
Adelaide United's Sasa Ognenovski beats Masato Yamazaki of Gamba Osaka to the ball during the Asian Champions League final match in Adelaide, Wednesday, Nov. 12, 2008. AAP Image/Rob Hutchison
At 9pm AEST tonight, Asia’s premier club competition will return, and like all good football, the Asian Champions League is a warts and all microcosm of Asian football.
On the downside, there’s the misguided political interference that means the majority of fans from the two teams who make it all the way to the end of the tournament won’t have the chance to see their team play the one-off final in Tokyo in person.
But while the ACL is still finding its feet, what gives the tournament the best chance of succeeding is the mostly under-appreciated quality of talent on offer.
Australia aside, the vast majority of Asia’s best footballers still plays within the region.
From the United Arab Emirates to South Korea, most national team players still play their club football domestically. Sprinkle in some exciting foreigners and promising young managers, and you’ve got an enticing mix.
While I’ve never quite understood why some choose to relegate the ACL to the same “worthless” status as UEFA’s Europa League, I’m once again looking forward to another chance to see some football from parts of the world I wouldn’t normally get to.
Just like last season, I’m particularly looking forward to seeing the exciting attacking brand of football played by J-League side Kawasaki Frontale. My only regret is that I won’t be able to see them mix things up with Melbourne Victory in person.
While I’ll take the opportunity to watch Kawasaki play in Seongnam tonight, my recommendation is for any football fan within or near Melbourne to get to Etihad Stadium on the 31st of March when Tsutomu Takahata’s men visit.
That brings me on nicely to how Australia’s two entrants, the Victory and 2008/09 A-League runners-up, Adelaide United, will go.
My heart sank a little yesterday when I read some of Melbourne coach Ernie Merrick’s thoughts on his first opponents Beijing Guoan.
“I think we have to be patient,” the 2009/10 A-League coach of the year explained. “(Beijing) are similar to Sydney, the way they come across and pressure centrally and on the flank and leave exposed the other side.
“They are very good at smothering the ball and it’s very hard to pass out of defence, so you tend to have to play longer balls.”
Those comments sent my mind spinning back to Victory’s failed debut ACL campaign from 2008. Throughout that tournament, Merrick’s men were caught offside so often they’d put Filippo Inzaghi to shame.
In both their games against Gamba Osaka, Melbourne players were offside 19 times. It’s a stat that becomes even more damning when you realise that Gamba’s tally didn’t even come close to exiting single digits.
At the time Merrick explained that because the Japanese side played such a high defensive line, he decided Melbourne would try and catch out Gamba by exploiting the space left behind the defence.
Considering that Archie Thompson is at his best when running into space – remember how “hopeless” the Victory striker was for the Socceroos when Indonesia sat deep in Jakarta last year – it would almost be a good plan.
Almost.
The problem was Gamba was playing a high defensive line so as to contract the field of play. This meant there was less space in midfield, an obstacle their more technically astute players could exploit. On the flipside, when the Victory got their hands on the ball they had less time to accurately pick out Archie Thompson’s runs.
Whenever a long ball did come over the top, Gamba’s centre-back pairing were more then adept enough to step up and catch Thompson offside.
So while all the sounds from the Victory has been that they’ve learned form their last Asian experience, Merrick’s comments have me worried.
Personally, I’m much more confident in Adelaide United’s ability to adapt to Asian football. A good example of this was how coach Aurelio Vidmar reacted to United’s 5-0 thrashing by Gamba in the 2008 ACL final.
Only weeks later, with a much more compact set-up, the Reds were unfortunate to loose by a solitary goal to the ACL champions.
At the time, I opined about how the Central Coast Mariners learned a similar lesson last year against Kawasaki Frontale. After a 5-goal drubbing at home, Lawrie McKinna’s men travelled to Japan and lost 2-1 in the driving rain in Kawasaki.
The fantastic Jonathon Wilson often refers to football as “the manipulation of space”. Judging form the acres of space left in A-League games, it’s a lesson that the A-League’s “personnel driven” coaching has yet to learn.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.

whiskeymac said | February 23rd 2010 @ 8:01am | Report comment
it would be a shame for the vicotry not to have learnt from their first foray into Asia. hopefully Ernie can adapt a lot more quickly than his soundbite suggests because to not get out of the group stage must surely be considered a failure nowadays. not saying HAL teams have a divine right to progress, nor are they the best, but if we harbour any ambition and pride then, and with the exploits of Adelaide (and then the Jets) a good yardstick, we should target next round qualification as a measure of success. We certainly shoudlnt accept the clubs eforts as being similar to the very first naive and “brave” attempts.
whiskeymac said | February 23rd 2010 @ 8:04am | Report comment
“the A-League’s “personnel driven” coaching ” this from Craig Foster’s recent article?
how do you reconcile that tag in your article whilst also mentioning how Adelaide and CCM admirably adapted, or is it just aimed at Ernie?
Davidde Corran said | February 23rd 2010 @ 8:46am | Report comment
Hi whiskeymac that’s a good point to make. While Adelaide and the Mariners adapted in those individual games I mentioned, its not an approach we have seen them use subsequently in the A-League. I’m not saying there’s a complete dearth of tactics in the A-League it’s just that generally they are under-developed ideas.
For example think of the Victory’s switch to 3-4-3 this season. It wasn’t because Merrick felt that formation would defeat individual opponents, it was an attempt to get his best three centre-backs on the pitch at the same time and protect a fairly inexperienced goalkeeper. I could list other examples as well.
Despite that I suspect Vidmar will know he is taking too much of a risk to set his team up on Wednesday night the same way he does in the A-League. I hope Merrick feels the same. Despite being critical I only want the two A-League teams to succeed and in this case especially Melbourne.
Also I thought your first comment was right on the money.
Australian Football said | February 23rd 2010 @ 3:52pm | Report comment
Good luck to Melbourne Victory and Adelaide Un tonight—-we shall be watching..
~~~~~~~
AF
MV Dave said | February 23rd 2010 @ 5:42pm | Report comment
“Good luck to Melbourne Victory ” Ok, whoever you are, what did you do with the real AF?
Australian Football said | February 24th 2010 @ 11:20am | Report comment
What was I thinking of.. ? Dave any crucial injuries that may help SFC ?
btw Chelsea play tomorrow…
~~~~~
AF
Ben of Phnom Penh said | February 23rd 2010 @ 7:05pm | Report comment
Tonight ESPN is showing Bunyodkor and Al ittihad so I’m settling in with a beer and shall enjoy the show
Davidde Corran said | February 24th 2010 @ 12:07am | Report comment
Great stuff. Would love to know your thoughts on the game afterward if you get a moment to post them up here.
Black Diamonds said | February 24th 2010 @ 5:10pm | Report comment
“While I’ve never quite understood why some choose to relegate the ACL to the same “worthless” status as UEFA’s Europa League, I’m once again looking forward to another chance to see some football from parts of the world I wouldn’t normally get to. ”
I found this statement of yours quite confusing Davidde. Isn’t it obvious?
It is perceived as worthless because there is a better league out there run in parallel that is much better to watch! Why watch B, or C Grade athletes running around when the A Grade athletes are on the other channel?
Have you noticed that people in this country rarely support State Cricket? The reason has been because we get to see a better standard of cricket by better cricketers run basically at the same time!
Sure, Twenty20 State Big Bash has taken off this Summer, and in recent years – Why? Because there is clearly a dearth of higher quality Twenty20 National Cricket being played in Australia.
Look at the NHL, NBA, MLB – these leagues are so popular that we rarely get any other leagues of these sports on our TV screens! Why is that? Because what’s the point of watching B-Grade athletes mate?
Its fairly clear isn’t it – when your competition is a better standard of your own sport – why accept mediocrity?
Saying all that – the only chance the Asian Champions League has of taking off is when the economies of Asia match and well exceed those of Europe. Despite all the hype – that is perhaps 50-70 years into the future. Only then will the ACL really be worth watching, it’ll be the old hasbeens in Europe who suddenly have an inferior product.
Why try and rush what is a natural evolutionary process through whinging like you have (at least in that paragraph).
Davidde Corran said | February 24th 2010 @ 10:30pm | Report comment
Whinging? Not in the least. I’m not sure how you drew the implication that I was whinging or even complaining about the apathy many have towards the ACL.
In regards to your main point, I agree with most of your sentiments. Though I wasn’t asking why the ACL isn’t as popular as it’s European counterpart (or any other globally recognised league) which is what you’ve explained.
I completely understand why most would choose to watch Inter Milan versus Chelsea instead of Seongnam versus Kawasaki.
However, what I sometimes struggle to understand is how some proper football fans wont even give the ACL the time of day without having actually sat down to watch it. While ACL football often isn’t of as high quality as that on show during UEFA’s tournament, generally its still entertaining football. There are about as many awful games in any European league as there are in the ACL and J-League.
Black Diamonds said | February 25th 2010 @ 12:20pm | Report comment
Ok – I apologise for referring to what you were saying as a whinge. I guess in regards to your last point – people only have so much time in their day – there are a helluva lot of top quality sporting options out there – and the World Game certainly doesn’t lack for options.
Davidde Corran said | February 25th 2010 @ 7:34pm | Report comment
No worries mate.
Agreed, though we are apart of Asia so the ACL is ours. I think that should count towards something. For that reason I prefer to watch the ACL instead of the Copa Libertadores for example. I’d never argue people should get into and watch the African Champions League (though I’d like to see it out of curiosity) but we have something invested into the ACL and the football is generally worth the attention.