
Reds Quade Cooper is tackled by Chiefs Brendon Leonard in a Super 14 Rugby match, Waikato Stadium, Hamilton, New Zealand, Friday, March 05, 2010. AAP Image/NZPA, Wayne Drought.
It’s Oscar time and The Roar’s Oscar for the pass of the rugby season is Quade Cooper’s no-look/pop-up pass to Will Chambers to put him under the Chiefs posts without a defender laying a hand on him.
The pass was pure magic. It was done so cleverly that one second Cooper had the ball in his hand running at the Chiefs defence, with Reds runners racing through with him, and the next second Chambers was dotting down. The Chiefs defenders didn’t know what had happened until they looked at the big screen.
I hesitate for obvious reasons to say that the episode was rather like a thief in the night unpicking a lock, taking the possession, and getting away before the inhabitants of the house even knew they were being robbed.
The pass confirmed for me that Quade Cooper is the Paganini of the Pass. He is able to get the ball away, with a sympathetic speed and loft for easy handling, in any situation.
The Chambers pass came with him taking the ball to the line (would that other Australian number 10s do the same!). On other occasions he floated long cut-out passes to put his wide men into space. And on other occasions he was able, magically, to get passes away even when he was severely dumped on his back by the unimpressed Chiefs forwards.
The new interpretations of the tackle law (which are, in fact, the old and correct interpretations), require tacklers to release the tackled player, even in ball and all tackles, before the tackler or his team-mates can play at the ball.
This fraction of a second is all Cooper needs when he is tackled to get away his passes.
Cooper, like Benji Marshall, has played a lot of touch football. This is a passing game, at speed. Cooper like Marshall has an amazing variety of passes he has learnt as a touch player, passes he can now release under the new intepretations. The Australian Women’s Seven side won the first IRB World Championship using touch footballers. Perhaps some Super 14 franchises should do the same thing.
The contrast between Cooper’s passing game and that of Berrick Barnes is startling. Barnes was good value under the old interpretations because he was tough enough to hold on in the tackle and place the ball back. Cooper was easily wrapped up ball and all.
Under the new intepretations, which put a premium on holding on to the ball and passing not kicking (Waratahs please note!), Cooper has sparked the Reds (even the seriously under-strength side that played the Chiefs) to two convincing victories against two strong New Zealand sides, the Crusaders and the Chiefs.
Against the Sharks, Barnes resorted to unintelligent kicking, along with Luke Burgess (an Oscar winner for the best imitation of a still life), Daniel Halangahu, Lachlan Turner and Drew Mitchell that drew boos from the normally partisan crowd at the Sydney Football Stadium.
I usually try to stay silent watching games and take notes (as befits someone who is supposed to be an impartial analyst) but I couldn’t help myself on Saturday night yelling out, time after time, as the Waratahs put in brain-dead kicks: ‘No. Noooooo. Don’t kick it!’
My guess is that if a Wallabies side were selected right now that Cooper would be the starting number 10, with Matt Giteau (who is still to show real sharpness) at inside centre. This leaves Barnes – correctly – on the outer, until he gets his running and passing game going.
Of course, Cooper is being fed by Will Genia who looks like being the next long-term Wallaby halfback. In fact, I reckon by the end of his career, depending on injuries and so on, that Genia will be bracketed in the company of Des Connor, Ken Catchpole and John Hipwell as Australia’s greatest halfbacks.
Genia’s long, sweeping one-motion pass from the ground, his decisiveness in running and his defensive game, the way he rounds up kicks and makes hard-shouldered tackles, should be a lesson to Luke Burgess, who is everything Genia isn’t.
Now the Reds have to learn to string wins together. They haven’t won back-to-back wins for several years. On Sunday they play the Western Force at Brisbane. Surely they will defeat a side that is a one-man band on attack, with that man, James O’Connor still being a teenager.
The ACT Brumbies did what they had to do to beat a valiant but limited Lions side. But they are, along with the Western Force, the only side in the tournament yet to score a bonus point.
The Bulls (with a game in hand) are leading the tournament with three wins and three bonus points. The Chiefs, the Hurricanes, and the Crusaders have, like the Brumbies, won three games. But, unlike the Brumbies, all these teams have recorded two bonus points each.
Why the Brumbies can’t achieve bonus points suggests a lack of direction, in the Cooper manner, in the backline. I would point the finger, too, at Josh Valentine who seems to have succumbed to an attack of the Burgesses, the symptoms of which are a tendency to stand over the ball at rucks, even when it is out, as if it were a time bomb that is going to explode if anyone touches it.
The other general point that emerged from the round, is that now we are into it’s fifth round the hard travelling is beginning to wreck a harsh toll on teams going to and coming back from South Africa.
The Chiefs, for instance, started brilliantly against the Reds with three tries in the first 20 minutes, and then their legs went and they couldn’t summon up the energy to stop the Reds comeback. The Chiefs, too, are rightly furious that they played on a Friday night rather than a Saturday or a Sunday (as the Reds are next week).
The Waratahs also started brightly before hitting the energy (or lack of energy) wall. Hopefully they should be able to emulate the first 40 minutes or so of their play against the Bulls against a Lions side that is all heart and little skill.
The Hurricanes who played in Wellington two weekends ago against the Lions also started well against the Cheetahs before their energy levels dropped. They were also playing at altitude which intensified the agony of the exhaustion they suffered.
We’ll get a better idea of how valid this theory is, though, when the Hurricanes play the impressive Stormers at Cape Town. They will be acclimatised. If they have any pretensions to being a finals side they should come away with a victory. That’s a big ‘if,’ of course.
But after a series of results that decimated my tips on The Roar, I am searching for a theory, any theory, that can explain why I got most of the winners wrong in the last round.
I’m backing the Reds and Quade Cooper next week. Surely it’s time the back-to-back winning hoodoo is broken by the Reds?
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- Quade Cooper, Queensland Reds, Rugby Union, Super Rugby, waikato chiefs, Will Chambers

warrenexpatinnz said | March 8th 2010 @ 3:47am | Report comment
I agree with you Spiro, Genia is a breath of fresh air, leads by example, reads the game so well and is as tough as teak, oh and being articulate is another feather in his cap.
The Tahs and Brumbies are rusty with that possibly being more to do with combinations and possibly some ego sorting. The Force will have a poor year, no team except maybe the Crusaders could have that sort of injury run and still get up yet to their credit they haven’t done up ‘Wallaby Wellington’.
But I guess the focus for most Aussie fans, regardless of supporter boundaries is that the Reds are playing a style of Rugby we all appreciate with the hardness of the forwards (even without Horwill!) and the speed and skill of the backs combinig so well you could be forgiven that this is a Reds side from the Mid nineties and earlier.
Enjoying my rugby so far and although it was a scratchy kick fest between the Tahs and the Sharks I guess you could forgive them as both sides needed a win and for the Tahs it was at all costs.
Who Needs Melon said | March 8th 2010 @ 5:30am | Report comment
Mmm… Paganini.
More than anything else the Reds seem to be REALLY enjoying their rugby. You just know they would be very stiff and sore but can’t wait for the weekend to come around again so they can show their wares. Evidence was Van Humphries little post match speech – he can’t wait to rip into them!
In contrast I’d reckon the Tahs are dreading their next game – there’s enormous pressure on each player individually to hold on to Wallaby spots or spots in the Tahs team, pressure to win and pressure to play attractive rugby as well as win while at the same time appealing to their coach and captain.
Benny said | March 8th 2010 @ 5:42am | Report comment
Can’t believe you rate Genia’s tackling…misses a tonne of tackles
Rob said | March 8th 2010 @ 7:02am | Report comment
I only saw 5 mins of the NSW game but what I saw made me question why NSW seems to have such slow delivery from the breakdown. I think the changes in interpretation allow quick ball. Either NSW don’t know what is expected to happen when play gets to a breakdown or the players are too slow into position.
In relation to Spiro’s piece about Cooper’s passing everyone today wants to throw a long spiral pass. There is a misconception that the idea of using the ball wide means that you have to pass the ball wide.Given the changes in breakdown interpretation, from set pieces the first point of contact should be No 12. A long wide pass from 9 to 10 who is standing a bit wider and flatter than currently with a closer and flatter 12 and 13.
9 to 10 should be the only spiral pass with all others being softer and closer. This would straighten the attack and draw the defence in closer. It then creates space out wide. And on a similar point I can’t see the logic as to why a winger for example receives an opposition kick and then throws a long spiral pass to a player infield who more often than not is in a worse position. While it may be taking the point of play away from the opposition it is also taking it away from your own support so that the only option is for the infield receiver to kick the ball downfield.
NickF said | March 9th 2010 @ 12:20pm | Report comment
Rob, just to add to that, with 10 giving a sympathetic pass to 12 then 13, each player has a responsibility to draw a defender to take that defender out of the play and if possible loop and support the outside players with the ball. Simple in theory, rarely played properly.
Hobart Friz said | March 8th 2010 @ 7:31am | Report comment
SPIRO – Do you think you could have a word with Quade about his entrechat-dix? It fools nobody and he loses precious time while he’s up there in the air. A half-goose al la Sivi would serve him much better. And did the Paganini reference occur to you because he’s wearing red? And are you a little down on Gits because his name is so close to one associated with Jim Garfield? I grant you these aren’t easy questions.
A possible new look Wallabies’ back line is starting to sound exciting – Genia and Cooper, Giteau and Ioane in the midfield, then a mix ‘em, match ‘em at 15, 11 and 14 like AAC and Hynes and maybe speedsters Morahan and Davies. The Reds start looking good and suddenly our RWC chances pick up.
Face the Facts said | March 8th 2010 @ 11:47am | Report comment
As in Charlie Giteau? you been listening to to much Johnny Cash Friz
jools-usa said | March 8th 2010 @ 7:31am | Report comment
Spiro,
Another Pagagnini pass was from Campese to Horan (blindly over his right shoulder) against NZ in semi of ’93 RWC when Wallabies went on to win final against England.
Afterwards, in typical Campese fashion, he said ‘Oh I knew he was there….was his turn to score!”
How sweet that was.
Have nothing to play my rapidly fading VCR tape on,so dates may be wrong.
Jools-USA
Harry said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:27am | Report comment
It was the semi of 91 Jools, in Dublin. Must have seen that a 1,000 times on various videos and tapes.
As for Quade, he is looking the goods at the moment. Spiro had it right in that he was the only 10 in Aus actually threatening the line on the weekend. Makes all the difference.
Amanda said | March 9th 2010 @ 11:06pm | Report comment
Is anyone else keen to see Toomua get some time at 10 for the Brumbies? That’s a confident young man who can threaten the line and pass beautifully. Good combo with Lealiifano, too.
Spiro’s comments about Valentine are spot on. He loses his cool, too, which is no good in a decision-making position, and it really told in the Bulls match.
johnny-boy said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:11am | Report comment
I’m with others who think Cooper is still a bit ‘fragile’ for such a responsible position in internationals Time will tell . I’d rather have Barnes at 10 although his time at the Tahs will do him no favours. Great career move Barnesie ! Bet your’e spewing now playing such crap when you could have been having so much fun playing for the Reds. What goes around comes around bro. I’m not sure we need you anymore anyway. The SBW of union. You’ll be lucky to get a spot next year. C’mon Reds dig in hard on Sunday, the Force will be gunning so don’t take your foot off now. Onwards and upwards !
Lee said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:46am | Report comment
The SBW of Union? That’s pretty rough.
Given the player movement in Aussie Super 14 teams – there are a lot of SBW in Australian union.
formeropenside said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:52am | Report comment
Not the way Barnes did it, talking like he was about to re-sign and then dropping a bombshell on moving to the Tahs. Apparently the Rebels are no longer interested since he only wants a one-year deal for some reason, so I guess he will be stuck at the Tahs for a while yet.
reds fan said | March 8th 2010 @ 9:04am | Report comment
I reckon he’s off to Europe after the RWC. He’ll do another year at the Tahs or one at the Rebels.
Banger said | March 8th 2010 @ 4:42pm | Report comment
Surely no coincidence, that he only signed for NSW after Tuquiri had been sacked and all of that third party money became available
Howi said | March 8th 2010 @ 2:20pm | Report comment
I was gutted last year when Barnes defected from the Reds. Friday night some of that pain healed well and truly. Maybe his departure steeled the Reds somewhat? Even though I wondered what must have been going through his head on the weekend as the reds completed a beautiful victory and the Tahs battered their way through and pretty ugly game, I couldn’t help think that blue was more his colour. I do know that he’d never look the same in Red ever again.
sheek said | March 8th 2010 @ 5:47pm | Report comment
Howl,
Wonderful article in today’s Australian by Wayne Smith how things can unexpectedly turn for the better (or worse) but in this case for the better as far as Queensland was concerned.
Barnes’ defection to NSW set off an extraordinary chain of events, virtually all unexpected, that sees the Reds playing wonderful rugby this year. Worth reading the article…..
Pete said | March 8th 2010 @ 3:50pm | Report comment
Barnes leaving was the tonic QLD Rugby needed. His leaving brought the demise of the administrators that have been shuffling deck chairs in QLD rugby. The new administration have looked at what has transpired over the last 10-15 years and are trying to rectify it by going to the ARU for help.
Barnes made an apparent turn around because he was promised the earth and told everything is fine. After some shrewd advice he didn’t buy it and left. Judge that action as you will, but ironically his departure has potentially saved Qld Rugby.
eric said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:20am | Report comment
Jools, every four years. Make that ’91.
Spiro, I think it is drawing a long bow to credit the new law interpretations with Cooper’s passing skills. He always had a great passing game, but the passor and passees all need confidence to make it work.
The performances of Qld & NSW make for interesting reflections about coaches and team cultures. I always blamed McKenzie for NSW’s ugly underperforming rugby in recent years, but I am now seriously wondering if Phil Waugh has a bad influence on the team. If so, NSWRU should get rid of him, because it must be costing a fortune in lost fans and attendances,
On the other hand, McKenzie has added to Phil Mooney’s groundwork. Well done.
bennalong said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:39am | Report comment
The idea of the trip to and from Africa taking a harsh toll is hardly a theory Spiro. It’s fact.
The home and away stats show you bet on the home team, but really it’s all about that huge hop. Jet lag is worse than the high veldt and for us can affect the home game on return.
The Reds have yet to travel to Africa
max power said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:41am | Report comment
Spiro I completely agree with your sentiments about touch players. I have thought the same thing for a while. As a case in point, the Kennedy twins for Warringah dominated the recent Kiama 7′s and are two of the best touch players in Australia. Darren Lockyer was another to play a lot of touch as junior. As far as I know no league or union sides have an affiliation with Touch Football Australia so it could be very worth while investment for the ARU. I remember reading an article a couple of years ago about the South African 7′s coach recruiting a couple Australian touch players to help with skills training.
Anyway here’s a couple of links to youtube clips of the Kennedy twins.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=canVh8mG5h0 They’re numbers 3 and 4 in this one.
and
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FMT4vFlH17c&feature=related they’re numbers 1 and 2 in this.
Hoy said | March 8th 2010 @ 8:59am | Report comment
At the risk of being a knit-picker, whilst that footage is impressive, I am sure a lot of the passes in it were forward.
Plus, all the “tries” could have been pulled up and we wouldn’t know it anyway, as the footage finishes up with the “try”.
But it looks good if nothing else.
max power said | March 8th 2010 @ 1:37pm | Report comment
Hahaha yes there are a lot of forward passes in it. I put it up to highlight the skills of touch players which I’m hoping the videos achieved.