By subrasub
December 27th 2009 @ 12:14am
Who should be in the team of the decade?
Another team of the decade debate, but a very intriguing one. Who were the best players during the AFL decade just past?
Criteria is: Longevity – those that have played during the whole or most of the decade will get preference; success – as a team, premierships (not essential), awards (this decade). There are no specific specialist positions such as goal-sneak, sweeping half back flankers, etc, just the best defenders, midfielders and forwards this decade.
The bench will consist of the best three midfielders squeezed out of the best 18 and a backup ruckman.
Defenders:
- Mal Michael (2000-2007). Three premierships; runner-up in 2004; three-time All Australian.
- Matthew Scarlett (2000-2009). Two premierships; runner-up in 2008; five-time All Australian.
- Dustin Fletcher (2000-2009). One premiership; runner-up in 2001; two-time All Australian.
- Darren Glass (2000-2009). One premiership; runner up in 2005; three-time All Australian; three-time club champion.
- James Clement (2000-2007). Runner-up in 2002, 2003; three-time All Australian; two-time club champion.
- Leo Barry (2000-2009). One premiership; runner-up in 2006; two-time All Australian.
- Max Houghton (2000-2009). No major honours individually or as part of his team, but has longevity and is being selected purely on ability.
Midfielders:
- Chris Judd (2002-2009). One premiership; runner-up in 2005; four-time All Australian; three-time club champion; Brownlow medalist in 2004; Norm Smith medalist in 2005.
- Gary Ablett Jnr. (2002-2009). Two premierships; runner-up in 2008; three-time All Australian; two-time club champion; Brownlow medalist in 2009.
- Adam Goodes (2000-2009). One premiership; runner-up in 2006; three-time All Australian; two-time club champion; Brownlow medalist in 2003, 2006.
- Simon Black (2000-2009). Three premierships; runner-up in 2004; three-time club champion; three-time All Australian; Brownlow medalist in 2002; Norm Smith medalist in 2003.
- Ben Cousins (2000-2007, 2009). One premiership; runner-up 2005; four-time All Australian; four-time club champion; Brownlow medalist in 2005.
Ruckman:
- Dean Cox (2002-2009). One premiership; runner-up in 2005; four-time All Australian; one-time club champion.
Forwards:
- Matthew Lloyd (2000-2009). One premiership; runner-up in 2001, three-time All Australian; three-time Coleman medalist in 2000, 2001, 2003.
- Fraser Gehrig (2000-2008). Three-time All Australian; two-time Coleman medalist in 2004, 2005.
-Barry Hall (2000-2009). One premiership; runner-up in 2006; three-time All Australian; one-time club champion.
- Warren Tredrea (2000-2009). One premiership in 2004; runner-up in 2007; four-time All Australian; four-time club champion.
- Matthew Pavlich (2000-2009). Four-time All Australian and club champion.
- Brendan Fevola (2000-2009). Three-time All Australian; two-time Coleman medalist in 2006, 2009.
Bench:
- Brett Kirk (2000-2009). Premiership in 2005, runner-up in 2006, All Australian in 2004, club champion in 2005, 2007.
- Peter Bell (2000-2008). Two premierships; runner-up in 1998; All Australian in 1999, 2003; club champion in 2000, 2001, 2004.
- Andrew McLeod (2000-2009). Four-time All Australian; two-time club champion.
- Clark Keating (2000-2006). Selected based on ability, and also due to a lack of backup ruckmen available. Darren Jolly, Josh Fraser and Aaron Sandilands have not played long enough to be considered.



(5)
![The ICC should be disbanded and the respective cricket boards go their own ways. They can then all live and die by the “market forces” they are so quick to turn to in defense of the indefensible. The ICC has Haroon Lorgat as the front man. He is hamstrung by a committee that gives him power [...] Vinay Verma: Who else is concerned about the future of cricket?](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/lee-gambhir-australia-india-th.jpg)
![With the inaugural NRL All Stars set to kick off this weekend, perhaps just one thing is left to be discussed before we focus on the action on the field: can, or will, the concept ever become bigger than Origin? It might sound crazy at first, but as the weeks have gone by, I’ve become unsure [...] Steve Kaless: Can the All Stars game ever be bigger than Origin?](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/nrl-all-stars-wendell-sailor-th.jpg)
![Exactly a month out from the start of A-League season five and with the number of imports from Asia steadily increasing through the likes of Surat Sukha, Shin In Sup and Byun Sung-Hwan, it’s time to take a trip down memory lane and reflect on the best and worst of the league’s imports over its [...] Tony Tannous: The best and worst A-League imports](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/a-league-excites-carlos-hernandez-th.jpg)
![When teams are announced later today, there’s a good chance – for the first time in three months – Nick Riewoldt’s name will feature. For St Kilda fans, seeing their captain added to the group of players that beat Geelong two weeks ago must be a tantalising prospect. After all, the notion that the wheels would [...] Michael DiFabrizio: Riewoldt return set to boost Saints further](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/nick-riewoldt-th.jpg)
![It has been announced that Israel Folau will be joining the AFL’s new Greater Western Sydney club. The move will delight some and infuriate others, but it sets up another intriguing code-switch experiment that is sure to capture plenty of interest. All three Monday night AFL programs, as well as newspapers in both Sydney and Melbourne, reported [...] Michael DiFabrizio: Israel Folau signing another win for the AFL](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/israel-folau-gws-th.jpg)
![Football in Australia has come a long way in the past five years, so much so that we now have two supporter groups claiming to act in the interests of Socceroos fans. But the rise of ‘The Green and Gold Army’ and ‘The Fanatics’ raises questions about the types of supporters who will travel to [...] Mike Tuckerman: Socceroos fans: please don’t embarrass us!](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/should-penalties-decide-socceroos-th.jpg)
![First, some background. I’m probably a fairly unlikely candidate to review such a program. I haven’t watched its rival The Footy Show for years and normally view ‘Family Entertainment’ in the same way I view ‘Family Restaurants’. No thanks. But let’s face it, there is some interest. Here is a bloke that less than twelve months ago [...] Steve Kaless: Matty Johns lands a few blows, on TV this time](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/caution-needed-matthew-johns-th.jpg)
![If I’m to be honest, this is the column I had really hoped to write last week. Obviously, a less than impressive Socceroos and a rampant if out-scrummed Wallabies outfit put paid to that. This week though, the tides have turned, and I’m proud to announce my arrival back on the Socceroos bandwagon. I wouldn’t say I’m [...] Brett McKay: Move over bandwagoners, here I come](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/harry-kewell-socceroos-world-cup-th.jpg)
![One of the biggest fascinations amongsst cricket-lovers is selecting Best Elevens: a World XI, Post World War II XI vs. Pre WW II XI, Best left-handers XI vs. Best right-handers XI, Best ambidextrous XI, Best Northern Hemisphere XI vs. Best Southern Hemisphere XI, and so on. I have selected an Unusual World XI and it [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: It’s a World Cricket XI with a mysterious twist](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/richard-hadlee.jpg)
![This was the mother of all Mondays at Wimbledon. Henin and Clijsters in the Battle of the Belge. Serena and Maria in their Battle of the squeal. And Lleyton Hewitt would be playing. All six of the men’s top seeds in fourth round action. All three top seeds having had five setters in their last matches. Every [...] Vinay Verma: Lleyton Hewitt: Our own Phar Lap](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/06/lleyton-hewitt-respect-th.jpg)
![Make no mistake, we are currently witnessing one of the most intriguing and wide-reaching expansion phases in the history of Australian sport with codes venturing into uncharted waters like never before. In the last week alone we’ve seen: - The AFL’s Gold Coast FC launching their inaugural membership drive. - An AFL NAB Cup match being held in [...] Adrian Musolino: Where will the codes look to next for further expansion?](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/sheedy-gws-th.jpg)
![It’s all aboard the Red Rattlers once again. Just over 15 months since wowing the nation with a wonderful run all the way to the Asian Champions League final, Adelaide United were back to their continental best last night, dishing up a dazzling display in seeing off the defending ACL champs from South Korea. There’s just [...] Tony Tannous: Back on Reds bandwagon as Leckie and Flores fire-up](http://cdn0.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/adelaide-united-typifies-ognenovski-th.jpg)






Hoy said | December 27th 2009 @ 9:56am | Report comment
I don’t profess to know a lot about AFL, but Voss is captain coach in my books. That man is a legend and a real presence on the field.
bever fever said | December 27th 2009 @ 1:51pm | Report comment
Mcleod, Black, Goodes have to be in it in my book.
Mushi said | December 30th 2009 @ 1:06pm | Report comment
Brown has to be in there.
You can’t include 1990’s accomplishments for players like Bell, who should not be in there as player of the decade (for him to beat out Voss or Hird is criminal)
Redb said | January 2nd 2010 @ 8:40pm | Report comment
No Hird? you must be joking.
Beast-A-Tron said | January 6th 2010 @ 12:32pm | Report comment
Buckley & Voss both ought to be included. Both penetrating kicks on left & right foot, sublime disposal skills and frankly they both could play any position on the field (except ruck).