There’s light at end of tunnel for the 2009 Wallabies
By Darren Walton, 16 Dec 2009 Darren Walton is a Roar Pro
- Tagged:
- 2011 Rugby World Cup, Rugby Union, wallabies
A first defeat to lowly Scotland in 27 years, four more losses to New Zealand – making it a sorry seven straight – last place in the Tri Nations, three wins from their past 11 Tests and no Australian franchise in the Super 14 finals.
Yet the Wallabies remain among the favourites to host the 2011 Rugby World Cup. Go figure.
But that is the extraordinary truth after Australian rugby’s leanest season of the 14-year professional era.
While the short-sighted point to the ill-fated grand slam campaign as further evidence the Wallabies are lagging behind perennial world powers New Zealand and South Africa, the end-of-season tour of Britain and Ireland in reality proved a resounding success.
Success should not be judged on results alone.
Besides, one one-point loss from six matches, including Tests against England, Ireland, Scotland and Wales on consecutive weekends for the first time in 25 years, is hardly an unmitigated disaster.
Yes, the 9-8 humbling in Edinburgh was difficult for fans to swallow – but even more so for vanquished captain Rocky Elsom, who looked to have scored a match-winning second-half try that ultimately would have meant the 2009 Wallabies became the first Australian travelling team in a century to complete an unbeaten grand slam tour.
It’s a fine line, especially for the most-maligned national sporting team in Australia.
Unless the Wallabies are winning week in, week out, they are seen as flops.
To Australia’s rivals, though, coach Robbie Deans is the envy of the international rugby world.
Classy 21-year-olds Will Genia and David Pocock may well be the world’s premier players in their respective – and key – positions with another 20-odd Tests under their belts by 2011, while 25-year-old loosehead prop Benn Robinson already is.
All up, the average age of the Wallabies line-up for the year-ending rout of Wales at Millennium Stadium was just 24, with Elsom and long-time match-winners Matt Giteau and second-half injection George Smith providing the necessary experience.
Throw in the likes of outstanding teenage utility James O’Connor, plus Digby Ioane and Quade Cooper – who proved a revelation as an untried centre pairing in the absence of Stirling Mortlock and Berrick Barnes – and Kurtley Beale as the 17th player Deans has introduced to the Test arena and the Wallabies coach looks blessed with backline talent.
But Australia’s greatest strength, strangely enough, lay in the forwards.
With Wycliff Palu back firing and Elsom and Pocock also among the form players on the Spring tour, there’s no longer room in the back row for 109-Test veteran Smith.
Up front, with Robinson joining forces with converted tighthead Ben Alexander and powerhouse hookers Stephen Moore and Tatafu Polota-Nau, the Wallabies scrum, after years of derision, is now winning front-foot ball for Genia and Giteau and co to work their magic.
The emergence of Genia, who started 2009 as Queensland’s reserve halfback, was arguably the single most important development of the year for the Wallabies.
It was no coincidence Australia’s first and only Tri Nations victory came in game five against South Africa when Genia was handed his maiden Test start.
The Papua New Guinea-born No.9 continued to deliver in a man-of-the-match display at Twickenham before signing off his rookie international season with another five-star performance against Wales.
Regardless of whether Deans chooses to play Giteau – the 2009 John Eales Medallist and world player of the year nominee – or Barnes at five-eighth next season, the Wallabies attack should continue to improve with the razor sharp Genia inside giving his twin playmakers added time and space.
Despite a modest return of six wins, a draw and seven losses from 14 Tests in ’09, Deans has every reason to feel optimistic about the final two years of his reign.
It’s worth noting that two years prior to their previous World Cup triumphs in 1991 and 1999 the Wallabies also endured similarly difficult seasons.
In ’89, Australia were two from six and in the midst of a run of seven losses from nine Tests against the All Blacks.
In ’97, the Wallabies won just six from 12 Tests and suffered a 61-22 hammering at the hands of the Springboks in Pretoria.
Rome wasn’t – and World Cup-winning teams aren’t – built in a day and Deans is rightly ever hopeful after exposing so many young bloods while also preserving Australia’s ranking inside the world’s top three.
“There were a lot of pluses in terms of players who have emerged off very little background,” Deans said.
“Players who are going to be genuine Test players and are going to serve Australia well for a long period of time. It is evident that this group has a really exciting future.
“We’ve just got to add consistency which comes with experience. Obviously, when you look at the profile of the group, it’s a remarkably young group and they are learning in the toughest arena.”
As one Wallabies insider said after the sapping, last-minute 20-20 draw with Ireland in Dublin: “The deposit’s in the bank. Who remembers results two years before the World Cup?”
While the Wallabies appear on the up, the second-ranked Springboks seem in decline, their team of ageing stars ending an otherwise dominant 2009 with a series of dismal tour losses to English club sides Leicester and Saracens as well as to France and Ireland.
After helping the Boks capture the Webb Ellis Cup and this year’s Tri Nations trophy, key forwards Victor Matfield, Bakkies Botha and skipper John Smit are all now on the wrong side of 30.
As ever, in addition to a lack of depth at halfback, a shortage of back-up props and the absence of a world-class second row, Australia’s greatest worry two years out from the seventh World Cup again looks to be the top-ranked New Zealanders.
Seven successive losses to their trans-Tasman rivals cannot be good for self-belief, with newly-appointed vice-captain Barnes conceding before the last-up defeat in Tokyo ago that the continual beatings were starting to scar.
After masterminding the drought-breaking win in South Africa last year, Deans’s priority next season must be plotting Australia’s first win in New Zealand since 2001.
That would really leave the tournament hosts nervous come the World Cup.
© AAP 2012SNAPSHOT OF AUSTRALIAN RUGBY IN 2009
Wallabies: played 14, won 6, drew 1, lost 7
bt Italy 31-8, Canberra
bt Italy 34-12, Melbourne
bt France 22-6, Sydney
lost to New Zealand 22-16, Auckland
lost to South Africa 29-17, Cape Town
lost to New Zealand 19-18, Sydney
lost to South Africa 32-25, Perth
bt South Africa 21-6, Brisbane
lost to New Zealand 33-6, Wellington
lost to New Zealand 32-19, Tokyo
bt England 18-9, London
drew with Ireland 20-20, Dublin
lost to Scotland 9-8, Edinburgh
bt Wales 33-12, CardiffYear-end world ranking: 3
Highlights: beat world champion Springboks, only team not to lose to Six Nations champions Ireland
Lowlights: first loss to Scotland since 1982, four losses to New Zealand in same year for the first time since 1962, finished last in Tri Nations.Individual honours
John Eales Medallist: Matt Giteau
Australian Super 14 player of the year: George Smith
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- 2011 Rugby World Cup, Rugby Union, wallabies

Crashy said | December 16th 2009 @ 6:25am | Report comment
would love to share your optimism, I really would but our slump has been going on for a few years now which suggests that there may be some structural issues with development, juniors etc.
I truly believe that by winning the 5th team in Vic, the much extended season for Aus players will actually be the saviour of Australian Rugby.
In previous years, a good Australian bench player ( Rodzilla, Gerard) would often head overseas as they were only playing 1 Super rugby games, a handful of tests and a few club games. Now that the super season will be 6-8 months long, it means that players will be playing topflight footy for most of the year and earning a lot more cashola. The drain to overseas clubs will be much lessened.
I understand that player numbers in WA are really growing year-on-year but they need to start producing their own professional players.
I have no doubt that the Vic production line will be fruitful especially as the Brumbies have been signing the Vics up for years. ( love the Brumbies by the way…)
We just need to survive nesxt year!
Blinky Bill from Bellingen said | December 16th 2009 @ 8:24am | Report comment
“Success should not be judged on results alone.” And on that note I think I’ll take my leave.
Here’s wishing the staff of Roar, contributors and fellow commentators a Merry Christmas & a Happy New Year.
May 2010 be a better year for the Wallabies and their loyal supporters than 2009 has been. If however it does not improve we can always look to find positives even when we don’t win.
Parisien said | December 16th 2009 @ 8:39am | Report comment
“Deans’s priority next season must be plotting Australia’s first win in New Zealand since 2001.”
I agree!
fred said | December 16th 2009 @ 10:09am | Report comment
DEANS handles his losses well,not a grey hair to be seen.
Darwin hammer said | December 16th 2009 @ 8:51am | Report comment
The last thing Australian rugby needs is a puff piece like this – everything that’s bad about australian reporting is in this – the over hyping of players, the classifying who is and will be worldclass in the next 2 seasons … “Classy 21-year-olds Will Genia and David Pocock may well be the world’s premier players in their respective – and key – positions with another 20-odd Tests under their belts by 2011, while 25-year-old loosehead prop Benn Robinson already is” – hogwash ..
“To Australia’s rivals, though, coach Robbie Deans is the envy of the international rugby world.” … really ? – I think every one of the major nations of the rugby (England excepted) are pretty pleased with who they’ve got and haven’t shelled out millions on a clearly floundering coach …
Australia were abject for the major part of the international season – a good result against a poor Welsh outfit doesn’t fix things over night … the “deposit’s in the bank” call is merely yet another excuse for a poor effort
rugbyfuture said | December 16th 2009 @ 12:52pm | Report comment
i agree with your sentiment that we cant allow puff pieces, but genia and pockock aswell as our front rowers really are extremely talented, even the english agreed they were the silver lining of the tour
Jerry said | December 16th 2009 @ 4:29pm | Report comment
I wouldn’t pay much attention to the English press, they put an inordinate amount of emphasis on how players go against England. Genia played one good game against England and they were elevating him to ‘new great’ status.
Justin said | December 16th 2009 @ 4:38pm | Report comment
To be fair Jerry he has played well in just about every game he has played for AUS. The great thing is he does the basics very well unlike Deans former love-child Burgess.
Jerry said | December 16th 2009 @ 4:48pm | Report comment
Oh, I’m impressed with Genia don’t get me wrong. I was just pointing out that citing the English press opinion isn’t actually really something that’s gonna win you arguments.
Justin said | December 16th 2009 @ 4:50pm | Report comment
Yeah fair enough…
JamesB said | December 16th 2009 @ 9:15am | Report comment
Dream on! Mentally they are stuffed against the AB’s. Many of the new players haven’t ever beaten the AB’s. It’s bad enough they have lost 7 in a row, but they can’t win in Auckland. And the Wallabies are drawn to face the French in the RWC2011 semi-final stage. 1987 again?
Cattledog said | December 16th 2009 @ 11:51am | Report comment
In a nutshell, the ABs are the best team in the world between world cups, no doubt. However, their track record in that major event is not great. With the added pressure of being at home…they’ll choke, you can just about bet on it.
Truth is, any one of about 6 teams can win it, if the moons align. Problem is, you can’t have a poor game and hope to recover. You’re done and dusted! There’s still much water to flow beneath the bridge and with two seasons to go, only a fool would be making predictions on who will win and why.
Justin said | December 16th 2009 @ 9:37am | Report comment
In a nutshell the positions that are not up to it and need to be fixed are second row, the 10-12 channel and 15. I think we will have the rest covered by 2011. But they are pretty dam important spots to fix.
Hansie said | December 16th 2009 @ 10:14am | Report comment
“Success should not be judged on results alone.” Why bother with the score board? The reality is that Australia has big problems, and would be better off facing up to those problems, rather than dreaming that it will be “all right on the night”.
Go_the_Wannabe's said | December 16th 2009 @ 10:36am | Report comment
I’ll reserve my judgement of Deans until after the world cup. It’s 50/50 at the moment and could easily go either way. He will either be a saint or a martyr.
Mike G said | December 16th 2009 @ 10:47am | Report comment
I’m backing history to repeat itself (poor results 2 years out), & for the Wallabies to win the 2011 World Cup . There, that was easy, wasn’t it???
PastHisBest said | December 17th 2009 @ 9:59am | Report comment
Putting some hard-earned on it MG???
Campbell Watts said | December 18th 2009 @ 12:32pm | Report comment
At Go_the_Wannabe’s odds (50/50) I would be!!!!
Even looser said | December 16th 2009 @ 10:51am | Report comment
Being positive is all well and fine but being realistic is more important. In reality we are not in good shape at the moment and at the current rate of improvement I expect us to be on the end of some serious losses in ’10. Whether Robbie and the boys can pull it off in time for the RWC remains to be seen but I wish him well.
My wish for 2010 is:-
1. A string of good wins over tough opposition.
2. A good solid win in New Zealand; and
3. Quaility depth for all positions.