Waratahs hang on for vital win over Sharks
By Darren Walton, 7 Mar 2010 Darren Walton is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- NSW Waratahs, Rugby Union, Sharks, Super Rugby
The NSW Waratahs held on for dear life to post a potentially season-saving 25-21 victory over the Sharks in Saturday night’s Super 14 clash at the Sydney Football Stadium.
Playing their first home match of 2010 after a draining fortnight in South Africa, the Waratahs spent most of the final quarter camped inside their own half starved of possession.
The Sharks argued they were unfairly denied a match-winning penalty try three minutes from fulltime when NSW replacement fullback Kurtley Beale was yellow-carded for desperately and deliberately knocking down a pass from his Sharks counterpart Stefan Terblanche.
NSW coach Chris Hickey felt Beale was attempting an intercept but, either way, had he not intervened and had Terblanche found his supporting winger, it would have been lights out for the Tahs.
Instead, the Waratahs opened their home campaign in winning, if unspectacular, fashion.
“Certainly there’s some things there that we’ll be working on during the week, but coming away with four points out of that game is really important for the season,” Hickey said.
“Sometimes you do have to grind out wins.”
After back-to-back defeats at the hands of Stormers and Bulls, another loss would have been disastrous for the lowly-positioned Waratahs, who now have a golden opportunity to climb the ladder with three of their next four games in Sydney and the other against the Western Force also in Australia.
The Waratahs had looked to be on their way to a comfortable win after resurgent halfback Luke Burgess put powerhouse hooker Tatafu Polota-Nau – the official man of the match – over under the sticks in the 52nd minute to give NSW a 11-point buffer.
But as the Tahs began to wilt, with Burgess and fellow Wallabies playmaker Berrick Barnes among the many second-half replacements, the Sharks refused to lie down, closing to within four points through a converted try to centre Adrian Jacobs and threatening to spoil the homecoming.
“I suppose it’s fortunate it’s an 80-minute game, not an 82 or 83-minute game,” Waratahs skipper Phil Waugh said. “The guys hung in there.”
In front of a healthy crowd of 20,651 fans at the SFS, NSW had ground their way to a 18-14 halftime lead over the ill-disciplined Sharks.
In an eventful opening stanza, the touring South Africans were briefly reduced to 13 men for a spell for downright unsporting conduct, but the Waratahs left it until late to grab their slender advantage at the interval.
Prop Jannie Du Plessis was the first Shark to receive a yellow card in the 20th minute for blatantly tripping Daniel Halangahu as the NSW five-eighth pursued his own kick down field.
Du Plessis could face suspension for his sinister act, especially given referee Paul Marks didn’t witness the trip and was guided by a linesman, meaning the Sharks may not be able to argue the matter was sufficiently dealt with at the time.
Three minutes later, Sharks fly-half and former England Test star Andy Goode was also sent to the sin bin for deliberately killing the ball in the ruck as the Waratahs attacked their line.
Incredibly, though, it was actually the undermanned Sharks who scored the only try during the pair’s absence with No.8 Ryan Kankowski racing 60 metres to cross in the 26th minute after intercepting from Burgess.
The five-pointer put the Sharks ahead 11-6 after Goode Barnes traded penalty and drop goals in the opening 17 minutes.
The Sharks extended their lead to 14-6 with a Ruan Pienaar penalty shortly after before the Waratahs finally nudged ahead with close-range tries to Halangahu and centre Tom Carter in the 32nd and 38th minutes.
© AAP 2012Recommend this story.
The Turkey 10
The Turkey 10 teams have now been selected, as Wild Turkey Bourbon's sport sponsorship kicks into the next exciting phase.
Choose which side you're going to support and get in the running to win $2,500!
Simply visit Wild Turkey Australia on Facebook for your chance to win.
Find out more.
- Explore:
- NSW Waratahs, Rugby Union, Sharks, Super Rugby


March 7th 2010 @ 11:33am
Ruckingisfun said | March 7th 2010 @ 11:33am | Report comment
I think you wll all change your tune when the Tahs hit the Finals – and finally deliver the Cup (at whatever price)
March 7th 2010 @ 12:03pm
Tom said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:03pm | Report comment
Yeah but if they struggle so hard against a team that was 0-3, what chance do they have against some proper opposition?
March 7th 2010 @ 12:26pm
Even looser said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:26pm | Report comment
“I think you wll all change your tune when the Tahs hit the Finals – and finally deliver the Cup (at whatever price)”.
Maybe so. I’d like to think it will happen in my life time though.
Meantime keep taking your medication.
March 7th 2010 @ 7:04pm
sheek said | March 7th 2010 @ 7:04pm | Report comment
This current Tahs mob won’t win any super rugby titles soon.
They don’t appear a united team, & carry too many players lacking the required qualities to win a title.
March 7th 2010 @ 2:37pm
katzilla said | March 7th 2010 @ 2:37pm | Report comment
Wow, that would be quite an embarrassing predicament. Having a mid table team deliver the cup to the final.
They’d be the laughing stock of Australian rugby……………………oh wait.
March 7th 2010 @ 11:58am
Working Class Rugger said | March 7th 2010 @ 11:58am | Report comment
Ruckingisfun
To make the finals they will need to accumulate bonus points. They had the opportunities last night but as they have so many times before bombed them. Carter has to be sat on the bench for Horne apart from his try everything else he did was rubbish. The Uni connection would be the only thing keeping there. No one had a good game. TPN was solid enough as was Palu but apart from that pretty average all around. Big improvements particularly at the restart are needed. I don’t see the Lions winning next week freom their performance in Canberra . However, its the weeks after that are a worry.
March 7th 2010 @ 12:03pm
Working Class Rugger said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:03pm | Report comment
On a positive note all three Australian teams that played won this weekend. Good weekend for Australian Rugby results wise.
March 7th 2010 @ 12:27pm
Even looser said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:27pm | Report comment
On an even more positive note.
Not one Australian team lost this weekend.
March 7th 2010 @ 12:37pm
OldManEmu said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:37pm | Report comment
Yes – I think that is the more accurate way of putting it Even. The Reds are starting to look pretty impressive aren’t they when compared to their more highly fancied brothers from the south? Surely it cant be the influence of the Link? But if not, what else has changed?
March 7th 2010 @ 4:37pm
Jimmy said | March 7th 2010 @ 4:37pm | Report comment
I wouldn’t get too excited WCR 5 NZ teams played last week and 5 NZ teams won, big turnaround this week
March 7th 2010 @ 4:59pm
Working Class Rugger said | March 7th 2010 @ 4:59pm | Report comment
Who said I was excited. Just thought I’d bring it up. It was either that or join in the already pretty accurate analysis of last nights game.
March 7th 2010 @ 5:17pm
Jimmy said | March 7th 2010 @ 5:17pm | Report comment
The only analysis I can gather here is that both teams played like rubbish, Even though the Tahs won it seems many still think they are pooh, last week they lost and many of these same people couldn’t praise them enough.
Damned if they win Damned if they Lose, Go figure.
The Reds can put their win down to the accurate kicking of Quade that kid is really special and for him to get one over his hometown heros has to be great for his confidence here on in. Lets get real here the Reds are about as consistent as mud. Their next game is a dead cert but then again didn’t we say this for the Auckland match but someone forgot to tell them.
The Brumbies struggled but they had just returned from SA so a few cobwebs can be excused here. The Brumbies are the best chance for Australian glory this year they have a fantastic lineup and it could and would be a fitting farewell for GS and possibly SM.
The Force are in a dire situtation and have a season of mitigation ahead. One win this year will be an achievement.
March 7th 2010 @ 12:10pm
OldManEmu said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:10pm | Report comment
A random collection of thoughts, nothing much original following what has gone before – heck maybe we are just all seeing it for what it is.
Tha Tahs are inept, the Sharks a little more so. Without the brilliant Kankowski and a great kicking and positional display from Terblanche the Tahs would have won convincingly – but it would have been wrist slitting stuff to watch all the same.
TPN received the MOM award and I would agree that if the hookers role was simply to monster everything in sight then yes, he was man of the match – BUT, his role includes also to hit his jumpers in the lineout and I counted five times when he did not do so. Presumably he has worked on this problem and there has been no noticeable improvement. So the answer is either to find someone else to throw or drop him. Nuff said.
Waugh has lost it. I shudder as I write that but I am afraid it is true. He has given enormous service to the Tahs but his skills are shot, he missed tackles, and the big part of his game – the pilfer and nuisance at the breakdown has disappeared with the new (and correct) application of the laws at the tackle. Piss him off right now because five weeks from now will be too late and next season will certainly be so. I would play Dennis at 7 and Mowen at 6 becasue like I say there simply is no call for a scavenger at the tackle any longer. And while the selectors are at itthey should get Tim Davidson’s phone number and get him into a Sky blue shirt.
The referee was deplorable. He quite simply missed things that occurred right in front of him and how Beale did not get carted for his deliberate knock down is beyond me. He permitted the Tahs to lie all over the ball in the second half, Mumm and Douglas in particular and he had no control over the scrum engagament. Sigh.
Halangahu was the best player on the field by a very significant margin. He outplayed Barnes noticeably although Barnes was not helped by having the absolute clunk Carter outside him. Fair dinkum, young man, it is called straightening up on the angle. And Carter dropped the ball cold three times under no pressure. He is shit house at this level.
Chris Hickey is surely on drugs if he tought that win was “ground out”. What on earth was up with the tactic of driving it up from lineouts in midfield? What did that achieve? Why did Burgess run sideways for five metres at almost every ruck. How did Carter survive his first twenty minutes? I want the truth; you cant handle the truth. No I probably cant.
I have tickets booked for the Panthers v Storm NRL game on 26 March 2010 with my young fellas and I cannot wait. Some of my mates think I am strange wanting to watch NRL but I simply cannot see the point of turning up like a lemming and having to watch the crap that was served up last night, from both teams, from the coaches, and from the referee.
Grrrr…………
March 7th 2010 @ 5:07pm
Tom said | March 7th 2010 @ 5:07pm | Report comment
Agreed on Barnes and Carter. Why is it no one in that backline knows how to run straight? Its a shame metres gained sideways don’t count because the Tahs would be leading the comp if they did.
And agreed on the NRL, looking forward to getting back on the hill at Brooky. The only saving grace of the Tahs at the SFS is that there are plenty of venues nearby to drink away the pain of sitting thru 80 mins of that rubbish.
March 7th 2010 @ 8:37pm
OldManEmu said | March 7th 2010 @ 8:37pm | Report comment
Amen to that Brother Tom – the Paddington pubs are about all the Tahs have going for them this season.
Myself and a group of fellas were going to travel down for the Brumbies Tahs game at that wellspring of hospitality ANZ Stadium, but we have decided that we would rather watch a decent game in a decent stadium for a decent price and with a decent RSA polcy i.e there is none, and so we have told our driver (Shane from Lewis Ponds) the plans are different and it is full steam ahead on 1 May 2010, leaving the jewel of the Central West at about noon, beef luch at the TownHouse Hotel Cowra, few stiffeners at the Koorawatha Hotel, quench the thirst at Boorawa, and by God if the six cartoons of New have not run out by the time we get to Hall, so we need to stop for new recruits. All stiffened up by an unending supply of chicken sandwiches made by Mrs Emu. Who cares what sort of game it is. Cannot wait.
And then back on the bus at game’s end (Shane will be there on his third packet of Champion Ruby for the day – you can get about 100 cigs to the packet) and it is homeward bound to our beds, kids, hangvers and loving brides and who gives a rats if the Reds or the Brumbies won becasue the main thing is we have not had to endure the heartbreak of a Tahs performance.
March 7th 2010 @ 12:15pm
Even looser said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:15pm | Report comment
One question after watching the game of the box. Why would Tah fans actually bother going out to watch the game live when there appears to be nothing to actually get you excited about?
Here’s what you know you will get:-
* lost ball on restarts
* a complete shift from running Rugby with ball in hand & good support play to booting the ball away
* uncontested lineouts as the norm
* one off running by the forwards
* no real home ground advantage with any fear factor (opposition teams love playing in front of polite Sydney crowds)
And the list goes on.
March 7th 2010 @ 12:29pm
Brett McKay said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:29pm | Report comment
Looser, that just highlights how much Adam Freier misses the point in his Sun Herald column today…
“…the one thing that should never been scrutinised is the character of one Waratah – Phil Waugh. I am sure if he had the energy at full-time he would pitch in his croaky, aged voice: ‘Are you not entertained? Are – you – not – entertained?’”
March 8th 2010 @ 4:34pm
Rug Rat said | March 8th 2010 @ 4:34pm | Report comment
Whats your point?
i thought it was pretty funny.
I am pretty sure he is taking the piss mate, he seems like that sort of bloke… Anyone who read the article would have seen that. Where did you watch the game saturday night ?
March 7th 2010 @ 12:31pm
Cattledog said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:31pm | Report comment
The old chest nut, deliberate knock on. When will the IRB and referee administrators wake up to themselves. If a player throws a pass late enough for it to be intercepted, touched, knocked down or in anyway handled, their bad! Second guessing whether a player attempted to intercept or he actually sets out to interfear with the ball with no thought of intercepting means the referee has to read minds.
As I’ve said in previous posts, a player could be a hero or villain, depending on whether he actually hangs onto the ball or knocks it forward in the attempt. If a player passes a ball so that an opponent can get any part of his hand on it, then he’s probably passed it a nono second too late. His problem, lets not reward him for his poor skills. And a penalty try, gimme a break!
Get rid of this ridiculous ruling.
March 7th 2010 @ 10:00pm
Tim said | March 7th 2010 @ 10:00pm | Report comment
Totally agree Cattledog.
March 8th 2010 @ 1:58am
mcxd said | March 8th 2010 @ 1:58am | Report comment
good point cattledog.. i was thinking how would i feel if that was the tahs in that position ie. last minute and a try needed to win the game yet a sharks player did the same as beale. i think id be peed off but mostly at the tahs ineptitude and strangely not that dissapointed with the sharks player. he did what he had to do. was it an intecept attempt or a cynical diruption of play ? how knows (other than beale) ? as you say i would put the issue down to a rubbish pass from a tahs player and deal with it.
March 8th 2010 @ 2:13am
Cattledog said | March 8th 2010 @ 2:13am | Report comment
Hello MC, you must be back in bonny Scotland with the hours your currently keeping! Back onto my old chest nut of deliberate knock downs. I’m sure the law will eventually be changed. It won’t happen overnight…but it will happen!
March 9th 2010 @ 5:49am
mcxd said | March 9th 2010 @ 5:49am | Report comment
yes mate im still up here in scotland freezing m’nads off (when will this bloody winter end ive really had enough of it now!).. im thinking that youre right.. this law wont be changed in a very long time. im sure theres a few more that need to be sorted asap at the same time !
i wont get the game this weekend dammit as its a friday night game and sky dont play the friday games so ill have to rely on the roar to keep me up to date with what really went on.. cheers for now, have a good one !
March 8th 2010 @ 7:10am
stillmissit said | March 8th 2010 @ 7:10am | Report comment
Agree to an extentl Cattledog, but it does have a place in the rules. I was told when I first started reffing in 1984 that if the player did slap at it with no attempt to catch it then it’s a deliberate knock on if not it ain’t. The rule stops players from NOT going for an intercept but trying to kill the movement.
If this rule is taken away it would change the game for the worse and was brought in, most probably, to stop the girls in the back line from avoiding tackles and slapping at it with their handbags.
March 7th 2010 @ 12:48pm
JK said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:48pm | Report comment
Not on topic, but can anyone confirm a rumour the Argies are in the Tri-Nations?
March 7th 2010 @ 1:12pm
rugbyfuture said | March 7th 2010 @ 1:12pm | Report comment
2012, they said there was gonna be an announcement next week.
March 7th 2010 @ 1:32pm
JK said | March 7th 2010 @ 1:32pm | Report comment
Thanks
March 7th 2010 @ 12:49pm
Ruckingisfun said | March 7th 2010 @ 12:49pm | Report comment
I am disappointed at the negativity in response to a hard fought win against a tough opponent
I admire the Tahs organisation for sticking to their guns and being very definite in their objectives of winning the competition
its a big improvement from 2008 when everybody in the organisation, the Board, CEO and Management were openly debating the future of the coach throughout the competition
Now they appear to have got their act together and are backing the coach 100% = it can only bode well for the team – Coaches and Players focusing on the sole objective – rather than fretting what was going to happen to them
looks like the powerbrokers are getting their act together
March 7th 2010 @ 1:02pm
OldManEmu said | March 7th 2010 @ 1:02pm | Report comment
I agree Rucking – the trio of L’Estrange, Medway and Zemanchef does seem to have drawn a line in the sand and are running the show in a professional way. But that is where you and I diverge.
Mate the Sharks are hapless.
The Tahs are for better or for worse in the entertainment business – and yes winners can write their own script, but that was not a “winning” performance last night. That was a “lets not lose” performance.
I am not a negative doomsayer of all things bad to do with Australian Rugby – at a national level the Wallabies punch well above their weight IMHO- but at S14 level the Tahs have become the perennial under achievers. Climate, sponsorship pool player pool, audience pool, facilities, culture and history, personel – it does not end as to why the Tahs should have made a name for themselves as THE powerhouse of Super Rugby – and the fact that they have not pisses a lot of NSW people right off – including me.
Rucking – I am all for being positive, but not at the risk of being delusional.
March 7th 2010 @ 7:07pm
sheek said | March 7th 2010 @ 7:07pm | Report comment
Old Man Emu,
Last sentence/paragraph hit the nail on the head!
Yep, let’s be positive, but not delusional.
March 7th 2010 @ 6:00pm
Red Rooster said | March 7th 2010 @ 6:00pm | Report comment
Rucking – I think you must be hiding under a rock – with all the rumours about Chieka getting the job it would be hard not to think that the powerbrokers aren’t stoking it particulalry as they cocked it up last time. What about the 3 year contract they gave Hickey to provide stability??? If he only does 2 years then it would suggest that the powerbrokers might not be good decision makers but I suspect the rugby public might already think this
March 7th 2010 @ 1:38pm
Johnson said | March 7th 2010 @ 1:38pm | Report comment
What are you talking about Rucking
Wern’t L’eastrange and Zenacheff the guys who sacked McKenzie the year he got them into the Finals because the team played boring Rugby? And then said there would be no excuses
Now they are backing the teams stance about winning is everything – even if its boring
I think you need to do some background checks before you make statements like that
We all want the team to win – but they must entertain as well
All the other teams do it – even those boring South Africans – why cant the Tah’s?
March 7th 2010 @ 2:11pm
johnny-boy said | March 7th 2010 @ 2:11pm | Report comment
It has become very important that Phil Waugh is not allowed anywhere near the Wallaby squad. It appears he has become a destructive, negative cancer in Australian rugby. A tumour that needs to be cut.