Waratahs hang on for vital win over Sharks
By Darren Walton, 7 Mar 2010 Darren Walton is a Roar Pro
- Tagged:
- NSW Waratahs, Rugby Union, Sharks, Super Rugby
The NSW Waratahs held on for dear life to post a potentially season-saving 25-21 victory over the Sharks in Saturday night’s Super 14 clash at the Sydney Football Stadium.
Playing their first home match of 2010 after a draining fortnight in South Africa, the Waratahs spent most of the final quarter camped inside their own half starved of possession.
The Sharks argued they were unfairly denied a match-winning penalty try three minutes from fulltime when NSW replacement fullback Kurtley Beale was yellow-carded for desperately and deliberately knocking down a pass from his Sharks counterpart Stefan Terblanche.
NSW coach Chris Hickey felt Beale was attempting an intercept but, either way, had he not intervened and had Terblanche found his supporting winger, it would have been lights out for the Tahs.
Instead, the Waratahs opened their home campaign in winning, if unspectacular, fashion.
“Certainly there’s some things there that we’ll be working on during the week, but coming away with four points out of that game is really important for the season,” Hickey said.
“Sometimes you do have to grind out wins.”
After back-to-back defeats at the hands of Stormers and Bulls, another loss would have been disastrous for the lowly-positioned Waratahs, who now have a golden opportunity to climb the ladder with three of their next four games in Sydney and the other against the Western Force also in Australia.
The Waratahs had looked to be on their way to a comfortable win after resurgent halfback Luke Burgess put powerhouse hooker Tatafu Polota-Nau – the official man of the match – over under the sticks in the 52nd minute to give NSW a 11-point buffer.
But as the Tahs began to wilt, with Burgess and fellow Wallabies playmaker Berrick Barnes among the many second-half replacements, the Sharks refused to lie down, closing to within four points through a converted try to centre Adrian Jacobs and threatening to spoil the homecoming.
“I suppose it’s fortunate it’s an 80-minute game, not an 82 or 83-minute game,” Waratahs skipper Phil Waugh said. “The guys hung in there.”
In front of a healthy crowd of 20,651 fans at the SFS, NSW had ground their way to a 18-14 halftime lead over the ill-disciplined Sharks.
In an eventful opening stanza, the touring South Africans were briefly reduced to 13 men for a spell for downright unsporting conduct, but the Waratahs left it until late to grab their slender advantage at the interval.
Prop Jannie Du Plessis was the first Shark to receive a yellow card in the 20th minute for blatantly tripping Daniel Halangahu as the NSW five-eighth pursued his own kick down field.
Du Plessis could face suspension for his sinister act, especially given referee Paul Marks didn’t witness the trip and was guided by a linesman, meaning the Sharks may not be able to argue the matter was sufficiently dealt with at the time.
Three minutes later, Sharks fly-half and former England Test star Andy Goode was also sent to the sin bin for deliberately killing the ball in the ruck as the Waratahs attacked their line.
Incredibly, though, it was actually the undermanned Sharks who scored the only try during the pair’s absence with No.8 Ryan Kankowski racing 60 metres to cross in the 26th minute after intercepting from Burgess.
The five-pointer put the Sharks ahead 11-6 after Goode Barnes traded penalty and drop goals in the opening 17 minutes.
The Sharks extended their lead to 14-6 with a Ruan Pienaar penalty shortly after before the Waratahs finally nudged ahead with close-range tries to Halangahu and centre Tom Carter in the 32nd and 38th minutes.
© AAP 2012Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- NSW Waratahs, Rugby Union, Sharks, Super Rugby

Ben C said | March 7th 2010 @ 7:10am | Report comment
The second half was absolutely dire. I think I drifted off to sleep a couple of times.
When the Tahs won a penalty on their line with the Sharks attacking about a minute out from the end, the ground announcer called out something like “Lets get behind the Tahs as they go for their bonus point try”. The laughter from the crowd was hugely sardonic and some bright chap behind yelled out “They better hope the Easter bunny is going to deliver it.” Indeed.
Justin said | March 7th 2010 @ 8:11am | Report comment
Unfortunately I was at the ground last night. What a pathetic game, no intent to use the ball just kicking the crap out of it. Do the Tahs not understand the benefit of keeping the ball this year???
stillmissit said | March 7th 2010 @ 8:59am | Report comment
Agree with you both BenC and Justin. Just wanted to add that it was pathetic use of the bench he kept Mumm on there regardless of how useless he was. The second half was nothing like the coach stated (Fox) after half time. He said something like “we must go forward first before we go wide” they went nowhere except to the boot.
If they really are not playing to the plan drop them, regardless of who they are. If it is the plan then Hickey needs a replacement, how could he possibly be that brain dead with the emphasis on the breakdown this year. Even my lowly 3rd div subbies know this.
joeb said | March 7th 2010 @ 10:35am | Report comment
Stillmissit, glad you mentioned Mumm, ’cause likewise what exactly does he do? Contests lineouts? The moment Mowen came on with 20 to go he ran the ball straight and hard causing problems for the defence, something Mumm rarely does effectively. But how do you explain last night’s 2nd-half kick fest to last week’s inspiring display against the Bulls? We played brilliant last week only to go back to our old boring habits last night… as for Beale’s binning, that was a bit rough considering his honest attempted intercept, eh?
Back later, gotta pop out.
mungo said | March 7th 2010 @ 9:37am | Report comment
As a former Tahs supporter and watching their usual game plan of kicking the ball away because their too afraid to run the bloody thing I was backing the sharks and willing them to win, only because this will hasten Peter Hickeys eminent departure, he could take with him all the kickers in the side including Berrick Barnes. A waste of a saturday night.
Brett McKay said | March 7th 2010 @ 10:12am | Report comment
“Sometimes you do have to grind out wins.” – Chris Hickey
Here we go again…..
sheek said | March 7th 2010 @ 10:35am | Report comment
I don’t think the Waratahs understand it is in the sports entertainment business, whether it likes the idea or not.
Rugby league has nothing to fear from their continuing inept displays. Adam Freier in his Sunday column pleads with fans to attend games live. But why would we???
The fans even booed the Tahs midway through the second half for contiinually kicking away possession. As the commentators suggested, is Phil Waugh the problem? It seems Waugh doesn’t believe in a ball in hand style of play, despite the talent of the Tahs’ backline.
I think the Sharks were terribly unlucky. If Beale deserved a yellow card in the dying minutes, then it’s reasonable to argue it should been a penalty try. There was no cover coming across to knock off Kankowski. That said, Beale took a bullet for his team, he had no choice to do otherwise.
Rugby union continues to be its own worst enemy, at least in Australia.
JTG said | March 7th 2010 @ 10:55am | Report comment
What a lucky escape thanks mainly to Paul Marks, hard to play 13 against 16. It is about time Sanzar does something about the poor referring quality, He missed just about every forward pass by both teams & at least 3 knock ons by the Tahs & 1 he was right in front of!!.( Steve walsh, Craig Joubert & Keith brown aren’t much better) It is a professional game yet we have inept people trying to control it. Berrick must be the worlds most expensive goal kicker cause thats all he’s doing, When under Robbie & Phil Mooney he had an attacking game but it’s only taken the Tahs a few games to get rid of any attacking skill he may have had. They are a joke if they think beating the Sharks last night was gutsy.
sheek said | March 7th 2010 @ 11:06am | Report comment
JTG,
Just want to point out the Sharks were down to 13 men for only about 8 minutes. So it’s not like the Sharks were playing with only 13 men for 80 minutes, which you infer, either intentionally or accidentally.
Maybe Marks was incometent in some areas, but I believe he was fair to both sides. Both sin bins were definitely justified. With the penalty try, the ref only has a very short-time to make up his mind, so if he didn’t call it, then he simply didn’t have the confidence to do so in the time frame given.
Maybe the video ref should be able to assist in this area also???
Rugby Fan said | March 7th 2010 @ 11:34am | Report comment
Good HeavensThe referee was pathetic.We do mot need such ineptitude in a professional game.
Even looser said | March 7th 2010 @ 11:41am | Report comment
The Referee was crap. Though I suppose he was more or less equally crap to both sides. Does that make it okay?
Sharks may feel hard done by with Beale’s attempt to intercept. Equally the Tahs may feel hard done by with off-sides that were missed & that trip may have seen a red card come out instead of a yellow. Though luckily for the Tahs it was only a yellow and 10 minutes because the Sharks actually went better with fewer guys on the paddock. How can that be?
Looks as if that wonderful style we saw in the Bulls game was a false dawn. I thought for a moment there that the Tahs had turned the corner discovered the running game, ball retention, running angles, pick & drive and lots more to tantalise our taste buds & bring the fans back. Instead it’s business as usual with kicking as first instinct, handling errors, failure to win ball on restarts, not contesting the lineouts and a game plane guaranteed to keep fans at home. More bread & water anyone?
Blinky Bill of Bellingen said | March 7th 2010 @ 11:19am | Report comment
Boy am I glad that others share my view. I was worried that when I finally got The Roar to fire up on my old Dell (anyone else have problems connecting last night?), that I’d encounter this crappy opinion of ‘better to win ugly than lose beautiful’.
My view is simple I want us winning and doing it in style. Shit a brick, what’s the point in having all of this firepower in the back line & just booting the ball away in such a brain dead and totally aimless fashion. Are they actually trying to piss off the fans? At least that parts working.
Look, to be fair, if we kicked for field position and it was paying off I’d no doubt see the method to the madness. But it wasn’t working and never looked like working. We kicked & kicked & then kicked some more and just got out kicked by the Sharks full back time & time again. Hello coach? Hello Phil? Anyone home? Time to change the game plan, cause it aint working.
Ref bashing – Where did they find that bloke with the whistle? Talk about inept. 50% of the officials were God Damn useless. The TMO was mostly good (I remain unconvinced about the Carter try though) & that linesman who missed Beale flick the ball back in play & bounced out & off a Shark’s player, was absolute rubbish. That was our throw-in. Clear as day.
The Austar slow-mo showed him right there as Johnny on the spot with a perfect line of site. Right in front of him and he still missed it. I must have been obvious because my Missus spotted it from the kitchen before the slow-mo replay and I’m pretty sure she’s not an assistant referee. Neither though was that dude.
After wtaching that game I’m at a total loss as to what the Tahs are aiming to achieve. The game plan was so crap that I’ll never know how the Sharks didn’t win. Even in the final minute or so they were in for all money. Until they stuffed-up.
Is that our plan? Wait until the opposition stuff-up? Farkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bench – It’s been mentioned BUT. If we’re so knackered from a trip back from Africa, wouldn’t it make even more sense to actually use the vast array of talent sitting their on the bench?
Something needs changing at Tahs HQ. Anyone got any ideas of how we can bring about change?
Sorry for the rant but I’m very, very unhappy with that effort from the coaches & the Captain. NOT GOOD ENOUGH!
Brett McKay said | March 7th 2010 @ 11:59am | Report comment
Blinky, that was too good a rant to try and argue with it (and not that there’s much to argue with!), so I’ll restrict myself to saying yes, I also couldn’t get to The Roar last night…
Blinky Bill of Bellingen said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:18pm | Report comment
Brett, cheers for that.
You think I went too far?
Not far enough maybe?
Brett McKay said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:23pm | Report comment
just spot on mate..
Working Class Rugger said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:10pm | Report comment
Don’t apologise. I share your sentiment. Last night was rubbish. We were fortunate that the Sharks were worse.
tarpo said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:46pm | Report comment
Blinky, good rant mate, I sure you still have abit left in the tank too!!
Couldn’t get on the Roar last night either.
I’d say to fix things, “bring back Link”, but we won’t let him out of Queensland now LOL.
Rickety Knees said | March 7th 2010 @ 6:35pm | Report comment
Spot on BBOB. I am starting to believe that the problem lies with Hickey and Waugh. Hickey’s platitude at halftime “we have to go forward before we go wide” really pissed me off. The Tahs made little or no attempt to do this. It seems to me that we had a clear illustration of the coach saying one thing and the players doing another. It’s time for a clean out of Hickey and Waugh before they kill he game in NSW stone dead.
Tom said | March 7th 2010 @ 11:29am | Report comment
I thought Phil Waugh was very disappointing last night. He made numerous errors, and was generally ineffective with the ball in hand.
The effort when the Sharks had two in the bin was pathetic as well. At one stage I noticed they had a two man overlap, but played two more phases of one out forward hit ups, before sending it to the backs about 5 minutes too late. If we are going to drop $2 million or whatever it was on a backline, why not use it?
Brett McKay said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:01pm | Report comment
Tom I had similar thoughts actually, and then when I started thinking who would be the backup 7 if Hickey did the highly unlikely, I went blank. I’m sure the Tahs do have another 7, surely?
Working Class Rugger said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:07pm | Report comment
Off the top of my head Chris Alcock could be a good option. Quick and strong, good in the loose aswell as in tight. Another option would be young McCaffery. Anyone know if the Tahs have Seilala Lam from Rondwick. Tough flanker could be another one assuming he’s not a Brumby.
Rockin Rod said | March 7th 2010 @ 6:04pm | Report comment
Just watched NSW A, Chris Alcock did his AC in the first tackle. He is a great player and probably on Melbournes hit list since they missed out on Pocock and Lipman
McCaffrey not a 7, a very good 6 or 8. His younger brother came Miles came on for NSW A today at 7, very good but needs to fill out
OldManEmu said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:12pm | Report comment
Brett see below -my view is we do not need a Number 7 in the traditional mould any longer. I would pick Dennis and Mowen and get Tim Davidson back into the squad as quickly as possible.
Brett McKay said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:21pm | Report comment
OME, I guess it depends on what you call the ‘traditional mould’ for no.7. Already this year we’ve seen the likes of Braid, Smith and Hodgson (and Pocock before he was injured) adapting and even thriving under the new breakdown interpretations, but Waugh seems to be getting left behind in some respects. How many times was he penalised for not rolling away last night?
You may be right though, suggesting a Mowen-Dennis option, becuase we’ve also seen some pretty handy displays from 6s around the country this year too (Elsom, McCalman, Schatz, Higginbotham, and of course Mowen himself).
Someone the other day mentioned the stupidity in letting Beau Robinson go at the end of last season, and those calls might be getting pretty bloody loud before too long, if nothing improves…
Ben C said | March 8th 2010 @ 9:27am | Report comment
Well, back in the day (ie 2 to 3 years ago), South Africa were not doing too badly with a backrow of Schalk Burger, Juan Smith and Pierre Spies. None of these are “traditional” fetchers. France are also doing quite well with Dusautoir, Ouedraogo and Harinordoquy/Picamoles combination as well.
In fact, a lot of the turnover ball has come from counter-rucking and blowing over the top of the ball rather than pilfering by a fetcher so a bigger but still mobile backrow could do so damage plus add ballast to the scrum and height to the lineout. The trick is finding players who are big and fast. Mowen seems to fit that role. I wouldn’t mind seeing 6 Dennis 7 Mowen 8 Palu.
sheek said | March 7th 2010 @ 2:13pm | Report comment
Brett,
This was the first Tahs game I saw. Tom Carter was another who I thought was out of his depth. On a few occasions, one running the ball out from his 22m & another coming poorly off his line in a switch move, didn’t seem to play with confidence.
Brett McKay said | March 7th 2010 @ 2:18pm | Report comment
Sheek, for someone who made their name as a crash-ball runner and hole-hitter, Carter’s inability to get through a massive hole created by Berrick Barnes highlights why he shouldn’t be playing 13. Barnes was on the money with his spray too, Carter could have driven several trucks through that gap last night..
mw said | March 7th 2010 @ 9:26pm | Report comment
Nobody has mentioned Tom Carter’s contribution to two tries last night in spite of his poor display.
Tom said | March 7th 2010 @ 5:02pm | Report comment
Agreed. He is just not Super rugby standard. Horne is younger and better.
sheek said | March 7th 2010 @ 7:02pm | Report comment
Yeah, but only when Horne learns to tackle…..
Rockin Rod said | March 7th 2010 @ 6:06pm | Report comment
If Waugh was to get injured Tahs would play Eastwood captain Hugh Perrett who has been part of extended squad.
Alcock now injured as is Coridas