Australia's James O'Connor

Australia's James O'Connor, center, tries to break through the tackle of New Zealand All Blacks during the Bledisloe Cup rugby test at the National Olympic Stadium in Tokyo, Saturday, Oct. 31, 2009. All Blacks won the test, 32-19. (AP Photo/Shuji Kajiyama)

61,551 fans saw the All Blacks get beaten by the Barbarians (with 7 South Africans and four Australians giving the side some flair and toughness) by 25 – 18. For all the complaints about ‘what’s wrong with rugby’ this festival match drew a crowd four times bigger than the London rugby league Test between England and Australia in the Four Nations tournament.

You could argue that the second string All Blacks side looked mediocre compared with the brilliant team that trounced France with five tries a week ago at Marseille. Stephen Donald at first five-eighths in the first half once again gave an impression of a puppet that had its strings cut every time he got the ball.

And the commentators, especially Justin Marshall, raved about Jason Leonard at halfback. Perhaps they have the same manager (only facetious, Jason) but it did seem to me that Leonard bombed about three tries, any one of which at the time would have sealed the game for the All Blacks.

Another way of looking at the second string All Blacks is that they came within one converted try of drawing with a terrific side, with Bryan Habana at his magical best. And they did this with a mediocre performance from Donald, Rondey So’aialo, Liam Messam, and without their great players (except for Richie McCaw in the first 40 minutes). This is the attitude that the usually All Blacks-knocking British rugby media has initially taken, anyway.

The All Blacks are ranked the number one team in the world despite the fact that they have had a 10 wins and five losses season.

The claims for the international side of the year, though, lie between the Springboks with their series win over the British and Irish Lions and their emphatic victory in the Tri-Nations tournament, and Ireland who have been unbeaten in 2009 with a Grand Slam (for the first time in 60 years) and defeating the Springboks two weeks ago.

Because I am a romantic as far as rugby is concerned I don’t think that teams that emphasise the football part of rugby football should be held up for admiration. The Springboks simply played too much boring rugby (admittedly winning rugby until they got to Europe and were defeated by France and Ireland) to be put on a pedestal.

Ireland won their Tests (and the draw on time against the Wallabies) by having a complete rugby game.

The forwards were combative and skillful, with the scrum being the only obvious weakness, and the backs were always inclined to run the ball at their opponents.

My man of the season must be Fourie du Preez.

He is, I am sure, the finest South African since Danie Craven (who I’ve only read about) in the 1930s. Du Preez’s attack, his sniping runs, his covering, his kicking, his ability to organise an attack make him the perfect player. So much of the Springboks and the Bulls success revolves around him.

For Australian rugby the season has been for the most part an annus horribilis.

All the Super 14 teams were poor. None of them made the finals.

Worse still, the NSW Waratahs, in particular, played in such a lethargic, brain-dead manner that even the most loyal of supporters felt inclined to give them away.

The Wallabies started the Test season well against Italy and France and then fell into a heap during the Tri-Nations. There was a stand-out victory against the Springboks at Brisbane which was followed by one of the most gutless performances even given by a Wallabies side against the All Blacks at Wellington.

Just as the All Blacks could not defeat the Springboks this season (a pattern maintained by the Boks-led Barbarians), the Wallabies could not defeat the All Blacks, losing four times to them this season.

It has been pointed out that the Wallabies came within a few points of winning a most unlikely Grand Slam on their Spring tour.

There were good victories against England and Wales: a draw against Ireland, after the home side was outplayed for most of the match, and a loss to Scotland when the home side was totally out-played throughout the match.

Like the All Blacks against France, the Wallabies ended their Test season on a high with a splendid victory over Wales, no easy thing at Millennium Stadium.

And for the Barbarians, Matt Giteau played a magnificent game to show that he is worthy (at times) of being mentioned in the same sentence as Daniel Carter.

The emphatic victory over Wales gave the Wallabies some momentum into next year.

Melbourne has won the 5th Australian Super Rugby franchise which gives rugby a footprint across the entire eastern seaboard.

And on Thursday, so I understand, the Super 14 coaches will meet with the ARU’s John O’Neill and Robbie Deans to be told that they have to lift the intensity, performance and entertainment levels of their teams.

All his gives hope for better things for 2010. Play on!

Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.

Get a daily rugby union email

Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it.

We value privacy. More.