On the upside, the Wallabies can only get better
By Brett McKay, 8 Jun 2010 Brett McKay is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Luke Burgess, robbie deans, Rugby Union, wallabies
It was yet another brisk winter’s night that greeted the return of International rugby to Canberra on Saturday night. Real brisk, beer-not-needing-a-fridge brisk. And coming out into these near-Antarctic conditions were noted ice-runners, Fiji. I know I said this last week, but Fiji, in Canberra, in June? Come on…
Anyway, Fiji it was, and in Canberra they were, and if there was to be any consolation for the islanders, it was that at least the mercury stayed in positive territory, unlike what the Italians endured last year.
I was certainly thankful for picking the seats high up in the western grandstand, rather than our usual digs down on the concourse.
Returning too, for the Fijians was the ever-mercurial Rupeni Caucaunibuca, who at the top of his game in the mid-Naughties was among the very best wingers in the world. Since then though “Caucau” has descended in the ranks due to off-field issues and a general lack of desire.
He’s been playing France for the last few years, but wanted to use this game as a starting point on the road to next year’s Rugby World Cup.
You couldn’t help but notice Caucau on the field either, not because of what he did with the ball, but more that there was just so much of him to notice. Apparently, he’s even shed seven or eight kilos since coming into camp for this Test, so I shudder to think what he looked like on arrival.
Either way, his jersey still needed a few ‘X’s on the label.
It was a pity too, because I had said during the week that it would be great to see him in open space once again.
The reality, though, was that there just wasn’t space open enough to accommodate him. He’s definitely enjoyed the cuisine in France by the looks of him. Let’s hope he can regain the necessary fitness to gain a berth for one of the Australian Super 15 sides, as he’s declared he’s chasing.
This Test failed to reach any real heights of excellence, which isn’t too big a surprise considering it was the first game of the international season. While it wasn’t unexpected that Fiji would regress into sevens mode at times, such is their want and preference, the surprise would be that the Wallabies would try to match them in this instinctive type of play.
While the Wallabies are blessed with players of immense instinct, like Quade Cooper and Digby Ioane, all too often the unnecessary pass would be pushed, usually resulting in dropped ball or other unforced errors.
The Wallabies’ set piece was rather hot and cold initially, though by midway through the second half they were being virtually unchallenged by the Fijians, in the lineout especially.
The Fijians held their own in the scrum contest too, and the loss of Ben Alexander with a knee injury in the second half would be another prop headache that Robbie Deans doesn’t need with England waiting for them in Perth.
At the breakdown, I got the impression the Wallabies were a bit gun-shy and seemed to be holding back, as if to counter the continual second-phase play of the Fijians.
Too often, the Fijians were allowed to pop a pass in the tackle, which allowed them to keep making metres up the middle. What ultimately let them down were their options with ball in hand, with the attack regularly killed off by nothing little kicks in behind the Wallabies defence.
You do have to give them points for persistence, but works in sevens doesn’t often carry over with eight extra players per side.
In the end though, the scoreboard shows seven converted tries to nil, and while the collective effort of the Wallabies would be flattered by the 49-3 score line, there were still some outstanding individual performances.
Quade Cooper’s long pass is something I could watch all day. The way he draws the defenders before letting rip with this perfectly spiralling work of art just begs to be run on to at pace.
His short game’s not bad either, highlighted no better than the ball that put debutant Rob Horne through a massive gap in the lead-up to Richard Brown’s try on halftime. Cooper had a strong game at flyhalf, more importantly, and the Wallabies won’t be let down by keeping him in the number 10.
David Pocock was in everything for the hour he was on the field, and while showing that George Smith might not be missed at all, he also showed that he’s a potential captain in waiting.
It was surprising the number of times we saw Pocock giving the forwards a rev up, and indeed, after one try he quite deliberately called the whole team together to ensure they never gave the Fijians a sniff.
Nathan Sharpe was named man-of-the-match at the ground, which surprised us as we’d made comment through the game that he seemed to be quiet.
On viewing the tape, though, it wasn’t hard to see why, as Sharpe played a really strong game in the tight stuff, and was a constant target in the lineout.
Scrumhalf Luke Burgess has been a constant target of critics this season, and much of it well warranted, but I actually thought he was pretty solid on Saturday night.
Whilst he still had his moments taking the poor option, his delivery to Cooper was on the money for the most part, and allowed Cooper plenty of time to do what he does best. If I do have one criticism of his display, it was that he would often stand too long at the ruck with the ball at his feet, which just allows the defence to settle.
However he plays though, Burgess is going to be a polarizing player, and I noted the critics still lined him up on The Roar on Sunday. It’s funny how different people see the same thing differently.
I’m happy to view him the same way as the Australian coach; it was telling, in my opinion, that Josh Valentine wasn’t used.
Without question, the dewy conditions didn’t help this game – a prime reason for daytime Tests, in Canberra especially – but there’s still plenty the Wallabies have to work on. In fact, the Wallabies can really only improve from this first outing.
The Wallabies’ scrum, work at the breakdown, and overall execution is still a long way off where they’d want it, and much improvement is needed for the long upcoming international season.
And starting with England this coming week, they’ll need it.
Recommend this story.
Follow Brett McKay on Twitter: @BMcSport
The Turkey 10
The Turkey 10 teams have now been selected, as Wild Turkey Bourbon's sport sponsorship kicks into the next exciting phase.
Choose which side you're going to support and get in the running to win $2,500!
Simply visit Wild Turkey Australia on Facebook for your chance to win.
Find out more.
The Crowd Says (94) | Page 2 of Comments
Have Your Say
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby Union articles
- Reds back in contention, but Waratahs need a cleanout (287)
- What Hansen’s first squad means for the Wallabies (191)
- ALAN JONES: We have the players, it’s the coaches that are to blame (161)
- Who will be in the Wallabies’ backrow? (158)
- Will Cooper and Mitchell be back in time for Wallaby selection? (156)
- CAMPO: Will Deans change the style of the Wallabies play? (128)
- Tahs out. Brumbies win ugly. And Quade’s back! (124)
- Reds focus on Brumbies, not finals
- A Kiwi’s advice to Wallaby supporters (2)
- Confessions of a rugby union traitor
- Brumbies vs Reds: a lesson for the other provinces (7)
- Chiefs vs Bulls: Super Rugby live scores, blog (14)
- Rocky Elsom axed from Wallabies (62)
- The burning question: Beale at 15 or 10? (122)
- A Kiwi’s advice to Wallaby supporters (2)
- Confessions of a rugby union traitor (0)
- Brumbies vs Reds: a lesson for the other provinces (7)
- Chiefs vs Bulls: Super Rugby live scores, blog (14)
- Hola Argentina, and welcome to the Rugby Championship! (21)
- Irish coaches looking to head Western Force (15)
- Dull Super Rugby coaches equal dull rugby (50)
- Explore:
- Luke Burgess, robbie deans, Rugby Union, wallabies


June 8th 2010 @ 12:34pm
kingplaymaker said | June 8th 2010 @ 12:34pm | Report comment
jiggles I see. Turner somehow kept Nemani Nadolo out of the Waratahs. How much talent Nadolo had I don’t know, though perhaps more than Turner. Now we’ll never know.
June 8th 2010 @ 12:58pm
JohnP said | June 8th 2010 @ 12:58pm | Report comment
Tell me about it, I struggle to see why we continue to persist with guys who willa lways be good but never great (Mitchell, Turner etc). God knows how good Nemani could have been now he is lost to French rugby. He is still young however and I do hope that he comes back, with his pace, height 6’5″ and weight 123kgs, he could have been devastating much in the mould of Digby Ioane with the right coaching. KPM you are right when you note that there is a chasm of talent between the rokocoko’s, sivivatus, habanas and turner. He doesn’t even belong in the same sentence, I would say the same of Mitchell and Hynes. Good players but not great. Ioane and Beale are shaping up like they could be these sort of players.
June 8th 2010 @ 1:15pm
kingplaymaker said | June 8th 2010 @ 1:15pm | Report comment
JohnP I think the best team in the world is normally full of players at a certain level, or at least has a certain number of these players spread across the critical positions. Australia last year I think were in a transitory phase when older first-rate players were just going off the scene (e.g. Mortlock, Smith), but had not been replaced by others (e.g. Horne, Pocock). Now they are almost there, except a shortage on the wing and in the second row. When that’s fixed, hopefully in time for the world cup, things will be rosy.
Poor old Nadolo thanks to the disastrous Chris Hickey is now unavailable forever to the Wallabies, as he has been capped by Fiji. If he was advanced as far as the Barbarians last year, someone must have seen more talent in him than the myopic Hickey.
June 8th 2010 @ 1:29pm
JK said | June 8th 2010 @ 1:29pm | Report comment
Nadolo got injured after tearing it up for the Wicks, he was never the same when he came back at that level, don’t see how that’s Hickey’s fault, happy to be corrected.
June 8th 2010 @ 12:59pm
Jameswm said | June 8th 2010 @ 12:59pm | Report comment
Guys this whole Mitchell goes missing in big games is the same thing that used to be said about Latho, plus Haydos in cricket. Then things changed and they became go-to guys.
Mitchell has made huge strides this year – he is clearly stronger, more aggressive and more confident – and so much better in contact. Surely you have noticed the difference.
It has been such a significant leap that he has to be given more opportunities in big games. Look at how the pace of everything changed on Sat when he came on. He fully deserves an extended go this int’l season.
I used to be one of his biggest knockers, but credit where credit’s due. You can’t judge someone on their distant past forever, especially when their more recent past is different.
June 8th 2010 @ 1:05pm
reds fan said | June 8th 2010 @ 1:05pm | Report comment
exactly my point above. players do improve. and its need to acknowledged when it happens, or else its pointless for them to try.
June 8th 2010 @ 1:09pm
Who Needs Melon said | June 8th 2010 @ 1:09pm | Report comment
Jeez it’s nice to be able to argue about who out of a set of pretty decent players should play in certain spots. Whether you are a Hynes-for-fullback fan or a Beale fan or a AAC fan, it’s nice to have the options and we wouldn’t be screwed if any one of these players was injured. Bloody fantastic!
More concerning are the spots where we can’t do this – in particular 1 through 5 (with the possible exception of hooker), 9 and 10. But I’ve had enough of bemoaning lack of decent backups to Genia, Cooper, etc. so lets carry on with the above discussion and be happy that our best in the not-so-deep positions are getting a bit of a rest and their backups a bit of a run.
June 8th 2010 @ 1:44pm
Brett McKay said | June 8th 2010 @ 1:44pm | Report comment
agree Melon, it’s a nice change from this time last year when the Wallabies bench was something of a work experience program at times. Someone touched on this above (or in another thread), would the Wallabies (and Baabaas) be looking so strong if Australia still only had three teams??
June 8th 2010 @ 4:40pm
ilikedahoodoogurusingha said | June 8th 2010 @ 4:40pm | Report comment
Agreed Melon….I would like to see To’omua develop into a potential back up for Cooper in time, I think he has the talent, its time and experience he needs. As to a back up 9….I have no idea.
June 8th 2010 @ 4:57pm
jiggles said | June 8th 2010 @ 4:57pm | Report comment
Long shot but that Turner Kid from the force this year looked pretty good when he played.
June 8th 2010 @ 5:13pm
ilikedahoodoogurusingha said | June 8th 2010 @ 5:13pm | Report comment
Unfortunately where I live we cannot get Fox, so I cannot comment……I’ll have to convince the Mrs that I have to spend the weekend in the pub watching S15 next year so that I can make more informed comments on the Roar………as long as it doesn’t clash with a Brumbies home game of course!
June 8th 2010 @ 1:16pm
kingplaymaker said | June 8th 2010 @ 1:16pm | Report comment
Who needs second row is the position to really worry about, especially if there were injuries there, and when the likes of Matfield come calling.
June 8th 2010 @ 1:35pm
el gamba said | June 8th 2010 @ 1:35pm | Report comment
king, I thought Sharpe was good but Mumm? What are our options?
June 8th 2010 @ 2:59pm
Cattledog said | June 8th 2010 @ 2:59pm | Report comment
Brett, I certainly hope RD keeps experimenting. Let’s get depth and experience and worry about settling on a 1st XV next year. He needs to continually try combinations then let them run for a few tests, but let’s not think that we need to set a 1st XV this early. There’s going to be injuries, others putting their hands up and a whole Super 15 season to go. It’s nice to win Bledisloes, TNs and the like. However, if the RWC is the Holy Grail, let’s work towards that as a goal. Anything else in the meantime is a bonus.
June 8th 2010 @ 3:23pm
Brett McKay said | June 8th 2010 @ 3:23pm | Report comment
Cattledog, it’s a fine line, isn’t it. When I said above “I think it’s just time to start developing the First XV…” I obviously don’t mean let’s play the XV for the RWC Final from this weekend on and no deviations. What I mean is develop combinations now, make subtle canges here and there, experiment to some degree. I’ve got no problem with that. What I don’t want to see is, say, an entirely different backline in consecutive weeks just for the sake of giving blokes experience. In my mind, that’s what the midweek games are for, and good on Robbie Deans (and England) for bringing them back..
I think it’s reasonable to think that whatever the strongest side is (and I realise that’s still something of an unknown at the moment), that we’ll see it during the TNs, and build on that up until the RWC next Sept…
June 8th 2010 @ 4:13pm
Cattledog said | June 8th 2010 @ 4:13pm | Report comment
Brett, I think we differ only on the fact that I’m probably a bit more for experimenting at this stage than you are. Whilst the midweek games are excellent for this, and I agree with you, we must then use identified talent with actual test combinations, whether this be forwards or backs. This must continue through the Bledisloe and TNs.
I may be less conservative than you (the fact that I run Guest Houses in the most volatile province in the world at present may be testament to this fact), however, I’m sure we all want to see the best possible outcome when the ‘money games’ are played in October next year.
The other shattering news for me is the fact that Super Sports have indeed stopped broadcasting outside of South Africa and so my only sanity check, some rugby, is no longer available!!
June 8th 2010 @ 3:08pm
Peter K said | June 8th 2010 @ 3:08pm | Report comment
The biggest issue is second row.
The front row problem is due to the excessive number of injuries and all those players will be good for next year.
The only real class second row we have is Horwill.
Sharpe is having a renaissance BUT always goes missing against the hard forward packs. Mumm is far worse, never does the in tight work.
I did read that Vickerman will be back and is in the middle of negotiations with the ARU but I cannot find the article again.
June 8th 2010 @ 3:20pm
el gamba said | June 8th 2010 @ 3:20pm | Report comment
Peter K, I have found a few articles that make a mention to it such as:
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/sport/hooker-has-robbie-deans-facing-a-big-dilemma/story-e6frg7t6-1225871780434
I struggle to find anything more specific though..
June 8th 2010 @ 3:28pm
Peter K said | June 8th 2010 @ 3:28pm | Report comment
Thanks Gamba.
”but the really exciting news for Australia is that it now seems certain Dan Vickerman will figure in Australia’s World Cup plans, even if he takes no part in next year’s Super 15.”
What I have heard on the inside is that ONeil does not want to offer much and that is the sticking point which is a joke.
ONeil values backs too much and forwards not enough.
June 8th 2010 @ 3:43pm
reds fan said | June 8th 2010 @ 3:43pm | Report comment
maybe he doesn’t want to offer alot cos the bloke has been on a university training regime, and i’m not sure that means he’ll be in top form to be playing Test rugby!
he’s just a blow-in.
June 8th 2010 @ 3:38pm
Brett McKay said | June 8th 2010 @ 3:38pm | Report comment
Gamba, Peter, have I read/heard it right that Daniel Heenan is also in negs with the ARU as well??
June 8th 2010 @ 3:41pm
reds fan said | June 8th 2010 @ 3:41pm | Report comment
I’m sick of these blow in’s showing up the year of a world cup.
June 8th 2010 @ 4:32pm
el gamba said | June 8th 2010 @ 4:32pm | Report comment
Good old google news Brett:
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/sport/mcmeniman-plots-world-cup-bid/story-e6frg7o6-1225875695514
Looks like there’s a few sniffing around for the World Cup! I can’t say that I disagree with you Reds Fan, not sure of the value of Japanese/University rugby in terms of International developnment…
June 8th 2010 @ 6:55pm
Brett McKay said | June 8th 2010 @ 6:55pm | Report comment
McMeniman too!! I have to say I with Reds too, I kind of wish the ARU would tell them they can have a three year deal or nothing. I don’t think they should even entertain the thought of letting these guys come back for one year only…
June 8th 2010 @ 7:07pm
Peter K said | June 8th 2010 @ 7:07pm | Report comment
Vickerman would be back for good and would love a 3yr contract. After all he didnt go to the UK chasing big rugby dollars but to study at Oxford.
It is McMeniman and Heenan who are after 1 yr.
June 8th 2010 @ 7:10pm
Brett McKay said | June 8th 2010 @ 7:10pm | Report comment
yes, quite true Peter, and that article from The Oz doesn’t actually mention Vickerman, just McMeninman and Heenan..
June 8th 2010 @ 3:47pm
reds fan said | June 8th 2010 @ 3:47pm | Report comment
next year Rob Simmons, who had an outstanding year, will be partnering Horwill at the Reds. They will be the premier lock pairing in Oz in 2011. (with old man van causing havoc from the bench).
June 8th 2010 @ 5:06pm
Peter K said | June 8th 2010 @ 5:06pm | Report comment
Simmons did NOT have an outstanding year.
The Qld lineout was weak and struggled. Also like all aussie S14 teams the Reds were very poor at restarts.
At best Simmons will be a middling intl lock next year and yes may be in the top 2 aussie locks which shows how weak we are there.
Forget about Heenan and McMeniman they were never that great.
Vickerman on the other hand was world class. Yes uni level is weak BUT it means his body will not be battered and broken. I for one would be very happy to have him back.
June 8th 2010 @ 4:13pm
jiggles said | June 8th 2010 @ 4:13pm | Report comment
Peter K,
I agree the 2nd row is also a huge problem, with back up for Palu being the second big issue.
Even with Horwill fit do you think it would be good enough against the Boks? the performances last year regarding our 2nd rows does not give me much confidence.
In regards to the front row, I have every confidence in Weeks, Faainga and Daley if they start this weekend. I think they showed this year at the reds they can front up to and not be intimidated by any front row.
June 8th 2010 @ 4:43pm
reds fan said | June 8th 2010 @ 4:43pm | Report comment
I think the Reds front row will be in for an almighty challenge. Benn Rob and TPN are still the best loosehead and hooker in the country.
June 8th 2010 @ 4:56pm
jiggles said | June 8th 2010 @ 4:56pm | Report comment
No doubt reds fan. you could even call ben robinson the best loosehead in the world, I know he would be at least in the top 2 or 3. TPN is one of the best ball running hookers going around too.
My point is that I think the reds front row will be capable as replacements until our 1st choice front 3 is back. They may not dominant England, but they will give it there best and not be intimidated, and will not let Australia down that is for sure.
June 8th 2010 @ 5:12pm
Peter K said | June 8th 2010 @ 5:12pm | Report comment
I am not sure that they will be capable, sure they will give it thier best but that might (probably) not be good enough.
The point is they are the best we have available. Maafu and Edmonds are shocking scrumagers, they struggled against a 3rd string fiji scrum which would be at club level at best.
June 8th 2010 @ 5:10pm
Peter K said | June 8th 2010 @ 5:10pm | Report comment
No even with Horwill back our second row is not good enough. Like I said he is our only class lock.
Maybe Vickerman will be back and maybe he will still be up to it.
Maybe Kimlin or Simmons or Caldwell will really improve next year.
We are very weak with Sharpe, Mumm and Chisholm being the current incumbents.
June 8th 2010 @ 7:50pm
Nashi said | June 8th 2010 @ 7:50pm | Report comment
I’ll be interested to see how Douglas goes tonight, he at least has youth on his side so there is plenty of development ahead.
June 8th 2010 @ 8:08pm
Seiran said | June 8th 2010 @ 8:08pm | Report comment
Any idea if the Fox Sports streaming rugby match will be available to watch internationally for us Aussie expats?
I can’t find it on any UK sports channels.
June 8th 2010 @ 8:20pm
Seiran said | June 8th 2010 @ 8:20pm | Report comment
Thanks JF. The site looks promising.
There’s nothing streaming yet but I presume there will be when the match kicks off.
June 8th 2010 @ 9:42pm
jiggles said | June 8th 2010 @ 9:42pm | Report comment
bloody typical my internet starts to come good at half time!
missed all tries bar the english one as well!
June 9th 2010 @ 1:38am
kingplaymaker said | June 9th 2010 @ 1:38am | Report comment
Mcmeniman must be crazy to think he can pull that one off. He must also be kicking himself knowing that with the injuries and low performance of the second row last year and the lack of form at in the Tri-nations shown by Wycliff Palua nd Richard Brown, he’s probably lost himself 15 caps last year and will be losing another 15 this year.
On the other how much the Wallabies could use him now. If he and Vickerman were to form a second row next year the Wallabies pack would have improved about 50%
June 9th 2010 @ 1:52pm
Go_the_Wannabe's said | June 9th 2010 @ 1:52pm | Report comment
Hey Brett,
Why no report yet on the Baa Baas game? Didn’t anyone watch the live stream on Foxsports?
news.com.au had theirs out first thing this morning……..slack, guys, slack.
And I thought you guys were the premier rugby site?
June 9th 2010 @ 1:56pm
Brett McKay said | June 9th 2010 @ 1:56pm | Report comment
GtWs, Spiro and I discussed this at length, and we decided to take the night off and let the copyboy (AAP veteran Jim Morton) cover the game
http://www.theroar.com.au/2010/06/08/oconnor-on-fire-for-baa-baas/
Jim’s was out last night too…