The end is nigh for our summer of discontent
By Adrian Musolino, 16 Feb 2010 Adrian Musolino is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- AFL, Basketball, Cricket, football
As the winter football codes launch into their seasons, Australia leaves behind what many are bemoaning as a forgettable summer of sport. A summer that Sport & Style labelled as the ‘Summer of dud’ .
Across all of the summer sports, off-field talking points overshadowed on-field performance – and what happened on the field wasn’t always of the highest quality.
The summer saw the following in each sport:
Cricket
Pakistan and the West Indies did little to entertain on their Australian summer sojourns. Their woeful and inconsistent performances shone the spotlight away from what was happening in the middle of the park and onto how the game could balance its three versions.
With the Big Bash Twenty20 comp making serious inroads this summer, and the debate on the impact Twenty20 will have on the game as a whole growing, the fifty-over form of the game suffered most with woeful crowds – only 8,378 turned up to Adelaide Oval, the lowest crowd ever for a one-day international involving Australia on home ground.
But before we condemn the fifty-over game, consider the mess of the summer calendar. The calendar had no semblance, jumping between the three forms of the games throughout the summer. The game has confused its audience, and off the back of Twenty20 fixtures, it’s hardly surprising the fifty-over format failed to entice crowds – particularly after such a congested and overloaded summer of fixtures.
Few classic moments on the pitch, lots of question marks off it.
Tennis
Make no mistake, Channel 7 stifled the summer of tennis with its Australian Open coverage, with the controversy around their coverage developing into the talking point of January.
In the absence of a gripping story arc – think Alicia Molik, Jelena Dokic comebacks or an Aussie bolter – the media seemed disinterested in events at Melbourne Park, running out of adjectives for Roger Federer’s brilliance. But it was Channel 7’s coverage that saw ratings plummet, and the Open was the innocent victim of their waywardness.
A-League
While the two biggest clubs in the country fought out a great Premiership battle, attention was never far from crowd figures across the league, not helped by the saga involving Gold Coast United owner Clive Palmer and his crowd capping saga.
With the FFA’s attention on the World Cup bid, the absence of significant promotion and advertising for the A-League – combined with the limited reach of Fox Sports – is costing the domestic game badly.
The A-League will continue to exist in the shadows if it cannot find a way to breakthrough the public disinterest and expand beyond its hardcore base of football fans.
Golf
Remember the fanfare of Tiger Woods’ Melbourne visit? It was soon swept away in a wave of sexual depravity and infidelity.
Basketball
Remember the NBL? Few can, it seems.
Hamstrung by its non-existence in major markets such as Sydney and Brisbane, and struggle in the strong sporting market of Melbourne (a 2,912 average for the Melbourne Tigers), the NBL’s presence in the Australian sporting psyche is, sadly, negligible – despite some strong support from regional centres such as Cairns.
It has become the forgotten summer code.
Each of these sporting codes faced their own dilemmas and questions this summer, and these undoubtedly overshadowed what was happening on the field and distracted the media.
It’s little wonder the media has been crying out for the return of footy, while filing their cricket obituaries together with their tennis ones.
And as Richard Hinds points out , albeit in an unusual way, the media has more than ever filled the summer void with any sprinkling of news from the winter codes.
While the media’s been quick to write-off the Australian summer of sport just past, it hasn’t been as bad as they’ve portrayed, except for Pakistan’s fielding.
The summer codes are merely in a state of flux and development.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- AFL, Basketball, Cricket, football


bruski said | February 16th 2010 @ 7:40am | Report comment
Remember the NBL? I think if you follow the NBL you will know it has been a great season, better than what could have been that is for sure..Product is great too!!
Look at the Blaze, near packed stadiums, in fact they are getting more than a run of the mill A-Leauge game so I would not think this season has been a bad one. They will continue to grow too, after hitting all time lows in the off-season things are looking good for them.
I also think the Golf was a great success and I hope Tiger comes back next year.
Cricket unfortunatly is too much of not a great thing (OD and 20/20)…..
A-League, they will continue to grow, I think the product is good – They now need someone to up the marketing in A-League HQ and some of the clubs to become more pro-active in marketing themselves.. Look at the difference between how the Gold Coast and Adelaide market themselves, in Adelaide you cannot go a day without hearing about their team where on the Gold Coast you have to look for news!! Nuff said.
James W said | February 16th 2010 @ 8:25am | Report comment
The NBL has been barely visible. I wonder how many people could name the team that finished top of the ladder? Not many I’d think.
Marshall said | February 16th 2010 @ 8:39am | Report comment
The decline of the Nbl has been amazing and it really has no visibility. I couldn’t tell you who finished top and I yet I watched the Nba All Stars last night. Kinda sad.
bruski said | February 16th 2010 @ 5:40pm | Report comment
So Marshall, because you do not follow the NBL and watched the all-stars game from the NBA that means that there is no visibility for the NBL?
Not sure how you come to that assumption, NBL news is all over Foxsports both internet and TV so to say it has no visibility is wrong.
You are right to a point, the fall from grace that the NBL has had has been sharp – But they are rebounding.
Thought I would clear that up.
Marshall said | February 16th 2010 @ 7:57am | Report comment
Fair call. It’s been a bit of a disaster this summer but each of the codes are going through big changes. Shame Windies and Pakistan were so awful
Davstar said | February 16th 2010 @ 8:03am | Report comment
The A-league had an extra 200,000 spectators this year even if the averages are down overall numbers are up so i think that’s positive because we have two teams that have just started out. NQF are doing well to build a football culture and GCU are even starting to take shape it takes time to promote a new sport in a new area and also the football being played has improved inquality from season 4. I think overall its been a successful year for he A-league.
Dogz R Barkn said | February 16th 2010 @ 10:07am | Report comment
I’m only writing this to point out something obvious – not to have a go at the A-League (I don’t mind watching the odd game on Fox, and I’ll be supporting the Rovers when they come in).
The A-League went from having 84 matches (4 x 21 rounds) to 135 matches (5 x 27 rounds).
That is, an additional 51 matches were required to get those extra 200,000 attendees (or 3,921 per additional match).
Art Sapphire said | February 16th 2010 @ 10:15am | Report comment
Dogz – they went from 84 matches 1,023,147 attendees to 135 matches 1,322,475 attendees.
Its actually an extra 300k attendees.
Dogz R Barkn said | February 16th 2010 @ 10:19am | Report comment
Sorry – Davstar mentioned the 200,000.
That makes the average of the additional games look better at 5,882 (and certainly looks closer to the mark in hindsight).
I’m sure the Rovers and Hearts will make the additional games look much better than that.
But I’m simply pointing out that the increase in aggregate crowds is off the back of 51 additional games.
Michael C said | February 16th 2010 @ 10:27am | Report comment
an 60% increase in matches for a 30% increase in attendees for a 20% decrease in average attendance,
and it can’t all be blamed on the new teams,
as Brisbane was down 33%, MVFC down 15% and SFC was down until the Rnd 27 match and managed to scrape through up by 6% at the SFS but still down overall if you include the Parramatta crowd.
Best ‘good news story’ was ruddy Wellington!!!!! SO, New Zealand was again making the HAL look almost half respectable (outside of Melbourne that is!!!!).
So – if EVER anything fits the ‘summer of discontent’ label – - – that’s gotta be it. New Zealand to the rescue……gawd.
btw – HAL avg attendances from one year to the next,
V2 +18%
V3 + 12.9%
V4 -16.7%
V5 -19.6%
V2 and V3 saw combined 30.9% up and next 2 years combined 36.3% down (I know you can’t just add %’s like that – - but, at a very rough level – - – that’s where it’s at and the avg attendance is sub V1 levels – sub 10K even, actually, a perfect breakdown, 45 matches 10K+, 90 10K-, so, 1/3 at 10K+, and 2/3 at 10K- exactly).
Art Sapphire said | February 16th 2010 @ 10:48am | Report comment
Michael C – you might have the numbers but you lack the required A-League knowledge to understand what these numbers mean. I might not be Einstein but I can tell definitely tell you that the attendance figures will be higher next season. 1 extra team – 30 extra matches – a new stadium in Melbourne, some clubs with work to do win back some of the fans and 2 clubs to keep building on what they start this season. The glass is more than half full.
Michael C said | February 16th 2010 @ 11:11am | Report comment
Art -
hmmmm, how does your hope and dream of better results next year invalidate the numbers I presented??
One 25K crowd at SFS in Rnd 27 doth not a successful domestic league make!!!!
but, correct in that we all wait and watch to see what happens in Melbourne town. Is it make or break yet for the HAL??
Is a 27 round season already too long??
People suggested the early start, the overlap with AFL and NRL finals was bad for crowds and after that it’d pick up………it didn’t, not until from Rnd 19 to 27 did it ‘pick up’ and even then only just.
More games may not actually be the answer.
Art Sapphire said | February 16th 2010 @ 12:06pm | Report comment
Michael – what you lack is perspective when looking at A-League attendances. Considering the standard of play, the attendances are very good. Are you actually aware of the A-League’s place in the global scheme of thing. The estimated total market value of the all the players currently playing in the A-League is about $100 million or $400k a player.
The average estimated market value of an EPL player is around $10 million dollars.
The average estimated market value of an English Championship player is around $1.5 million dollars. The Championship averages 18,000 spectators a game. The A-League averages around 10k a game. Once the standard of football is equivalent to that of the English Championship I can guarantee you that the average crowd in the A-League will be the same. Perspective!
Michael C said | February 16th 2010 @ 12:27pm | Report comment
Yeah – I’m aware of the table that shows HAL in the worlds top 20 drawing soccer leagues……doesn’t say much for the world of soccer leagues when the HAL is about 2/3rds NRL and about 1 qtr AFL……but, if you want to attach such abstract measures as ‘player worth’……..or just save that for your ‘fantasy football’ league.
btw – so, are you saying the HAL is probably paying under halves the market value??
AndyRoo said | February 16th 2010 @ 12:53pm | Report comment
Additional games was always going to decrease the average especially since most teams used it as an opportunity to increase membership prices (which to be fair to them they had to because of stadium rent). Even though for the fan there isn’t really extra value, because I would have been quite satisfied with an 18 round season (I am sure some of the owners who lose money on match day agree) but we have to get closer to that magic 34 round mark for the ACL criteria……. Yet I don’t see us ever getting more than 2 spots but we have to keep chasing the rainbow.
All other things remaining equal the average would decline for next season too when we go from 27 rounds to 33.
Some teams will go up and some will go down. With better fixturing the averages would have stayed above 10k this year despite the management of Bne Roar, GCU and Jets being absolute failures, neither of them look set to turn it around next year. Those clubs are poorly run and that hurts in any code, it’s been an eye opener about the pitfalls of private ownership.
Once we stop increasing the number of rounds the averages will become a more useful measure. As it stands now their not really very insightful other than seeing which teams have coped better.
So I would predict next season will be much the same avg as this one, but the year after is when we will be back in the black crowd average wise.
I don’t see where the make or break season comes into it more make or wait and I can’t see the league having an important make or “wait” season before the Rovers and FTA are in place.
Art Sapphire said | February 16th 2010 @ 1:18pm | Report comment
michael – How about I put it in more simpler term for you. If an A-League club had the operating budget of an AFL club the standard of football the club will massively improve. Once the standard improves so will crowd attendances. Comprende. When our eurosnob soccerfans see something of similar quality in Australia to what they see on their TV screen from Europe they might decide to turn up. That costs money!
Punter said | February 16th 2010 @ 1:30pm | Report comment
Art you are asking someone to use commonsense when their sole aim is to discredit.
Imagine if any country outside of Australia, AFL had 1/10 in the attendance of the A-League, this same person would be jumping for joy.
Michael C said | February 16th 2010 @ 1:39pm | Report comment
Art -
the HAL dost not operate in a sporting vacuum – - thus, it is as it is – the HAL is not the pre-eminant football code of this country and it’s treading a fine line of financial sustainability (but, then, all codes/leagues do, as, any budget expands to consume at least the funds available to it)
Punter -
imagine that Australian Football had been running in any other nation for 120 years and had instigated a national league about 30 odd years ago and had the benefit of wave after wave of ‘sports skilled’ migration and had the benefit of FTA coverage of the top international league and rep comps etc…..
no comparison really. WHich is why we are pleased with Aust Footy international developments dating back 5-10 – 20 years compared to you being pleased with a game that has been embedded in this country for 120 years (granted – some soccer folk, perhaps yourself – prefer to focus ONLY on the last 5 years as if the first 115 years means nothing).
Art Sapphire said | February 16th 2010 @ 2:08pm | Report comment
Michael – Unlike some others who frequent this website I could not care less when or if football becomes the pre-eminent code in the country. What I am more concerned about personally is getting more bang for my buck. The more money that comes into the sport the better for me and the other spectators because as you note correctly note the a-League does operate in a vacum. But unlike AFL, it competes in a global marketplace.
Michael C said | February 16th 2010 @ 2:48pm | Report comment
Art -
correct – which makes it doubly difficult for the HAL -
in the overall balance of Aust sport,
soccer has an advantage on the international stage,
but, a disadvantage re a domestic league,
were the AFL and NRL to not exist in their positions of strength….then perhaps another tale may unfold -
in the mean time, successive years of not even sluggish attendances – but, of crap attendances, along with domestic T20 putting Fox ratings into perspective – - the HAL has to be careful to NOT dig itself a shallow grave……..as per the NBL.
AndyRoo said | February 16th 2010 @ 3:19pm | Report comment
“the HAL has to be careful to NOT dig itself a shallow grave……..as per the NBL.”
The A league will be fine. You can keep wishing it but it won’t come true. And you may be surprised to learn that the NBL is still going.
What’s your prognosis for Rugby Union then, the numbers are much more alarming but their will still be super Rugby in 10 years time.
Could always do a big bash and charge just $10 to get in but that’s not sustainable.
Punter said | February 16th 2010 @ 4:56pm | Report comment
My learned friends Andyroo & Art have explained it to you perfectly, the A-League, not matter how much you wish it to be true is not going anywhere. What I experienced on Sunday was huge, would’ve been better if there was 80K instead of 25K, yes it would’ve been nice but did it matter, no. Would you not like to be in a crowd of fellow AFL supporters cheering your national team on, of course you would, but does it matter, well probably no.
MV Dave said | February 16th 2010 @ 3:41pm | Report comment
The HAL aggregate attendances have risen from 920,000 in season 1 to 1.33 million in season 5. That is 400,000 more spectators attending games in less than 5 seasons. This number will keep increasing as 2 more city teams are added. The fact that there has been a 40% increase in total attendance is cause for celebration for all football lovers. There are still the finals attendances to add for season 5.
Michael C said | February 16th 2010 @ 4:13pm | Report comment
you and I both know that that’s not 400,000 extra unique individuals.
And given that in key markets – the average attendances have dropped – it’s entirely possible that less unique individuals have attended in Melb, Syd and Bris than in any year thus far,
off set by Townsville??? or Wellington NZ???
Spin it how you want – - if your ecstatic about the V5 result then you’re easily pleased.
If Melb, Syd and Bris were on the rise (with successful teams in Melb and Syd at least) and GC and NQF were bringing the average down – -fair enough perhaps – but, with the results in those key markets……it smells like the NBL!!!!
AndyRoo said | February 16th 2010 @ 4:24pm | Report comment
Melbourne’s numbers are fine and despite having a second team come into the comp and extra games MV’s average crowd should actually increase next season. Nothing grows along a gradient.
Sydney improved their average despite the extra games and are in much better shape to take advantage of their success this time.
Brisbane however next season will surely be the current owners last throw of the dice. Unless they do something drastic in the off season come 2011/2012 they will be FFA run and with the world cup bid out of the way better for it.
MV Dave said | February 16th 2010 @ 4:39pm | Report comment
Ahhh so when AFL attendances increase its not extra unique individuals? Just the same poor souls watching more games? Well those NQF supporters must have done a lot of travelling in recent years to watch those HAL games around the country.
The stats show 40% growth in total attendance over 4 seasons…not too bad me thinks for a comp thats about to die (in your eyes).
Michael C said | February 16th 2010 @ 4:52pm | Report comment
MVDave -
with only one game in each market per fortnight……it’s pretty easy for the same poor souls to attend week in week out……that’s the argument always presented against the Sydney Swans anyway.
Problem about your spin of 40% growth in absolute terms is that there’s been a 60% growth in number of matches – and therefore a growth in costs.
Given that who knows what the break even point is for each venue for each given match – trying to sustain 60% extra costs on 40% overall growth is a struggle when in relative terms you’re incurred a 20% drop in average attendances so as to service the average incurred match costs.
That’s not healthy.
Not in anyones language.
go on…spin spin spin, reality is to achieve 100,000 more attendees in V5 compared to V3 – - you’ve had to run 51 extra matches of including over 6 extra weeks and all that effort – - – thus, the real terms are that if financials were a struggle for clubs inside the first 3 or 4 years – - they aren’t likely to trend upwards based on internal factors……..you guys desperately need the Govt to keep funding your WADA tests and national rep sides and desperately need a golden goose in the form of a very generous broadcast deal. Either that, or a couple more Clive Palmers…….
MV Dave said | February 16th 2010 @ 5:09pm | Report comment
Quite happy for a 40% growth every 4 years in attendance. Coupled with the rumoured massive increase in TV deal, ACL involvement, new stadium in Melb and the inclusion of 2 new city teams (as opposed to regional teams this season) very happy how the HAL is progressing. As with MLS and JLeague after their early dip in crowds etc,we are now on the long sustainable growth phase…and although you try to paint a picture of doom and gloom for HAL, IMO, it has never been in a better position to increase its presence on the Oz sporting landscape.
James W said | February 16th 2010 @ 8:28am | Report comment
The A-League’s punched above its weight this summer. Cricket’s struggled, apart from Big Bash, and Tennis had an ordinary one. Not the greatest summer but I can’t help but think the media step on and belittle the summer as a way to fire people up over the winter codes.
JiMMM said | February 16th 2010 @ 8:50am | Report comment
Some excellent points in there Adrian, but because it’s an opinion site my 2 cents are.
Cricket
Ordinary opposition and the ashes next year (which will change focus), the continuos nature of of the game isn’t helping as it hardly seems a week can go by withoput some sort of meaningless series occuring, there is such a thing as oversaturation of a sport.
On the domestic front though it has been a great summer because the Big Bash series made up for much of teh low crowds during teh international series’, so overall hardly a bad summer.
Tennis
Fell victim to channel 7, are locked in for a few more years but hopefully when that broadcast contract expires Tennis Australia will have learnt thier lesson and wont even talk to 7. The Brisbane International was a continuing success though with talk of having to build a second stadium after only 2 years of the event, now if only they could get it broadcast by anyone but 7.
A-League
Not a bad summer, just not as good as previous seasons. Need to get the franchises to conect with thier local community more, and price appropriatly. Was a victim of thier own success and a few supporters who fail to look at reality.
Golf
Had a good year, but has the perennial problem of getting lost in the lights of the US PGA tour.
Basketball
See golf, and also has a complacencey problem with trying to constantly trying to feed off teh NBA.
Derryn said | February 16th 2010 @ 9:02am | Report comment
Tennis is lacking characters. Although Federer and Murray are amazing players they don’t really get the crowd pumped up. Gonzalez and Tsonga are exceptions to the norm of being boring.
In the cricket we lacked a decent opposition. The Windies players were very likeable but unfortunately were not quite up to it on the field. Bring back the Saffas, Poms or India cricket will have its excitement and crowds back for sure.
Shame about the A-Leagues lack of promotion. The quality of football has been decent, but its hard to watch a game being played in a mostly empty stadium.
The NBL is doing better then expected after the financial difficulties they have had, buit it’s hard to see Basketball ever reaching again reaching the heights of the early nineties.
Golf has the same problem as tennis. Apart from Woods and Daly there aren’t many characters in the game.
It’d be good if sports stars actually spoke their mind other then just continually churning out mundane predictable responses.
whiskeymac said | February 16th 2010 @ 9:05am | Report comment
I think (hope) the HAL is merely waiting for the WC and Asian Cup to help promote the game next season – this year had negligible promotion (OK crowds albeit disappointing in many areas outside of Nix, Adelaide, CCM and MV). if they saved their money to make a big splash for 2010-11 then hopefully this years piss poor efforts will be forgiven and forgotten.
sad re:ODI. i actually liked that version of the game; cant comment much on the NBL but its not good that Sydney have no team at all, but then again if regional centres like Cairns can keep it going then maybe thats its base niche.
channel 7 killed tennis (they have form on this ie when they massacred “soccer” but that was on purpose) or is there just a sense of inevitability wit the same 2-3 players always winning?
James W said | February 16th 2010 @ 9:07am | Report comment
Risky strategy for the A-League. I think the World Cup bid has taken much needed money and resources from A-League advertising.
Dogz R Barkn said | February 16th 2010 @ 10:09am | Report comment
That shouldn’t be the case – the FFA received $50 million for the WC bid – and that would pay for a fair bit of advertising and PR.
James W said | February 16th 2010 @ 10:11am | Report comment
True, but I wonder how much extra from their own coffers they’ve put in. I’m also thinking in terms of staff and resources.
James W said | February 16th 2010 @ 10:40am | Report comment
I mean, the FFA isn’t a big organisation and lost a key member of its marketing/PR staff recently.
Marshall said | February 16th 2010 @ 9:19am | Report comment
I also think the media is a harder judge on summer sports – and have been quick to jump on cricket and tennis for bad summers. Winter codes are their bread and butter.
Michael C said | February 16th 2010 @ 11:30am | Report comment
Summer of discontent -
Cricket – shock horror – if you broadcast pretty uncompetitive ODI’s live against the gate in the host city – - then, people won’t turn up in their droves….but, they will next year for England. The West Indies aren’t what they used to be. and the Test series x 2 weren’t as bad as was forecast.
Domestic T20 is a winner, and the depth of overall Aust talent is as good as ever??
HAL – increased aggregates and decreased averages. Requires a careful balancing.
NBL – no Sydney, no Brisbane…..and perhaps the better for it!!! Farewell Slamdunk and Anstey.
Tennis – crowds up most of the time, but, againt, Croats and Serbs don’t mix too well, and TV ratings down – and ch.7 cut to the news on Leyton!?!??
Golf – just lucky the Tiger saga explosed AFTER coming to MElbourne and not before – - was there a money back guarrantee??
F1 GP not far away.
Ch.9 winter Olympics opening ceremony……beat the NAB CUp in Melb by about 1000 in the ratings. Money well spent??
cross code relations (WC bid) -
dented severely by FFA bungling of WC bid. Lost any goodwill with NRL and AFL, has a lot of Govt sponsored work to do to regain it.
Gibbo said | February 16th 2010 @ 11:54am | Report comment
was the worst thing to happen to the cricket shane watson becaming the hero? we all love to hate that guy, but now he’s carrying the top order!
James W said | February 16th 2010 @ 12:19pm | Report comment
That’s an issue in itself this summer – the lack of star names and attractions in the Australian team.
Marshall said | February 16th 2010 @ 1:32pm | Report comment
The cricket team is still in transition and the lack of a Warnie type star is costing them dearly I think
Gibbo said | February 16th 2010 @ 2:42pm | Report comment
dont forget Mr Marketeers-Wet-Dream coming out of a car wash wearing only a towel, Andrew Symonds!