By ScottWoodward.me -
November 28th 2009 @ 12:07am
Get a Roar profile
Related coverage
Greg Bird no guarantee for State of Origin
I woke the other morning to Sky Radio’s Big Breakfast with anchor Terry Kennedy expressing his view on Greg Bird to Jimmy Smith, who gained a start off the bench when Michael Slater had more pressing concerns at the Gabba.
Now that the controversial court case is over and Greg can add “FREE AS A” to his middle name as opposed to “JAIL”, TK just assumed the former Test pivot will be handed the prized number 6 guernsey for NSW in the State of Origin next year. He made no mention of the Anzac Test and if the former Australian Juniors Captain would replace Darryn Lockyer.
In my previous article on who will replace Darren Lockyer, Greg Bird was not on my list of suggestions, which included:
Jonathan Thurston: The best half back in the world, but plays a similar game to Lockyer and handles 6 without a problem. Providing the selectors could find the right 7 to combine with him, the dilemma would be solved. Scott Prince and Cooper Cronk would be the contenders.
Todd Carney: No question marks on his talent, but he has some fences to mend and how he starts at the Roosters will determine his playing future. If Coach Brian Smith elects to play him at fullback, his rep chances will be dashed. In a perfect world I would love to see him combine with Thurston in the national team. The combination would be a nightmare for any opposing coach.
Terry Campese: Didn’t grab his chance at his first crack at Origin football, and there is a feeling that he is not a big time player, but still highly regarded by selectors.
John Sutton: With Mateo he has the most God given talent, but he can go wandering which concerns the men that count. He has a new head coach now, and if he can put it all together weekly, his sheer talent will make it impossible to ignore.
Feleti Mateo: Born in Auburn NSW, he has already played five eight for Tonga and the Australian Schoolboys as well as representing NSW (under 19s) against Queensland. He is unstoppable when he is hot, but he is not always hot.
Jarrad Mullen: Thrown to the wolves in State of Origin, he has never shown his true talent. He may struggle to get another crack.
Daniel Mortimer: An immense talent but he does not have the organizing skills for such a key job.
Jamie Soward: The selectors only think about his poor defence.
Tim Moltzen: Benjy playing at 6 at club level hurts him.
Wade Graham: Promising but behind in the long queue.
Also I suggested that Trent Barrett and Braith Anasta are the two most experienced 6s and could always plug a hole if the selectors choose to not go with youth.
Greg Bird may have been acquitted of glassing his girlfriend, but the Gold Coast Titans fans have convicted him with the vast majority voting against him playing for their team in 2010 in a poll taken. There is a concern that if the Titans do sign Bird, that they may have a backlash, especially from female supporters.
But getting back to TK and his statement that Bird will be given the Blues State of Origin number 6, a miracle would need to happen.
Bird would need to:
1. Want to play in the NRL
2. Be cleared by the NRL
3. Sign with a club
4. Find his best form after such a long break from the NRL.
There can be no doubting the toughness and the talent of Greg Bird, but even if all of the above four points could be ticked of, his best position is lock forward and not pivot, and that is taken by his ex team mate Paul Gallen.
If TK happens to be correct, fans of Trent Barrett, Braith Anasta and Terry Campese will likely follow the Titans supporters.
I’ll go with my original list.
Get Australia's best NRL opinion emailed daily.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...


(12)
![There was a strange mood around the DW Stadium in Wigan on Saturday night following the Kangaroos defeat of England, and it was tricky to work out just what you’d witnessed and what it all meant. Saturday’s Test was certainly the best example of ‘a game of two halves’ I’d seen in a long, long [...] Steve Kaless: Kangaroos win a hard one to read](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/kangaroos-win-hard-one-th.jpg)
![Peter Roebuck in a forthright column in the SMH some days ago made the fearless statement that the current Australian side cannot win back the Ashes. If this is true then the much put-upon selectors (who got Shane Watson right as an opener, it must be remembered) will have to start putting together a side [...] Spiro Zavos: Can this Australian side win back the Ashes?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/australian-cricket-ponting-th.jpg)
![Australian rugby could find itself with nothing to celebrate this weekend as its Super rugby teams head for a clean sweep of losses heading into Round Two of competition.
With several players either ruled out or under injury clouds, and only the Reds playing at home, it shapes up as a rotten weekend for Aussie rugby [...] Andrew Logan: Look out Aussies, it’s a Super ambush!](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/reds-stormers-th.jpg)
![In wake of Geelong’s Matthew Stokes’ alleged possession and trafficking of cocaine, the AFL has again been forced to defend its illicit drugs policy, which was introduced in 2005 with the assistance of the AFL Players’ Association.
Stokes is facing criminal charges and there is no proof, at this stage, that he has actually taken any [...] Luke D'Anello: Forget the criticism, AFL’s drug testing not a soft hand](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/is-there-place-bump-ben-cousins-th.jpg)
![Despite their reality check overnight, the Socceroos, for so long the underachievers and forgotten Australian national team, are making a strong case for being the countries premier sporting entity, the most marketable and the biggest drawcard.
Since their long awaited World Cup qualification in 2005, they have threatened the domination of the Wallabies and [...] Adrian Musolino: Socceroos are now Australia’s premier national team](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/socceroos-australias-premier-national-viduka-th.jpg)
![I know, I know. In the past I have been critical of Ricky Ponting’s leadership and of the Australian selectors’ wisdom. But their performances in the series against India on foreign soil against all odds show that Australia is a champion cricket nation.
Losing nine players through injuries, besides Andrew Symonds and Adam Gilchrist, in [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: Hats off to Ponting’s professionals](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/ponting-only-current-player-th.jpg)
![Despite individual brilliance, Pakistan has not reached its full potential in Test cricket. They have made headlines of the wrong sort in their 57 years as a Test nation. Internal dissensions, captaincy disputes and accusations of ball-tampering, bribery, and match-throwing are often associated with their national teams.
One might say, when Pakistanis play a match, can [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: Are the Pakistan cricket controversies really justified?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/are-pakistan-cricketers-shoaib-malik-th.jpg)
![Casting an eye over the A-League over the past month or two, what is becoming abundantly clear is that the teams that are using technique and mobility in the front third are the ones playing the most fluid and effective football.
You only have to look at the top of the table to see how [...] Tony Tannous: Technique and mobility up front are all the rage](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/technique-mobility-up-frontrudan-ognenovski-reinaldo-th.jpg)
![It was a good weekend for the underdogs in the Four Nations, and it’s almost beyond comprehension that England finished top of the table after their first forty minutes against France.
Without question the side that most impressed over the weekend was New Zealand.
Hit hard by injuries, the Kiwis showed their World [...] Steve Kaless: Four Nations review: Kiwis look the goods](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/four-nations-kiwis-warriors-th.jpg)
![Enough is enough. It’s time for the FFA and Melbourne Heart chief executive Scott Munn and chairman Peter Sidwell to bite the bullet, ignore the competition to name the club being run in the Herald Sun, and keep the working title of Melbourne’s second A-League franchise.
In case you haven’t been following the saga [...] Adrian Musolino: The Melbourne Heart name saga rolls on](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/how-important-names-colours-schip-a-league-th.jpg)
![Forget for a moment the cause of Robbie Fowler’s tiff with North Queensland Fury coach Ian Ferguson – that type of disagreement can happen at any club in any league around the world. What’s been fascinating is the response from the public and media.
For the uninitiated, Fowler refused to play on Saturday night against [...] Adrian Musolino: Fowler ‘crisis’ shows A-League’s precarious state](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/fowler-smarts-th.jpg)
![Rugby is a game defined by its lower levels, and in terms of basic hygiene, few bathroom facilities would rate lower than the gentlemen’s restroom under the Charles Wells stand at Goldington Road, the home of the Bedford Blues.
Airing an odour similar in my imagination to Anchorman’s notorious fragrance Sex Panther, these restrooms and [...] Garth Hamilton: The ARU should stop deriding English rugby](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/england-host-rugby-cup-phil-vickery-th.jpg)




Firestarter Bob said | November 28th 2009 @ 7:36am | Report comment
Unless and until Bird apologises for the damage he has done to the code’s reputation and image he should not even be considered back into a NRL team.
M1tch said | November 28th 2009 @ 7:46am | Report comment
If Bird comes back he would be a good 13 for NSW
Springs said | November 28th 2009 @ 9:55am | Report comment
If Bird replaces Gallen then put him in.
ScottWoodward.me said | November 28th 2009 @ 10:33am | Report comment
Springs did you see the Final of the 4 Nations? Gallen was our best forward and if NSW want to beat Q’Land, who have some real problems at the moment, then Gallen MUST play.
M1tch said | November 28th 2009 @ 6:21pm | Report comment
Gallens origin record is poor, heaps of penalties and drop ball, he has passion which I love but his a always a risk
Springs said | November 28th 2009 @ 10:45am | Report comment
I would rather have Hindmarsh than Gallen. Gallen was our best forward in the Four Nations Final but has a history o stuffing up at Origin level. If he can get the terrible offloads and dirty penalties out of his game then he should play, but if he doesn’t I see no reason for him to be picked over Hindmarsh, Watmough, Creagh, Lewis, Laffranchi, Waterhouse, even Bird.
ScottWoodward.me said | November 28th 2009 @ 11:01am | Report comment
The role of a back rower is to defend and be dangerous in attack, hopefully hurting the opposition and setting up your outside backs. Hindmarsh is a great defender but he does not hurt or scare anyone when he has the ball. If I have backed his team, I sit back and relax when he has the ball because he just has not the skills offensively like Gallen, Watmough, Tupou, Stewart, Hoffman, O’Donnell and Creagh. All these guys can also play for 80 minutes if required.
He is an out and out robot but some coaches love robots in their team and the Eels certainly go much better with Hindmarsh in, but NSW is completely different.
Springs said | November 28th 2009 @ 11:11am | Report comment
Well NSW picked a team full of ‘attacking’ back rowers last series and their attack was terrible. Hindmarsh bribgs more than just great defence. Do you remember when Folau kicked back inside in Game 1 and Thurston ran past three NSW players to dive on the ball, the NSW players just gave up. Hindmarsh would not give up. That’s the difference he makes to a team. I would have him as NSW Captain. And NSW seemed to go much better with Hindmarsh in the side.
ScottWoodward.me said | November 28th 2009 @ 11:49am | Report comment
Dont disagree with anything you said and I would have no problems with him in my team although I like to see my skipper talk on the field.
If Kimmorley is the number 7 and based on SOO 3 this year it would be hard to take it off him proving he starts 2010 ok, then he will be the on field Captain regardless of who has the big “C” after their name.
Springs said | November 28th 2009 @ 11:52am | Report comment
I support Kimmorley for halfback and have no problem with him being captain.
Mick from Giralang said | November 28th 2009 @ 12:54pm | Report comment
Are Braith Anasta and Barrett considered to be past it?
ScottWoodward.me said | November 28th 2009 @ 2:05pm | Report comment
Neither Kimmorley or Barrett are past it. They are a little slower, but are both very fit and play a smart game.
2009 was clearly one of Kimmorleys best seasons which is saying something given that he kept Andrews Johns from the Test 7 jumper once. With Barrett it is what you see you get. he rarely has a bad game and always is dangerous. I thought his contribution in 2009 was immense under difficult circumstances. I would love to see him have a full season with Gallen and Tupou.