Storm-gate isn’t the NRL’s biggest ever scandal
By Davidde Corran, 27 Apr 2010 Davidde Corran is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- AFL, football, Melbourne Storm, NRL, Rugby League, salary cap scandal
Related coverage

Brett Stewart celebrates after he scoring his 73rd try for Manly - AAP Image/Action Photographics, Grant Trouville
I must say that I’m a bit bemused by the “biggest scandal to rock the NRL.” For starters, there’s something fascinating about why Melbourne Storm, a club whom the majority of Melbournian’s have never actually cared for, has garnered so much attention in its darkest hour.
In fact, with over 20,000 attending the first of many Storm “dead rubbers” on ANZAC day, it almost seems as if they are more popular than ever. At least the fans have been galvanised, albeit temporarily.
As Adrian Musolino wrote on this site yesterday: “Now that the emotion of proving a point to themselves, their fans and the rest of the competition has been left at Etihad on Anzac Day, the reality that the rest of the 2010 season will be a point-less exercise with that emotion of last night’s match dwindling with each round sets in.”
While this response from the fans was both expected and intriguing, there is something much more important that seems to have been missed by the media.
Now, having a football writer waxing lyrical about league might seem strange, but please indulge me for a minute as my point goes beyond any single sporting code. In fact, it’s a problem for Australian society at large.
The words of a acquaintance of mine about the Storm’s self-inflicted plight have been echoing around my head since I heard them on Saturday. Her argument was essentially that the biggest scandal to have hit the NRL has been ongoing for the last six or so years and involves the constant degradation of women by players.
I agree wholeheartedly.
Not convinced? Remember the NRL has been confronted by a sexual assault allegation every year since 2004. Three of these accusations went as far as formal police charges.
In the past four years, three other players have also been convicted of assaulting women.
I’m not picking on league, either, here. And anyone who thinks “I’m not a League fan, so it’s not my problem” is gravely mistaken.
Whether it’s “partner swapping” in the AFL or the systemic infidelity I see all the time within the sport code I cover, the issue stretches right across the Australian sporting landscape.
I found myself torn between laughter and despair recently when I saw a leading Australian sportsmen showing off his “perfect family” on national television and talking about how important his wife and children are to him. My reaction was such because the tales of this player’s infidelity at a recent international tournament are famous within that sport’s circles.
The list of such cases is endless, and the way women are often and routinely viewed within sport shocks me. Journalists, sportsmen and administrators are all guilty of it.
If this issue is so widespread within Australian sport, then it is clearly an issue for the country at large.
I’m not asking that we go back over the history of league or any other code’s track record with women, but a bit of perspective when discussing Melbourne’s salary cap cheating would seem appropriate.
Storm fans have a right to feel aggrieved, NRL haters have more ammunition for their cannons, and sports lovers who believe in fair play should be disgusted.
But I hope everyone will take a moment to remember that there is a greater malaise lying beneath the surface of both our sporting culture and Australian society at large.
Most alarming of all: it’s one that goes beyond the white lines our games are played within.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby League articles
- An open letter to Channel Nine (107)
- Gallop and some of his precious Sydney NRL clubs must go (101)
- The NRL is back baby! (65)
- The NRL’s scariest players (56)
- The NRL needs a vision (52)
- Federal Court has it wrong on sports broadcast copyright (48)
- Bulldogs setting benchmark for Sydney’s NRL clubs (46)
- New league chief coy on TV deal
- RL Commission was never in doubt, says Searle RL Commission was never in doubt: Searle
- Chalk predicts bright rugby league future
- Clubs must stop knifing Gallop, if commission is to succeed
- Rugby league’s new era: where to now? (23)
- New dawn for rugby league gets underway (11)
- Rugby league commission ushers in new era (3)
- Rugby league’s new era: where to now? (23)
- Federal Court has it wrong on sports broadcast copyright (49)
- An open letter to Channel Nine (108)
- The NRL’s scariest players (56)
- Is the All Stars match increasing the divide? (25)
- Channel Nine needs NRL-cricket ODI compromise (36)
- The NRL needs a vision (52)
- Explore:
- AFL, football, Melbourne Storm, NRL, Rugby League, salary cap scandal

oikee said | April 27th 2010 @ 6:50am | Report comment
Agree with you, but you have to remember that rugby league is curently deeling with this issue. They have programs in place for young players. It wont solve the issue, but its a start. To be honest, this is really old news. it has already been covered over and over by the Matty Johns and Cronulla boys incident.
Tell you something, i was watching a American show about men having affairs with under age girls(13-15) being set up by police on the internet. Now this really shocked me, according to this program, men from every walk of life, Rabbi’s, preists, men married with children, 20 year olds 50 year olds being caught left right and centre, turning up to this sting operation., Seemed to me that every man and his dog turned up to this set-up for a peice of the action. This operation has been taken to lots of cities around America to highlight how big the problem is, and this is a small part of the problem, it was only from internet exposure, imagine how many predetors are not useing the net.
Right here in Brisbane at southbank they have a detention centre for ex-fellons charged with this practise. I remember having to stare down a seedy guy at south-bank a few years ago because he was watching children swimming at southbank, then i found out that this rehabilatation centre was in fact at southbank.
This shocked me, it made me realise that rugby leagues problems are minute,, compared to other seedy issues in society as a whole.
Rugby league might have problems, but no bigger than what you dont know about the guy next door, or people you pass in the street every day.
Davidde Corran said | April 28th 2010 @ 3:00am | Report comment
Oikee it’s an interesting point you raise but I don’t think we’re doing anywhere near enough to handle it.
JK said | April 27th 2010 @ 7:03am | Report comment
How have the media missed this stuff? it’s constantly in the papers,
Davidde Corran said | April 28th 2010 @ 3:02am | Report comment
It’s not about lack of coverage but remembering that this scandal is not the biggest issue the game has faced. There is a bigger problem facing all of sport in this country however I suppose respecting women doesn’t sell papers as well as a cheating scandal does.
Dirk said | April 28th 2010 @ 3:44pm | Report comment
When will people like you realise the problems regarding respect for women is not a Football, or a certain codes problem. It is a problem for society.
Davidde, the cheating aligations facing the Storm are one of the biggest scandals that the NRL has faced.
Respect for women or NRL players showing lack of respect for women has nothing to do with the NRL.
It is a problem of the induvidual and society. The media is nothing but detrimental for the cause for respect for women when reporting on such incidents. The level of jornalism in this country is a discrace. And yes Davidde have proven with this article you are part of the jornalism that is utter judmental rubish.
Mister Football said | April 27th 2010 @ 7:56am | Report comment
The show of support for the Storm in Melbourne is very easy to understand within the usual Australian sporting mores:
1. support for a club fighting back against a major blow, backs to wall stuff;
2. understanding the pain of having administrators wipe away two premierships from the record; and
3. for the moment, an appreciation that the exploits of coach and players stands quite apart from the actions of the administrators.
Geoff said | April 27th 2010 @ 10:13am | Report comment
Except that its looking like Inglis, Slater, Smith and Bellamy knew only to well.
Bellamy had to know.
Gerry Faehrmann said | April 27th 2010 @ 12:13pm | Report comment
Bellyaches all round, I’d say.
Ken said | April 28th 2010 @ 12:20pm | Report comment
Yet to be seen if it all comes out rosy, a great response but I’m sure there will be some bad times through the year ahead for the Storm. If anything though they’ve shown the way to Melbourne’s heart – give them a reason to stick it up Sydney! You would think with the history of the QLD-NSW rivalry that the RL administrators should have worked out ages ago that they’ve got to set Melbourne up as the underdog fighting against the oppresive tyranny of the Sydney-centric leaders of the game.
Chris said | April 27th 2010 @ 8:04am | Report comment
I reckon all this talk of Melburnians not having much interest in the Storm is rubbish. A pure myth. Its just a perception from outside VIC. The crowds are always decent, well above many games in Syd. They get ok coverage in the media, certainly more than the AFL Lions get in Brisbane. I think the support has always existed – add a scandal and a hint of david v goliath and sports fans will always rally for the underdog
Tom said | April 27th 2010 @ 9:17am | Report comment
Lived in Melbourne my whole life. I once worked with one bloke who’d been to a couple of Storm games. Apart from that, don’t know anyone who’s been to a game or could name more than three players.
Until this week they were completely anonymous. They get quite a bit of press in the Herald Sun (a News Limited paper) but not much apart from that. Never spent much time in Brisbane but the Swans certainly get more coverage in Sydney than the Storm do in Melbourne.
captain nemo said | April 27th 2010 @ 9:35am | Report comment
the last week we have had a friend and his wife staying at our house on holidays from Dallas. He played a bit of rugby at college but knows little of league. As a true Texan, watching this, he reacons any news is good news if your brand is on the front and back page of the papers. Storm have to look on this as an opportunity, they have the community in Melbourne talking about them with a now sympathetic tone. Storm need to promote themselves not a as a league team but as a Melbourne team.
apaway said | April 27th 2010 @ 9:28am | Report comment
And Melbourne are now that underdog? That’s got to be the greatest feat of spin-doctoring in years. The team that cheated their way to 4 successive Grand Finals is “the underdog.” More like the deer caught in the headlights…
Ken said | April 28th 2010 @ 12:25pm | Report comment
Yeah but a lot of talk about this killing them made them something of an underdog. And more importantly it made them ‘Melbourne’s’ underdog fighting to stay alive against the Sydney administrators that are trying to drown them.
I don’t disagree with your assessment though, they’re the bad guys in this. It’s for the good of RL (specifically, but at some level all Australian sport) if they do survive their punishment though
Crosscoder said | April 27th 2010 @ 8:11am | Report comment
I must have missed something or the thread author has ,any issues involving rugby league players and the degradation of women,have been in the past in the papers,electronic media and covered to the large extent they should be.Public condemnation by letters on radio,which I totally have supported.It was there in bold black and white,and loud in the media.
As a matter of fact one ongoing issue involving the courts has media people following like a herd.
They are issues that are in the past and were indeed huge issues for the code,and the NRL has education programs in place and pushing the respect for women issue.
The point made by Oikee it is current issues we are now dealing with.
I agree with the problems of treatment of women,being it is across the broader sense of the communty to deal with and involves all levels of society(from the highest stratas to the loewst starta) and ***all sports***.As a matter of interest a women from the women’s crisis centre in Sydney stated after the Bulldogs’ drama,talking about the Nth Shore of Sydney had a large problem with physical abuse of women due to alcohol.The latest scandal involving a WA Pollie who has a less than favourable record supports my argument.
Brian said | April 27th 2010 @ 8:27am | Report comment
Why mention this again now?
And also no mention of the Sydney FC player caught up in the underage sex scandal? Or the French National football team? Those in glass houses……..
Davidde Corran said | April 28th 2010 @ 3:04am | Report comment
Brian if you can please read the article again. Football gets a mention. The French incident you mention is entirely irrelevant. This is about Australian sport not French soccer.
M1tch said | April 27th 2010 @ 9:05am | Report comment
Biggest scandal for Rugby League was Super League – nothing will ever come close
Dogz R Barkn said | April 27th 2010 @ 9:42am | Report comment
Not sure if that was a “scandal” as much as a powerplay that continues to plague the game to this day..
Hansie said | April 27th 2010 @ 5:20pm | Report comment
Exactly right. The SuperLeague war wasted millions of dollars and set the game back years.
Freddy the Panther said | April 27th 2010 @ 9:22am | Report comment
The biggest scandal is the fact that the Storm remain in the competition at all.
It fine for us all to say that we hope the Storm get back on thier feet but it come at a cost for the other clubs. When the Storm play away from home I dare say that the away crowds will be smaller this will come at a cost to the other clubs.
2nd is other clubs can never come close to getting the same quality players as the Storm because they cheated and there fore bringing down that they couldnt get the same player and they have to play against them. But imagine Storm with 1/2 thier stars going to other clubs I dare say that they wouldnt be winning grand finals.
I am absolutely disgusted at the board of the Storm including the coach they all knew what was going and expect us ( other league supporters) to get behind them, hoping them to get back. The problem is that the Storm are to big too important to fail. I am also dismayed by the large crowd that turned up at the game. Its pretty much saying to the Storm ok you cheated but we love you any way. The Storm have treated thier fans with contempt and the fans repay the Storm rocking up to a game. I am truly amazed. But it seems that the bigger the scandal the more new coverage, the more popular the game, last year was a shocker for the NRL but last year was the best year ever for support.
bazza said | April 27th 2010 @ 10:12am | Report comment
What an odd article that says nothing
Men like to root women – even ones that they aren’t married to. I doubt that is limited to sportsmen
apaway said | April 27th 2010 @ 10:04pm | Report comment
Wow. Is it that simple? No mention that they like to do it against the woman’s will, perhaps in a 10 on 1, or if it’s a team mate’s wife? What an amazingly offensive statement.
Davidde Corran said | April 28th 2010 @ 3:16am | Report comment
apaway you have my respect. Well said.
Davidde Corran said | April 28th 2010 @ 3:05am | Report comment
Classy.
gingerbeer said | April 27th 2010 @ 10:12am | Report comment
The biggest scandal is yet to come if Waldron does get shut up by a court order, it could get really messy.
Waldron has been stating quite openly in the media that every club is guilty of salary cap breaches. The NRL should be looking to sue or restrain Waldron if these comments are not true as he is clearly defaming the other clubs.
But what happends if more clubs get done. Where does that leave the league?. I havent seen the NRL look to shut him up I remember last year Ken Talbot was on the witness stand in a corruption trial admitted to lending money ( but not expecting to get repaid) to Broncos players. This type of activity has obviously been going not just the Broncos but every other club.
http://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,8659,25749762-23214,00.html?from=public_rss
Dogs Of War said | April 27th 2010 @ 10:16am | Report comment
I am sure he would be paid off. Really this whole episode just validates why an Independent Commission is required.
Need more talk about this comign about. Not sure why they are sitting on there hands. Hopefully Steve Mortimer gets well soon (He was involved in a car crash on the weekend), so he can start shouting from the rooftops again.