Contenders and pretenders for the 2010 NRL title
By Steve Kaless, 5 Mar 2010 Steve Kaless is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- Melbourne Storm, NRL, Parramatta Eels, Rugby League

Ben Roberts drops the ball during the Parramatta Eels V Canterbury Bulldogs National Rugby League match at the ANZ Stadium in Sydney, Saturday, March 15, 2008. AAP Image/Action Photographics, Robb Cox
There are three groups of clubs heading into the 2010 NRL season, the contenders, the dark horses and the battlers. The contenders have recent history and the cattle to suggest they could be slugging for the title. The dark horses have the capability to surprise people and the battlers will be hoping 2010 represents a positive year in terms of their rebuilding.
In no particular order, the contenders are Melbourne, Parramatta, Manly, Canterbury, St George and the Gold Coast.
Melbourne Storm: They came back into the pack during the regular season, but cut loose in the finals to win it in a canter. They are rugby league’s Terminator and refuse to be stopped. Will Dallas Johnson’s departure finally take the wind out of their sails? Time and Todd Lowrie will tell.
Parramatta Eels: Last season’s Cinderella have the weight of expectation on their shoulder’s this year. How do Parramatta perform under pressure? Ha! To be fair Justin Poore, Shane Shackelton, and Timana Tahu are impressive signings and Daniel Anderson is well entrenched there now. The Eels have no excuses.
Canterbury Bulldogs: Looked to have run out of ideas at the end of last year, won’t have the element of surprise this year and their recruitment has already been hit with injuries. Need someone to find a new level in the finals and Jamal Idris looked like he was starting his second year syndrome at the back end of last year.
St George Dragons: Like the Dogs fell away badly after a great performance during the regular season. Need to hit their straps in the finals, not three months before it. Big question: Will Wendell Sailor get more exposure than any current Dragons player?
Gold Coast Titans: Of the top three of 2009, the Titans have recruited the best to cover their shortcomings with Greg Bird and Joseph Tomane? If they can win more regularly on the road they could be a good shout for the minor premiership.
Manly Sea Eagles: How the Sea Eagles respond to the departure of Matt Orford and whether Brett Stewart stays on the park are the key questions for 2010. Graham Lowe should steady the ship off the field and Brett Kite must produce big time on it after losing some key support players in the off season.
The dark horses could claim a few big scalps during the season, but will count the year as a success if they can sneak into the eight and may even receive a rugby league miracle.
South Sydney Rabbitohs: A monster pack filled with workers and flair. If Mick Crocker can get back to his best after his offseason rebuild which included something like three reconstructions they really good be cooking. As stated previously, their year comes down to the Sandow and Sutton combination and whether a revived John Lang can still come up with the plays.
Wests Tigers: All the talk, but we’ve heard it all before. Tquiri must avoid father time as well as league defences and Marshall and Farah must fire on all cylinders…consistently. Sheens must take this team to the finals.
Brisbane Broncos: While others rise, the Broncos seem to be treading water after another off season in which they lost more than they gained. The chiseling at the roster and the miles on Lockyer’s clock must surely start to take their toll. The famed Bronco production line will need to come up with something special to cover the loss of Hunt and Hodges.
North Queensland Cowboys: The hopes of the Cowboys rest of an ageing Matt Bowen, a distracted Jonathan Thurston and Willie Mason. It could be tough. Thurston’s tag as one of the best players in the world hasn’t got his team into the finals for the past two years, hard to find the confidence that will change.
Penrith Panthers: A great batch of homegrown talent, and the purists rate them, but it could still be a season early for the mountain men. Big years needed from Petero and Pritchard as well as developing a dominant halfback. They have the points in them, but need to muscle up in defence to come from the clouds.
The battlers start the year on the same amount of points as everyone and in some cases with as much as optimism for how long that lasts remains to be seen.
Canberra Raiders: The Raiders have enjoyed bucking the wooden spoon tip for the last few years, but they are looking like they are running out of steam, how long can a team survive on Alan Tongue’s work rate? Unable to attract big names and an injured Joel Monaghan puts pressure on this year’s batch.
Sydney Roosters: Surely must improve on the rabble that wore the tri-colours last year, but the exit door also swung on Craig Fitzgibbon who is close to irreplaceable in terms of workrate, professionalism and experience. Injuries have already hit a young squad, they’ll start with plenty of enthusiasm but it could still prove a long season.
New Zealand Warriors: Ivan Cleary is the coach most under pressure and the roster is looking thin. Warriors fan must hope Steve Price has inherited Ruben Wiki’s stock of kava. They still hold some class players but the semis of 2008 seem light years away.
Cronulla Sharks: Dodged the spoon last year thanks to the Roosters, they should be right in the frame this year. Will Albert Kelly become the latest young halfback to fall foul of Ricky Stuart’s mentoring?
Newcastle Knights: Brian Smith was hailed as the man who transformed the Newcastle culture. He did this by bringing in, amongst others, Danny Wicks and Chris Houston. Nice one. The wooden spoon has traditionally gone to the club who have imploded mid season. Newcastle look specials to do that with the inexperienced Rick Stone leading the team from their worst ever preseason.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- Melbourne Storm, NRL, Parramatta Eels, Rugby League

terrykidd said | March 5th 2010 @ 6:40am | Report comment
Can’t argue too much with that Steve but I reckon Manly should drop out of the contenders, they will win more than they lose but they will struggle without an experienced organisor. Who is going to keep Watmough’s mind on the job?
KR said | March 5th 2010 @ 7:04am | Report comment
Steve, the Warriors were last called the ‘Auckland Warriors’ in 2000. Sharpen up.
Steve Kaless said | March 5th 2010 @ 12:24pm | Report comment
Well spotted. Mea culpa.
KR said | March 5th 2010 @ 7:03pm | Report comment
Cheers, Steve. The current name is a disgraceful one of token identity and I (unnecessarily) tend to get a bit snippy about it. Sucks that a simple name can do that.
Gerry Faehrmann said | March 5th 2010 @ 7:37am | Report comment
Steve, all the analysis counts for nada, all I can say is see what happens.
I mean, can you believe another Newcastle player departing the game? The game is too fickle purely because you cannot predict how some of the young guns (and older ones for that matter) will behave.
Anyway, you were right about one thing, the Bulldogs are definite contenders…I got that from Peter Moore in my dream last night!
Steve Kaless said | March 5th 2010 @ 12:26pm | Report comment
Well on Weds the Newcastle boss said he was confident of nothing further and on Thurs he refused to rule it out. So you work it out.
Gerry Faehrmann said | March 5th 2010 @ 8:08pm | Report comment
Steve, you’re not hearing me!
Terry Kidd said | March 5th 2010 @ 7:47am | Report comment
Frank facer was older and therefore wiser than Bullfrog Moore … Frank told me its a dragons year !!!!
Interesting point Steve, lets see how many readers of the Roar know who Frank Facer was.
MyGeneration said | March 5th 2010 @ 9:42am | Report comment
I had a dream where Ken Arthurson was playing poker with Frank Facer and Bullfrog Moore. Arko said “I’ve outlasted you both, so it’s Manly’s year!”
Dogs Of War said | March 5th 2010 @ 8:48pm | Report comment
Difference is that Bullfrog Jr is still around, and is showing plenty of his fathers pedigree. Bulldogs for sure this year!
oikee said | March 5th 2010 @ 7:53am | Report comment
Its hard, very hard Steve, but yes your lineup and thoughts look good. Parramatta look the goods this year. As long the Broncos make the 8, i really dont give a damm. Frankly.
Having said that, any team is capable of making the 8, but parra look the goods.
Brett McKay said | March 5th 2010 @ 8:17am | Report comment
all I know, Steve, is that you can’t win a premiership in March and April, but you definitely can lose one…
Chris said | March 5th 2010 @ 10:56am | Report comment
Usually, Brett.
I was one of the many who wrote Parramatta off when they lost 5 of their opening 7 games. The NRL season is so long that you can’t start putting a red line through teams until at least Week 9 no matter how bad they are. Early points are valuable in any comp – but the NRL isn’t exactly like the S14 where you can be (more or less) out of the comp after the first 3 weeks.
Corey said | March 5th 2010 @ 9:45am | Report comment
Just a question, where did the Broncos money go- Darren Lockyer admitted to taking a pay cut so the Broncos could hang on to the up and coming talent….then Hunt leaves, they signed Kemp (who, IMO, is a waste of money) and Tim Smith- that is all, they also lost Gorrell and Clinton. So where are our star players, Hodges is out, so there is money, Folau and that is it. Corey Parker is a major asset to the Broncos, along with Thaiday.
In saying all that the Broncos have got some class in the full backs, Corey Norman and Josh Hoffman look like great players coming through the ranks.
woppadingo said | March 5th 2010 @ 10:05am | Report comment
The Raiders dont live and die on Alan Tongue’s performance. Raiders have known for a long time how hard it is to recruit from out of town. Thats why they have a great development program. Now they’re in the position to reap the benefits. You must have forgotten that. With Dugan, Vidot, Thompson and Campese in the backs, Monaghan would have a hard time making first grade even if he was fit. The Raiders also have a huge representaitve forward pack – Shillington, TLL, Tongue, Waddell, Harrison, Logan and the mighty Josh Miller, just to name a few.
The Raiders forward pack is up there with the best in the NRL and the backs are brimming full of talent and speed.
If you think they’re battlers this year, you just have not done your homework!
oikee said | March 5th 2010 @ 12:23pm | Report comment
This is why i say anyone can make the 8, i have looked at every pack in the comp. I cant find any weakness at all. Even the Broncos look good. But yes, i agree, with the young players Canberra had last year, i myself think they could make the 8, but i say this about every team. Panthers are another that look good. The young Shark pack look better for the run last year. I think they had 2 origin prospects. Mate, i could go through every squad, and they all look good.
Steve Kaless said | March 5th 2010 @ 12:28pm | Report comment
Granted Canberra have plenty of young talent but it tends to take a few seasons for players to develop. I still reckon the Raiders will run out of puff.
rob said | March 5th 2010 @ 10:24am | Report comment
I think the cowboys are a better chance most others seem to think. Have a look at their forward pack:
Kaufusi Payne Scott
Mason Webb
ODonnell
They have Southern and Rapira on the bench also. I believe that is a pretty decent pack for a player like Thurston to
play behind. I admit that some of those guys aren’t the most reliable, but if they do hit good form and get a roll on, anything could happen.
I guess I’m saying that due to questionable consistency, I won’t be surprised if they don’t make the finals. However due to the potential they have, I wouldn’t be overly surprised if they finish in the top 4.
oikee said | March 5th 2010 @ 12:25pm | Report comment
Cowboys look good this year. Should make the 8. Mason was a good pick-up.
frank said | March 5th 2010 @ 10:58am | Report comment
Broncos will have a tought seaon, they have lot of talent but not a lot of older harden forwards, the backs are looking light with hodges, hunt gone, locky looking ot retire.
Parker, Thaiday, Wallace, Falou are the pick but after watching them play Redcliff the other day it wasnt a pretty win and it look like they under performed to the usually high standard. they aint going to make the 8 and I thnk they willl make 10 -12th.