It’s time for rugby league to have a transfer window
By Steve Kaless, 23 Feb 2010 Steve Kaless is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- David Gallop, NRL, Rugby League, Willie Mason
This is a tough time of year for a league journalist. The season has sort of started, with the All Stars game and the various Shields up for grabs. But it also hasn’t.
You are left with column inches about bad boys promising to behave and how much they are looking forward to being role-models, fringe first graders talking up their Origin chances, and players reflecting on their hardest pre-season ever.
Get the feeling you’ve been here before?
But surely what you shouldn’t be writing about is where players are heading in 2011. Let’s first get the cliches out of the way. The players in question will always say: “I’m putting my football first. I won’t be distracted.”
If you believe that line, you’ll give any of the proclaimed new tee-totallers the beer deliveries and tell them not to worry about a receipt.
It is always followed by their first interview the following year when we hear: “Yeah, my form was pretty patchy last year, but I had a lot on with my contract talks and everything.”
For as long as I can remember, people have been complaining about the way in which players have moved during the season.
Any claim to have it sorted at the end of the season is quickly stymied by managers claiming a breach of rights (I swear I’ve even heard some refer to human rights. Quick, call the Hague!)
We hear how it can’t possibly be done, as players need to find houses, organise foxtel connections and the rest.
Of course, that the majority all live in Sydney anyway seems to be lost on the naysayers, as does the fact that if they move interstate, they do so in a small window anyway.
But if football can do it across a global marketplace and factor in all manner of language and cultural differences. Why can’t we? What is holding us back.
“Yes, Willie, you can still get Corona’s in Townsville.”
As Wayne Bennett rightly pointed out, when it suits players, they are happy to resemble contestants on the Amazing Race.
Surely it would be in the best interests of the game and the fans (you know, the ones who are asked to shell out for memberships and jerseys) to bring order to the chaos.
The most successful European football clubs have relocation experts (people who help you find a house and a baker) to help players settle in.
Seeing a good chunk of transferring players these days are at the same time seemingly reintegrating themselves into civilised society with their new club, I dare say I’ve spotted a niche in the market.
They could even help them find jobs, which the Roosters Anthony Cherrington believes is an important role for the NRL to take.
Yes, Anthony, because in between negotiating TV rights and considering the cost benefit analysis of an expanded competition, or fronting the press after the latest bloke has run amok, I think David Gallop should ring a few bricklayers and see if any of them need a few ton of bricks lumped.
Or players who have the urge could DO IT THEMSELVES, and not only increase the chances of them actually turning up, but also cut the umbilical cord between themselves and the code, which many claim actually prevents them developing into mature adults.
But I digress. So let’s cut the crap.
The window opens for all uncontracted players or those seeking release one week after the Grand Final and ends on February 28th. Surely enough time for all third parties to get their cut.
I’d say that is task one for the Independent Commission right there.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
The Crowd Says (12) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- David Gallop, NRL, Rugby League, Willie Mason


Dogz R Barkn said | February 23rd 2010 @ 10:00am | Report comment
Definitely filed away in the “I’d like to see that” folder.
M1tch said | February 23rd 2010 @ 11:19am | Report comment
Beat me to it Steve
its pretty simple they way you have done it
Dont see why a 2 week window year mid as well cant be in place for players ie: Finch situation
Steve Kaless said | February 23rd 2010 @ 1:38pm | Report comment
I don’t think we want to encourage further situations like the Brett Finch saga. I think people would be pretty turned off by players jumping ship mid season. In the rare situation where a player is cut loose mid season, you could just term them a free agent and they could go cap in hand looking for a gig.
The other thing about the mid year window is the salary cap, nearly all clubs have spent up to the maximum from day one so they could hardly afford to go shopping mid year, it could get very messy. Look at Big Willie, even if they wanted to most clubs couldn’t afford to make an offer due to cap restraints. It’s why players often want to sign early for fear of the cash disappearing.
Brett McKay said | February 23rd 2010 @ 11:26am | Report comment
had to argue with any of this, it just seems logical (and therefore doomed)….
gurudoright said | February 23rd 2010 @ 2:48pm | Report comment
I think you are spot on. There is nothing worst than cheering on a player who you know will be playing for the team he is playing on that day. It is like the old saying “it’s like kissing your sister”.
I agree a transfer window should open up between one week after the Grand Final has been played. I don’t see a time limit of the finishing of the transfer window if someone is off contract as someone might miss out on playing if a deal isn’t done by a certain date.
If soccer players can do it all around the world(and even mid season) there should not be an arguement from players in Australia about moving around Australia in a certain time frame. I mean they are meant to be professional sportsman in the time of professional sports. Even the AFL players sign contracts and move from one end of Australia to the other after the season is finished. The NRL players just use it as an excuse
Like in soccer I would like to see huge fines for any deals or offical approaches made to players either personally or through agents before the transfer window is opened. Eg if it is a club making an approach to a player and is caught in the act a suitable fine would be $500,000 -$1Million. If it is an agent making a approach to a club on behalf of a client, the agent and their agency should be discredited as an offical agent and any players contract submitted by the agentg there after would no longer be offically recognised by the league.
oikee said | February 23rd 2010 @ 2:55pm | Report comment
Nice reply Brett, hey Steve, read all my posts lately, until we get a independent commission, lets not even think a good idea is a good idea. I hate being sarcastic, but mate, mate, rugby league is run by fools, dinosaurs from past eras, living off the game like leaches , fat hungry suckers being spoon fed.
Why do you think any amount of talking on here can solve 1 issue, they cant even introduce weigth divisions in rugby league, ? Something we had years ago.
Perth is a boom state, yet our comp does not think it a via-able option for expansion. Mate, we are walking with dinosaurs, until we get some brains in rugby league, the game is great, dont get me wrong, but, we need guiding, and fast.
Yes, great idea Steve, should have happened years ago, but it hasn’t.
james said | February 23rd 2010 @ 3:39pm | Report comment
I love the idea, i also believe there should be a two week window mid season to allow players to be loaned. This would help out teams around origin time who are hit with rep commitments or injuries, and is a good way for teams to offload unwanted or out of form players. They then return at the end of the season
It could be worked in with the salary cap aswell, e.g. if the roosters loan minichello who is on 200 000 a year, and he is loaned to brisbane, then brisbane take over his contract for the rest of the year, brisbanes salary cap goes up 200 000 and the roosters goes down 200 000. This means the roosters are now able to loan a player from another club valued up to 200 000 a year and have the player for the rest of the season.
Realistically this would be utalised with fringe or young players, which is good as it gives more players a go. and it works for both parties. The club with the out of form player gets rid of them for the season (and when they return they are hipefully in form again) the club who recieves the out of form player covers an injury, or has a player with more experience, also get the chance to bring the player into form (obvioiusly they would see potential to do this prior to loaning). The player has the chance to recieve regular game time.
For this to work properly, it should be added, players who recieve season long injuries prior to the loan window should be exempt from the cap for the remainder of the year
Steve Kaless said | February 24th 2010 @ 11:02am | Report comment
The crux being clubs wanting to take out of forms players….
Certainly the cap needs tweaking in regards to injuries. I know of one NSW Cup player last year who despite the wishes of thefirst grade coach was not called up as it would have busted the salary cap because of bonus payments he would have been paid.
oikee said | February 23rd 2010 @ 4:48pm | Report comment
Thats also a good idea James, if you read what Wayne Bennet was saying a week ago, he also mentioned the exemption from the salary cap for season ending injuries,. So your idea should come into play for fringe players, Under 20 or senior players who might be running around in qld or nsw cups.
Great idea, dont tell anyone, its to senseable, it just might work. The NRL and ARL would look absolutely stupid if they come up with such a good idea.
oikee said | February 23rd 2010 @ 4:52pm | Report comment
Steve, please tell me you can see the funny side to all our good ideas. ? You need a sense of humour to even follow rugby league.
Just one more thing, isn’t life boring now with no behavior issues, surely we can catch someone taking a pee somewhere.
Steve Kaless said | February 24th 2010 @ 10:59am | Report comment
Certainly some good ideas Oikee, I must admit I don’t share your complete lack of faith in the NRL nor am I willing to celebrate no behavioural issues just yet…..
Season kick off is getting close though….
The Red Devil said | April 28th 2010 @ 3:04am | Report comment
Hate to drag up an old(ish) post but I am a football fan (soccer) in the UK and I have just finished writing an article on why I think the transfer window should be scrapped and I was looking for counter-arguments/reasons why there should be one and I found your site.
What we are seeing here in the UK is a great number of clubs in financial difficulties and it is probably due to player wages being astronomical.
However, because of the transfer window, I believe managers are “over-stocking” on the player front in an attempt to account for every possibility that may arise during a season (injuries, suspensions etc). If he has a rough patch outside the transfer window and he did not “over-stock” in that position during the transfer window then he is basically stuffed and just has to make do with what he has, rather than going out and buying or loaning a player.
I believe that this means that clubs are basically paying players good money who may not even be required during the course of the season and are there for “emergency” situations.
When players are earning seven figure annual salaries, these players are a pretty expensive form of “insurance”.
On a lesser note, just because a player cannot be bought outside the transfer window does not remove the speculation that he will be off as soon as the window opens and this can be equally distracting for the player, irritating for the manager and annoying for the fans who would rather see a player just go if he really wants to go and not just “go through the motions” until the window opens.
Be careful what you wish for is all I’m saying!