The NRL can learn a lot from the NFL
By Paul J, 10 Nov 2009 The Crowd is a Roar Pro
- Tagged:
- NFL, NRL, Rugby League

Jarryd Hayne in action during the Week 3 Playoff NRL match between the Bulldogs and the Parramatta Eels at ANZ Stadium in Sydney, Friday, Sept. 25, 2009.The Eels beat the Bulldogs 22 - 12. AAP Image/Action Photographics, Robb Cox
For those rugby league fans who are excited about the potential for the game now that an independent commission seems imminent, here are some ideas that may give you even more reason for optimism.
Michael Searle and Co. have advised that the new leadership model will be based on both the AFL and NFL independent commissions with more emphasis being on the NFL model.
If you are not yet sold on what an independent commission can do, then consider what Paul Tagliabue achieved for the NFL in his time as NFL commissioner from 1989 to 2006.
For starters, he increased the leagues revenue from $975 million in 1989 to a staggering $5.7 billion in 2006. He also has helped to cement American Footballs place as easily the number one sport in the USA.
Considering that level of success, here are four initiatives from the NFL that should be seriously considered by rugby league’s new controlling body.
1. TV rights: Sell, Sell, Sell…
To gain maximum revenue regular season, NFL games are broadcast on no less than five separate networks: CBS, Fox, NBC, ESPN and the NFL Network. The NRL is currently shown on only one free to air network –Chanel 9. To increase revenue, one channel cannot be given a monopoly on all rugby league games.
Thankfully David Gallop has indicated that Rugby League games will be sold separately in the next TV rights deal starting in 2012. Speculation is that talks have already begun with Channel 7 and Channel 10 in regards to the sale on State of Origin and regular season games.
Imagine two games on Friday night on Channel 9, one on Saturday afternoon on Seven, one Saturday night on Ten and one Sunday afternoon on Nine. Plus Monday night football and mid week games on Foxtel.
State of Origin could be shown for the first time on Seven and the four nations on Ten.
Ex-Channel Nine commentators such as Ben Ikin, Paul Harrigan, Mario Fenech, Laurie Daley and even Matthew Johns may well have jobs at Seven or Ten in two years time. And who’s to say Channel 9 stalwarts such as Peter Sterling or Andrew Voss would not jump ship for a pay increase?
2. Three strikes, you’re out
Tagliabue has always stressed presenting a professional and clean cut image of the NFL and its players to the public. The NFL banned substances policy is the longest running in American professional sports.
He has even gone so far as to having strict rules in place (and enforced) as to players’ sock length, uniform appearance and sideline attire.
Protecting the NFL brand from tarnishing has been a key priority and is exactly what the NRL needs to come into effect as soon as possible.
Offences such as DUI, alleged assault, and recreational drug use should fall into a strict three strikes and you’re out policy.
First strike will incur a fine and suspension and compulsory counselling. A second strike an increased fine and suspension and compulsory counselling. Third strike and you are banned from playing in the NRL for life.
No appeals.
Any player who tests positive to a performance enhancing drug is given an immediate two year ban. Any player convicted of assault is given a minimum five year ban or more if the commission deems fit.
This will greatly improve the codes’ damaged image and show fans that an independent commission is serious in protecting the game and its future.
Let’s give the game back to the good guy majority.
3. Build it and they will come.
Tagliabue also established a fund that allowed the NFL to build its own stadiums rather that rely on public or Government funding.
Of the 32 NFL teams, 17 play in new stadiums that have been built since Tagliabue became commissioner in 1989. The NFL makes money through football, but also by being a stadium construction company.
A long-term commitment to a similar fund would greatly benefit rugby league (in a smaller capacity – the USA does have a population of approximately 300 million).
This fund would allow the NRL greater flexibility in regards to expansion by allowing it to build a stadium at the Sunshine Coast or Perth (where it could be rented out to other rectangle field sports such as rugby and soccer).
They could also look at renovating and modernising existing stadiums. Newer stadiums increased crowd figures for the NFL, especially an increase in women and children watching the game.
The Broncos and Titans have the best crowd figures in the NRL and both play in new stadiums. Your first visit to Suncorp Stadium or Skilled Park will leave you in no doubt as to the benefits a modern stadium can bring to sport.
4. Revenue sharing.
Tagliabue instituted revenue sharing between players and owners and maintained the sharing of TV income equally among the franchises.
Essentially to the NRL, this would mean that it wouldn’t matter if a Broncos or Bulldogs game gets a higher TV rating than a Raiders or Cronulla game or if a team has private ownership or is owned by a leagues club or the NRL.
Every team gets an equal share of the profits of future TV broascast deals.
When the NRL is flush from its next TV broadcast deal, the first priority should be an ongoing commitment to increasing player payments.
The salary cap is to be increased by as much as possible with each new TV rights deal signed. This will help retain our star players to our code and allow young players to choose rugby league as a lucrative career option.
These are just a few of many ideas from the NFL that an NRL commission could use to its own advantage and it can realistically strive to achieve them.
Taking the inconsistencies of the decision-making of the clubs out of the picture and having an independent commission to have unbiased control of the game will give rugby league potential that it has never before dared to consider.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby League articles
- Rugby league commission ushers in new era
- Ennis confident about his NRL fitness
- Why sporting seasons should never cross paths
- Independent Commission four years in the making, but worth the wait
- Kearney still to choose Eels kicker
- Federal Court has it wrong on sports broadcast copyright (38)
- An open letter to Channel Nine (80)
- Federal Court has it wrong on sports broadcast copyright (38)
- An open letter to Channel Nine (80)
- The NRL’s scariest players (56)
- Is the All Stars match increasing the divide? (25)
- Channel Nine needs NRL-cricket ODI compromise (36)
- The NRL needs a vision (52)
- New breed of NRL players continue to develop (24)
- Explore:
- NFL, NRL, Rugby League

danwighton said | November 10th 2009 @ 2:21am | Report comment
Awesome article – looks like you have gone to a great length in researching etc – and I am getting excited just reading it!
While a lot is speculation, lets hope that an Independent Commission can have a similarly positive impact on league as on the NFL.
As for salary cap, it wouldnt take much for the NRL to be the highest paying Rugby league in the world (which is fair considering its status as the most watched and the most well attended).
The current TV deal is approx $520m. I know its ambitious, but if it can be increased to levels near the AFL deal (approx $750m – which wouldn’t be unreasonable considering the NRL rivals the AFL in ratings), with Internationals, All Star games and SOO on top, the game would be flush with money.
If this allowed the NRL to increase its salary cap to AFL levels of $7/8m, $1m for one player would not be unheard of. The game could then compete to buy players of Dan Carter, and Bryan Habana quality.
Paul J said | November 10th 2009 @ 7:40am | Report comment
Thanks Dan
Australian sports fans can see how productive an independent commission has been for the AFL but we probably would not know as much about the NFL.
The more i read about what this type of leadership has done for the AFL & NFL the more i realise just how poorly rugby league has been run for years. It was no where near as good as it could have been before the super league war and even worse since.
An independent commission can improve rugby league greatly and i believe it is the most important thing to happen to the game in many many years, possibly ever.
MyGeneration said | November 10th 2009 @ 8:22am | Report comment
I haven’t read the article in detail, but on overview one thing stuck out. You praise the NFL’s drugs/behavioural policies. Be careful there. The NRL’s behavioural issues pale in comparison with the NFL’s (multiple star players have been implicated in violent incidents in recent years, from Michael Vick’s dog-fighting up to numerous assaults and a few murders as well), so I’m not sure they should serve as a template. And I don’t know why, but when I think of steroids, I think of weightlifters and NFL lineman. I think in many cases, the NFL is a template for how not to acculturate young, aggressive men with too much money too quick. Mind you, it hasn’t stopped the sport making money, and that’s the point, isn’t it? Isn’t it?
M1tch said | November 10th 2009 @ 8:23am | Report comment
Great article..
It does sound all so simple and it shows how much the game has been held back the past 10 years.
Hopefully the independant commission comes in ASAP to stand up for the game and lets see it grow.
sheek said | November 10th 2009 @ 8:55am | Report comment
“Build it and they will come”.
Great line from an equally great movie, but it’s flawed, just like that other great saying,”if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it’.
Back in the 70s, was it, the VFL built Waverley Park, their very own owned & controlled ground, but it never really took off with the public. Way, way back in 1908, the then NSWRU bought its own ground, but this only alienated players & fans who believed the controlling body was hoarding funds. Another reason why league broke away from union.
The point is, while the two issues above were great ideas, they still need to be built on solid ground (viable reasons), not just a couple of dreams!
Dave1 said | November 10th 2009 @ 3:14pm | Report comment
The SANFL built their own ground Football Park in 1973.
It has been successful. Though it looks like it now might of have had its day.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Football_Park
The SANFL has been run by an independant commision since 1991
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Australian_Football_Commission
JiMMM said | November 10th 2009 @ 9:03am | Report comment
While I think the idea of an indeoendant commision for League is a good move, and would hopefully do a lot of things that you mention Paul, unless the commision is willing to do teh hard yards that teh NFL and AFL have done in terms of raionalistion of teams, relocating teams and expanding into new areas, there wont be any gains.
The simple fact is that in a 16 team comp to have 9 teams in one market is unsustainable, and some of these clubs will need to close merge or relocate, but as we constantly see in the media (including internet) none of these clubs are willing to do so.
The only way that I can see anything like this happening is the creation of a nationl second tier comp, relegating some of the existing clubs into this and bringing expansion franchises in at this level
PastHisBest said | November 10th 2009 @ 9:11am | Report comment
And don’t forget that white elephant concord oval, sheek.
prowling panther said | November 10th 2009 @ 9:42am | Report comment
great stuff. particularly like the tough stance on off field issues. Speaking of which, its been pretty quiet on that front. maybe the players are realising the extra scrutiny theyre under…hope i didnt jinx it
prowling panther said | November 10th 2009 @ 9:45am | Report comment
and whats the latest on the commission. are they certainties to get it up and running by next year? i for one would like them to cover all bases before it becomes operational so hopefully its not rushed…
Paul J said | November 10th 2009 @ 10:11am | Report comment
Prowling Panther
About a month ago there was a lot of media reports about the independent commission, seemingly for out of nowhere. It was all kept very hush hush up until then.
I keep looking for any more info on this but they seem to be keeping it under their hats again, sort of a need to know basis. A bit frustrating for the fans but maybe they think it’s more productive to keep it quiet while it is all finalised.
A lot of media types are talking about it as if its a fore gone conclusion.
prowling panther said | November 10th 2009 @ 10:19am | Report comment
‘sort of a need to know basis’ thats probably a good thing. shows their damn serious about it. i wouldn’t mind if it was delayed to 2011 just to make sure all bases are covered. only problem with that is they leave themselves little time for tv negotiations. in any case theyve gotta have most of the deal done as they afl finishes their deal in 2012 otherwise the networks will have less money to offer and god forbid ch9 may be the only bidder.