Our first look at Osieck offers some optimism
By Tony Tannous, 5 Sep 2010 Tony Tannous is a Roar Expert
While it’s far too early to jump to any broad conclusions, the Socceroos’ first steps under Holger Osieck were encouraging if not quite as green as the picturesque hills that surround St. Gallen.
While they were perhaps fortunate to finish level after Swiss legend and skipper Alexander Frei missed a second half penalty, the first half in particular showed that the Socceroos, when they can get control in the midfield, are bound to play are more pro-active game under the new manager.
Switzerland, as we saw at the World Cup and in previous tournament, are traditionally a conservative, counter-attacking side, but there is a new liberation in their football, encouraged by some excellent recent youth development and an influx of immigrants.
With youngsters of the ilk of Xherdan Shaqiri and Eren Derdiyok now coming through the national team, and Euro qualifiers pending, this was always going to be a big challenge for the Roos, and the second period proved exactly that.
With Ottmar Hitzfeld making four changes at the break and introducing plenty of forward run, the Socceroos looked shaky, rattled even, and were fortunate to survive a succession of chances. Mark Schwarzer, as usual, played a big role.
But what was produced in the first period was very positive, including the split in space between the two central midfielders.
Under Pim Verbeek the Socceroos two holding midfielders were often seen in a straight line, working close together, playing square or backward passes. Late last year I called for Verbeek to scatter his square lines, but it was advice he didn’t heed until it was far too late.
Here it was good to see Carl Valeri, as rusty as he was, playing deeper than Jason Culina, with the latter invariably providing an advanced, angled option, meaning the passing was inevitably of a forward and diagonal variety.
In the second period, as the Switzerland got on top, there was evidence of Culina and Valeri slipping back into old habits, where they got too close to each other, but that was as much down to the immense pressure applied by the likes of Shaqiri, Xavier Magairaz and Gelson Fernandes.
The other positive note from the first half was the sight of many bodies in forward motion.
The Socceroos played a 4-4-1-1, with Tim Cahill playing as the second striker close to Scott McDonald. With Brett Holman tucking in on the left, Brett Emerton also working a narrower channel on the right, and Culina more advanced than Valeri, it meant many bodies in forward motion and in support of McDonald.
The Middlesbrough striker may have missed another couple of golden opportunities to open his Socceroos account, but his overall performance in the first period was one of his better ones in green and gold, mainly due to him not being totally isolated.
While it might take a little more time to warm to Osieck’s want for him to play combination with likes of Cahill, Holman and Emerton, the exciting sight for McDonald was that when he did hold the ball up, and looked up, there were bodies nearby.
In the first half he had the too much run for Stephane Gritchting, but the introduction of Steve von Bergen at the break made life more difficult in the second.
Nevertheless, it was a spirited effort from the diminutive front-man, who looks as fit as he ever has.
How Osieck nurtures and encourages McDonald will be fascinating to observe, but the early signs are that he rates him. Ultimately though it will be the goals that decide how long the love lasts.
Osieck has spoken of giving everyone a clean start, so performances should ultimately do the talking. To that end, he would have put an early tick alongside most of the team, but a couple of question marks near the names Valeri and David Carney, who, in fairness, looked short of a gallop.
Meanwhile, both central defenders, Matthew Spiranovic and Lucas Neill had some good and not so great moments, but you sense they grew more comfortable as the game went on.
Spiranovic, for example, invariably wanted to play out, and should be applauded for that, while Neill, after making a clumsy challenge for the penalty, showed his experience in the dying minutes.
Osieck looks like the type that will build his team at his own pace, giving opportunities and rewarding performance.
He has indicated he will make changes for the Poland friendly on Wednesday morning (our time), seeking to have a look a few more players and how they handle the occasion.
It’s early days, but Osieck’s reign has begun in a positive way.
Follow Tony on Twitter @TonyTannousTRBA
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Football articles
- Phoenix need more than flash in the pan crowds (133)
- ‘New football’ fans may help save the game in Australia (124)
- Does Tasmania have a case for A-League inclusion? (119)
- What happened in Port Said was not a football riot (118)
- Magilton struggling to make a mark (68)
- Does the A-League need an injection of humour? (44)
- Socceroos screwed over by FIFA, again (41)
- Sydney and Perth eye A-League crunch game
- Melbourne Victory vs Central Coast Mariners: A-League live scores, blog (97)
- Liam Miller: Bargain buy of the A-League season? (9)
- Zambia plays Cup of Nations final in memory of their fallen (7)
- Capello’s resignation ends an awkward marriage (8)
- Does the A-League need an injection of humour? (46)
- Redknapp the best bet to clean up Capello’s England mess (2)
- Melbourne Victory vs Central Coast Mariners: A-League live scores, blog (97)
- Liam Miller: Bargain buy of the A-League season? (9)
- Zambia plays Cup of Nations final in memory of their fallen (7)
- Capello’s resignation ends an awkward marriage (8)
- Redknapp the best bet to clean up Capello’s England mess (2)
- Melbourne derby reveals tale of two journeys (3)
- O’ so close for John: How JON almost landed the biggest job in sport (16)
- Explore:
- Alexander Frei, Carl Valeri, Holger Osieck, Jason Culina, Pim Verbeek, Socceroos, switzerland

Alders said | September 5th 2010 @ 3:47am | Report comment
I am actually living in Switzerland right now and had no idea the game was even on. I read the Australian papers as well. Might have gone to watch.
Tony Tannous said | September 5th 2010 @ 7:49pm | Report comment
Pity Alders, you missed a good one.
Alders said | September 5th 2010 @ 11:20pm | Report comment
It would have been cool to go and see. I would have put in the hours driving pretty happily.
Midfielder said | September 5th 2010 @ 6:23am | Report comment
Tony
Will in interesting to see if Troisi & Inman to name just a couple get a look in… I will hold my judgement for a little longer but can say he has impressed me with his first game in charge.
Hopefully I am not saying this with my Mariners glasses on but keep an eye on young Griffiths… he reminds me very much of Jedi when he first came to the club only bigger and with a much better passing game…
Tony Tannous said | September 5th 2010 @ 7:54pm | Report comment
Mid, there’s a heap of youngsters, in Europe and the A-League, with claims for inclusion based on talent, but it will all come down to Osieck’s preferences…ie the type of player he rates.
Defensive minded players and athletes got a real look-in under Verbeek.
I’d be surprised if Griffiths is among the type of players Osieck rates, but if he develops and improves considerably, one never knows.
James said | September 5th 2010 @ 7:54am | Report comment
Certainly was a decent start from Osieck. Thanks for another enjoyable read Tony. Here’s hoping Holger’s work is just as measured.
Tony Tannous said | September 5th 2010 @ 7:55pm | Report comment
Cheers James, will be very interesting seeing his eye for detail.
Davstar said | September 5th 2010 @ 11:06am | Report comment
it was encouraging ill give you that certainly wasn’t dull and boring like Verbeek
Tony Tannous said | September 5th 2010 @ 8:03pm | Report comment
It’s funny Davstar, I somewhat expected the Roos to be more offensive than what we’d seen under Verbeek for a couple of reasons;
1. The words coming from Osieck beforehand. He seems to appreciate that he is expected to produce positive football. Verbeek’s job was to get results, so Osieck has a different responsibility. He knows it, Lowy has stated it, and we expect it, so no real surprise for me.
2. Switzerland, as I wrote, are traditionally a defensive counter attacking side, so I felt that style might suit our want to get forward. But at home they showed som real enterprise in the second period, and forced Neill and Spiranovic back.
Fussball ist unser leben said | September 5th 2010 @ 1:40pm | Report comment
Nice analysis, Tony. In my opinion, this practice match delivered only positives and no negatives.
1. Nice style of football: tick
2. Kept a clean sheet: tick
3. Created chances: tick
Under Pim, we nearly always kept clean sheets but I was not happy with our style and/or the number of chances we created.
Tony Tannous said | September 5th 2010 @ 8:05pm | Report comment
Fair point Fussball, plenty of positives and a good point about the number of chances. The clean sheet was lucky somewhat, but Switzerland were equally fortunate to keep theirs.
whiskeymac said | September 5th 2010 @ 6:47pm | Report comment
good read as ever – so with new names being played does this mean naming a new squad or rather giving more time to those he’s already got in the squad (which makes more sense to me)
Tony Tannous said | September 5th 2010 @ 8:10pm | Report comment
Cheers Whisky. In answer to your question, it’s the latter. The likes of Federici, Jedinak, North, Vidosic, Oar, Burns, McKain and even Garcia should expect more game time.
Adam said | September 6th 2010 @ 9:45am | Report comment
Good to hear the performance was promising. What line-up would like like to see for the Poland game? I would like to see Burns in there, what do you think?
Tony Tannous said | September 6th 2010 @ 8:45pm | Report comment
Adam, I’d like to see Burns get at least some game time, maybe 45 mins or more.
Poland, like Switzerland, will be tough, but I’d like to see North in the mix for a start, Jedinak given a crack in midfield and Vidosic definitely starting in the front third. Something like this 11 would be good, with subs in brackets;
————————Schwarzer (Federici)———————-
Wilkshire———–Neill (Spiranovic)——North———-Carney
—————————–Jedinak (Valeri)————————
——-Vidosic———Culina (McKain)————-Holman (Oar)
—————————————-Cahill (Burns)————
—————————-McDonald————————-
I should qualify, when McKain comes on for Culina, throw him in central defence alongside Spiranovic, North to right back and Wilkshire into midfield.
Lmacca said | September 6th 2010 @ 10:09am | Report comment
Tony – agree with your analysis. I was heartened to see Spiranovic playing the ball out from the back – I’m sure plenty of people at home were yelling ‘boot it’ but I’d much rather see him look to play a pass to a midfielder. And the positivity going forward meant the ‘roos were good to watch – something we’ve hardly said in the last 3 years. Th next generation still have to show they can be better than Emerton, McDonald, Cahill and Holman, all of whom looked good. Hoping Burns gets a chance with some of the first choice players, I think he’s the pick of the new bunch.
Only negatives were Valeri and Carney. Valeri I can excuse, he was one fo our best at the World Cup and seems to have lost a bit of touch since he’s not playing much in Italy. A mate of mine did ask why he was kept on for so long when it was clear he wasn’t up to it. I think Wilkshire could move into central midfield with Culina and be a good option also, if Rhys Williams comes back from injury and can play right back. Carney on the other hand seemed to show he’s not much of a defender. I’d be interested in seeing what other options we have there – perhaps Lowry?
Glad to see a coach not just looknig for results, but good football. Good football should bring results. And if it doesn’t – at least they’re better to watch!
Tony Tannous said | September 6th 2010 @ 8:50pm | Report comment
Good post Lmacca, I think you got it pretty spot on. It was great to see the team trying to play, even if it wasn’t all in-synch. Here’s hoping it’s good football and good results.
Phil H said | September 6th 2010 @ 10:29am | Report comment
I thought Emerton was excellent but I was less impressed with Culina. I look forward to MacDonald scoring just so we can all move on – full marks to the new boss for giving him a go and adopting a more adventurous outlook. There was a fluidity between Holman, Cahill and MacDonald that we don’t get with Josh Kennedy. Spiranovic is worth persisting with but I look forward to the day we can retire Neill – I’m no longer confident of his ability to marshall a defence, he concedes too many fouls – including penalties – and for the second game in a row he proved to be the wrong man in the right spot with that point-blank miss.
Tony Tannous said | September 6th 2010 @ 8:55pm | Report comment
Good post Phil, I admit to thinking the same at times about Neill throughout the game, but in the last 5 or 10 minutes I think his experience showed, and I’m not yet convinced anyone is ready to step up and lead the defence.
Like eveyone though, I think he is on notice and should be on notice. No-one, Cahill, Neill and Schwarzer included, should ever have a mortgage on their position.
Like everything in life, ongoing performance should be the key.