By Laine Clark
November 28th 2009 @ 1:16am
Related coverage
Johnson happy with new system despite his demise
While still believing he was not out, Australian dangerman Mitchell Johnson on Friday backed the new umpire review system that has caused controversy at the first Test against the West Indies.
Johnson left the Gabba field in obvious disappointment when dismissed for seven in Australia’s first innings of 8(dec)-480, but changed his tune by stumps on the second day.
Johnson was given out caught behind off spinner Sulieman Benn but asked for the decision to be reviewed.
Although hot spot technology did not detect a knick, the outcome was deemed “umpire’s call”.
Umpire Ian Gould duly stuck by his decision – much to Johnson’s disappointment.
But the Australian later said he had copped the decision on the chin and fully backed the new system that still has some players confused.
“Originally I thought I wasn’t out, that’s why I went to the referral, and it came back that I was out so I guess you just accept those decisions,” Johnson said.
“I still think the system works pretty well.
“It went upstairs and came back I think as the umpire’s decision.
“At the time I didn’t think I hit it, that’s why I referred it but you accept it – you move on.”
There were no grey areas when the tourists used their two appeals for the innings in quick succession on Friday as they crashed to be 5-134 by stumps.
But it still didn’t seem to clear up uncertainty about the new system judging by Windies keeper Denesh Ramdin.
“I am still trying to get used to it,” he said.
“It has its bad side and it has its good side.”
Asked to elaborate Ramdin said: “You saw it today.”
Ramdin (22 not out) and Travis Dowlin (40 not out) battled on to stumps.
But they must try to hold out Australia knowing they do not have the luxury of an appeal following the dismissals of key batsmen Chris Gayle (31) and Shiv Chanderpaul (2).
Gayle was trapped in front by Ben Hilfenhaus and began walking before asking for a review.
Ball tracking technology revealed it was one of the most plumb LBWs in Test cricket history.
Chanderpaul then asked when he was given LBW to Peter Siddle – and technology’s findings were just as ugly for a Windies supporter.
Ramdin didn’t begrudge their best two batsmen using up the team’s appeal quota.
“Generally if it is an important batsman, try to use it, unfortunately it didn’t come off today,” he said.
Of the Windies’ reviews, Johnson said: “We thought they were pretty much out, but that’s how they want to use it.”
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...

(1)
![First we had Super June, now it’s the Octoberfest of Football, with the FFA overseeing over 200 games and more than 18,000 minutes of action this month.
Admittedly the vast majority of the games will take place at the national youth championship for our best under 14s and 15s boys, currently being held Coffs Harbour, but [...] Tony Tannous: A mouth watering week of football ahead](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/open-letter-socceroos-th.jpg)
![I enjoy all forms of cricket. But I was initially against last year’s IPL Twenty20 extravaganza staged in India: cricketers auctioned like cattle, teams chosen by billionaires with little interest in cricket, teams not selected to represent their country or State. Not my cup of tea.
But it was a grand spectacle and I watched [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: Is the IPL a mutant destroying the game?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/ipl-mutant-symonds-th.jpg)
![Late last week, the South Dragons pulled out of the 2009/10 basketball season. A few days later, the Melbourne Tigers joined them. By that point, it seemed like finally someone in the sport had the foresight to say enough is enough. Pity it didn’t last.
Now Basketball Australia is forging ahead with the teams that didn’t [...] Michael DiFabrizio: Forget the bandaids, the NBL needs genuine reform](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/forget-bandaids-nbl-dragons-th.jpg)
![Oh what a fickle bunch we are! Three months ago the Sharks were everyone’s sneaky tip for the Grand Final now you are hard pressed to find anyone who reckons they deserve a place in the comp.
They become a punching bag for the press and if there is one thing that everyone seems to [...] Steve Kaless: The Sharks are worth fighting for](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/sharks-out-of-depth-quinn-th.jpg)
![As the time of the year rapidly approaches where we take time to reflect on all things good and bad over the past twelve months, it seems the perfect time for me to cleanse the mind of all those seemingly confident and assured predictions made this year on The Roar.
So where do I start?
Well, back [...] Brett McKay: Confessing the worst sports predictions of 2009](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/david-warner-th.jpg)
![Tonight, UEFA Champions League football returns to the Emirates, 113 days since its last appearance at Arsenal’s home ground. On that occasion, Gunners fans held up giant placards that spelled “believe,” before seeing their team humbled by Manchester United.
This time round it will be the away fans clinging to hope with Arsenal expected to [...] Davidde Corran: As history repeats, there’s no way back for Scotland](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/a-league-celtic-scott-mcdonald-th.jpg)
![The player drain is now without doubt the biggest concern for the A-League and all the other issues – crowd numbers, style of play and franchise development – can be traced back to this exodus. While it can never be stopped, measures can be taken, and quickly, to slow this trend.
Firstly, it is important [...] Adrian Musolino: FFA, it’s time to slow the player-drain now!](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/central-coast-mariners-player-drain-th.jpg)
![Are the Australian selectors expressing the growing concerns of the greater national cricket punditry by giving Brad Haddin a match in charge of the international team?
Haddin had shown for a number of years at New South Wales that he had the tactical and leadership nous to be a skipper at the elite level. In [...] Geoff Lawson: ACB have had enough of blonde tips and sports cars](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/why-clarke-haddin-th.jpg)
![No doubt Lionel Messi, Xavi Hernandez and Andreas Iniesta were the stars of this wonderful Barcelona performance, but I want to pay a tribute to the unsung heroes and tactics that helped them claim their second European title in four seasons.
Leading in, I felt Manchester United held the aces. Not because they have the [...] Tony Tannous: Bow to Barcelona’s superb work off the ball](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/06/bow-to-barcelona-yaya-toure-th.jpg)
![When Football Federation Australia chairman Frank Lowy announced that Australia were hoping to both host and win the 2018 FIFA World Cup you could almost hear the sniggers echoing around the globe.
The Socceroos squad that made such great inroads in Germany 2006 might have been filled with players of European quality like Viduka, Kewell and [...] Davidde Corran: Socceroos 2018 aspirations to begin in Egypt](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/socceroos-2018-egypt-blatter-lowy-th.jpg)
![Troy Bayliss continues imperiously towards his third World Superbike crown tonight at Vallelunga, Italy. When he claims the crown, it won’t command back page headlines or sports bulletins in Australia.
Sporting success by Aussie athletes competing overseas is taken for granted in this country.
But Bayliss deserves to be considered amongst the great Australian sporting exports.
In [...] Adrian Musolino: Bayliss one of Australia’s great sporting exports](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2008/10/troy-bayliss-th.jpg)
![There are losses, and then there is what happened to the Minnesota Vikings in last weekend’s NFC Championship Game. Vikings fans thought 1998 was horrible, but this puts that to shame.
In 1998, Vikings’ kicker Morten Anderson missed a field goal which would have clinched the game — at least then they got to kick.
This time [...] David Wiseman: Are some teams just destined for heartbreak each season?](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/why-sept-soward-young-th.jpg)




davido said | November 28th 2009 @ 12:29pm | Report comment
So does that decision, although blatantly wrong, count towards the 97% of decisions umpires get right?