Your Bledisloe Cup live report
By ohtani's jacket, 2 Nov 2009 The Crowd is a Roar Pro
- Tagged:
- All Blacks, Bledisloe Cup, Japan, Rugby Union, wallabies
Related coverage
- Rugby Union news
- Wallabies news
- New Zealand All Blacks news
- 2011 Wallabies squad news
- Wallabies v All Blacks news
A dead rubber, a money grabbing sojourn… call it what you will, but a Bledisloe Cup match was played in Tokyo.
I hadn’t seen the All Blacks live since we won back the Bledisloe Cup in 2003, so initially I viewed it as a chance to go to the rugby. But I’d be lying if I said I didn’t enjoy every single minute of it.
Was it a great game? Probably not, but the sight of All Blacks players wandering around Tokyo like a bunch of confused tourists made it a pretty eventful week for me, and the game itself gave me a rare chance to be a fan instead of some distant observer on a laptop.
First, a word on the stadium: I know a lot of people complained about the video referee and the ground itself, but National Olympic Stadium was a damn sight easier to get in and out of than Eden Park, which is traditionally a nightmare.
A couple of train rides and a brief wait in line and we had our pick of the unreserved seats. There were no problems on the way out either.
We got there early, but I couldn’t get over how good our seats were for non-reserved tickets.
National Olympic Stadium is primarily a track and field stadium, since it was a purpose built stadium for the 1964 Olympic Games. I’m sure you’ll have noticed on TV that it’s not really a rugby ground.
The only purpose built rugby stadium in Tokyo is Chichibunomiya Rugby Stadium. National Olympic Stadium hosts some of the bigger University clashes and the annual All Japan National Championships, but it’s not an ideal Test match venue because of the athletic track.
Still, I’ve never had such good seats at Eden Park. I pretty much had a wide angle view of the entire pitch, and since Japanese people don’t stand up too often, I was able to watch the game undisturbed. For such a long standing stadium, I was truly impressed with the seating design.
The stadium sits 48,000 and the official crowd attendance was 44,449. The organisers gave away a fair number of tickets to high school students, but at least they invited high school rugby players to the game.
The actual paid crowd was probably somewhere in the vicinity of 40,000. I was actually surprised by how many Kiwis and Aussies flew over for the game. It was a far greater number than I expected.
Naturally, the Kiwis and Aussies were by far the most raucous section and managed to frighten and entertain Japanese people at the same time, but there were a fair number of knowledgeable Japanese fans and I even met a Sri Lankan man who told me the All Blacks were a gift from heaven.
I went to the game with my wife, who has never sat through an 80 minute rugby game in her life, and my student and former colleague, who spent five years in Australia but was otherwise oblivious to how the game is played.
We met up with a Japanese couple who spent seven years in New Zealand and were die hard fanatical All Black fans who knew the game inside out.
I’ll tell you now, I was never as proud of my wife as I was when she made it through 80 minutes of rugby. She watched the game with a pair of binoculars that my father gave to me on one of his trips to Tokyo. I couldn’t understand why he’d give me binoculars, but he said they’d come in handy one day, and what do you know?
My wife officially declared Richie McCaw as more handsome than Daniel Carter, though Daniel Carter is still handsome. Apparently, his face is too well organised. I have the same problem.
I was surprised by how little of the game the New Zealand fans actually watched. It seemed like more of an excuse to get together and have a piss up, but I guess it reminded me of back home.
They tried numerous times to start a Mexican wave, which made it around the stadium a few times, but the Aussies were more fun. I’ve got to give props to the guy who did a stirring rendition of Advance Australia Fair.
One thing I’ll say for the Aussies is that they kept a sense of humour about the whole thing. Loved the guy outside the stadium singing: “We are the losers! We are the losers! No time for winners ‘cos we are the losers of the world!” Can’t imagine too many Kiwis taking it that well.
Insights into the game?
Well, the All Blacks started their warm-ups earlier than the Wallabies and looked a hell of a lot more focused. They practised a lot of catching under the high ball and other drills. Steve Hansen monitored their preparation, whereas Stephen Moore appeared to be running the show down the other end.
The All Blacks were also the first team onto the field after half time, and my overall impression of the game was that if it hadn’t been for Sivivatu’s awful challenge then the result would’ve been largely the same as Wellington.
That ought to be a worry for the Wallabies, because they tried a hell of a lot harder than they did in Wellington and the All Black performance was more clinical than committed.
I can’t tell you what happened in the rucks, since from where I was sitting I could only tell if it was a turnover or not, but I will say that the All Blacks had a far superior lineout and their backline formations left the Wallabies looking pretty amateur.
Genia had a good game, but the Wallaby back play still consists of guys making half breaks on their own and too much lateral movement.
I’ve been saying this all season, but it’s far too easy for the All Blacks to scramble back in defence and cover the Wallaby line breaks, because every single Wallaby player has this idea that they’re going to run in a solo try.
They only know two routes – straight up the middle or out wide – and the latter is poor.
They seemed to think they could create an overlap from a lateral formation and somehow beat either the inside or outside man, but the All Blacks have shut this down seven times in a row.
The turning point was Giteau’s kicking in the second half. I don’t know how it came across on TV, but he was kicking straight up in the air. As I said earlier, the All Blacks were practising their catching during the warm-ups and Giteau kept gifting them possession and territory. The All Blacks’ kicking wasn’t much better to be honest, but they were at least kicking towards the touch line.
The crowd were a bit quiet in the second half. I think they would’ve preferred a few more tries.
There was time on the clock for a Wallaby comeback, but aside from some half chances, realistically the All Blacks had sealed it with ten or fifteen minutes to go. They milked the clock from there on out, but at least the Wallabies made them preserve the score line.
The game ran over time and Woodcock ended up being suspended as a result, but the whistle blew and so ended another chapter in the world’s most one sided rugby rivalry.
Richie McCaw received the Man of the Match award and two hundred thousand yen for his efforts, and they had a token presentation of the Bledisloe Cup since the game had somehow been advertised as the Cup decider.
The Wallabies left the field pretty early, but a group of All Blacks stuck around and came and greeted us fans in the cheap seats.
As critical and judgemental as fans like me can be, it was a real thrill to see the All Blacks live in person, even the guys who shouldn’t be in the team. I stood up and hollered as much as anyone else and I must say it was awesome seeing the All Blacks live.
In the end, it was a game for the fans: expats, Japanese rugby fans, folks with a connection to either of the two countries, random strangers from other countries. I offered commiserations to every Wallaby supporter I met, but they were off to drink some more.
Later on, I saw a bunch of supporters wearing Halloween costumes and climbing street poles in Shibuya. No dwelling on the result!
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby Union articles
- Will Super Rugby crowds continue their slide? (198)
- Will South African rugby force a Super 21 by 2018? (172)
- Brumbies 2012: New coach, new players, new attitude (128)
- Dan Parks and the unsolved questions of expat rugby (61)
- Pocock set to be named new Force skipper (56)
- Can the ‘Tahs win the battle after losing the Waugh? (51)
- What does the future hold for the Six Nations (50)
- Wales show Southern Hemisphere how to play running rugby (27)
- What opening matches of Six Nations taught us (18)
- Will Super Rugby crowds continue their slide? (201)
- Clinical Chiefs cost rusty Rebels in Corio (9)
- Six Nations shows rugby is a parochial game at heart (5)
- Goose’s Super Rugby up-and-comer XV for 2012 (29)
- What does the future hold for the Six Nations (50)
- Explore:
- All Blacks, Bledisloe Cup, Japan, Rugby Union, wallabies

Brett McKay said | November 2nd 2009 @ 8:44am | Report comment
Great read OJ, thanks for the insight. Perhaps Mrs Othani and Mrs Emu need to get together, they seem to have similar rugby interests and appreciation!! For the record, my wife will take Daniel Carter’s “well organised” face quite happily, which is a worry both for me, and the fact that she claims there hasn’t been an Australian equivalent since Michael Lynagh..
Anyway, I digress. You mentioned “God’s green astroturf” in another thread, and that was certainly obvious on the vision. When Conrad Smith drove the Queen Mary II throught the gap Ryan Cross left open for his try, and ran around behind the posts, and dived (!), I thought for sure he’d forgotten that the lighter green stuff was “I can’t believe it’s not grass” and he was about to become a victim of self-imposed carpert burn..
But the stadium looked great – astroturf aside – and the crowd reacted accordingly, and seemed in good spirits all night. All in all, it wasn’t even too bad a game, but perhaps I can say that now after a period of …well, you know, the last few years.
Onto Twickenham!!
True Tah said | November 2nd 2009 @ 11:34am | Report comment
Thanks for that OJ, excellent insight into the night.
Dan Carter did help get my girlfriend interested in rugby, although Im not sure if its too much of a good thing!
OJ, its clear that there are going to be issues with proper venues for RWC 2019 if this is the best they have got, the ground went to pieces, and astroturf is a bit dodgey.
ohtani's jacket said | November 3rd 2009 @ 1:44pm | Report comment
I think the plan is to host the final at Nissan Stadium in Yokohama. National Olympic Stadium will probably figure into the pool stages. The problem with the grounds is that Chichibunomiya only fits 27,000, though to be honest it also has pitch problems due to overuse.
True Tah said | November 3rd 2009 @ 1:59pm | Report comment
How big is the Nissan stadium
I just hope the Japanese Rugby Union do their hardest to spread the word and get as many people interested as possible. Does the JRU focus on developing pathways from high school rugby, which is fairly well established, to universtity to Top League games?
ohtani's jacket said | November 3rd 2009 @ 2:04pm | Report comment
Nissan Stadium has 72,000 seats, which is the seating capacity of any stadium in Japan, but it’s also a track and field stadium. http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/cd/ISY_VIProom.jpg/800px-ISY_VIProom.jpg
There are pathways through to the national side, and Kirwan has done more than any prior coach to actually include squad members from the University sides, it’s the profile of the sport that’s a problem.
Brett McKay said | November 3rd 2009 @ 2:13pm | Report comment
more importantly OJ, how much astroturf does it have?!?!
ohtani's jacket said | November 3rd 2009 @ 3:13pm | Report comment
I’m not sure. If the picture works, you’ll see that there’s no space for any in goal area. That’s not a good sign. I thought the IRB had regulations about field dimensions?
Brett McKay said | November 3rd 2009 @ 4:36pm | Report comment
thank goodness there’s no tries in rugby any more…
Sam Taulelei said | November 2nd 2009 @ 11:35am | Report comment
Thanks for this OJ, it was a great read and I agree that while we can be extremely critical of the team when we’re watching them live we holler, cheer, scream, boo and are thrilled as unabashedly as the next person. While we may question the administrators true motives for playing these offshore fixtures it shouldn’t be forgotten how special an event this is for expats and locals who only ever watch an All Blacks test on tv.
On the game itself I don’t know if it’s just me but watching Bledisloe tests has been so rigidly scripted that not once did I feel like we were in danger of losing the game. Even if the Wallabies had scored after pressuring our line late in the first half and extended their lead I knew that we would step up a gear, reel them in and then finish them off in the second half.
Deans and co. must be sick to death of playing the All Blacks now and will be happy about playing different teams. First time I’ve ever seen cracks in Deans cool demeanour when asked to explain another loss to NZ – 7 straight losses to the same team is a new experience for him, as well as coaching against Carter and McCaw. Now he knows what opposition coaches were challenged with when they played the Crusaders.
Spiro Zavos said | November 2nd 2009 @ 11:44am | Report comment
Terrific report, Ohtani’s Jacket. I sympathise with you trying to get your wife interested in the complex game as I have had the same experience. The notes about the All Blacks coming on to the field before the Wallabies resonates with me, as one of the features of the All Blacks over the years is their willingness to get on with the game. They don’t wear jackets coming to the field, for instance. There were instances when with the All Blacks tryline under threat you could hear chants of ‘All Blacks! All Blacks!’ But I didn’t hear similar chants for the Wallabies.
I believe that this Test was a real rugby occasion, not just a festival of rugby. They are talking about where to hold it next year, either Toyko or Hong Kong. If it is Tokyo, the video referee might have sorted out what he has to do by then.
Sam Taulelei said | November 2nd 2009 @ 11:57am | Report comment
Ha, ha Spiro and even then it will probably be lost in translation.
I wonder how many of us have had the same challenge of getting their wives interested in rugby. When I first met my wife she was a die hard passionate Collingwood supporter with next to no knowledge of rugby.
Attractive players like Doug Howlett, Carlos Spencer and Dan Carter helped shift her allegiances to NZ from Australia and while she can watch a game together with me she still struggles with the more technical rulings of the game – don’t we all.
Knives Out said | November 2nd 2009 @ 11:44pm | Report comment
My girlfriend has sat through a few games at Twickenham (including an empty and rain sodden England A v Scotland A match) having persuaded me that she enjoyed the day out and match day atmosphere. Recently she confirmed what I had always suspected, that her alleged enjoyment was in fact a complete and total lie. I feel slightly deflated now, a feeling that was exacerbated last night when upon noticing Ben Foden featuring in a magazine (he is dating a ‘pop star’) I spent 10 minutes explaining why I wasn’t a fan of him, and his switch from 9 to 15 etc. At the end of the 10 minute ‘conversation’ I noticed that she was stifling laughter. Obviously she hadn’t been listening to a single word. I’m curious as to why it has taken me 5 years to notice this. (Sigh)
Good article, OJ.
Who Needs Melon said | November 2nd 2009 @ 12:06pm | Report comment
Thanks OJ. Whilst I like many viewed this overseas fixture with a bit of bemusement beforehand, it did look like it would have been a great game to go to.
There are a few posters floating around this site today complaining about Aussie whingers. I think that’s a tad unfair. I don’t think anyone is claiming that, but for the reffing, the Wallabies would have won, are they? Anyone? But that doesn’t mean we aren’t allowed to comment on the reffing at all does it?
Whilst the All Blacks have looked very rusty at times this year, I thought they looked VERY good in all aspects of the game last night. Lineout totally dominated ours. Scrum held their own. Usual superior commitment at the rucks and mauls. Backline play looked VERY slick. Great support play. And decent kicking.
If everyone can stay healthy (and out of suspensions!) then I think the All Blacks will do very well this tour. Of course it depends a bit on whether you think the Wallabies are team of duds in which case the win hasn’t proved anything. Whilst we’re not in the league of the All Blacks and Springboks at the moment, I don’t think we’re a team of total duds either. Time will tell.
Brett McKay said | November 2nd 2009 @ 12:08pm | Report comment
..and don’t most Refs, Sam…
MM Fike said | November 2nd 2009 @ 1:54pm | Report comment
Terrific write up OJ.
We had a text from our son saying he loved the game and the total experience.
My wife loves rugby but she doesn’t know the difference between the hooker and fullback. The rules are in the same category but she hates the referees penalising ‘her’ team. But don’t we all.
Thanks again and I’m glad you had a great evening at the test.
Harry said | November 2nd 2009 @ 4:07pm | Report comment
Great read OJ thanks.
Very telling the kiwi’s pre-match preparations focusing on handling high kicks … no doubt their less than successful experiences against the world’s Number 1 team this year has shown them this is a critical area of the modern game at the highest level, and one where they need to improve. NZ rugby is always smart and cutting edge.
Of course on the weekend NZ were only playing some yellow rabble formerly know as the Glorious Golden Wallabies and comfortably put us away, as you saw live we can’t even do basics like secure our own lineouts, manufacture an overlap, kick accurately and catch passes. I don’t know what it was like at the ground but at no stage watching on the box did I think Aus were a realistic chance of winning. To much wrong and an enourmous amount of ground to be made up …A few weeks back I suggested this (catching high balls) was a skill the Wallabies needed to learn and practice and was shouted down by other roarers that of course they would be doing that. I am yet to see any evidence that the Australian rugby union team does in fact practice this skill and can translate it on match day.
Marty Christopher said | November 2nd 2009 @ 7:34pm | Report comment
Lovely article OJ! I’m a kiwi, and find the press in NZ very negative, and always berating the All Blacks. A perfectionist mind set really, and when the perfection diminishes, the NZ public and media want payback…anger, revenge etc. So here I am to hear a bit of softness, positivity, insight. Cool story, not to serious, nice and truthful.