggling to the break-down Adelaide City and Marconi defences marshalled by Costanzo.
Again, last night, in the Jets’ 1-1 draw in Brisbane, Costanzo was outstanding, teaming up with the equally brilliant Topor-Stanley and Kantarovski to shut-out both Sergio van Dijk and Mitch Nichols for all but the equalising spot-kick.
It was far from a classic game and far from a classic performance from either side, but given the dire position both sides found themselves in, and Brisbane’s desperation for points after four straight losses, it was hardly a surprise.
The Roar, now under Ange Postecoglou, showed signs of a neat counter-attacking game last week in Sydney, but without Reinaldo for this one, they were short up front, with Mitch Nichols and Isaka Cernak struggling to get forward and provide the requisite support to van Dijk.
Time after time Tommy Oar whipped in a delightful cross, only for it to be dealt with by Costanzo and Co.
Effective, if not always pretty, the Jets have now picked up four points from six, emphasising again just what a crazy game this football can be.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...

(8)
![The ELVs, the experimental law variations being trialled in the 2008 Super 14 tournament, should have been introduced in 1895.
The laws of rugby union were quickly evolving from 1871 to 1895 to turn the game from a predominately scrumming game to a passing game.
But when the Great Split in rugby occurred in England in [...] Spiro Zavos: The ELVs should have been introduced in 1895](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2008/04/western-force-highlanders-th.jpg)
![How ironic that on the day Australia formally lodged its bids for the 2018 and 2022 World Cups proverbial knives were being sharpened in Kuala Lumpur for the head (Neck? Back? Damn, it’s gonna be messy, whatever happens) of the president of the Asian Football Confederation, Mohammed bin Hammam.
As we saw with Anwar Ibrahim, Malaysians [...] Jesse Fink: The Malaysian fly in Australia 2018’s ointment](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/malaysian-fly-ointment-rudd-salisbury-mccallum-th.jpg)
![There’s been some misguided and unconstructive talk this week that Brazilian World Cup winner Roberto Carlos is looking to join an A-League club.
According to the Australian FourFourTwo website, the Brazilian is looking for a new club once his time at Fenerbahce finishes at the end of this month and Carlos “has employed a local [...] Davidde Corran: There’s no point dreaming about Roberto Carlos](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/theres-no-point-roberto-carlos-th.jpg)
![Ewen McKenzie has firmed as a prime candidate to coach Victoria’s proposed Super 15 team after being a stunned victim of the cut-throat nature of French rugby.
The former Melbourne schoolboy suffered a shock axing as Stade Francais’ head coach just five rounds into the Top 14, a season after he took them to the semi-finals.
Club [...] Jim Morton: Axed McKenzie freed up for Victorian Super 15 job](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/axed-mckenzie.jpg)
![They say the Sydney sporting market is one of the most competitive in the world. Rather, it’s one of the most fickle sporting markets, with such incredible fluctuations in crowd figures across all codes.
But, aside from form, the presence of a star name is the only guarantee of increasing, or at least stabilising crowds, no [...] Adrian Musolino: West Sydney franchises need to find star power](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/robbie-fowler-th.jpg)
![Are the Australian selectors expressing the growing concerns of the greater national cricket punditry by giving Brad Haddin a match in charge of the international team?
Haddin had shown for a number of years at New South Wales that he had the tactical and leadership nous to be a skipper at the elite level. In [...] Geoff Lawson: ACB have had enough of blonde tips and sports cars](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/why-clarke-haddin-th.jpg)
![Wednesday’s decision by the FFA’s Independent Match Review Panel to rescind Iain Fyfe’s red card from Adelaide’s 3-2 loss to Perth was staggering. It hints at an odd softening of the application of the laws by the A-League’s governing body.
Fyfe’s ‘game changing’ sending-off was a contentious moment for many, especially considering Mile Sterjovski’s poor first [...] Ben Somerford: Have the FFA suddenly gone soft?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/gold-coast-expansion-mensink-bleiberg-buckley-th.jpg)
![After almost 20,000 fans packed out Christchurch’s AMI Stadium for last weekend’s Wellington-Adelaide clash, many pundits have been asking whether the South Island’s largest city should be a site for future A-League expansion.
Last Saturday’s brilliant crowd turn-out definitely suggests there is an appetite for football in Christchurch, and with a population of just under 400,000 [...] Ben Somerford: Can NZ accommodate a second A-League team?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/wellington-phoenix-tim-brown-th.jpg)
![The Fox Sports effects microphone has become a fair barometer of an A-League match’s excitement level. When you can hear the players and coaches cussing, it’s a fair indicator that the crowd isn’t really into the match. Sadly, it’s a common occurrence.
Aside from the raucous at Etihad Stadium caused by Melbourne’s passionate and large supporter [...] Adrian Musolino: Lack of atmosphere stifles A-League games](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/33-or-22-rounds-a-league-ryall-th.jpg)
![On the 23rd of March 1895, on a grassy clearing in Northern London, a group of women gathered to make history. Few would notice, and even fewer cared. But history it was. A whistle was blown and 22 women played out the first recorded game of women’s football.
For the record, North London won 7-1 [...] Davidde Corran: Women’s football is finally back in business](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/womens-football-bompastor-sauerbrunn-th.jpg)
![First we had Super June, now it’s the Octoberfest of Football, with the FFA overseeing over 200 games and more than 18,000 minutes of action this month.
Admittedly the vast majority of the games will take place at the national youth championship for our best under 14s and 15s boys, currently being held Coffs Harbour, but [...] Tony Tannous: A mouth watering week of football ahead](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/open-letter-socceroos-th.jpg)
![If there is one cricketer who gives Pakistan a whiff of a win, it is Boom-boom Six-o-Maniac, Shahid Afridi. In the first ODI against Australia in Brisbane last Friday, he made a difference in the Pakistan attitude by smacking 48 runs off 26 deliveries, belting 5 fours and 3 sixes, with a strike-rate (SR) of [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: Big hitting Afridi should be in the Pakistan Test team](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/never-afraid-shahid-afridi-th.jpg)




albe said | October 31st 2009 @ 6:35am | Report comment
it did seem umm… workmanlike for the jets last night. I’m kinda glad to see this outlook from Branko, particularly away from home. He’s much better at adapting a line-up to whats available and the circumstances that week. GVE always seemed to rigid for me.
agree on the potential up front now, Haliti especially is a great pick up and i’m surprised by the energy Bridges is showing!
whiskeymac said | October 31st 2009 @ 8:45am | Report comment
bridge showed some great touches throughout the game but the roar were frustrating -cernak, tiatto etc passing was way off at times. oar was well marked but still managed to getsome great passes… just a ity that nicholls wasnt there for most of them.
Rob said | October 31st 2009 @ 12:05pm | Report comment
Watched the game on the box last night and felt that the Roar is still a bit too disorganised at the back. The goal was a classic example of crap organisation – 4 defenders all sucked towards the one ball carrier leaving a player free wide to pick out Haliti in the box. Mind you, with 3 (count them, 3) Roar defenders clustered around him, you’d think one of them might have actually challenged for the ball.
I think Roar need to find someone else to take free kicks too, beause Cernak sucked last night. Tiatto probably came back a week too early, and now might be out for longer given the way he limped out.
Van Dyke played really well I thought, and Nichols played ok – he isn’t an out-and-out striker, though, which explains why he spent more time dropping into midfield.
I’m impressed by the way the Jets have started to play too – vignaroli looks like he’s taken on the Marquee role now, but i’m surprised I didn’t see Ali Abbas or Kaz Patafta in the starting lineup this week. Bridges is a great acquisition!
Midfielder said | October 31st 2009 @ 5:54pm | Report comment
Tony on the F3 derby … trying to allow for my bias BUT over ten games on that display we would win 7 draw 2 and loose 1…
Its funny if we play like the the Jets do now … we get called names and the Scottish efffect on Australian football.. shall be interesting to see the fair Fozzie comment…
AndyRoo said | October 31st 2009 @ 6:17pm | Report comment
Everyone else has allready said, the Jets were good value for their point but the Roar lack the X factor.
A fit Charlie miller perhaps?
Pippinu said | October 31st 2009 @ 10:03pm | Report comment
The GCU express has completely derailed.
While everyone’s 2nd favourite team continues to rocket up the charts.
Fowler’s first goal looked like a carbon copy of about five other goals he’s scored this season!
When are defenders going to learn?? He runs in late boys – you gotta watch him – half a sniff and he nails them mothers every time!!
Chook said | November 2nd 2009 @ 9:25am | Report comment
NJ certainly commanded thier defensive line and BR didnt really look like scoring, it where all teams start from a good defensive structure. But the BR had one dimension to attack via Tommy Oar, (which isnt a bad thing as he certainly is a very capable player and is only getting better) But I think that the cross into the box isnt going to work with NJ unless you have them on the back foot. If you can commit the Italian bloke forward there is room behind him for a smaller quicker player to do the 2 NJ central backs.
As far as the the BR they arnt looking as bad as I thought with most of the possession and hopefully the inclusion of henrequie, murdocca, Mccloughlan there is hope.
Whilst they look jaded in attack there is good opportunity for the Roar.
Cernaks passing I can fogive and he had about 4 totally shockers but to his credit improve
, Tiatto I cannot 8 passes went astray will little or no pressure this is diabolical coming from a senior player and should be shelved with Malcolm.
Tony Tannous said | November 2nd 2009 @ 9:10pm | Report comment
Good point about the one dimensional approach with Oar Chook. While there were some good crosses, they were largely from deep and it was pretty comfy for Costanzo and Topor Stanley I thought. Meanwhile, the Roar could certainly do with a little more penetration from central midfield. McKay had been getting into some good positions of late, but his finishing, as Andy Harper has pointed out, has been wasteful.
Midfielder, the trick for NJ is to get back to the way they were playing, and still pick up points.