Toll on bodies makes sport a tough profession
By Andrew Sutherland, 12 Feb 2010 Andrew Sutherland is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- AFL, Collingwood Magpies

(L-R) Josh Fraser of Collingwood, Joel Selwood of Geelong, Travis Cloke of Collingwood, Harry Taylor of Carlton, Joel Corey of Geelong, Shannon Cox of Collingwood, Gary Ablett of Geeong & Martin Clarke of Collingwood in action during the AFL Round 03 match between the Geelong Cats and the Collingwood Magpies at the MCG. Slattery Images
Recently I bent down to pick up the kids. My hip ached as I lowered myself. And then as I pushed upwards, a sharp pain attacked the joint of my left big toe – it was arthritis caused by playing football.
I know because during a foot X-ray for a suspected break, the doctor pointed out a small area he said was the first sign of the condition. That was fifteen years ago, but it’s now taking hold.
It should have been in the right foot as that was my preferred one.
But as I was long sighted in the left eye, blurring my peripheral vision on that side, I would often, in the helter-skelter of a contest near goal, swing around the other way, on to my left foot; unwittingly damning it with the trauma of impact.
And then there is my back.
Some time ago my brother told me of an outing he made with some friends. They stopped the car on arriving at their destination but one of them, a recently retired Melbourne player, was so stiffened by the journey he couldn’t get out of the car.
He was in his early thirties.
Aaron Moule retired from rugby league when he was only twenty six so he could be physically capable of playing with his kids when he was older. He began playing again shortly after, however, because it was the only way he could support those same children.
A professional footballer knows the harsh truth about the balance of nature.
In order to look, feel and perform like a god he punishes his mortal body. And then later, after retirement, it reminds him what he put it through: a forty year old ex-footballer has the limited mobilty and insistent pain of his seventy year old father.
Barry Humphries recently boasted that he had outlived most of the macho sporty types that attended Melbourne Grammar during his time there.
As if a contact sport was a way of keeping healthy.
It’s the midweek excitement over the upcoming game that makes you forget the pain of the previous one. The adrenalin-induced feeling as you prepare to run out can’t be replicated in normal life.
But there is also a moral imperative that leads you to torture your body. Grasping his own chest the coach would yell: “You’re playing for this jumper!”
And he was right, of course, whether you liked it or not. You weren’t just a sportsman or someone plying a trade, you were representing a club and its people.
There is a psychological legacy too. If you’re not an aggressive person to start with you will soon become one. Often you would find yourself despising an opponent. Less skillful but stronger and more experienced defenders would give a you a quick elbow to the stomach if they thought you were going to lead.
A celebrated captain of a VFA club once held me down while play continued around us and hissed: “If you move I’ll kill you”
And most shocking of all, there can be your own teammates. I got to play alongside one of my idols in an AFL reserves match. He was returning from injury and keen on impressing.
I was free on the half forward flank with a good chance of kicking a goal. He was about to be tackled so I called for the handball. “F*ck off!” he screamed. He was then tackled with the ball giving away a free kick. I bent down towards him and found myself saying – to a Collingwood legend – “And you f*ck off!”
Psychologically I was never quite the same again.
“You’ve got to ask yourself: ‘Do you want to play League football?’”, said Leigh Matthews after catching me smiling while the team was being thrashed on a horrible day at an underwater VFL Park.
He assumed I didn’t want to play, but he was wrong.
My smile had been an obliging response to a joke made by a more senior player (who would later play in the 1990 premiership team). “Of course I want to bl**dy play AFL football” I said to myself, if only a single game so I can be immortalised in the Encyclopedia of AFL Footballers!
I chose to walk because nothing about the place seemed right, and so I wasn’t immortalised. I have regretted it ever since … I think.
And I’ll soon be crippled too.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
AFL articles
- More rugby league players to defect to the AFL? (160)
- Mobile madness: Optus decision bad news for codes (153)
- AFL divisions are the way of the future (106)
- Foxtel’s AFL coverage is nirvana for footy fans (89)
- AFL’s most hated club turns 120 years old (78)
- Israel Folau now ready for AFL (76)
- Optus ruling actually a good thing for AFL fans (52)
- Ling holds hope for club loyalty in AFL
- Andrew Krakouer given four weeks leave from Collingwood
- Giants inspired to prove doubters wrong (32)
- Malthouse not fazed by assistant issue
- Richo says look out for the Tigers in AFL
- AFL clubs’ leadership groups getting out of hand (15)
- Who’s to blame for the Majak Daw beat-up? (32)
- AFL clubs’ leadership groups getting out of hand (15)
- AFL divisions are the way of the future (107)
- Crows changing, but will this AFL preview change your life? (2)
- Is Heath Shaw the right leader for Collingwood? (11)
- Could a female coach succeed in the AFL? (36)
- Demons’ two captain Jacks the right leadership choice (5)
- Mobile madness: Optus decision bad news for codes (153)
- Explore:
- AFL, Collingwood Magpies

manny said | February 12th 2010 @ 3:50am | Report comment
tough times.. maybe the average age of AFL footballers shouldbe even shorter!!
Dandy said | February 12th 2010 @ 8:09am | Report comment
This relates to the story
http://www.theroar.com.au/2010/01/20/they-average-230000-a-season-but-are-afl-players-underpaid/
is it worth $230,000 to destroy your body?
AndyRoo said | February 12th 2010 @ 2:34pm | Report comment
Plenty of people destroy their bodies for free, so the answer is probably yes.
Andrew Sutherland said | February 12th 2010 @ 4:17pm | Report comment
Particularly some of the players in the suburban comps where impacts are more common and brutal due to the small grounds, low skill level and the presence of a few genuine psychotics.
Michael C said | February 12th 2010 @ 2:10pm | Report comment
Rusty Crowe’s show ‘Damage Control’ to feature Essendon too, hopefully we see somewhat better sports science and health management than from 20+ years ago…….or, just kids getting pushed harder than ever??
Did OP exist 50 years ago??
Redb said | February 12th 2010 @ 2:19pm | Report comment
No wonder they picked the Bombers we’d had enough injuries to sink a battleship – robbed us for the last 9 years.
The Answer said | February 12th 2010 @ 2:48pm | Report comment
I believe Daniel Chick just used a similar argument to beat the charge of importing a growth hormone from Thailand.
Certainly one of the best (or worst) excuses I’ve heard.
Andrew Sutherland said | February 12th 2010 @ 4:32pm | Report comment
I hope he wasn’t expecting his finger to grow back.
Al said | February 12th 2010 @ 3:05pm | Report comment
Oh boo hoo, sports people get paid much more than the average citizen and it is their choice to compete in sporting contests, no one forced them. A much tougher job would be working in the mines for months on end rather than playing a game for a couple of hours every weekend and having 3 months of the year off.
jim_bar said | February 12th 2010 @ 4:15pm | Report comment
Hear hear Al, Suck it up I say!
Andrew Sutherland said | February 12th 2010 @ 4:26pm | Report comment
You forgot to mention the daily training Al, but you’re right about the mining. That would be horrible but then again no one is forcing you to do that either.
If you happen to be born into a repressive mining community do a Derek Zoolander and move to the big city as a male model.
Dogz R Barkn said | February 12th 2010 @ 4:46pm | Report comment
Mining as a job?
That’s noothing!
You should try being a human propeller on an aeroplane – now that’s bluddy hard wook!!
But tryng telling the young people of today – and they won’t believe yer!!
Tifosi said | February 12th 2010 @ 4:36pm | Report comment
Concussion has become a very big issue in the NFL over in the states.
Players are subjected to many head to head contacts via the helmets and the payback for such bravado is waiting for these players in later life.
Its only now that the NFL has finally agreed that concussion from football games can cause long lasting side effects.
Unfortunately players are seen as weak if they are missing games for concussion related hits so many players play thru it.
andrew said | February 12th 2010 @ 6:16pm | Report comment
Tifosi, I think it is AFL policy that a player misses a match after concussion. It doesn’t apply in the NRL where head-on-head collisions occur regularly between front rowers. During the qualifying final last year Manly’s Brent Kite was concussed. Channel 9 showed footage of a trainer/doctor pushing down on Kite’s head (to heal his brain, or perhaps break his neck) with Peter Sterling commenting: “There’s Brent Kite receiving treatment [!] on the sidelines.”
The link between concussion and neurological conditions like epilepsy and Parkinson’s are unclear but common sense would tell you that Muhammad Ali’s ploy of letting opponents take slugs at him while he lent on the ropes was never going to end well.
A head injuriy more serious than mild concussion increases your chance of developing Parkinson’s 4 times. On average the disease appears twenty years after injury:-
http://www.neuroskills.com/pr-parkinsons.shtml
SideShowBob said | February 13th 2010 @ 7:03am | Report comment
Serious concerns with long term head injuries in American Football.
http://www.time.com/time/video/player/0,32068,64253995001_1957921,00.html
http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/10/19/091019fa_fact_gladwell?currentPage=all
Given that reverting to playing without helmets (as it once was when the sport was in its infancy) is off the table, the NFL would be hard pressed to maintain the status quo without any reduction in the current quality of the spectacle.
SideShowBob said | February 13th 2010 @ 6:54am | Report comment
An interesting article on the ordeals endured during a short pre-season stint at the Western Bulldogs, from the perspective of an Irish rookie under trial:
http://www.arfli.com/index.php?p=news#b45363