Storm-gate isn’t the NRL’s biggest ever scandal
By Davidde Corran, 27 Apr 2010 Davidde Corran is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- AFL, football, Melbourne Storm, NRL, Rugby League, salary cap scandal
Related coverage

Brett Stewart celebrates after he scoring his 73rd try for Manly - AAP Image/Action Photographics, Grant Trouville
I must say that I’m a bit bemused by the “biggest scandal to rock the NRL.” For starters, there’s something fascinating about why Melbourne Storm, a club whom the majority of Melbournian’s have never actually cared for, has garnered so much attention in its darkest hour.
In fact, with over 20,000 attending the first of many Storm “dead rubbers” on ANZAC day, it almost seems as if they are more popular than ever. At least the fans have been galvanised, albeit temporarily.
As Adrian Musolino wrote on this site yesterday: “Now that the emotion of proving a point to themselves, their fans and the rest of the competition has been left at Etihad on Anzac Day, the reality that the rest of the 2010 season will be a point-less exercise with that emotion of last night’s match dwindling with each round sets in.”
While this response from the fans was both expected and intriguing, there is something much more important that seems to have been missed by the media.
Now, having a football writer waxing lyrical about league might seem strange, but please indulge me for a minute as my point goes beyond any single sporting code. In fact, it’s a problem for Australian society at large.
The words of a acquaintance of mine about the Storm’s self-inflicted plight have been echoing around my head since I heard them on Saturday. Her argument was essentially that the biggest scandal to have hit the NRL has been ongoing for the last six or so years and involves the constant degradation of women by players.
I agree wholeheartedly.
Not convinced? Remember the NRL has been confronted by a sexual assault allegation every year since 2004. Three of these accusations went as far as formal police charges.
In the past four years, three other players have also been convicted of assaulting women.
I’m not picking on league, either, here. And anyone who thinks “I’m not a League fan, so it’s not my problem” is gravely mistaken.
Whether it’s “partner swapping” in the AFL or the systemic infidelity I see all the time within the sport code I cover, the issue stretches right across the Australian sporting landscape.
I found myself torn between laughter and despair recently when I saw a leading Australian sportsmen showing off his “perfect family” on national television and talking about how important his wife and children are to him. My reaction was such because the tales of this player’s infidelity at a recent international tournament are famous within that sport’s circles.
The list of such cases is endless, and the way women are often and routinely viewed within sport shocks me. Journalists, sportsmen and administrators are all guilty of it.
If this issue is so widespread within Australian sport, then it is clearly an issue for the country at large.
I’m not asking that we go back over the history of league or any other code’s track record with women, but a bit of perspective when discussing Melbourne’s salary cap cheating would seem appropriate.
Storm fans have a right to feel aggrieved, NRL haters have more ammunition for their cannons, and sports lovers who believe in fair play should be disgusted.
But I hope everyone will take a moment to remember that there is a greater malaise lying beneath the surface of both our sporting culture and Australian society at large.
Most alarming of all: it’s one that goes beyond the white lines our games are played within.
Recommend this story.
The Turkey 10
The Turkey 10 teams have now been selected, as Wild Turkey Bourbon's sport sponsorship kicks into the next exciting phase.
Choose which side you're going to support and get in the running to win $2,500!
Simply visit Wild Turkey Australia on Facebook for your chance to win.
Find out more.
The Crowd Says (37) | Page 2 of Comments
Have Your Say
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby League articles
- NSW State of Origin 2012 team announced; expert reaction (221)
- Five hit ups: the talking points from State of Origin one (221)
- That Origin try: Did Inglis score or did the refs get it wrong? (186)
- Make this the last Origin in Melbourne (181)
- League and Union: we should embrace the different codes (141)
- An answer to Sydney NRL crowd problems? (120)
- Who missed out on NSW State of Origin selection (115)
- Melbourne Storm vs Brisbane Broncos: NRL live scores, blog (6)
- South Sydney Rabbitohs vs Canberra Raiders: NRL live scores, blog (20)
- NSW should stop whinging and ask why they couldn’t score points (122)
- WIZ: Melbourne State of Origin was a winner (33)
- A Ray of sunshine in modern sports commentary (34)
- Price would have led players off in Origin (23)
- League Round 12 preview panel
- Melbourne Storm vs Brisbane Broncos: NRL live scores, blog (6)
- South Sydney Rabbitohs vs Canberra Raiders: NRL live scores, blog (20)
- NSW should stop whinging and ask why they couldn’t score points (122)
- A Ray of sunshine in modern sports commentary (34)
- The mystical powers of the video referee’s box (5)
- Referee inexperience was Origin’s worst decision (9)
- What can Channel Nine learn from other sports? (11)
- Explore:
- AFL, football, Melbourne Storm, NRL, Rugby League, salary cap scandal


April 27th 2010 @ 11:48am
AGO74 said | April 27th 2010 @ 11:48am | Report comment
I tend to agree with the article. Being a lifelong Bulldogs supporter the 2002 salary cap competition expulsion was tough and you copped heaps as a fan. But that was almost a walk in the park compared to the atmosphere surrounding the Coffs Harbour stuff in 2004. Media organisations have to sensationalise everything to make it seem bigger or worse or scarier than before. I’m not downplaying the Storm stuff because it is very big – I just agree that it’s not the biggest. I sympathise with Storm fans and with the players who didn’t know (you’d have to think at least some were aware of what was going on) and was very pleased for those ‘innocent’ people get such a turnout and great performance but they are in for a long, long season. The only saving grace for Bulldogs in ’02 was that we got exposed 5 or 6 weeks from seasons end. Unfortunately for Melbourne they don’t even have that.
April 27th 2010 @ 2:38pm
oikee said | April 27th 2010 @ 2:38pm | Report comment
I cant be to hard on the storm, the broncos looked like getting the wooden spoon this year, thanks to the storm, we are now safe. Our younger players will have more experience next year, the storm might be busted, but i think they have saved 2 teams and coaches, the sharks and the broncos.
Long live the storm, you cheating sods. I have a right to be unhappy, they knocked us out of the comp 2 years ago, we had a better chance of beating manly than they did. 40 nil lads, 40 nil.
Independent commish, bruno gone, bears back, melbourne sorted, all will be good, how long will this take. ?
April 27th 2010 @ 4:17pm
John said | April 27th 2010 @ 4:17pm | Report comment
If Brian Waldron told me the time I would check my watch.
Waldron has been caught out and is trying to pull other people down with him for the hell of it.
April 27th 2010 @ 4:26pm
Michael C said | April 27th 2010 @ 4:26pm | Report comment
hmmm, John, 2 sides to this story,……and one of them is a massive multi national media corporation.
I’d be taking everything with a healthy dose of salt grains.
That first day when the stage managed line up of Hartigan and Gallop did their very best to portray Waldron as an RL ‘outsider’ who’d infected their clean game……that just smelled severely of ‘scapegoatism’.
Waldron no doubt is no clean skin, however, ……. let’s just wait and see what comes out.
Just notice though how many ‘character assassination’ stories News Ltd has been carrying on ‘Wally’.
Good luck to Waldron, he’ll need it. Good luck to those of us who will have to rely on Fairfax to attempt to keep this from becoming a media driven kangaroo court. The NRL and News Ltd is an unholy partnership that just makes this all really, really ugly.
April 27th 2010 @ 6:56pm
amused said | April 27th 2010 @ 6:56pm | Report comment
yes, a soccer writer musing on league. and you mention adrian. i’d say neither of you are biased at all.
/yawn…..
April 28th 2010 @ 3:12am
Davidde Corran said | April 28th 2010 @ 3:12am | Report comment
I don’t think any perceived bias is relevant here at all. I have not partaking in any “rugby bashing” in this article. I am simply asking people to remember there is a bigger picture that is getting missed. Let’s not get carried away.
If you’d like to know a bit about my history with the Storm, I started attending games from the very first season. I can’t remember how many times I’ve been to Olympic Park to see them because I’ve lost count.
Meanwhile, as I know nothing about you I won’t make assumptions about any biases you may or may not hold. I’d appreciate if you did the so with me.
I can’t speak for Adrian’s thoughts on League as I’ve never discussed it with him but either way, you can rest assured he is as professional a journalist as you’ll find.
April 28th 2010 @ 3:35am
JVGO said | April 28th 2010 @ 3:35am | Report comment
By your own logic this is a societal problem and has nothing specifically to do with the NRL so it is not really an NRL scandal it is a societal scandal. Vilfying, destroying or removing the NRL will do nothing to solve the issue. These problems exist just as much in the other codes and in every bar and street on Saturday nights. The microscope is just trained harder and more relentlessly on NRL players to the extent that a 7 year old scandal that was common knowledge even then was revived for no real purpose other than to serve rival codes marketing agendas. The general populace who actually get out on the streets and bars on Saturday nights are aware of all this. The whole process of blaming a code or even sport in general for a wider societal issue is simply counter productive.
April 28th 2010 @ 1:48pm
Crosscoder said | April 28th 2010 @ 1:48pm | Report comment
JVGO
Amen to that comment.
April 28th 2010 @ 1:54pm
John Melbourne said | April 28th 2010 @ 1:54pm | Report comment
Davidde Corran good call!
I have done a lot of reading around this topic… and it is now TIME for ALL clubs to open up ALL their top players Tax & Bank accounts to be matched to their contracts. Lets get to some real facts and see how many rat clubs and players are in the comp. Then after that reset the rules. The cap is not working. At this time in the comp I see two NRL in play, one is the LOCAL sydney club system weekend footy (small) and the other is the NATIONAL world champs system (large), one needs to be KILLED and give way to the real direction. Time to make the game GREAT with the very BEST players and take the hack footy out of the fotmula. NRL = National Rats League
April 28th 2010 @ 3:53pm
Dirk said | April 28th 2010 @ 3:53pm | Report comment
John Melbourne
I too would like to read up on this topic. Can you direct me to where you read about this topic (books links etc.)?
Can you elaborate on what you have been reading on the subject, so we can discuss.
Thanks in advanced, Dirk