Four of Australia’s new breed make their mark
By Brett McKay, 16 Mar 2010 Brett McKay is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Reds, Rugby Union, Super Rugby, Waratahs
One of the more common criticisms of the state of Australian rugby is that there’s no depth, or even that there’s not enough quality to cater for four Super rugby teams, let alone one more with the arrival of the Melbourne Rebels in 2011.
These criticisms place Australian rugby in the classic catch-22; without the four (and soon to be five) professional teams, places are very limited and the chance for young players to impress is often brief, and almost always cut-throat.
Either way, the talent argument or how much of it there is or isn’t, is actually for another day. Looking around the Super 14 this year has seen some pretty handy young players making their mark already, and I’ve picked out four to focus on this week.
NSW Waratahs flanker and lock Dave Dennis is one player who has already got plenty of wraps from the actual and armchair experts, which should come as no surprise after Robbie Deans took him to Europe at the end of 2009 after a starring season captaining Sydney University’s premiership side.
The 24-year-old didn’t take long to establish his place for the Tahs this season, and his strong form on their South African tour was enough to consign long-standing lock Will Caldwell to the bench after the return of Dean Mumm from suspension.
Moving back to blindside flanker has been a godsend for Dennis though, and his performance in Friday night’s rout of the Lions particularly, was pretty hard to ignore.
In the first half on Friday night, Dennis’s large frame was a constant presence in the tackle and ruck areas, but it was in the second half as the game opened up where Dennis really came into his own.
Suddenly he was making line breaks and offloads seemingly at will, and proved to be a headache for the already-aching Lions defence in centre field. If there were repeat phases to be had, Dennis was in them up to his ears, and he was a crucial link between forwards and backs in attack.
I don’t want to go making rash statements (for a change), but I can see a lot of Wallaby captain Rocky Elsom in Dave Dennis currently. It wouldn’t surprise me one bit to see him in a Wallaby jumper before the year is done.
ACT Brumbies playmaker Christian Lealiifano was tipped by plenty – me included – to be the main loser with the return to Canberra of prodigal son Matt Giteau.
After young flyhalf Matt Toomua finished the 2009 season in strong form, and found himself as a late call-up on the Wallabies’ Spring Tour, the thought was that Lealiifano would spend most of 2010 on the bench, and that the Melbourne-raised midfielder would become an inevitable signing for the Rebels.
He may well end up returning home in 2011 yet, but if he does it won’t be because he’s unwanted in Canberra.
Lealiifano has instead benefitted massively from Giteau’s return, and has slotted into the inside centre position almost seamlessly. What’s more, because Giteau is under pressure to deliver a title and walk on water at the same time, Lealiifano has been able to ply his creative trade at No.12 with little or no pressure at all.
More often than not, Lealiifano is calling the plays for his outside men, rather than Giteau, and it would appear that the Brumbies are pinning their attacking game around Lealiifano in that New Zealand-style second five-eighths position.
Queensland Reds inside centre Anthony Faingaa was something of a surprise naming in the Reds’ No.12 at the start of this season, but since then, he’s repaid new Queensland coach Ewan McKenzie’s faith in spades.
While the likes of Quade Cooper, Will Genia, and even rookie speedster Luke Morahan are getting the rave reviews in the Reds’ cracking season start, Faingaa has been a constant performer among these names, even if he hasn’t been as widely noticed.
His defence has always been a strong point, and this has certainly continued to be the case in 2010, though admittedly, anyone defending in the line next to Quade Cooper is going to look fairly solid.
But he’s also a straight, hard running centre, not unlike NSW’s Tom Carter, and Faingaa’s ability to hit holes really shone in the Reds’ 50-10 demolition of the Western Force in Brisbane on Sunday, where he scored his first and then second try for the Reds since moving north from Canberra at the end of 2008.
While his talent was always evident, it seems he’s finally benefitting for the same thing every young player craves: opportunity. On current form, there should be plenty more of it coming his way.
Western Force flanker Ben McCalman first caught my eye a few weeks back, when I forced myself to ignore a lifetime’s worth of backline instinct and watch forwards for a weekend (yes, it was painful, and no, I’m not quite back to normal).
Having made his Super rugby debut from the bench in round 1, McCalman was elevated to the starting line-up following the long-term injuries to Wallaby backrowers Richard Brown and The Roar’s own David Pocock, and has just gone from strength to strength since, albeit in some fairly well-beaten Force teams this year.
While there’s been seemingly weekly shuffling of the troops in the Force pack of late, McCalman has been a fixture in the No.6 jumper, and his work in combination with openside flanker Matt Hodgson has been a rare highlight so far in a season the Force desperately needs to get back on track.
Like his Sydney Uni team-mate Dave Dennis, who then went to Europe last Spring, McCalman was brought into the Wallabies pre-tour training squad having grabbed the attention of Robbie Deans while playing strongly in last year’s Shute Shield finals.
His ability to cover lock and backrow can only be a good thing for his future selection hopes, and it’s not difficult to picture him in Australian colours in the coming years.
Recommend this story.
Follow Brett McKay on Twitter: @BMcSport
The Turkey 10
The Turkey 10 teams have now been selected, as Wild Turkey Bourbon's sport sponsorship kicks into the next exciting phase.
Choose which side you're going to support and get in the running to win $2,500!
Simply visit Wild Turkey Australia on Facebook for your chance to win.
Find out more.
- Explore:
- Reds, Rugby Union, Super Rugby, Waratahs



March 16th 2010 @ 10:28am
Jameswm said | March 16th 2010 @ 10:28am | Report comment
Geez Bruce it’s like you’re some sort of Carter White Knight, seeking out those that dare to criticise him and defending him against all attackers.
March 16th 2010 @ 11:12am
Nick P said | March 16th 2010 @ 11:12am | Report comment
From what I gather Bruce is an avid Syd Uni man. Carter, along with Halangahu, are Uni’s favourite sons.
It;s simply his natural paternal instinct.
March 16th 2010 @ 12:01pm
JF said | March 16th 2010 @ 12:01pm | Report comment
Speaking of Uni, I am surprised that no one has mentioned the result of the Australian Club Championship over the weekend Brothers 36 d University 26, not a huge brothers fan but good to see the queenslanders get up.
http://www.qru.com.au/library/news/2010/100313_brothers_beat_sydney_uni,71235.html/section/62400
March 16th 2010 @ 12:08pm
reds fan said | March 16th 2010 @ 12:08pm | Report comment
two years running now. seems sydney shute shield isn’t quite the quasi “third tier” some have suggested on this site.
March 16th 2010 @ 12:41pm
Nick P said | March 16th 2010 @ 12:41pm | Report comment
I’ve probably only been to Qld and NSW 2 or 3 times each in my life so I’m unbiased.
Uni has alot (read:ALOT!) more players current stitched up in academies across the country. They were fielding a team that was a mesh of 2nd and 1st Colts players. Yes yes, there were a couple of firsts in there, but not many.
It wasn’t really a fair fight. That doesn’t mean it wasn’t a great thing for Qld rugby but still, they did have a slight advantage.
March 16th 2010 @ 1:09pm
reds fan said | March 16th 2010 @ 1:09pm | Report comment
it was Brothers first game of the season. no trials prior. just training. and certainly not with their first xv. it was pretty even on that score.
March 16th 2010 @ 2:48pm
Bruce Ross said | March 16th 2010 @ 2:48pm | Report comment
I don’t think you can take anything away from Brothers or from Brisbane Easts last year for that matter. Each of the three clubs put their best sides available at the time on the paddock and Sydney Uni got touched up both times. No argument, no excuses. Congratulations to the Queenslanders.
March 16th 2010 @ 2:52pm
Big Steve said | March 16th 2010 @ 2:52pm | Report comment
be nice to play this game at the end of the season to actually make it a match between the 2 teams who won last year and not two completely different teams wearing the same coloured jerseys.
March 16th 2010 @ 3:13pm
reds fan said | March 16th 2010 @ 3:13pm | Report comment
true. it reminds me of the League world club challenge in that respect.
And I know many on here pray for a district/regional approach to a third tier, but i still think the big sydney and bris clubs would provide the best foundation for a third tier.
March 16th 2010 @ 10:49am
reds fan said | March 16th 2010 @ 10:49am | Report comment
Talking about bright young things. Dan Palmer has signed with the ponies for 2 years.
March 16th 2010 @ 11:03am
formeropenside said | March 16th 2010 @ 11:03am | Report comment
So he’s going from being behind former Wallaby THP prop Baxter, current Wallaby Kepu (both sides) and Benn Robinson, Wallaby LHP to being behind current Wallaby THP Alexander, and the THPs preferred to Alexander by the Brumbies in Shepherdson and Ma’afu.
And yet the Rebels are trying to get Weeks to move south. Something does not add up here.
March 16th 2010 @ 11:06am
JK said | March 16th 2010 @ 11:06am | Report comment
Yep, from one warehouse to another, go figure!
March 16th 2010 @ 11:16am
Nick P said | March 16th 2010 @ 11:16am | Report comment
Comfirmed? Maybe the Brumbies know something we don’t?
He doesn’t seem like an idiot, and even if he is, his manager wouldn’t be. Plus, I read somewhere Dan has been playing some LH so it will be alright..
March 16th 2010 @ 11:37am
Brett McKay said | March 16th 2010 @ 11:37am | Report comment
Reds, this is an interesting move, because it now places the burden of decision squarely on the shoulders of Guy Shepherdson, who has been mooted as a Rebels target. Now if Palmer’s motive was to push for game time, wouldn’t he have been better off going straight to Melbourne, rather than now facing the prospect of backing up Alexander and Ma’afu??
As FOS says, this seems like a curious move for Palmer, and even a curious signing for the Brumbies…
March 16th 2010 @ 11:41am
reds fan said | March 16th 2010 @ 11:41am | Report comment
yeah. I suspect that either one of the Ponies props are Melb bound. Or he’s been told he’ll probably be part of the match day 22 before Ma’afu.
March 16th 2010 @ 12:42pm
Nick P said | March 16th 2010 @ 12:42pm | Report comment
Ma’afu starts over Shep in more games than not. It would be the other way around.
March 16th 2010 @ 1:06pm
reds fan said | March 16th 2010 @ 1:06pm | Report comment
oh right… thanks for that.
March 16th 2010 @ 11:19pm
jeznez said | March 16th 2010 @ 11:19pm | Report comment
Palmer has started ahead of Shepherdson for Southern Districts – so he only has to back himself over Maafu to think he’ll get game time for the Brumbies. You’d have to think that a Brumbie front rower might be on the move south though.
I think this is shocking miss by the Tahs, Baxter might be in some of the best form of his career but I don’t think he is scrummaging as well as Palmer did in his Super 14 games last year. Kepu is failing to convince me as well, his body shape looks wrong. His legs look too long compared to a shorter torso than you would prefer in a prop, also he seems to be suffering from being another prop who packs with his legs too far back.
I’d been looking forward to Palmer starting for the Tahs since Baxter got dropped from the Wallabies last year, now he is down the road to a rival outfit – gut wrenching!
March 17th 2010 @ 8:34am
Brett McKay said | March 17th 2010 @ 8:34am | Report comment
Reds, I was speaking to a mate about this yesterday, and to our best knowledge, both Shepherdson and Alexander only just re-signed for a couple of years at the start of THIS season, but we’re not sure about Ma’afu’s situation…
March 16th 2010 @ 10:51am
mudskipper said | March 16th 2010 @ 10:51am | Report comment
Faingaa looks like his going to break the line each time and Tom Carter doesn’t… Faingaa played some 12 at the Brumbies but was unfortunately hit by a series of injuries… I’m looking forward to more of his work this season… jeez he smashed James O’Connor a few times on the weekend…
March 16th 2010 @ 10:54am
Grimmace said | March 16th 2010 @ 10:54am | Report comment
Good on him, they recon he’s one of the better scrummagers getting around.
March 16th 2010 @ 11:45am
johnny-boy said | March 16th 2010 @ 11:45am | Report comment
I’m picking Higginbotham to blossom in to something awesome, maybe. He is one big solid unit and mobile. Took some great kickoff takes last Sunday. Not sure he has the concentration and composure to fulfil his potential but if he has or can develop them, he will push Elsom all the way, and beyond. There is some fair dinkum quality competition developing for Wallaby places are there not ? Maybe Deans isn’t as dumb as his 1st five selections makes him look.
March 16th 2010 @ 11:50am
Gary said | March 16th 2010 @ 11:50am | Report comment
Great post. There is plenty of talent out there in clubs in Sydney, Brisbane AND Perth. It’s up to the Super 14 sides to get out there and discover them. It’s not rocket science. Go to any club and ask the coaches who deserves a Super 14 start and you’l quickly have a short list.
March 16th 2010 @ 1:21pm
Nick P said | March 16th 2010 @ 1:21pm | Report comment
Melbourne and Canberra have competitions equal to Perth I’d say. You wouldn’t be able to squeeze more than 3 or 4 S14 standard players out of each of them, but they are there.
March 16th 2010 @ 12:17pm
AR said | March 16th 2010 @ 12:17pm | Report comment
I now understand why Bruce Ross is so partial to Sydney University players.
His profile says it all:
“President of Sydney Uni Sport & Fitness”.
March 16th 2010 @ 8:58pm
Loyal Tah Supporter said | March 16th 2010 @ 8:58pm | Report comment
I suspect why “AR” is so upset by Bruce Ross showing a logical and sometimes different point of view is because he is worried that Bruce’s positive and insightful ideas might rub off on him. Heaven forbid Bruce show loyalty to the game and some of its players. It is afterall easier to be negative and focus on the personal, rather than the game. “AR” if you’ve had a bad day, ask yourself am I going to predictably tear others down or surprise people by being less ordinary.
For the record, it is great to see these new young guns have a good run- brilliant rugby on friday night, just brilliant
March 17th 2010 @ 12:16pm
AR said | March 17th 2010 @ 12:16pm | Report comment
It was more of an observation on my part than anything else ‘Loyal Tah Supporter’, and the bias towards a Sydney Uni player like Tom Carter. He may be a great guy off the field but on it well he’s just keeping the position warm for when Rob Horne returns – a non one dimensional player with speed, finesse, and strong fend that Carter seems to lack. I will give credit where credit is due and if there are any players out there that are not firing (Force minus Hodgson) then they will get it too.
http://www.greenandgoldrugby.com/video-alternative-round-5-highlights/
For the record, the Tahs played well in patches. Putting on a massive score does not mean it is brilliant rugby. Brilliant rugby is the way the Bulls have been going about this business and to a lesser extent the Reds. I’m still not convinced the Tahs have their best backline on the field but when they do – look out.
March 16th 2010 @ 12:27pm
Brett McKay said | March 16th 2010 @ 12:27pm | Report comment
interesting quote in Wayne Smith’s piece in The Oz today, about Anthony Faingaa’s defence:
Certainly, it hasn’t harmed Faingaa that he is playing outside arguably the best halves combination in the Super 14, Genia and Cooper, but he also is establishing himself as the “jackal’ of the Reds side, responsible for more defensive turnovers, according to Reds defence coach Matt Taylor, than any other player in the team.
“It’s like having another openside flanker,” Taylor said.
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/sport/reds-stir-wallabies-pot/story-e6frg7mf-1225841110981
March 16th 2010 @ 12:33pm
formeropenside said | March 16th 2010 @ 12:33pm | Report comment
Mostly those turnovers are jolting tackles rather than a steal from a ruck, and it is using this quick ball that has led to a number of Reds tries – certainly against the Crusaders, and even the Morahan try v the Chiefs (although I cant recall if Faingaa’s was the hit in that case).
March 16th 2010 @ 1:36pm
Bay35Pablo said | March 16th 2010 @ 1:36pm | Report comment
Thee resurgence of the Reds with much the same line up under McKenzie, and the Brumbies likewise recovering some of their mojo under Friend (although not enough most would say – yet) puts the focus on the importance of the coach.
Many have been critical of the tahs coaching, and queried what they might do with a different coach.
Mitchell seems to have been very quiet, and the Force seem to be plateuaing, although much must be put down to dpeth and injuries.
However, depth is as much about what you do with it as whether you have it. Remember Bob Dwyer picked Kearns from Randwick 2nd grade over the then 1st grade hooker – one Eddie Jones.
You could have a virtual line up of super stars, but if the coach isn’t up to it, they aren’t going to perform as well.
One of the biggest issues for Australia, both Super and international level, over the last few years has been our coaches.
In some ways, many of the best Australian coaches are overseas, or learning their trade there rather than here.
March 16th 2010 @ 4:07pm
OldManEmu said | March 16th 2010 @ 4:07pm | Report comment
I would argue that there are going to be a few “veterans” if I can use that term who are going to play a big role for the Wallabies this season.
Van Humphries has been in great form and played all over Nathan Sharpe at the weekend. I see him being first choice starting lock the Wallabies come June.
Daniel Halangahu is far from a veteran but has been on the Sydney club scene for five years and thereabouts for the Tahs for three seasons now. He is rock solid. The stellar, dare I say, flashy form of Cooper has everyone going wow, but I would rather Halangahu at 10, Cooper at 12. Berrick Barnes…………need to lift your game mate. Halangahu for Number 10.
Mortlock has been written off in all quarters but the big fella has a massive motor and is one player who the Saffas and Kiwis genuinely rate and fear – not fear in the scary sense but they know he is a leader and a gamebreaker.
March 16th 2010 @ 11:06pm
Andrew Logan said | March 16th 2010 @ 11:06pm | Report comment
Yeah and Sam Wykes will be partnering Van, and Dane Haylett-Petty will be a bolter at fullback……
March 17th 2010 @ 12:22am
bennalong said | March 17th 2010 @ 12:22am | Report comment
Andrew…………..!!!!!
March 17th 2010 @ 6:34am
OldManEmu said | March 17th 2010 @ 6:34am | Report comment
Hehe, fish are biting this morning
LOL on Haylett Petty – poor bugger is well out ofhis depth this season but hopefully he will learn from the experiences.
Justin Harrison and Van Humphries in the second row……………….