Ricky Ponting is maturing as a captain, at last
By Spiro Zavos, 3 Apr 2010 Spiro Zavos is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Australian Cricket, Cricket, Ricky Ponting, The Ashes
All things come to those who wait, and it seems that Australian cricket is being rewarded with the maturing of Ricky Ponting as a captain of the national cricket side, one of the most iconic and difficult jobs open to an Australian.
Ling time readers of The Roar will know that I’ve expressed the view many times that Ponting is the best Australian batsman since Don Bradman.
And one of the worst captains.
There is no need here to relive the mistakes, tactical and cultural, that Ponting has been involved with as captain. This season, though, he seems to have matured on and off the field.
He has taken a relatively inexperienced bowling attack, and with some astute captaincy, has contrived to get 20 wickets a Test out of his bowlers time and time again. The mentoring role involved in this exercise has forced him to think more about his responsibilities for setting the style of the team.
At Hamilton, for instance, in the just finished Test there, Ross Taylor absolutely monstered Nathan Hauritz in the first innings, taking 25 from him in one over.
In the second New Zealand innings, Ponting held Hauritz back until Taylor was dismissed. Michael Clarke did the spinning, and did it well, until Hauritz’s nemesis was out of the way.
Off the field, too, Ponting won plenty of plaudits from the New Zealand officials for his supportive manner in performing his duties as the team’s captain. He was invariably pleasant and co-operative, and when he expressed an opinion, it was positive and helpful.
This positive and helpful attitude stretches to his views on the future of the game. Cricket lovers around the world will applaud his forthright statement that he is against day-night Tests with pink balls.
Cricket administrators are in danger of destroying the unique experience Test cricket provides by trying to turn it into a juiced-up version of the one-day game.
This sort of nonsense, with the ideal of playing Test cricket at the obnoxious ANZ Stadium, needs to be firmly rejected by the big name in the game.
Ricky Ponting has correctly shown the way on this issue.
Test cricket is slow and fascinating, the way a game of chess is slow and fascinating. If you turn into a series of hands of poker (which is what the Twenty20 game is), then you lose all the streams of interest that make Test cricket so fascinating.
Ponting has also made the point that “we can’t be better placed for the Ashes at this monent.” And he is right, with a few qualifications.
Ponting and the selectors (who I’ve also bagged a lot in recent years) deserve congratulations on a series of intelligent and constructive decisions in the last year.
Shane Watson is a great success at opener (who would have thought it?)
Watson’s belligerence and Simon Katich’s solidity make for a great opening pair.
It is time now, though, for Michael Clarke, arguably now Australia’s best batsman, to follow Ponting in the batting order. Michael Hussey has consolidated his position in the side with his consistent batting and splendid fielding.
Hussey is particularly good with the tail-enders, as he showed at Sydney, and for this reason alone he should bat at six rather than five.
Marcus North has justified his retention, although the New Zealand bowling attack was of the pop-gun variety by the time he came into bat. The improvement in the bowling of Nathan Hauritz means that North is being played purely as a batsman.
In time, probably after the Ashes series later this year, Stephen Smith will take his position, or Brad Haddin will move up one in the order with Smith coming in next.
But this won’t happen until, or if, Australia gets in trouble in the Ashes series and absolutely needs a victory.
Hauritz, as a finger-spinner, can’t be expected to win Tests the way a quality leg-spinner can do. But there is no doubt he has become a good Test bowler, a sort of Ashley Mallett-type, capable of slowing down the run-rate when needed and picking up a couple of wickets from time to time.
The fast bowling attack in the last Test of Doug Bollinger, Ryan Harris, Mitchell Johnson and Shane Watson, should go into the first Ashes Test. Bollinger is taking his wickets at an average of just over 20 runs a wicket, which is exceptional.
Harris has taken 9 wickets in his first two Tests and impresses as a genuine fast bowler, with a bit of cut away, who will trouble the best batsmen with his speed and accuracy.
As Ponting says, it is beginning to look very good for an Australian triumph in the Ashes series.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
The Crowd Says (7) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- Australian Cricket, Cricket, Ricky Ponting, The Ashes


vinay verma said | April 3rd 2010 @ 7:16am | Report comment
Spiro, I have been in the minority on the subject of Ponting’s captaincy and it is a matter of record that I have stated he should be judged as a whole and not in isolation. I do not believe you are exonerating his past tactical gaffes but I do believe you are acknowledging his maturity. This is good and honest (and brave) journalism on your part.
Not only is Ricky advocating the eminence of Test Cricket but he is also pleading to preserve the sanctity of the Sheffield Shield. His mentoring role with not only the young guns but also with North and Clarke show the influence he has. He was recently at odds with Gilchrist,Hayden,Symonds and Lehman on the subject of the security surrounding the IPL.
Not only Ponting, but players like Tendulkar and Dravid have recently expressed a desire to lift the profile of Test cricket. The debate of day/night Tests will wax and wane depending upon the suitability of the pink or other coloured balls. Night Tests go against the grain but it will be inevitable,at least in India. It has a bit to do with a time poor society but it is largely a question of primetime programming. This is something all sports have to mindful of. We have very little daytime footy (any code) at present and the majority of games that rate are played at night.
It is time that the cricket Test captains start voicing their opinions. I believe they are the ones who can make a difference. I do not think any current Australian player would be happy about International cricket (even one game) moving to Homebush.
This agenda is ,I suspect,more driven by Cricket NSW than by Cricket Australia. Tradition,it would appear, is not a negotiable currency,in the eyes of David Gilbert. It is also at odds with the major sponsor of Australian Cricket,the Commonwealth Bank. It does not make good business sense to move an International game to the ANZ stadium. It can only serve to alieniate a loyal sponsor.
But back to Ponting, I believe History will judge him kindly.
drewster said | April 3rd 2010 @ 10:04am | Report comment
Nice Article Kersi, I have at times been a been on the “Ponting Captaincy” bashing bandwagon and with due cause I believe. However you must give credit where credit is due and I take my hat off to his decision making for the entire summer and the NZ tour. He appears to be a much more decisive captain when he has something extra to motivate him (eg. Ashes 06/07, Sth Africa 09) and since losing the Ashes in 09 he really has had an axe to grind. The team appears to have responded well to the challenge with a one day series win in India right through to the recent NZ test series win.
cosmos forever said | April 3rd 2010 @ 3:52pm | Report comment
the team is playing well, he’s captaining well, but don’t for a minute forget he is the man who has been in charge while Cricket Australia has consistent research that shows them the Australian Cricket team is considered “unlikeable” from just about every quarter.
http://www.smh.com.au/sport/cricket/the-team-its-hard-to-fall-in-love-with-20100116-mddp.html
No forgiveness from me yet
Ali Khan said | April 3rd 2010 @ 11:07pm | Report comment
Observation is spot on Spiros. I too feel that Ponting has matured well in the role. Although unlike you I have always maintained that he has always been a shrewd leader. Aussies have had relatively easy opponents this summer, his metal will once again be tested under pressure… good luck to him
Lolly said | April 4th 2010 @ 7:33am | Report comment
The batting line-ups have been very poor in the past three series. It will be a very different kettle of fish against England and the other top teams. 20 wickets may be hard to come by, especially if MJ has bad days, and the regular batting collapses are still a real worry.
I wish they had blooded more young batsmen than just Hughes.
cosmos forever said | April 4th 2010 @ 5:48pm | Report comment
Lolly – who are the “top teams” in Cricket – basically England and India maybe. We’ve faced West Indies, Pakistan and NZ this summer – bit of a worry there are seemingly only two test playing nations worth watching the Aussies play!
There’s a post in that Spiro
Tommy said | April 5th 2010 @ 11:09pm | Report comment
Agree with all what you say on the article but found the comment about poker;
“If you turn into a series of hands of poker (which is what the Twenty20 game is), then you lose all the streams of interest that make Test cricket so fascinating.”
Before you comment on the great game of poker I think you need to get your facts straight. Obviously you have been watching poker on the TV and assume it is big hand after big hand. When playing with big stack to blind ratio (200 big blinds deep) the game is far from the wham, bam thank you mam than you are making out.
Poker can be the slowest game out there, even slower than test match cricket.
I have played cricket for 18 years and poker 10 – 2 years of the poker proffesionally – so I am more than qualified to make a comment like this.
Dissapointed with that shout Spiro !