Sentimental Swans back when it matters most
By Subrasub, 23 Aug 2010 Subrasub is a Roar Rookie
- Tagged:
- AFL, Brett Kirk, Paul Roos, Ryan O'Keefe, Sydney Swans
Related coverage
With all the talk of Collingwood, and the ominous warnings being fired by Geelong during the past fortnight, it seemed as if only two teams looked likely to win the ultimate prize in 2010.
Perhaps a hard judgement, but with St Kilda only scrapping home against Richmond and losing that relentless defensive pressure and killer instinct to a considerable degree this season, which has seen them slip to third, many see this year’s competition as a two horse race.
The Western Bulldogs’ disappointing form leading into September is too hard a task to overturn at this stage, with injuries to key players and confidence ripped into shreds.
It begs the question, with the Sydney Swans’ thrilling and comprehensive victory over the Bulldogs in Brett Kirk and Paul Roos’ final game at the SCG, are Sydney a contender once again?
Now, readers may think I’m crazy to think so considering Sydney were hammered in consecutive weeks by Melbourne and Geelong to the tune of 73 and 53 points, but Sydney have won four of their last six games against Carlton, Hawthorn, Fremantle and the Western Bulldogs.
In those games the Swans have comprehensively beaten three of those teams by seven goals.
To think that these are teams that Sydney is going to face in a likely home final just a week out from the finals will be a huge factor.
The Swans have been missing bookends Craig Bolton, Mark Seaby and Daniel Bradshaw along with Roberts Thompson and Craig Bird for huge chunks of the season, which makes the Swans’ form all the more impressive.
However, good form against the bottom eight teams does not make you a contender.
But with the Swans now considered the best from the rest, purely on form over the last six weeks, and only losing to St Kilda in round 1 by eight points, and giving Collingwood a run for its money earlier in the year, Sydney are sitting in the box seat to do what only Collingwood did during the noughties, and make a prelim final from the bottom eight.
A win against Brisbane – which is probable – will mean Sydney will host a final against Carlton or Hawthorn, and a win there could mean a semi final against the Bulldogs.
The Bloods have got as good a chance as any to make a grand final again for outgoing co-captain and coach.
Easier said than done, and is unlikely to happen, but the last time the Swans won four games on the trot going into the finals they took the flag home, and with Ryan O’Keefe and Jared Moore returning next week, along with possible inclusions Daniel Bradshaw and Craig Bolton, the Swans are a real chance of giving September an almighty shake if rounds 1-6 are anything to go by.
Add to that sentimental emotion riding high and red hot form and you’ve got a genuine dark horse.
Looking to join The Roar team? We're searching for an experienced Group Sales Manager to lead our team in Sydney. Yes, this does mean you get to work with the site all day long! If you're a digital media sales star, we want to hear from you. Apply now.
![]()
Passionate about your AFL? Then sign up to The Roar's brand new daily AFL email, delivering Roaring articles directly to you day-in, day-out. You'll love it!
Click here to join now!
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
AFL articles
- Record low AFL crowd for GWS home match (209)
- Giant challenges ahead for Greater Western Sydney (200)
- Kevin Sheedy sticks by comments (143)
- My open-letter to AFL supporters (91)
- Long, cold winter ahead for Western Bulldogs (86)
- Why we should ease up on the Giants (81)
- Who was the greatest: the 2001-03 Lions or the 2007-09 Cats? (80)
- Indigenous round marred by shocking racial slur (5)
- GWS on search for star recruits: Sheedy
- No mid-season slump for Bombers: Hird
- Freo not in market for Jack Watts – yet
- Sydney beat Collingwood with ease
- Collingwood vs Sydney Swans: AFL live scores, blog (91)
- Why Bombers CEO Ian Robson had to go (15)
- Indigenous round marred by shocking racial slur (5)
- Collingwood vs Sydney Swans: AFL live scores, blog (91)
- Round 9 tips: Collingwood to edge Sydney, Hawks will continue streak (2)
- Port Adelaide’s ‘super sub’ spark (4)
- Preview: Collingwood vs Sydney Swans (2)
- 2013 AFL season: Round Nine preview (0)
- A dummy’s guide to AFL rules (29)
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- AFL, Brett Kirk, Paul Roos, Ryan O'Keefe, Sydney Swans


August 23rd 2010 @ 8:27am
Fivehole said | August 23rd 2010 @ 8:27am | Report comment
“make a prelim final from the bottom eight.” – pretty impressive seeing the finals excludes the bottom eight teams!
August 23rd 2010 @ 9:00am
LK said | August 23rd 2010 @ 9:00am | Report comment
I’m not getting carried away just yet. The Bulldogs had a few injuries and were down on form, I’m not sure how much to take out of Saturday night’s game. Mumford is a big out for this weekend, hopefully he will be right for the finals.
August 23rd 2010 @ 9:13am
Michael C said | August 23rd 2010 @ 9:13am | Report comment
Yeah, agreed with LK, Mumford is critical for the Swans.
That said, how good were Mike Pyke’s numbers with 13 disposals, 13 hit outs, 5 marks & 6 tackles. That’s a reasonable set of numbers for a number 2 ruckman. Sure, it’ll be a big ask to go number 1 and you’d have to think the best Swans line up would still be Mumford and Seaby, but, Pykey has been consistantly over the last few weeks at least equalling the ‘numbers’ of the opposition ‘number 2′ ruckman if not beating. And some of Pyke’s tap work HAS been top notch. Granted, a Ben Hudson type ruckman still out bodies him a fraction too easily.
January 21st 2011 @ 10:50am
captain nemo said | January 21st 2011 @ 10:50am | Report comment
long time no post Micheal C??
August 23rd 2010 @ 10:41am
LK said | August 23rd 2010 @ 10:41am | Report comment
Yeah, Pyke has been pretty solid this year. His tap work has always been decent, this year he has been much better around the ground. Probably the greatest compliment is teammates kicking the ball to him. That didn’t happen last year or early this year.
August 23rd 2010 @ 11:43am
Richard said | August 23rd 2010 @ 11:43am | Report comment
There’s a good spirit up there at the SCG and its a credit to the leadership at the Sydney Swans that they remain a united, committed and successful team even as they rebuild. Sydney is everybody’s second team (assuming it’s not your first) and it would be good to see them competitive in the finals. Just don’t get in the way of the ‘Pies. We are hungry for that day in the sun.
August 23rd 2010 @ 1:33pm
Bob Mcgregor said | August 23rd 2010 @ 1:33pm | Report comment
Nice article and full of information I was not aware of about previously injured Swans possibly returning this week. Hope they are fit and ready to perform against the Lions as they were impressive against the Bombers and the Swans must win to finish both 5th and secure a home final.
If they do, the game will be played at the old Olympic stadium at Homebush – a venue not at all kind to the Swans. Why they agree to the AFL dictates on such an occasion and neutralise their home ground advantage at the SCG I’ll never be able to fathom. I’ve attended ALL their home finals at the SCG since 1990s – but I refuse to go to the Homebush white elephant.
Only when they decide to play ALL games at the SCG will I again become a Swans member again.
Being a SCG member I didn’t need to be a dual member to attend Swan’s home games at the SCG, but I was to show my support for the Club. I didn’t renew that membership once they “decided” to play supposed block buster games at Homebush.
I wish them well in their finals endeavour, but to progress they will need a huge dose of luck and form reversal of their lamentable display against Richmond in the final 15 minutes and their woeful display against the Demons. Nevertheless, I wish them well for the finals.
Seems hard to believe the “ROOS” era is coming to an end. What a servant he has been for Swans both as a player, Coach and mentor. A truly magnificent contribution and I’m sure ALL Swan supporters would so acknowledge.
Like wise Brett “Captain” Kirk – the life and soul of the club since the end of the Kelly era. I wish them both the very best of everything that life after the Swans holds for them. BRAVO!
August 24th 2010 @ 9:18am
Redb said | August 24th 2010 @ 9:18am | Report comment
Great win by the Swans on Sat night. Top crowd.
Jack, Hannebery, DLT, Jetta offer some excitement for the future.
Note to Jetta – don’t stage for free kicks ever again! – hopefully the coaches showed him the footage and left him in no doubt.
Well done to Roosy and Kirk – terrific result and tribute to these greats of the game.
August 26th 2010 @ 1:31pm
Ian Whitchurch said | August 26th 2010 @ 1:31pm | Report comment
This is a bloody good rebuilding team.
But as someone who remembers Simon Minton-Connell at full forward, I’d back us against the Dogs or St Kilda, but we get blown off the park by Geelong or Collingwood.