The fly on the wall report from Murrayfield
By Brett McKay, 24 Nov 2009 Brett McKay is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- murrayfield, Rugby Union, scotland rugby, wallabies

Australia's Quade Cooper, top right, leaps for a ball during the International Rugby Union test match against Scotland at Murrayfield Stadium, Edinburgh, Scotland. Saturday, Nov. 21, 2009. AP Photo/Chris Clark
So while I went back to bed at 6:15am on Sunday morning wondering how the bloody hell the Wallabies could lose to Scotland like they did, the fly on the wall in the Murrayfield dressing rooms did some scouting for me.
On his return, after a long flight from cold and wet Edinburgh, he landed in front of me, pulled out his recorder, and said only one thing.
“I’m not naming names, but the voice you’ll hear has a slight Kiwi accent, and was wearing a Wallabies jacket.”
With that, he hit Play.
“Rocky, just gather them in, we’ve gotta head down to the press conference in a minute.”
(Muffled response)
“Yeah, I know mate, but at least you’ve only just been appointed. No knives out for you just yet.
“Right guys, I’ll try and keep this brief. How can I say this…..? Not happy, boys. Not happy at all. They’ll ask me if this is the lowest point of my international coaching career, and right now all I can think of as an answer is ‘Undoubtedly.’
“That’s probably the best I can offer.
“I can just imagine what the news back in Australia’s going to be like. Imagine what that mob on The Roar will be saying. Davey Pokes, I thought you writing for them was supposed to get them off our backs?
“I’ll just go around the room quickly. Where’s the Bens? Ben-with-two-Ns, I know your shoulder’s not flash, but what was happening in the scrums before you came off? I thought you reckoned you’d have these blokes covered?
“The other Ben, you came into the camp saying you were a flyhalf trapped in a prop’s body at the Brumbies, but you’ve barely touched the ball since we left home. Get involved more mate, if we wanted a no-impact tighthead we would have stuck with Baxter.
“Scrum was great once Keps came on, though; the Scots couldn’t go backwards quick enough.
“Moorey, great throwing tonight, the quick throw really caught them off guard. In hindsight I probably shouldn’t have dragged you. But how did you not score that try?
“Murrayfield has the biggest in-goals on the planet and you still couldn’t find a blade of grass somewhere?!? Actually, Rocky you’re in that boat too.
“Kev, Chis, just give your jumpers to the managers, we’ll use them again next week in Cardiff. Actually Chis, just hold yours up mate… yeah, they won’t even need washing.
“The lineout, boys. First half was great, quick throws, jumping at two, all worked a treat. So why when Taffy came on did you start calling the throws to the back again? Didn’t you learn that lesson in Dublin, and London? And Tokyo? And Wellington? And … well, you get the point.
“Now you blokes reckoned you’d be right at training this year with Jimmy on his own, that was why we let Foles take the Head, sorry, Forwards Coach job with the ‘Tahs. You’re not convincing me, boys.
“Cliffy’s headed off to hospital for scans, but he was great again tonight. Now you know much work you’ve gotta do to get back, don’t you Browny?
“Rocky, well played again tonight mate, I heard Growden in the tunnel saying something about another glowing write-up. Smithy, you’ve done well again, and that should keep bloody Waugh out of the papers with his opinions. Pokes will probably be back in Cardiff, but keep working hard at training.
“Genii, more quality tonight mate, I thought there was two of you. If you’re not going to shave the head and really be The Next George Gregan, can you at least start telling the refs how to do their job? Burge, you can play against Cardiff, and you can probably sit on the bench next Saturday, but I don’t know much beyond that.
“I told you it’d be a roller-coaster, and you’re driving the up-and-down train currently. Actually, you should go with Moorey and Taffy when they find a barn door to practice throwing at this week.
“Gits, kick through the ball, for Carter’s sake! Why are you stabbing at everything suddenly? And hurry up too mate, you nearly kicked that last one into them! Enough of this one-out crash ball too, this is rugby mate, not mini-league in Queanbeyan.
“And I know you don’t like Burge, but when he comes on, I expect you to take the pass – wherever it comes – and play from there. Stop this business of shooting back glares and general moping. You tell the world you prefer playing 10, so start playing 10.
“Quadey, another good game tonight mate, great passing, and defence too. Thought your long ball for Mitch was thrown backwards actually, but when you ignore three blokes and throw the pass 35m on the run, it’s gonna drift forward, isn’t it?
“Crossy, have you met Mitch and Hynesy? They’re the two blokes that stand on the sideline without flags. They’re actually there to support you in attack, so you know, feel free to use them. That said, you blokes on the wings can always wrap back inside and cut Crossy out too.
“Yes Crossy, I know you got the try mate, but what about the other 79 minutes?
“Coopy-two-names, some great counter tonight, and not so many dud kicks for a change. Thought you worked well with Hynesy too, but when Mitch is going to run through after a kick, you’re gonna need to go with him, ‘cos someone will need to make the tackle.
“You bench guys, keep working hard at training, and play well against Cardiff with the bag-carriers and Kurtley. Jamesy, little fella, you’re obviously a talent, we’ll keep bringing you on slowly.
“Anyway, I better get down there, though I’m sure it won’t be pretty. I just saw Eddie Jones reminding the League hack the Telegraph sent over of his win percentage. More bloody Lote questions, too, I’m sure.
“Undoubtedly …”
Follow Brett McKay on Twitter: @BMcSport
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- murrayfield, Rugby Union, scotland rugby, wallabies

pothale said | November 24th 2009 @ 4:39am | Report comment
Nicely done, Brett.
Rickety Knees said | November 24th 2009 @ 5:37am | Report comment
Good one mate
Arky said | November 24th 2009 @ 5:38am | Report comment
Agreed – nice read.
fred said | November 24th 2009 @ 6:44am | Report comment
BRETT,nice one ;and i wonder if the theorists view of coaching being physical,technicai, tactical and mental has rob deans struggling in the all important mental side.they say your thoughts fuel your emotions dont they?pragmatically deans needed to handle this culture differently;imo he has misread it and suffers the consequences.
LeftArmSpinner said | November 24th 2009 @ 7:04am | Report comment
Brett, and excellent article. The premise and structure are just fantastic. Once again, it shows THE ROLE that the Roar has to play in journalism’s future.
I also had a recording device in the Wallabies change room. It must be an older version then yours, because mine didn’t have the foul language editing function that yours was clearly did.
Here are some excerpts of my recording
” Matthew! Matthew!!!!!!!!! MATTHEW!!!! Lose the comb! and get the fock over here. Now. Now! NOW!!!!!!
“You have been playing test match rugby for seven years. 51 test matches. You are paid $1,000,000 to play footy. So, Fill me in on what the fock was going on out there?? Are you completely stupid? Are you completely deaf or have you been wearing your “mummie’s boy” Headgear too tight again? We have a deal. You get the jersey with 10 on the back and then stay out of the first receiver position. No ifs and no fockin buts!!!!!”
There is a long pause!
“Giteau, Giteau. GITEAU!!!! Concentrate on what I am saying to you. Giteau, Giteau. GITEAU!!!! Fock!!! You have the attention Span of a nat! So the deal was to stay out of first receiver? What’s happened if there? WHAT HAPPENED THERE??? Just for your benefit, in every fucking game of rugby we have eight players and times more, trying to get hold of the ball, you know, the white oval thing!!!! Fill me in on what is going through your head when you then decide to kick it straight back to the poeple we have just got it from. What the fock!!!!! How many times have I told you the fastest thing on the field is the ball?? How many times?”
There is another long pause with some huffing and puffing in the background.
“Our forwards, despite Pre tour injuries in the locks and losing Bennie in the game, got you a stack of ball and you’re wasted it completely against some courageous tackling but a lowly rugby team. So here is the deal. Next TIME I see you at first receiver, be prepared to join the bench warmers. You will be picking splinters out of your arse for a very long time.
“And for what it is worth, with your goalkicking, when you start missing things to the left, adjust your technique or at least aim more to the right!!!! Dont just keep kickin’ it like the last time!!!!!!”
shaun lewis said | February 7th 2012 @ 12:16am | Report comment
nobody talk to giteau like that
Harry said | November 24th 2009 @ 7:36am | Report comment
Very good.
I wonder what they do actually say ? Managing Gen Y’s aint easy I know. Clearly Gits is in a permanent sulk these days, I think Deans has to bench him for this weekend. May as well experiment and we can’t 1) goalkick worse 2) be any worse in the backline attack. Defensive weakness if we play Quade or Kurtley at 10? For sure, but heh if it means some tries (for both sides!) I’ll wear it
I have banged on before how this tour reminds me of the 81 tour. Those with long memories might remeber that one of the main reasons we lost those games was the sudden loss of form in the goalkicking department of the previously reliable toepoker-style Paul McLean. Similarly, it can be reasonably argued that had Gits had his kicking boots on against Ireland and Scotland we would have won those games.
But of course he didn’t and the Wallabies didn’t. In 84, 3 years after that disappointing tour, Roger Gould (the last of the toepokers) and an emerging Michael Lynagh banged em over from everywhere. Fine line some times in history.
Brett McKay said | November 24th 2009 @ 8:03am | Report comment
Hi guys, glad you all enjoyed the read. As well as shaking my head as I went back to bed on Sunday morning, I was thinking “what would Robbie be saying to them right now?’, and from that it all flowed. Flowed so well in fact that I knocked the whole article out in under an hour!! Anyway, we can only guess what was said, and so here’s mine.
Leftie, we spoke of this yesterday (and I had to be very careful not to say anything I’d already written here!), but Giteau HAS to kick THROUGH the ball. It’s probably just a minor tweak needed, but it is needed nonetheless. Maybe sit in a room with a copy of Caddyshack (“Just be the ball….”)
As for the team this weekend, injuries may play a big role in selection, but if everyone was fit and available, I would probably only swap Cooper and Giteau, and tell Gits to start getting used to 12 again. I still wonder if that’s where he’ll play for the Brumbies next season too, with young Toomua (or Lealiifano) at 10. Once Barnes is fit, he’ll be in the 10, so Giteau’s transition may as well start now…
pothale said | November 24th 2009 @ 8:15am | Report comment
Brett – lovely piece of writing. when it flows, it flows – doesn’t matter the time of day or night. Love that feeling.
Brett McKay said | November 24th 2009 @ 8:38am | Report comment
absolutely Pots – I looked up at my wife on Sunday afternoon, and said “I’m done”, and her reply was “what, already?!?” It was only when I looked at the file create time that we realised I’d knocked it out in just under an hour. Love that feeling indeed, makes writing about sport worthwhile.
As do all these comments, thanks again guys!!
Pete said | November 24th 2009 @ 3:12pm | Report comment
I heard/read this morning that Gits kicking coach, who is sitting back in NZ, said that he has started putting the ball too upright on the tee, in the style of Wilkinson and Carter. The difference is that Carter and Wilkinson are power kickers. Gits isn’t he said. The coach (whose names escapes me) said that these small technical flaws creep in on long tours that are barely noticeable unless the coach is there to correct it… he reckons Gits kicking will be on song next weekend now they have picked it up. Shame they didn’t pick it up after the Irish match!
Perhaps on future tours the kicking coach should come or at least send practise videos to him for analysis!
Rusty said | November 24th 2009 @ 8:09am | Report comment
top read
sheek said | November 24th 2009 @ 8:27am | Report comment
Brett,
Lovely stuff. When confronted with tragedy, it’s better to find something to laugh about, rather than cry.
Your humorously imaginative narrative did just the trick.
Well done again!
Brett McKay said | November 24th 2009 @ 8:35am | Report comment
Sheek, it truly is a sad old world if you can’t laugh at yourself – and it beats crying, everyday of the week, and especially in the early hours of Sundays in November!!
LeftArmSpinner said | November 24th 2009 @ 9:16am | Report comment
Shame we can’t cheer it!!! But you go for the almighty big dollars at Roar Corp and you leave us of the grassroots behind. (Sob, Sob!!!)
But, While Chis is not a test player (anymore???) and Horwill has yet to recapture his earlier form, the rest are doing acceptably given age, lack experience and new combinations. But, the team has no brain!!!! A brain that calls the plays, gives direction and “encouragement”. Rocky is doing his best but the VC from the backs could do so much more.
Ben A has gone off the boil a bit but this must be tempered with his being the rock of the scrum at such a young age and with ssssssso little experience. Dropping Moore has had the desired effect and he is in better form than early in the season.
Forget the locks. as a player category, they are the last to be renewed with youth (excluding Horwill) but it is a timing issue.
the back row is looking good with Palu back to form, Pocock improving and Elsom consistent.
Genia is still improving. Burgess has things to offer but is 2nd fiddle to Genia. Cooper is improving with every game. I liked his broken field play and running, he has a lovely pass and he is tackling well. Ioane was direct and strong in attack and defence on very little game time since April. AAC is my favourite and first picked. Mitchell is playing better than early in the season, but is providing about 30% of Hynes. a waste
Giteau is out of position and out of step with the coach and other players is “focked” in the head. Yes, the emperor has no clothes. Bench him and see whether he gets the message and then what he has really got.