Forget the drama, Clarke will make a great Test captain
By David Sygall, 19 Mar 2010 David Sygall is a Roar Rookie
- Tagged:
- Australian Cricket, Cricket, Michael Clarke, Ricky Ponting
Michael Clarke will lead Australia when Ricky Ponting retires and will finish his career as a respected and successful skipper. The chaos of the past couple of weeks will not hinder this in any way. Rather, it genuinely begins Clarke’s path to the post of captain.
Just like Ricky Ponting’s wake up call came at the end of an ugly night out in Kings Cross all those years ago, Clarke’s came during the debacle that followed his decision to return from New Zealand to deal with problems in his relationship.
The factors were different, but the results will be similar.
Both Ponting and Clarke were identified from a very young age as outstanding cricketers. Neither will work a day in his life. Both will finish their careers as late-30 somethings with millions of dollars and the rest of their lives to do as they please.
The flipside to that privilege is a disconnection from reality, no matter how one might try to keep one’s feet on the ground.
Ponting had little comprehension of his responsibilities as a young batsman in the Australian team when he copped a black eye that night at the Cross.
Clarke, too, has been living in a dreamworld since the age of 23, when he scored 151 on debut in Bangalore.
I spoke to Clarke when he was on the way home after that knock. He was innocent, gleeful, cracking jokes, telling stories and laughing like a kid in a toy store. He was always supremely confident and friendly.
But after living in the barely sustainable goldfish bowl of the Australian cricket team, being adored, feted, mollycoddled and paid a fortune – especially during a period of unprecedented controversy and greed in the game – things finally got out of hand. A reality check was inevitable.
And it has arrived.
Clarke was warned that his relationship with Lara Bingle would become a sideshow. He was happy to go with it. But if you are famous and keen to show off your private life when all’s going well, you can’t expect to shut the door when things turn awry and demand everyone accept your behest.
Australian team media manager Lachy Patterson’s decree to a throng of educated and experienced journalists at Clarke’s media conference on Wednesday that if the wrong questions get asked ‘‘we’ll walk away’’ was embarassing. Clarke should have answered questions.
And he certainly didn’t need a media manager to hold his hand.
Sure, you can’t help love. And, he really did love Lara. But Clarke was also warned that buying a $6 million penthouse right on Bondi Beach (with huge windows) was hardly going to afford him privacy.
He could have helped that.
He didn’t have to get tattoos, advertise underpants or buy a ferrari (which his manager strongly advised him to sell straight away, advice Clarke acted upon).
He didn’t have to organise his engagement party on the same night as the NSW presentation, nor flaunt expensive diamonds and cars, nor get into fights with teammates, all of which have made people question what this bloke is all about.
You suspect Clarke won’t make such poor decisions again after what he’s just been through. You would hope that he’d settle down and begin a new chapter in his career, exhibiting the type of maturity needed to become a respected and admired public figure.
You would anticipate that people like Ponting and Clarke rarely make mistakes twice. They learn, perfect and move on.
Australians forgive those who screw up but get up, dust themselves off and get on with the job. Clarke will do just that and he will be applauded for keeping his dignity during this ordeal, irrespective of whether it was he who invited it.
He has nothing to apologise for, but hopefully will learn more about humility and class.
You would hope that this will be the corner around which he turns from wide-eyed youngster living the fantasy, to a respectable, measured and learned leader fit to lead the nation’s most famous sporting team.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- Australian Cricket, Cricket, Michael Clarke, Ricky Ponting


Rickety Knees said | March 19th 2010 @ 8:54am | Report comment
I hope that you are right.
SouthernWaratah said | March 19th 2010 @ 9:18am | Report comment
Well Said Dave!
I was sticking up for “Pup” (as he was being called the other day on this site by a member of the crowd) and suggesting he showed great leadership by putting an end to the circus that was his private life. Characteristics of a great leader is to take control of a situation that’s getting out of hand and makeing it right, it happens everyday in business, in a sense Michael Clarke’s life is his business.
I applaud his actions of the past week it has shown great maturity and he has held himself with dignity through out this whole situation, he will make a great Australian Test Captain.
RickG said | March 19th 2010 @ 9:25am | Report comment
As I said elsewhere I reckon he’s got a spring in his step and has taken a huge burden off his shoulders. I’ve been copping it from the fiminists at work by suggesting it would never work with Lara if he was Aus captain. Can you imagine the wife of the captain with her own manager?
James said | March 19th 2010 @ 3:10pm | Report comment
We’ll see how he rebounds from Bingle. If there is more tears and soap operas then I think it’s time to find someone else.
Punter said | March 19th 2010 @ 3:23pm | Report comment
Clarke just got his 100.
James said | March 19th 2010 @ 3:23pm | Report comment
Clark scores 100 in NZ! Good rebound….but it is against the Kiwis
Republican said | March 19th 2010 @ 3:33pm | Report comment
Yep, and the grounds are like postage stamps, so I wouldn’t get too excited.
Why Hussey continues to be selected is beyond me!
Hansie said | March 19th 2010 @ 5:14pm | Report comment
Clarke started the post-Bingle era well. I doubt we’ll hear any more dramas and soap operas from Clarke. I think he’s had enough of that and, anyway, he realises that his career won’t be helped by more teenage dramas.
David Sygall said | March 20th 2010 @ 11:07am | Report comment
Kicking myself for not putting a wager on Clarke to score a ton in this match… Easy money!!
Rabbitz said | March 21st 2010 @ 5:35pm | Report comment
Well he may or may not be a good Captain, but there is no way he will Ever be a GREAT Captain. I do not believe he has the inner grit (aka guts) to be a tough captain, a leading batsman and a latte drinking, Chardonnay sipping, metro-sexual snag all at the same time, especially when it comes to hard fought matches.
Frankly, if he does become Captain, I, for one, will not attend any games nor will I watch it on TV.