Is 2010 finally the year of the NSW Waratahs?
By Spiro Zavos, 9 Feb 2010 Spiro Zavos is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Rugby Union, Super Rugby, wallabies, Waratahs
112 Have your say
Related coverage

Brumbies' Stirling Mortlock (left) and Waratahs' Lote Tuqiri take to the air in the Super 14 rugby match at Canberra Stadium, Friday, March 13, 2009. The Brumbies beat the Waratahs 21-11. AAP Image/Alan Porritt
At the launch of the NSW Waratahs’ 2010 Super 14 season, officials were happy to play down expectations about how their team will perform this year, with public utterances of confidence. But privately they are convinced that this is the Waratahs’ year.
The sales pitch for Waratahs tickets reflects this, with the punchline: It’s Our Time.
Last year the Waratahs were one try off a finals placing.
They won all three of their matches in South Africa, the only time this has been done by any Australian or New Zealand team. They won more matches than the Crusaders.
But they did not win enough bonus points, and especially early on in the season, played in a negative way that turned off supporters and the media.
This year, the coaching staff is into its second season and has a better understanding of what it takes to complete a successful Super 14 ‘journey.’ They have learned, for instance, that playing a battering ram at inside centre like Tom Carter does not help the continuity game the Waratahs are aspiring to play.
More importantly, the squad has been given an impetus from a series of excellent additions.
The key new signings are Berrick Barnes and the try-scoring machine Drew Mitchell. Barnes will give the Waratahs a world class five-eighths for the first time in Super Rugby. Mitchell should ensure that tries are scored from breaks made by the clever and incisive running of the inside backs.
The pack did well last year and in the trial matches has been over-powering its opponents.
In Benn Robinson, the side has a world class prop who lifts the entire pack with his combination of mongrel, scrumming skills and energy around the field on attack (he has one of the best catch and pass games in the side) and defence.
The Waratahs play only six matches at home. But they also play only two matches in South Africa – against the Sharks and the Bulls.
I am the only Greek I know who is not a gambling man, but the odds against the Waratahs on the TAB Sportsbet of $13 – $1 seem to be so outrageous that a habit of a lifetime might have to be broken.
The TAB Sportsbet market is: $3.50 on the Crusaders, $5 ACT Brumbies, $6 Bulls, $9 Hurricanes, $10 Chiefs, $11 Blues, $13 Waratahs and Sharks, $14 Stormers, $81 Reds, Force, Highlanders, $126 Cheetahs, $251 Lions.
The bookies put their money where there mouth is so you have to respect their judgment on these matters. But they seem to rely a lot on past history with the market they have set.
Their first three sides are three of only four teams (the Blues are the fourth side) that have won a Super rugby title.
The Crusaders, with Daniel Carter and the addition of a new superstar winger Zac Guilford, who should give his team some easy tries, look to be a good bet.
The Bulls, too, with Fourie du Preez, with Carter, one of the great backs in the history of rugby, should be contenders.
But they have lost Bryan Habana to the Stormers. In my view, Habana was about 80 per cent of the Bulls kicking game and it will be interesting to see if the team adjusts and runs more as it did when it annihilated the Chiefs in last year’s final.
The Sharks and Waratahs are relegated to a seventh position in favouritism, behind even the Blues.
My first fearless prediction for 2010 is that the Blues will play some fantastic rugby and some awful rugby that will keep them out of the finals.
On paper, at least, the Sharks and the Waratahs seem like sides that have been unfairly written off by the bookies.
The Waratahs, as I’ve observed, appear to have ticked all the boxes needed for a successful season. The playing list of the Sharks, too, suggests that coach John Plumtree should have a rewarding season.
There are players like Bismarck du Plessis, Juan Martin Hernandez, Adrian Jacobs, Ryan Kankowski, Rory Kockett, Tednai ‘The Beast’ Mtawarira, Odaw Ndungane and Ruan Pienaar. A squad with these players in it should be a finals side.
The Highlanders are a side, too, that could surprise.
Last season they lost a number of matches by 3 points or less. They have a strong pack with the All Black Tom Donnelly certain to be a strength in the lineout. They have some of the most talented and exciting young backs currently going around in New Zealand rugby.
Israel Dagg (what a great NZ rugby name!) is a talented fullback. Robbie Robinson may be as good as Aaron Cruden (the Hurricanes great new talent) as a five-eights. Winger Ben Smith was a surprise All Black on the European tour and then revealed himself to be an excellent, all-round player.
Going back to the Australian sides, I’m surprised that the ACT Brumbies are ranked so high.
Admittedly the addition of Matt Giteau is a plus. But Giteau was not able to lead the Western Force (which had a better squad in my view than the Brumbies) into the finals. There doesn’t seem to be much depth in the Brumbies squad and the pack, apparently, was monstered by the Waratahs in their trial game.
The Western Force was dealt a terrible blow with the long-term injury to Andre Pretorius. The team has some prodigious young talent in James O’Connor and David Pocock. But there is not much depth in the squad.
Part of the fun of the pre-season posturing is to make predictions, knowing that the future rarely unfurls in an expected pattern. So here goes: the Crusaders, Bulls and Waratahs are finals sides, for sure.
The Hurricanes, Sharks and the Highlanders are most likely (in my view) to contest that fourth position.
And the winner of the 2010 Super 14 title? I fall back on a mantra that has served me well in the past when I have been asked for a prediction: “We’re having the tournament to find out the answer to that.”
Game on!
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- Rugby Union, Super Rugby, wallabies, Waratahs

Who Needs Melon said | February 9th 2010 @ 5:42am | Report comment
Spiro, Spiro, Spiro…
You’ve been watching this game (and the Waratahs) longer than I have. Do you really want to go into another season expecting ‘for sure’ that the Waratahs will make the finals?
For me the main question mark hanging over the Waratahs is: How early in the season, if it all, will the find a settled, gelling backline? Without this we are going to see a repeat of last season. Of course the answer to the question depends largely on the health of Barnes and others. I hope they go alright. I’d hate to see two aussie sides hobbled due to injuries to their fly halves.
matt said | February 9th 2010 @ 6:20am | Report comment
So letÅ› look at the Brumbies pack that you have doubts about Spiro:
Alexander, Moore, Ma’afu/Henderson,
Harrison/Kimlin, Chisholm
Smith, Hoiles, Elsom
If these guys are not up for a challenge then there goes a huge chunk of the Wallabies pack as well.
Central North said | February 9th 2010 @ 8:29am | Report comment
Ummm hasn’t Henderson signed with the Force? And Kimlin’s out for the season isn’t he?
jeznez said | February 9th 2010 @ 10:14pm | Report comment
Not sure where Henderson is but Sheperdson is the tighthead at Brumbieland. Kimlin is out but they do have Hand and Mitch Chapman has been cruelly ignored when looking at their depth in the backrow. Certainly not a lightweight pack just not as good as the Tahs! I just hope that Al Baxter doesn’t start this year although judging by the last two trials he will be. Bring on Palmer!!!!!
Chris said | February 9th 2010 @ 6:47am | Report comment
The Sharks have lost Hernandez. It was pretty big news at the time. I guess it can be excused – it didn’t happen in Sydney.
Brett McKay said | February 9th 2010 @ 8:20am | Report comment
thought the same thing Chris, that Hernandez was gone for the season, a la Pretorius for the Force. Have the Sharks found a new 10 yet, or is Francois Steyn set for another year of play-making??
Mike G said | February 9th 2010 @ 8:39am | Report comment
I thought Francois was playing in France?? Sure I saw him on Eurosports the other night…
Lee said | February 9th 2010 @ 9:11am | Report comment
Steyn is at Racing in France
Chris said | February 9th 2010 @ 6:57am | Report comment
The 2009 Force had a better squad than the 2010 Brumbies?
Mortlock, Elsom, Smith, Ashley-Cooper, Moore, Gerrard, Alexander vs. what exactly? Drew Mitchell and Sharpe? Even the 2009 Brumbies finished ahead of that mob!
“You CANNAWT be serious!”
Go_the_Wannabe's said | February 9th 2010 @ 9:49am | Report comment
They must have a better squad……they beat the Brumbies at home in 2009. In fact they beat all the Australian teams in 2009.
Chris said | February 9th 2010 @ 9:52am | Report comment
Next time you reply to a comment have the courtesy to read it.
PastHisBest said | February 9th 2010 @ 10:20am | Report comment
How do you know he didn’t???
Comrade Bear said | February 9th 2010 @ 10:33am | Report comment
“The 2009 Force had a better squad than the 2010 Brumbies?”
Chris – I also thought Spiro was comparing 2009 squad to 2009 squad also with:
“…But Giteau was not able to lead the Western Force (which had a better squad in my view than the Brumbies) into the finals …”
jeznez said | February 9th 2010 @ 10:18pm | Report comment
yeah but Chris names Mark Gerrard and Elsom in the same squad – not quite right…….
Sam Taulelei said | February 9th 2010 @ 6:59am | Report comment
I don’t know why the Brumbies are rated above the Waratahs even with their offseason signings. In another thread assessing the Brumbies chances I stated that they’ll have to improve their record in SA to have any chance and that the Waratahs have proven that they can win on the road better than any other Aussie side and they appeal to me as the better punt. The signing of Giteau is interesting as he was one of the heavily criticised players from last year for not performing towards the business end of the competition when the Force needed him to front. The bookies must know something is bubbling at Bruce Stadium and they have to be respected but I’d gamble on the Tahs if I was to pick a title winner from Australia.
Last year before the competition started I predicted that a SA side would win the title and that the Crusaders would just miss out on making the top four. I was right on one prediction and narrowly missed out on the other.
This year I predict that a NZ team will win the competition and that the Bulls will miss out on making the top four. The men from the high veldt have a number of disruptions to their preparation and will be missing several of their top players for most of the first half of the competition and have lost Habana to the Stormers who as Spiro mentioned formed a large portion of their kick and chase strategy.
If the Blues improve their defence and repeat their efforts in attack last year where they scored the most points, the most tries and the most four try bonus points then they’ll be a strong contender for the top four and maybe even the title. However with the loss of Ali Williams there are serious question marks over their tight five with only Anthony Boric a recognised lock forward of any quality.
The Highlanders will surprise many teams this year and will win more games than they did last year but anything higher than a mid table finish will be an overachievement for a young and developing side.
The Crusaders, Hurricanes and Chiefs appeal as the strongest NZ teams this year, especialy the former two. The Hurricanes are in a similar position to the Tahs and have the same weight of expectation for a constantly underachieving side, the Sharks fall into the same category.
Like the Waratahs, the Hurricanes have strengthened their side with some off season transfers and signings, the most hyped being young no.10 Aaron Cruden. If he delivers on his promise and can form a combination with Piri Weepu then the Canes will have an inside back combination to guide them to another finals appearance and maybe a title win.
Smart money however is on the Crusaders to overcome their blip last year and with McCaw and Carter in tandem again, that’s as good as money in the bank.
Go_the_Wannabe's said | February 9th 2010 @ 9:55am | Report comment
Gits carried the Force last year, especially towards the business end…..he was the one of a very few that fronted. He probably didn’t want to leave on bad terms even though his third party sponsorship fell through…….hats off to him for doing that.
PastHisBest said | February 9th 2010 @ 10:23am | Report comment
“…then the Canes will have an inside back combination to guide them to another finals appearance and maybe a title win.”
Sam, Sam, Sam….you know as well as I do that the ‘canes always flatter to deceive.
DingoBob said | February 9th 2010 @ 7:00am | Report comment
Come on Spiro are you really going back to the old line about the Brumbies not being up to it? NSW have been saying that since 1996 and since then the Brumbies have won two Super Rugby Championships and the Waratahs have won how many?
DingoBob said | February 9th 2010 @ 7:07am | Report comment
I think you’ll find part of the reason the Brumbies are rated higher is because they know how to win a Super Rugby Championship. After all they have won 2. how many have the Waratahs won?
RickG said | February 9th 2010 @ 7:17am | Report comment
We get the point Dingo
Sam Taulelei said | February 9th 2010 @ 7:11am | Report comment
And as each year passes without a title for the Brumbies how long before the public and press realise they can no longer trade on their past glories. Their last title was in 2004, the Blues last title was in 2003, only 12 months separate them but you don’t see the Blues being talked up as title contenders as much as the Brumbies this year.
Chris said | February 9th 2010 @ 7:37am | Report comment
and you didn’t see the Brumbies being talked up last year. Must be something to do with signing 2 World XV players.
Central North said | February 9th 2010 @ 8:39am | Report comment
Geez.. you Brumbies types are so touchy.
Hope they manage to keep Gits happy. ‘Cause all Wallaby fans know what happens when he doesn’t get his way. And Rocky can’t carry a team on his own – or the Tahs would have won a title by now.
Hammer said | February 9th 2010 @ 9:04am | Report comment
“2 World XV players” .. the australian dream machine continues unabated
Central North said | February 9th 2010 @ 10:49am | Report comment
That should read “Brumbies dream machine” Hammer.. Don’t lump the rest of us in with the true believers from the home of the roundabout and the public servant.
I think from the various comments on this thread, Spiro is the only Tahs fan shouting their title credentials from the rooftops. The rest of us read this piece with a sigh and a hope – and a hope alone – that this year won’t be another case of “here we go again…”
RickG said | February 9th 2010 @ 7:16am | Report comment
I posted an article a couple of weeks back questioning whether this season was going to be overshadowed by the looming S15, but I’m happy to say I’m looking forward to it again and, hopefully!, a title to the ‘tahs this time. Just don’t jinx it with too much talk of the ‘tahs being sure things for the finals!
I hope and expect Hickey has his mind settled on the best backline and, barring injury, we should see some consistency.
A couple of times people here have mentioned how you can download S14 games to watch afterwards. Can anyone point me in the right direction? I don’t have Foxtel and will have very little access to the games so it’ll be a challenge t okeep up with what’s happening.
Bay35Pablo said | February 9th 2010 @ 7:44am | Report comment
RickG, iinet offers it to people who have their broadband internet with them.
Brett McKay said | February 9th 2010 @ 8:26am | Report comment
Rick, as Sam says below, there is Rugbyzone, but I think it has restrictions placed on streaming into the SANZAR countires, and so it’s 6hr delay only (happy to stand corrected, btw, but that’s definitely how it was). For games in South Africa though, it means you can watch them from about 9am Sundays.
The Fox Sports website has offered the Rugbyzone streams in recent years too, I think a season pass was about $70 for all the Super 14 games, or for $100 you could get all the NPC and CC games too. You could also go with single games for about $4.95 from memory.
RickG said | February 9th 2010 @ 9:06am | Report comment
Thanks Brett, I thought you needed to be a Foxtel subscriber to access the online streams? Will check it out.
Brett McKay said | February 9th 2010 @ 9:20am | Report comment
no, not at all Rick, this is/was through the Fox Sports website.
They got the details for 2010 up now – check out http://www.rugbyzone.com/channel/foxsports/2009.asp directly, or get to it from the Rugby section of the FS site.
S14 season pass has dropped, only US$49.95 this year. Not sure if it’s still on delay, but would presume so..
RickG said | February 9th 2010 @ 10:43am | Report comment
Thanks again, this was just what I was after but couldn’t find it the other day. Entering via rugbyzone direct seems to suggest you can’t access thsi in Aust, but as you say via Fox it’s fine.
Sam Taulelei said | February 9th 2010 @ 12:33pm | Report comment
From that site I’ve worked out that buying a Super 14 season pass at $49.95 USD roughly equates to $60.00 AUD giving me all 94 matches across four months that would otherwise cost me $224.00 in Foxtel subscription is a much better value deal.
Combining that with the freezone streams from iiNet featuring all games involving Aussie teams I could watch the iiNet feeds without affecting my monthly quota and then cherry pick the NZ games I want to watch at $7.00 AUD a game from FoxSports Rugby on demand puts me even further ahead.
Now here’s the kicker. If the rumours that the ARU has rengotiated broadcasting rights for the Super 14 on FTA (presumably One HD) then I could get all the rugby that I want via FTA and the internet without paying $600.00 a year to Foxtel when all I really watch is the rugby and none of the other programs that get bundled in their basics package.
I’m going to buy a game pass this weekend and test the picture quality of the feed on my TV. The games are delayed six hours after they’ve ended which doesn’t bother me and in some cases works out better when the games are in SA. There is a limit of 3 PC’s that you can stream the feed to but you can stream it from your PC to a media player and watch it on your telly instead of your PC. Now all I have to do is work out how to archive the content.
Rick you will have to be mindful of how much bandwidth these feeds will eat into your monthly internet plan but even if you increase your plan to meet your demand it still works out much cheaper than subscribing to Foxtel.
Thanks for the link Brett.
Brett McKay said | February 9th 2010 @ 12:45pm | Report comment
Sam, I’ve watched the streams via Fox/RZ in the past, and they’re quite good quality from memory, so I’ll be interested to see how you get on. Also from memory, a full game stream was approx 700Mb; I had to keep track of this sort of thing with the plan I was on at the time…
Re the FTA rumour, I’ve heard it too, and I like what I hear. I presume you’ve meant S15 though, not the S14 this year?? I really hope YOU’RE right, by the way!!
Jameswm said | February 9th 2010 @ 7:22am | Report comment
How many years have we been asking this?
A good pack and (at last) a good 5/8 – well, one very good one and two good backups. Pace out wide. I don’t think they have the coaching for it though.
Sam I was thinking exactly the same thing. Since the Brumbies won their two titles, the Tahs have made 2 finals, have one or two other finals appearances, and (correct me if I’m wrong Brumby fans – and I’m sure you will) the Brumbies haven’t even made the finals.
By the way Matt
That Brumby pack you see as awesome – they’re suspect at tight head and lock, and have a small no.8. We’ll have to see how they go over the season. NSW are suspect at tight head (though a lot less suspect) and lock and have a huge no.8.
Craigb said | February 9th 2010 @ 2:29pm | Report comment
Light at tighthead? The wallaby tighthead in a newly respected pack not good enough for s14???
jeznez said | February 9th 2010 @ 10:24pm | Report comment
Alexander is back playing loosehead to Shepherdson’s tighthead.
Justin said | February 9th 2010 @ 3:21pm | Report comment
I would say the Tahs have the better LH, Brumbie better TH and both hookers hot n cold. Would take the Brumbies locks and back-row over Tahs any day of the week. To me Palu if he continues his Nov form is the only certainty in a combined back 5 from NSW.