ARU need to allocate more resources to schoolboy rugby
Roar Guru
By Bay35Pablo, 13 Nov 2009 Bay35Pablo is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- GPS, juniors, KIngs school, Rugby Union, schoolboy rugby
Recent articles and comments have highlighted the apparent dependence of rugby on the players coming out of private schools (especially GPS), and how those same private schools are increasingly drifting away from rugby as their one and only sport.
This caused me to pull out my Waratahs program for 2009 (which my wife hasn’t made me throw away yet. See honey, there was a reason for keeping it!), and check the origins of the various players this year.
Given NSW does tend to produce the lions’ share of players in Australia, they are likely to give a pretty good guide on this issue.
They were, in the main squad of 30:
Phil Waugh – Shore
Ben Batger – Kings
Al Baxter – Shore
Kurtley Beale – St Josephs
Luke Burgess – St Josephs
Will Caldwell – Kings
Matt Carraro – St Josephs
Tom Carter – Knox
David Dennis – Richmond High School
Matt Dunning – Northolm Grammar
Scott Fava – Kiama?
Adam Freier – Waverley College
Daniel Halangahu – Kings
Rob Horne – Georges River College
Sekope Kepu – Wesley College (NZ)
Ben Mowen – Villanova College (QLD)
Dean Mumm – Kings
Ratu Nasiganiyavi – St Josephs College Nudgee (QLD)
Sam Norton-Knight – All Saints College, Gold Coast (QLD)
Dan Palmer – Warilla High School
Wycliff Palu – Balgowlah Boys High
Tatafu Polota-Nau – Granville South High
Beau Robinson – St Stanislaus College, Bathurst
Benn Robinson – Kings
Brett Sheehan – St Josephs
Timana Tahu – Cardiff High School
Chris Thomson – Marist College Canberra
Jeremy Tilse – St Josephs
Lote Tuqiri – Sunnybank State High (QLD)
Lachie Turner – Newington
Academy – Professional (8)
Ben Coridas – Westfield Sports High
Kane Douglas – Maclean High
Damien Fitzpatrick – St Josephs
Ed Jenkins – Riverview
Sitiveni Mafi – Westfield Sports High
Ben McCalman – Kinross-Wollaroi School
Pat McCutcheon – St Josephs
Jeremy Su’a – Westfield Sports High
Academy – Non-Professional (16)
Kotoni Ale – St Augustine’s College, Brookvale
Damon Anderson – Cranbrook
Phoenix Anderson – Marist College, Canberra
Harry Bennett – Kings
Tim Bennetts – Pennant Hills High
Eddie Bredenhann – Anglican Church Grammar (QLD)
Josh Daley – The Southport School (QLD)
Greg Jeloudev – Kings
Mark Johnson – Kings
Michael MacDougall – Kings
Salesi Manu – St Augustine’s College, Brookvale
Cameron Mitchell – Kings
Sam Robertson – St Stanislaus College, Bathurst
Sam Latunipulli, Lachie McCaffrey & David Tautaiolefue – not disclosed
Leaving aside the pure league converts (Lote and Timana), we are dealing with an extended squad of 52. Ostensibly the best pick of NSW (leaving aside those playing for other states and in Europe).
Of those:
Kings – 10 (19.23%)
St Josephs (Hunter Hill) – 7 (13.46%)
St Stannies – 2 (3.84%)
Shore, Know, Waverley College, Cranbrook, Newington, Riverview – 1 each (1.92%)
It appears the team is essentially a combined Kings/St Josephs team, with a third of the entire team! Of course, those two GPS schools are known as rugby nurseries.
Further, this becomes a self-perpetuating system, as those schools attract the best players.
However, the dependence on the GPS (and private schools generally) is worth noting. If those schools all started playing soccer or AFL tomorrow, where would rugby be (OK, joke – the committed rugby players would go to other schools).
It is worth noting the newer players coming out of St Augustine’s College and Westfield Sports (2 and 3 respectively).
What it shows to me is that if rugby in the traditional heartland of GPS and private schools is truly on the wane, then rugby may have a serious problem.
As we all know, many players carry on with the sport they play at school. If they aren’t playing rugby at school, will they play (or follow) it at all?
Further, it also begs the question, are there really so few, or so unskilled, players coming out of non-GPS schools? Or is it about being seen, or getting the opportunities from going to a “rugby” school, or do those players get snapped up by those schools from non-GPS schools?
Or so few non-GPS schools playing rugby?
Ultimately, the rugby powers that be need to be committing as much of their resources as possible to schools, and “brain washing” the kids (and parents of tomorrow) into playing rugby.
Give me the child until 10 and I’ll give you the man for life?
Give them to AFL, league or football, and never see them at all …
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby Union articles
- Will Super Rugby crowds continue their slide? (198)
- Will South African rugby force a Super 21 by 2018? (172)
- Brumbies 2012: New coach, new players, new attitude (128)
- Dan Parks and the unsolved questions of expat rugby (61)
- Pocock set to be named new Force skipper (56)
- Can the ‘Tahs win the battle after losing the Waugh? (51)
- What does the future hold for the Six Nations (50)
- Chiefs continue to wait for SBW (2)
- Nathan Sharpe to retire at end of 2012 (2)
- Queensland ready for Super challenge (2)
- Australian teams at Super disadvantage (51)
- Foley excited about Samoan rugby challenge
- Force rugby coach praises his pack (2)
- The real story of how John O’Neill turned Manchester City down (62)
- Wales show Southern Hemisphere how to play running rugby (26)
- What opening matches of Six Nations taught us (18)
- Will Super Rugby crowds continue their slide? (201)
- Clinical Chiefs cost rusty Rebels in Corio (9)
- Six Nations shows rugby is a parochial game at heart (5)
- Goose’s Super Rugby up-and-comer XV for 2012 (29)
- What does the future hold for the Six Nations (50)
- Explore:
- GPS, juniors, KIngs school, Rugby Union, schoolboy rugby
The way it is! said | November 13th 2009 @ 7:42am | Report comment
As my playing days are closing I have recently put my hand up to coach at Colts level. We couldn’t even field 3 teams consistently and the standard of player coming out of the schools was below average. This I believe is a direct reflection on the playing numbers at the non private schools in the district. When I played colts 5 grades among all of the clubs was the norm and the playing ability much higher as it was a combination of non & private schools. This problem will get worst if it’s not address urgently.
Old Pig said | November 13th 2009 @ 8:00am | Report comment
Interesting analyses and somewhat concerning. Not sure what the answer is but I know from first hand experience with my sons school (a member of the CAS) that soccer will be offered as an alternative to rugby from yr 3 onwards, starting in 2010 and this is going to seriously weaken the pool of talent that the school has to draw on. It has been suggested that this change has been driven by a group of parents concerned that rugby is too rough and dangerous and for some reason they think soccer is safer. I think it also has something to do with the fact that soccer & AFL are heavily promoted to this age group and once hooked it is difficult to change. These kids are already playing soccer/AFL when they arrive at school.
I firmly believe schools rugby needs to get serious with it competitions and start playing genuine 2 round fixtures with semis & finals, combine the GPS, CAS and whoever else wants to join in into a divisional competition, mix it up and watch the spectacle unfold. The kids will love it, parents get bragging rights and the schools an opportunity to compete in a broader market.
Yes, I know this has a private school bias but lets face it this has been the heart land of rugby for too many years and to not use it as established platform would be stupid to say the least. I’m sure the ARU could throw a few resources at this and make the right moves to get all interested parties to agree to a format without upsetting too many people. Who knows maybe some kids will go home and tell their mums that they are switching codes and playing rugby next yr because it is more popular and better resourced.
mickeym said | November 13th 2009 @ 10:22am | Report comment
The problem with statistics is that there are always more…
It seems that of all students in Australia, 32% go to private schools, with most private schools in NSW playing rugby.
On the other hand, of the 68% of other students, you might assume that less than half of those schools actually play rugby. Which means that say 34% of students go to rugby playing public schools. So, of all rugby playing schools, it’s about a 50:50 split of public:private.
Which means that the public school system is over represented at Waratahs level, with a 60:40 split of players coming from public:private schools. And that is despite private schools offering scholarships to promising rugby kids…
Skip said | November 13th 2009 @ 10:39am | Report comment
The stats are skewed as a lot of the players from GPS schools on scholarships and were recruited from Govt schools.
I agree that there needs to be a greater focus on schools but I think we need a greater focus on the Colts structure.
It is my expreience that player believe that if they have not made representative honours at school then there is no chance to be a proffesional footballer so they give up.
Harry Wombat said | November 13th 2009 @ 3:30pm | Report comment
Skip, if clubs are not converting their players to colts once they finish juniors then they need to take a long hard look at themselves. And that may be the problem. How many schools have a colts program ? Often they might have an Old Boys team but that does not always appeal to a youngster wanting to play Colts
Harry Wombat said | November 13th 2009 @ 3:20pm | Report comment
Waiting until the child goes to high school (private or public) is too late. If you want to catch the child then aim for them to start in the U6′s. For NSW it is only touch at this stage, played with a parent on the field who should ensure everyone has a turn with the ball, no scrums. In fact everything to make it safe for the protective parent to appreciate. If you want to plough money into the high schools do so by all means but by then you are really only preaching to the converted and maybe one or two extras.
AndyS said | November 13th 2009 @ 3:35pm | Report comment
Agreed. For mine the future should be clubs, not schools. They may have been the bastion in the past, but it doesn’t mean they are the key to the future. I look at my nephew in NZ, and he is well engaged by his rugby but it has nothing to do with his primary school.
waterboy said | November 13th 2009 @ 3:42pm | Report comment
You private school fathers beware.
While your schools have done everything over the last 100 years to keep the perceived enemy (rugby league) out, you have allowed the devil (AFL) to slip in the back door.
The AFL will decimate rugby school programs in private schools over the next 10-20 years now that they have a foothold.
Pippinu said | November 13th 2009 @ 3:45pm | Report comment
Not another reds under the beds post!!
So let me understand this – Melbourne’s elite schools have kept rugby going for 100 years in a city where the game is barely known – but aussie rules willl decimate rugby in the elite schools of Sydney and Brisbane??
Have I understood that correctly?
Harry Wombat said | November 13th 2009 @ 3:45pm | Report comment
So where does soccer fit into the equation
Pippinu said | November 13th 2009 @ 3:48pm | Report comment
Australians aren’t allowed to use their own vernacular anymore – we are forced to use the French, Spanish or German word.
Harry Wombat said | November 13th 2009 @ 3:59pm | Report comment
If you mean soccer its origins are English, as are mine.
Pippinu said | November 13th 2009 @ 4:11pm | Report comment
Yes, well, surprisingly (or maybe not so surprisingly) much of the Australian vernacular is actually of English origin.
Cattledog said | November 13th 2009 @ 4:03pm | Report comment
I have long been an advocate for supporting the transitional phase from schoolboy to club with more resources. Several posts on this site and elsewhere atest to that. Rugby in schools, especially the non-traditional schools is growing. Both primary and many secondary state schools are introducing rugby next to league, not as an alternate, but as a sport for the following term, which is a step in the right direction.
There are significant resources in the GPS and many CAS schools for rugby. As a member of a GPS 1st XV, this will be the closest you will come to a structure not unlike the set up within a Super franchise or even the National team, believe it or not. This, of course, can be a double edged weapon. On the one hand, these boys receive in the main exceptional coaching, support and resourcing as a part of this exclusive club. The problem, of course, is when they leave this environment and move to club land, where the support, resourcing and coaching, except at premier level, is well below expectations. Unfortunately, due to maturity and resourcing, many are lost as they struggle to come to grips with going from ‘king of the kids’ to the bottom of the club heap. Of course, those lucky enough to gain a Super contract or Academy position straight from school remain in the mix, but there are the others, who have shown potential at either State of even Australian level during their schoolboy days, to warrant support during this transition. The moving of resources from a number of overpaid, underperforming ‘stars’ would perhaps assist in securing the future of 20 other possible stars of the future.
I’m also an advocate of an extended rugby season, particularly within the GPS / CAS schools although this would be difficult to achieve with a summer and winter sport, together with the representative requirements of GPS-CAS / State / and National competitions. Having said that, it’s not impossible, although a home and away series would severely limit preparation and further reduce the ability to play a summer and winter sport, be it rugby / rowing; or rugby / cricket. Difficult yes, impossible, no. However, with the dynamics of these sports changing dramatically over the last 10 years or so, rarely do you see a 1st VIII rower play for the1st XV and excel in both sports, or even cricket. Years ago, the 1st XV tight five were generally the engine room of the 1st VIII. Not any more. As I say, difficult, but not impossible.
In summary, the ARU should provide resources to assist with keeping talented players moving from schoolboy rugby to the club scene. In addition, a home and away competition within the GPS / CAS should be investigated to give the players the opportunity to improve their skills further before moving on to the club scene, with talented players who have shown themselves worthy of support by playing at State or National level, resourced to a small extent whilst transitioning to club level. IMO, this would have a significant benefit in keeping talented lads from drifting elsewhere or just losing interest. You would only need to keep a relatively small percentage of these boys to have a significant impact, not only on the club scene, but to also bolster new Super franchises coming on line in the next few years!
Klestical said | November 13th 2009 @ 4:22pm | Report comment
They should televise Schoolboy rugby. Best games of the round etc
AndyS said | November 13th 2009 @ 4:29pm | Report comment
I’d settle for a level playing field with respect to rep teams etc….
Firestarter Bob said | November 13th 2009 @ 4:32pm | Report comment
The schools could easily counter the “rugby is too rough” argument and the encroachment of soccer & AFL by offering Rugby 7s to their students. No parent could say that Rugby 7s was more dangerous than soccer or AFL.
Clubman said | November 13th 2009 @ 8:24pm | Report comment
Why does everyone rate a player on where they spent their last two years of school. McDougall & Mitchell went to Marist Eastwood and were picked up by Kings after appearing for Junior Club rugby and Sydney Under 15′s.. They were only picked up by Kings after performing at Club level and not through the school system. As for McCaffery he too was picked at junior Club level via Hillview and Eastwood well before being noticed at Riverview. You can throw all the money you want at Schoolboys Rugby but the real talent pool is Club Rugby which clearly identifies talent well before the school system does. Oh and Mark Johnson went to Knox not Kings. Find which junior clubs the players came through and see where the real money should be going. Twice the result at a tenth of the cost.