Gripping night at the SFS as the GF heads to familiar turf
By Tony Tannous, 8 Mar 2010 Tony Tannous is a Roar Expert
Related coverage
- Sydney FC news
- Melbourne Victory news
- Wellington Phoenix news
- Newcastle Jets news
- Football news
- A-League news
As an advertisement for the A-League and for finals football, you can hardly ask for a better five or six hours than we saw yesterday, with two games, across two countries, going the distance.
We got colour, crowds, cracking goals and class, in abundance.
After a wonderful Wellington crowd and some typical wizardry from Paul Ifill saw the Phoenix continue their imposing home record with an extra time win over the Jets, it was over to the second leg of the major semi final, and what a fantastic game those of us at the SFS were dished up.
While 98% of the almost 24,000 crowd left disappointed as Melbourne sealed grand final hosting rights for the third time in four seasons, it was hard not to have enjoyed this classic.
It was gripping throughout, as the play and the pendulum swung from one team to the other and back again.
Talk about a game living on a knife’s edge.
In the end Melbourne had the bigger guns to bring off the bench, able to draw upon the class of Archie Thompson and Marvin Angulo, and the legs of Evan Berger.
The introduction of Thompson and Berger, midway through the second period, and Angulo a short time later, swung the momentum back in Melbourne’s favour at a time when Sydney were threatening to run away with the game.
Credit then to Ernie Merrick for taking the gamble, and to the Melbourne Victory medical staff for even getting Thompson back on the pitch so soon.
Given the tie was locked at 3-3 on aggregate after Mark Bridge’s breathtaking piece of work on the edge of the box early in the second half, Merrick could have been forgiven for waiting to make his substitutions, but he correctly sensed something need to be done.
Sydney were all over his side, and the Victory looked to be struggling to make any impression in the front third as Robbie Kruse, who had an excellent first period, capped by an outstanding solo strike, became isolated in the early part of the second.
By introducing Thompson, suddenly Melbourne had fresh legs and a threat in the front third, and against a tiring Sydney side, they started asking questions again.
Fortunately for Sydney, Clint Bolton was in fine form.
While Sydney dominated the possession and territory in the first period by a staggering ratio of 67% to 33%, the Victory had looked a real threat on the counter attack.
Merrick’s game plan was obvious. Melbourne were happy to sit back, soak it up and look to hit Carols Hernandez as the first outlet. His job was to spin and hit Kruse, who was always looking to find space wide and beyond Sydney’s backline.
While Sydney dealt with most things, they backed off Kruse and gave him enough space to shoot in the 15th minute, and some strike it was.
Vitezslav Lavicka’s men had started the game very upbeat, with Stuart Musialik dictating the tempo and Alex Brosque and Mark Bridge looking to combine in the front third and cause headaches for Kevin Muscat, Adrian Leijer and Rody Vargas.
While Lavicka had pledged patience throughout the week, he started with a very offensive formation, with Bridge and Brosque joined by John Aloisi in a three pronged attack.
Meanwhile, Sebastian Ryall and Sung Hwan Byun were pressing forward on the flanks at every opportunity and pinning back Melbourne’s wing-backs, Surat Sukha and Leigh Broxham.
But Kruse’s wonder strike rocked the hosts, who had to now prove they could come from behind for only the second time this season.
It looked a tough ask, but they got down to work, and had a touch of luck when Strebre Delovski awarded them what looked a soft penalty.
From there Sydney got on top, and in front, and it was only the depth at Merrick’s disposal that shifted the momentum back to the visitors.
Even before extra time Sydney looked to be struggling, but in almost customary Lavicka style, he stuck with the status quo.
Clearly he didn’t have the cattle at his disposal that Merrick did, but surely his team could have done with the fresh legs of Chris Payne and Brendan Gan a lot earlier.
Brosque, especially, was limping around with what looked a tight hamstring, for some time.
Perhaps Lavicka was trying to nurse him to the penalty spot, and perhaps his defence was thinking about penalties when Thompson caught them out, getting on the end of a rapidly taken Muscat fee-kick to silence the SFS.
Needing two goals, Sydney had no time and no legs.
Now Melbourne go on to host yet another grand final, and given their imposing home form this season, and how crucial home form has been in the second half of this season, they are now clear favourites to lift the golden toilet seat for the third time.
Follow Tony on Twitter @TonyTannousTRBA
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- A-League, football, Melbourne Victory, Newcastle Jets, Sydney FC, Wellington Phoenix


agga78 said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:16am | Report comment
“While 98% of the almost 24,000 crowd left disappointed”
I would suggest it would of been more like 70% of the crowd left disappointed, as Melbourne had over 5000 at the game, But it was a fantastic adevertisement for A league football, great football, great atmosphere, all the things that make football great. With all the negative press football gets in this country, (unfairly) there are only positive things to write about the two matches yesterday, ibut there is the possibilty that Rebecca Wilson will write some negative story about the games and the A league.
Rob said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:33am | Report comment
Agga… No way melbourne had over 5000 people there, id guess about 750-1000….still a great showing from an interstate club who have been here twice now in a couple of weeks..must be getting pretty expensive. And they managed not to fight amongst themselves this week.
Congrats to MV…although Im still a little pissed that the ref missed 2 blatant handballs in the MV box yet managed to imagine one for the “winning” goal…..thats football I guess.
apaway said | March 8th 2010 @ 1:42pm | Report comment
Rebecca Wilson still writes? What a shame…
Al said | March 8th 2010 @ 1:56pm | Report comment
Rebecca Wilson CAN write?
Travers said | March 8th 2010 @ 6:27pm | Report comment
Rebecca Wilson aside I think that the press in Sydney is quite football friendly really.
You do need someone to provide some balance in reporting which some of the football reporters don’t but Rebecca Wilson does take it too far.
agga78 said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:16am | Report comment
“While 98% of the almost 24,000 crowd left disappointed”
I would suggest it would of been more like 70% of the crowd left disappointed, as Melbourne had over 5000 at the game, But it was a fantastic adevertisement for A league football, great football, great atmosphere, all the things that make football great. With all the negative press football gets in this country, (unfairly) there are only positive things to write about the two matches yesterday, but there is the possibilty that Rebecca Wilson will write some negative story about the games and the A league.
Australian Football said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:35am | Report comment
Rebecca Wilson, said on the ABC Offsiders programme that what irritates her about Australian Sokkah is that, the A-League does not produce any Socceroos. Hmm can someone please tell me who was the team who played the Indonesians on Wednesday night at Suncorp stadium Brisbane in the Asian qualifier? I thought they were OK.
I’d love to know who they were..
AndyRoo said | March 8th 2010 @ 9:33am | Report comment
Dario Vidosic, Mile Jedinek and Mark Milligan come to mind as young players who have played for the full strength Socceroos who had a stint in the A league.
It’s was also pretty helpful at getting Archie, Thompson, Dean Heffernen and Michael Beauchamp into 06 world cup contention as well as playing a big part in the careers of Galekovic and Carle.
Not bad as we haven’t even finished season 5.
Punter said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:43am | Report comment
While I don’t think there was 5K MV fans, I agree with most of your post. Totally disappointed, absolutely gutted, such an empty feeling, yet I can’t wait for next week’s game.
Unlike MV fans a couple of weeks ago, no complaints over result, great game by 2 huge combatants. One had to be the loser & it happen to me my team. I just feel sorry for the MV fans in 2 weeks to feel that empty feeling at home.
MV Dave said | March 8th 2010 @ 9:22am | Report comment
Punter and AF
AA said | March 8th 2010 @ 4:58pm | Report comment
Needs a Melbourne vs Sydney GF. Move it to the MCG too if this happens. Then we’ll see some real income to the FFA, if that’s what it’s all come down too.
Call yourselves football fans pfftttttttttttttttttt
Australian Football said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:08pm | Report comment
MVDave,
. SFC will be watching on Tuesday night. We hope you can at least keep your lads on side for this one.
Chelsea had a good win today—the treble is still lookin’ good and the Russian architects have been looking at new adjoining trophy room plans; one for John Terry alone
~~~~~
AF
jimbo said | March 8th 2010 @ 1:48pm | Report comment
Didn’t lose, it was a 2-2 draw.
Archie Thompson late goal – same as last time we drew 2-2 with them at SFS.
Punter said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:48am | Report comment
BTW, great article Tony, thought you capture the atmosphere quite brillantly.
Australian Football said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:51am | Report comment
“Clearly he didn’t have the cattle at his disposal that Merrick did, but surely his team could have done with the fresh legs of Chris Payne and Brendan Gan a lot earlier.”
Tony, I thought the same why Lavicka did not make the changes straight after the 90 minutes and put all 3 subs on at that time. Foxe looked like the old Foxe we use to know and his experience was starting to show in a clearly tied SFC. Lavicka blundered badly in not making the changes much earlier with Foxe, Gan and Payne. Now Brosque looks to me he will be missing for next week with a hamstring injury because of it.
~~~~
AF
AGO74 said | March 8th 2010 @ 9:46am | Report comment
Agree with you on Hayden Foxe and the holding back of using Sydney’s bench. Foxe played well when he came on and perhaps should have played from the start. Seb Ryall had an unhappy game. Kruse’s goal was a wonderful strike, but it came as a result of Ryall being caught with the ball and not playing safety first back to Keller.
Australian Football said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:11pm | Report comment
Hayden Foxe has signed for next season
Tadpohle said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:55am | Report comment
Really happy that I have Fox as I am unable to attend games.
Unfortunately I struggle with Commentators that describe Muscat as “Hard and physical “etc, all I see is a bloody cheat that exploits the system and the definition of fair play. I don’t see how hard and physical fits with the beautiful game. The fox commentator described the referee as economical with yellow cards, in other words, people like Muscat can exploit the edge of physical to the beautiful games detriment. A referee that is “economical” with yellow cards, is not calling the game impartially, a yellow card offense is a yellow card offense. In the second half he refrained from showing a yellow card that would have seen the player off for a sec card, That is the game rules, not the referee’s discretion.
MV Dave said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:57am | Report comment
Brilliant game with Arch coming on and making the difference. Well done to the travelling fans who made plenty of noise in supporting MV. When can l book my tickets for the GF?
Australian Football said | March 8th 2010 @ 9:07am | Report comment
MVdave,
no need you can use Mr Football’s old membership card—he has no use for it now or ever again..
~~~~~
AF
Stevo said | March 8th 2010 @ 9:02am | Report comment
Lavicka is far too cautious to be a top manager/coach. You have to have wit and guile on the field and as well as in the coaching staff. Basically SFC is a well organised, plodding kinda team with little cutting edge.
AndyRoo said | March 8th 2010 @ 9:38am | Report comment
They are missing an attacking midfielder, I can see why he wants Carle he would be a great addition.
Like everyone else though i don’t know why he didn’t put Payne on when Brosque first started pulling up hurt.
Realfootball said | March 8th 2010 @ 9:23am | Report comment
What is all this nonsense about a “soft” penalty. Leijer shoved Brosque off the ball in the penalty area. Is it a foul? Yes. No question. Is a foul against an opposing player in the penalty area a penalty? Yes. No question.
So where do you get off, Tony, suggesting it was soft? Surely it is either a foul or it isn’t. There are no shades of grey here. It was a penalty.
All commentators like you are doing are weakening the public perception of a very good referee – our best, in fact. Why don’t you focus on the incorrect offside calls from the Assistant, one of which clearly cost Melbourne a goal from Archie Thompson?
AGO74 said | March 8th 2010 @ 10:12am | Report comment
I agree completely on the penalty. He clearly shouldered him off the ball. Leijer was an idiot for doing so as Brosque was going nowhere running away from goal. Also agree that Delevski is the best ref in the comp but while he got the penalty decision right there were some he got wrong (for both teams). I hope he doesn’t get dropped as I still consider him comfortably the best ref.
Tony Tannous said | March 8th 2010 @ 9:56am | Report comment
Realfootball, Strebre Delovski is undoubtedly our best. I was the first to say as such last season, when other referees were getting the accolades and big games.
Having said that, I don’t feel he’s had as good a season this year as he did last year, and I don’t feel last night was necessarily one of his better games.
Not that the players, one either side, helped.
Muscat is always in the ref’s ear, whoever the ref, but last night he had a few helpers, with Vargas and Leijer particularly constant.
I have generally been loathe to criticise referees, feeling they need to be encouraged (the game needs them), but that decision, I felt, was soft. Brosque made the most of it, and it is hard to blame him given players on both sides were looking for every little advantage.
I thought Brosque did well to get his body in front of Leijer, and made of the most of light contact.
As for the assistant refs, that has been my bugbear all season, the amount of times they get offside calls wrong. I can’t say I had a particularly conclusive angle at the stadium, but there was one a touch earlier when Archie was flagged when he looked to be on side.
MartyB said | March 8th 2010 @ 11:32am | Report comment
Soft is debatable, but it is a penalty. I agree that looking at it live, it looked soft from where I was, but the replay clearly shows Leijer shove him in the back with no attempt to play the ball.
If you want soft, how about the handball that led to Melbourne’s second, eh? Or Pondeljak’s handball clearance off the line in the second minute?
Lavicka doesn’t have a lot of faith in his bench. That much is obvious. He was more ready to throw on Danning or Grant, when they were available, but it’s palpably obvious that there’s a big difference between the starting XI and the reserves for Sydney at the moment. Bringing on Archie at 60 minutes worked wonders for Melbourne, but Sydney has no game-changer on the bench.
Going to the bench is a good option if they’ll offer something, but change for change’s sake doesn’t always work the way you intend (I’m looking at you, Branko).
Stebre had a tough day at the office and got handled well by Muscat, as is his modus operandi. It was a difficult one to officiate and I thought he did well at least in mostly letting it flow while keeping it under control most of the time. There’s always going to be contentious decisions in a finals match.
Just want to add – well done to Melbourne for securing the draw that they needed. It was a great game to watch, even if i was gutted by the final result.
Realfootball said | March 8th 2010 @ 12:01pm | Report comment
Agree. Definite lack of depth on the Sydny bench. Lavicka is still struggling with the squad he inherited. Hopefully next season he can rebuild further. He hasn’t had a lot to work with this season. The best first 11 are good, but there’s no real quality beyond that. Gan, for instance, really isn’t up to standard, nor is Payne.
Al said | March 8th 2010 @ 10:11am | Report comment
It was one of the most enjoyable afternoons of sport in a long time.
Punter said | March 8th 2010 @ 11:28am | Report comment
I totally agree, despiter the empty feeling of losing. As a said 2 huge combatants.
Went to pub near SFS to watch Pheonix beat Newcastle then onto the SFS for live action, what a great afternoon/evening.
Al said | March 8th 2010 @ 2:05pm | Report comment
The only disappointment was the 23,000 odd crowd, surely the Sydney public can do better than that for a major semi-final.