By AP
November 22nd 2009 @ 1:04am
View The Roar's top rugby union writers.
Love new art, fashion, music? Check out Aussie site which unearths all things cool and creative.
Join Australia’s community for solo & micro business at FlyingSolo.com.au
Related coverage
IRB ref manager apologises to Dickinson
International Rugby Board referees manager Paddy O’Brien has apologised to Australian match official Stuart Dickinson for publicly criticising his performance in New Zealand’s 20-6 victory over Italy.
O’Brien was quoted as saying that Dickinson, considered Australia’s leading referee, had made the wrong decisions in scrums late in the game, awarding penalties to Italy when it should [...]
This article is over 2000 days old and has been trimmed.
Going to the Waratahs v Brumbies blockbuster at ANZ Stadium, Saturday 24 April? If you're keen to meet up with other Roarers, register you interest and we'll keep you informed on the place to meet. Register now.
Get Australia's best Rugby opinion emailed daily.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...

(5)
![If there’s one thing which characterizes Australian rugby at the moment, it’s frustration. Just about everyone you speak to is frustrated and angry, frustrated and worried, or just frustrated and sad.
After fourteen years of professionalism, rugby lovers outside the professional sphere are feeling their game slip away from them.
Where once they felt a part of [...] Andrew Logan: It’s time for the launch of Rugby Australia](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/next-five-things-john-oneill-th.jpg)
![Troy Taylor was one of the feel-good stories of the draft. Nabbed by Richmond at pick 51, the 188cm teen from the Northern Territory had made it to the AFL despite his troubled past. At the beginning of last year, it would have looked like an impossible dream.
As The Age reported prior to the draft: [...] Michael DiFabrizio: Troy Taylor a work in progress, on and off field](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/troy-taylor-th.jpg)
![It was a good weekend for the underdogs in the Four Nations, and it’s almost beyond comprehension that England finished top of the table after their first forty minutes against France.
Without question the side that most impressed over the weekend was New Zealand.
Hit hard by injuries, the Kiwis showed their World [...] Steve Kaless: Four Nations review: Kiwis look the goods](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/four-nations-kiwis-warriors-th.jpg)
![The appointment of Kevin Sheedy to the new Western Sydney franchise has most in the AFL world talking. Whether it is a good idea or not, it has definitely generated interest amongst the AFL community.
Sheedy has been a master for years now at what people believe he does best, and that’s coaching. But he [...] Troy Chaplin: Sheedy’s appointment smart, but it’ll take time to work](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/sheedy-signing-sydney-th.jpg)
![Many long time fans of the European game will remember Ruud Hesp as the Barcelona custodian during the Louis van Gaal era in the late 1990s, when the Dutchmen teamed-up to win back-to-back La Liga titles and a Copa del Rey.
Hesp also featured in the Dutch national squad in a couple of major championships, at [...] Tony Tannous: Ruud reality: Verbeek needs to scatter his square lines](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/ruud-reality-pim-verbook-th.jpg)
![With his team 14-6 up after 65 minutes at an ANZ Stadium that was resembling the adjacent Aquatic Centre more and more as the game wore on, it looked for all money that Michael Ennis had secured victory for the Bulldogs.
Four Rabbitohs tried in vain to keep a firm grip on the rain soaked [...] Gabriel Knowles: Rugby league is doing away with the push and shove](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/league-doing-away-ennis-th.jpg)
![Enjoy your betting this footy season, but don’t be expected to be allowed to win. I received the following message from the bookmaker Victor Chandler. Or to be more precise, from one of his drones, last year.
“Dear Mr Kaless,
We are contacting you today advise that a business decision has been taken by our Senior Traders [...] Steve Kaless: Fighting the battle with the bookies](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/jarryd-hayne-th.jpg)
![One of the highlights of Sydney Tests is the dinner hosted by The Australian Cricket Media Association (ACMA) to present the Australian Cricketer of the Year Award at Sydney Football Stadium.
This year’s winner was Shane Watson. Brad Haddin was the winner last year and Mitchell Johnson the previous summer. As this was a Silver Jubilee [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: Watson named Australia’s best by the media](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/australian-cricket-watson-th.jpg)
![My mind was drawn to many pieces I’d read on the Roar over the past year or so when I had the chance to speak to the Cardinals’ Ben Graham ahead of Sunday’s Super Bowl. Watching Graham at ease in front of the world’s media gave me a lasting impression that footballers aren’t dumb, they [...] Steve Kaless: Ben Graham on what it takes to make it in the NFL](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/ben-graham.jpg)
![Only six points cover the bottom six on the A-League table with the finals series fast approaching. With five rounds left, plus three matches left to complete the floating Round 19, which clubs will book their finals place with a top six finish?
With Sydney, Melbourne and Gold Coast three points clear of the rest, and [...] Adrian Musolino: Which teams will be playing finals football?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/jets-fury-daal-th.jpg)
![Plenty of well wishers have dropped me a line recently in light of a fairly startling turn of events. For the first time this season, Shimizu S-Pulse have moved to the top of the J. League standings.
That the provincial outfit should currently find themselves on top of the standings is of itself no great surprise.
Under [...] Mike Tuckerman: J. League is no answer to A-League’s problems](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/kenta-hasegawa-th.jpg)




Cattledog said | November 22nd 2009 @ 2:33pm | Report comment
As I said in a MUCH earlier post. I would have expected PO’B to do exactly that. Whilst it was poor judgement initially, it takes strength of character to apologise for such actions. Well done Paddy.
ThelmaWrites said | November 22nd 2009 @ 11:20pm | Report comment
More than the apology, I am heartened by the assurances from the IRB of best practice protocols. Joh4Canberra provided the link to worldcupweb.com and this is part of the statement:
“A clear and best practice protocol exists for match official appraisal and feedback.
“While such meetings with team management are regular practice, the IRB said in a statement that it was not IRB policy to publicly comment on refereeing appraisals or to discuss details of meetings held with team officials and such feedback should be conducted via appropriate channels.
xxx “A clear and confidential best practice protocol exists for match official appraisal and feedback involving stakeholders and I regret breaking this protocol.”
I have taken the trouble of reproducing part of the statement in the hope, however vain, that the other posters in the longer thread will note this.
Joh4Canberra said | November 23rd 2009 @ 5:16am | Report comment
The problem was NOT that Paddy O’Brien thought what he thought or even that he said what he said. The problem was when, how and to whom he said it. It’s O’Brien’s job to watch refereeing performances, rate them and report back on areas of concern. But not to the media. And not to the coaches of the New Zealand All Blacks. O’Brien’s job is to raise these concerns with the referee and report back to the IRB.
This is not some wall of silence to immunise referees from criticism but rather a simple matter of respect for Dickinson as a person, for refereeing as a profession, and for the position which O’Brien holds. O’Brien’s job is not to publicly criticise referees in the media. If he wants to do that he should resign his current position and become a sports journalist or just one of the other countless armchair critics. O’Brien’s job is to assess referees’ performances, and report back areas of concern to the referee and to the IRB. By going public to the NZ media he abused his position.
Just imagine if that was a coach slagging off one of his own players like that in the media. The player would be offended as would his team mates and a lot of fans would be thinking “What on earth is going on? Why is the coach doing this before the media instead of face to face with the player his team mates at a team meeting? Does this man not have any sense of decorum?”. Yes, the coach should be honestly appraising his team’s performance and forcefully criticising a player whose performance is worthy of criticism but he shouldn’t really be slagging off his players in the media rather than going through the appropriate channels to raise his concerns. But when the referees boss does the same thing to one of his referees people somehow think that’s OK. Honestly.
Anyway, having said that at least he realised his error of judgement and was man enough to issue an apology.
Wix said | November 23rd 2009 @ 7:55pm | Report comment
Refereess must be publicy criticised, just like players. The ARU has all but said it is ok to do so. Refereeing standards have been abysmal for many years. Most of them, like Stuart Dickinson, have next to no playing experience. And it shows mostly in their adjudication of forward play, where 80% of the game takes place.
Please do not tell me that playing experience is not a pre-requisite. This is rugby, not simplistic codes like League, AFL and soccer.
Spare me
Cattledog said | November 23rd 2009 @ 8:24pm | Report comment
Wix, you may be at the right grid reference, but your definately on the wrong planet!