By Roger Vaughan
November 12th 2009 @ 1:51am
Related coverage
Malthouse, Buckley deal hinged on one final meeting
The ground-breaking deal that has established Collingwood’s coaching structure for the next five AFL seasons eventually hinged on one 30-minute conversation.
After months of intense media scrutiny and careful negotiations, Collingwood’s hierarchy had to wait as Mick Malthouse and Nathan Buckley went into a separate room to discuss the radical proposal.
When they emerged, the deal was effectively done.
Malthouse will continue to coach the Magpies for the next two seasons, with Buckley now at the club as an assistant.
From 2012, Malthouse will have a three-year term as director of coaching at the club as Buckley takes over the team.
The story behind the power-sharing agreement is detailed in Side By Side, a new behind-the-scenes book about Collingwood’s tumultuous 2009 season.
Malthouse was coming out of contract at the end of the season and his future proved one of this year’s biggest AFL stories.
It came down to the meeting at the office of club president Eddie McGuire on a late-July Saturday morning.
Football director Geoff Walsh chaired the meeting, with chief executive Gary Pert also in attendance.
McGuire, Pert and Walsh waited as Buckley and Malthouse discussed the proposal in private one last time.
Buckley says he would not have accepted the proposal if Malthouse showed any reluctance.
“I could not have painted any rosier picture for the alternative,” Buckley says in the book.
“Mick said, no, this is what he wanted to do and second, and in many ways more importantly, did he think it was a good thing or the right thing for the footy club?
“Ultimately his answer to those questions was `yes’ and `yes’.”
The agreement was made public three days later.
The book also looks at the confidence within the club that the Magpies can win a premiership in the next couple of years.
At last year’s annual general meeting, McGuire told members that the Magpies had set themselves to win a flag within three years.
They made this year’s preliminary finals, losing to eventual premiers Geelong.
At a February pre-season meeting for Collingwood’s coaching staff in Sorrento, Walsh was even more specific.
“In 30-40 games, we’ll be in a position to win a premiership,” he is quoted as saying.
“This bloke (Malthouse) is the man to take us there – I’m not pissing in his pocket or putting pressure on him.
“We’re in a better position at the start of 2009 than Geelong or Hawthorn were at the start of their premiership years.”
“Side By Side, A Season With Collingwood”. Author: Peter Ryan. Publisher: The Slattery Media Group. RRP: $49.95
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...


![The concessions to be given to the new Gold Coast club have given rise to this year’s draft being termed as “the last uncompromised draft.” But should clubs really be all that worried?
Paul Roos fronted the media this week expressing his fear over what may lie ahead in coming years. “We can’t go down for [...] Michael DiFabrizio: Clubs can benefit from compromised draft](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/06/clubs-benefit-gold-coast-th.jpg)
![There are are two ways to punctuate the question: how good were the expert picks for the Melbourne Cup!? The exclamation punctuation suggests that the experts were spot on. But the question mark punctuation, which goes with this Roar, suggests that they were mug punters (like you and me) rather than gurus of the turf.
I [...] Spiro Zavos: How Shocking that the experts got it so wrong](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/how-shocking-melbourne-cup-th.jpg)
![It’s the turn of Australia and New Zealand to put forward their candidate to become chairman of the International Cricket Council in 2012. According to The Australian and The Sydney Morning Herald, the candidate, who is assured of the appointment, will be John Howard, the former long-serving Prime Minister of Australia.
When Howard was approached by [...] Spiro Zavos: Should Howard be appointed ICC chairman in 2012?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/why-john-howard-league-th.jpg)
![It’s been an unusually busy AFL Trade Week this year, with big names like Brendon Fevola, Darren Jolly and Shaun Burgoyne all finding new homes. And with Friday’s deadline ending proceedings, it’s time to analyse who won and who lost in Trade Week.
Adelaide
Gains; did not trade
Losses; did not trade
Draft Picks; 13, 29, 45, 61, 77
The [...] Ben Somerford: The winners and losers of AFL Trade Week](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/the-winners-losers-afl-trade-darren-jolly-th.jpg)
![The biggest challenge facing the NRL isn’t ensuring Brad Fittler knows which is his hotel room but rather ensuring that the One RL dream becomes a reality.
While, Fittler was busy buying some extra strong nails and a jumbo hammer for a coffin with the headstone marked “my coaching career” it also emerged than [...] Steve Kaless: One rugby league vision is failing](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2008/05/david-gallop-th.jpg)
![There’s no ‘I’ in team. At least that’s what coaches say, and most of the time they are correct. But on rare occasions in the world game a sensational talent comes along who single-handedly scores victories for his side.
This to me is what makes a one-man team, not a player who has a [...] Benjamin Conkey: The most dominant players in the history of club football](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/steven-gerrard-dominant-players-th.jpg)
![It’s been a bit of a gloomy start to the new A-League campaign. Crowds have stagnated. Certain pitches are a disgrace. And now the mainstream media has a new show reel of ‘crowd violence’ to dredge up every time football threatens the status quo.
The so-called ‘clashes’ between Adelaide United and Melbourne Victory supporters last [...] Mike Tuckerman: A-League boneheads need a new hobby](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/a-league-boneheads-th.jpg)
![Having footy games broadcast live on TV has been a recurring topic this week. With two of this weekend’s finals – both featuring two Victorian teams – being shown on delay in Victoria, Geelong president Frank Costa kicked it off by pushing for all finals to be screened live.
The talk continued yesterday in the Herald [...] Michael DiFabrizio: The tide is turning for live football](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/tide-turning-live-tv-football-th.jpg)
![In the end the Wallabies defeated England quite comfortably 18 – 9 to win the first Test of this Grand Slam tour. This was a Test the Wallabies had to win. And they won it playing inventive, attractive and skilful rugby with a confidence that grew as the Test developed.
The Grand Slam dream remains alive, although [...] Spiro Zavos: The Wallabies slam England in a terrific Test](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/how-wallabies-look-th.jpg)
![The most overheard phrase around the Olympics must surely be “there should be no politics in sport.” What a load of rubbish! There should be more, lots more. It makes it more interesting.
The most exciting part of these year’s Olympic build up is wondering just when the Chinese might roll out the tanks.
Giving the Games [...] Steve Kaless: Why we need more politics in sport](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2008/08/olympics-2-th.jpg)
![It was only when I started scribbling some notes for this week’s column that I realised the errors of my timing. For some time, I have suggested on The Roar that a massive opportunity sits as yet untested for both Football Federation Australia and Cricket Australia.
And I thought this week was time to expand on [...] Brett McKay: Show A-League and Twenty20 on Friday nights](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/is-a-league-boring-rudan-ognenovski-costa-th.jpg)



